This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
Deborah O'Neill NSW, Australian Labor Party
12:52 pm
The committee is considering the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 and the deferred division on amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116. The question is that the amendments be agreed to.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
12:53 pm
by leave—I move the amendments on sheet 4132 together:
(1) Schedule 1, page 4 (before line 5), before item 1, insert:
1A After section 101
Insert
101A Dismissal by registrars where no reasonable prospects of success
(1) Before a registrar exercises a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) in relation to an application for a proceeding, the registrar must:
(a) if the registrar is not certain it is appropriate to exercise the power—consult a senior member in the relevant jurisdictional area; and
(b) give written notice to each party to the proceeding that the registrar is considering exercising the power and invite the parties to make submissions in response to the notice by a day specified in the notice (which must be no less than 14 days after the notice is given); and
(c) consider any submissions made in response to the notice before the day specified in the notice.
Note: A registrar may be authorised by the President to perform or exercise certain functions or powers of the Tribunal (see section 285).
(2) The exercise of a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) by a registrar is not valid if the registrar fails to comply with subsection (1).
(2) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), omit "this Act.", substitute "this Act; and".
(3) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), at the end of the item, add:
(d) a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) must not be exercised by a registrar unless:
(i) the registrar has obtained a degree from a university, or an educational qualification of a similar standing, in the field of law; and
(ii) in the opinion of the President, the registrar has sufficient experience in the field of law to exercise the power.
Labor and the coalition have done a stitch-up job here, as they usually do. They have come up with a process where whereby registrars will now be empowered to dismiss matters where a registrar forms the view that there are no reasonable prospects of success.
Now, let's say a couple of things. I'm sure registrars are all very nice. I'm sure that they're all people largely trying to do the right thing. But they do not have tenure of appointment. They're just members of the executive. They're not members of the tribunal; they're members of the executive and can be hired and fired by the principal registrar without any statutory protection. They don't even have to have the legal qualifications of a member, and they're being given the power to dismiss matters, when they have a subjective view about whether or not the matter has reasonable prospects of success.
As the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said in their submission to the inquiry on this bill—a neat summary of their position is: this is a dumb idea, it undermines the independence of the tribunal, and registrars are not the right people to make that decision. I will just read into the record some of what Joshua Strutt from IARC said:
You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members.
Members and senior members are not registrars. Members and senior members are statutory appointments, they have statutory protections, and they're there to make the decisions. Registrars are just employees. Mr Strutt went further:
We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.
When we asked the Attorney-General's Department about this, they asserted that registrars would be using this power only in 'objective circumstances'. When we asked them how tests such as reasonableness could be objective—reasonableness is the quintessential subjective test. From a legal perspective, the test that is so obviously subjective, that doesn't actually have objective parameters that you look to, is reasonableness. So, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department, 'How could you say that giving registrars the ability to knock off matters where there are no reasonable prospects of success would be an exercise of objective decision-making against objective criteria?' they just floundered and failed to even address the issue.
Now, maybe that's the advice that the government's been getting. I'd be interested to know from the minister: does the Attorney-General accept the position from the Attorney-General's Department that a test of whether or not a matter has reasonable prospects for success is an objective test? Does the Attorney-General adopt that evidence from the Attorney-General's Department?
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:58 pm
I'm happy to speak to the amendments put forward by the Greens before going to the substantive question. Firstly, the government will not be supporting these amendments. The proposal under the bill is appropriately designed to balance enhanced efficiencies in the tribunal processes with strong safeguards that exist. The function of the tribunal to dismiss an application if satisfied the application has no reasonable prospects of success is intended to be exercised by registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature and can be adequately performed by an authorised registrar. As a safeguard, the president would be able to issue directions in relation to registrars' use of the dismissal power for no reasonable prospects of success, and registrars would be obliged to comply with any directions when they exercised that power. The ART Act already requires the tribunal to provide each party with a reasonable opportunity to present their case, and, as a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal will write to an applicant to seek their submissions before dismissing an application for no reasonable prospects of success. Under the act, there's a requirement that a person cannot be appointed a registrar unless they have certain qualifications, so they're not just nice people; they are qualified people.
The question that Senator Shoebridge put was discussed yesterday during debate. Rather than refer to the entire answer I gave in full, I'll just provide the example that I gave. The power to dismiss applications for no reasonable prospects of success, as I said, is intended for registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature where clear and objective criteria demonstrate that an application is bound to fail. What that means is that it would be appropriate for a registrar to dismiss an application where the applicant fails to meet an objective visa criteria, for example, where the applicant is required to be onshore in Australia at the time the application is made, but they are in fact outside Australia. Another example might be where they must be below a certain age when the application is made by the original decision-maker and they are older than that age. Perhaps they've been required to have a nomination in place at the time of their visa application, but the decision-maker and the nomination have not been approved. Finally, one that we often see come through the ART system is that the applicants are required to provide evidence when making their visa application that they have undertaken an English language test and achieved a specified score, but they have not been able to do so. As I said previously, as a safeguard, the president would be able to issue these directions to ensure the powers of dismissal for no reasonable prospects of success are complied with, and they would set out circumstances in which it would be appropriate for the registrar to exercise this dismissal of power.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
1:01 pm
I'm not sure that answered the question, but we could probably try again and get the same non-answer to the core question. Of course the legislation contains none of those safeguards. The legislation just gives a power for registrars to dismiss where there are no reasonable prospects of success. A small subset of those matters may have an objective element to them—like failing to attach the English language certificate. But the legislation is in no way limited to that. The government was unable to provide a draft direction from the principal registrar. When questioned, the principal registrar could provide no clarity on what the principal registrar's thoughts were for a direction. You're just providing this incredibly broad power that, if it's not abused by this principal registrar or this attorney-general, could well be abused by a future one because there are no statutory protections.
The amendments that the Greens are moving here on sheet 4132 are based upon the evidence we got from the Law Council. The Law Council said that they oppose these changes to give registrars these kinds of powers. They were unambiguous about it. They said it's bad—bad for the independence of the tribunal, bad for individual justice—and that registrars are not the right people in the tribunal to have the power. But they then said, 'Well, look, if you are going to insist upon these changes, put some legislative safeguards in.' This is what is picked up in our amendments on sheet 4132.
The Law Council said in their submission that, while they preferred for these changes not to happen, if they do happen, there should be the following: 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-admission experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. We'll just stop there. We got some kind of woolly statement from the minister then that there are some kind of criteria required for registrars in the selection process, but they are not the minimums that the Law Council is calling for. To be clear, that was 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-administration experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. That should be a limitation.
They also said 'a qualification requiring that a registrar be required to consult with a senior member or the relevant jurisdictional area leader where uncertain about a finding before committing to that finding'. So get some advice from someone who knows and who has the qualifications and the independence.
The third point they said was 'ensuring that, if an application is dismissed under this power, this will not prevent an applicant being able to make a request to the media to the minister under section 351 of the Migration Act or for the ART to continue to be able to refer a matter for consideration to the minister under that section'. Lastly, they said 'an express requirement that, before an application is dismissed, the applicant must be given notice that the registrar has formed a view that it may be appropriate to dismiss an application and the applicant be provided an opportunity to be heard specifically on that question'. They continued:
A failure to give notice or to hear the applicant should be expressed as rendering any dismissal to be of no effect.
These are the amendments that are contained in the Greens amendments on sheet 4132. For those reasons, we commend the amendments to the Senate.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
1:05 pm
The coalition will not be supporting the amendments moved by the Australian Greens. It is our belief that these amendments would impose additional procedural requirements and restrictions that risk undermining the very efficiencies that the legislation was indeed drafted to address.
As we know, and it was again confirmed with us at the most recent Senate estimates hearing, the Administrative Review Tribunal is already facing extraordinary pressures. In fact, in 2024-25, the tribunal received more than 83,000 applications with almost 80 per cent relating to migration and protection matters. We also know that the Federal Circuit and Family Court is also experiencing significant pressure from increasing migration litigation. The actual stated purpose of the bill—certainly, this was the evidence that was elicited by many witnesses, including the tribunal's head at the hearing into the bill—is to address those pressures by reducing unnecessary administrative burdens, streamlining decision-making and allowing tribunal members to concentrate on what are substantive matters. Yet the Greens are proposing amendments—and Senator Shoebridge just outlined what they would be—that we believe risk making these processes and procedures more complicated.
Their amendments to expand the registrar powers would introduce additional statutory procedures, including mandatory written notices, a minimum 14-day period for submissions and further restrictions on which registrars may exercise dismissal powers. Of course, the coalition supports appropriate safeguards, but these proposals risk adding unnecessary delays to decisions about applications that have no reasonable prospect of success. We believe the tribunal must retain the flexibility to determine where appropriately qualified and experienced registrars should exercise these powers, rather than having unnecessarily prescriptive requirements imposed by legislation. That's what would happen if the Australian Greens amendments did indeed pass the Senate.
The Greens also propose restricting the use of oral decisions and oral reasons to circumstances where a decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. Again, the coalition believes that this would substantially undermine what is actually one of the bill's central efficiency measures. We recognise that written reasons are important, particularly where an applicant is considering whether or not to take a further step in the process and apply for judicial review; however, the bill as drafted will actually preserve the ability of the applicants to request written reasons.
The Senate committee has also recommended that applicants receive clear written notice of the relevant timeframes for requesting reasons and seeking judicial review, and we believe that the recommendation coming out of the Senate committee in that regard is a more proportionate approach than effectively reinstating the existing requirement for written reasons in every unsuccessful application. On that basis, as I said, we believe that the priority must be to ensure that Australia's administrative and judicial review systems operate efficiently, that unmeritorious applications do not unnecessarily consume resources and that genuine applicants receive timely decisions. We won't support amendments that risk increasing delays, adding administrative burdens and frustrating the practical improvements that this bill seeks to deliver. As I said, for those reasons, the coalition will not be supporting the amendments put forward by the Australian Greens.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
1:09 pm
The Law Council, law societies, people appearing before the ART and people who have applications before the ART do not consider things like natural justice, the right to be heard and having your matter decided by a tribunal member who actually has tenure and who is not an employee who can be hired and fired by the government of the day to be additional procedural requirements. They consider those rights a fundamental part of a fair tribunal and the rule of law.
But we hear the coalition's views. They believe procedural fairness and the rule of law are just additional procedural requirements that can be just cast aside at any moment. Of course, they're in good company there, because the Labor Party believes the same thing. Natural justice and the rule of law—they're simply additional procedural requirements on which the coalition and Labor, as always, can team up to take away basic rights from Australians, basic rights from applicants and basic rights from people appearing before a tribunal whose whole purpose is to hold the government to account and challenge the decisions made by the executive. That's the whole purpose of the ART—to challenge decisions made by the executive. Now, Labor and the coalition want critical decisions in that tribunal to be made by members of the executive not members of the tribunal with protected statutory tenure—have the executive passed judgement on the executive. That's how little you care about independence or basic legal structures and basic concepts.
We can see the stitch up is in, because this is how both Labor and the coalition—there's so little between you. There is so little between the Labor Party and the coalition. Every time they see a chance to pump up executive power and to push down against rights, Labor and the coalition join together, like you're doing today. You may as well just get a merger happening here. When it comes to national security and when it comes to basic rights in our legal system, why don't the Labor Party and the coalition just do a joint ticket on this stuff, like you're doing today?
Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
1:15 pm
The question is that amendments (1) to (3) on sheet 4132 be agreed to.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
1:17 pm
by leave—I move Greens amendments (1), (2) and (3) on sheet 4133 together:
(1) Schedule 1, item 35, page 17 (lines 12 to 19), omit paragraphs 111(2)(a) and (b), substitute:
(a) the Tribunal's decision:
(i) in writing; or
(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant—orally, and later in writing;
(b) reasons for the Tribunal's decision:
(i) in the form of a statement of reasons; or
(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant—orally, and later in the form of a statement of reasons if the party requests a statement of reasons under subsection (4);
(2) Schedule 1, item 38, page 19 (line 11), omit "paragraph 111(2)(b)", substitute "subparagraph 111(2)(b)(ii)".
(3) Schedule 1, item 58, page 24 (line 4), after "orally to the applicant", insert "if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant".
One of the key proposals in this bill is to remove the obligation to provide written decisions to applicants, and, of course, pretty much every submission we received included deep concern about what that would mean in practice. As the Refugee Council of Australia said in its submission:
Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the tribunal's findings, decision-making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.
Witnesses also raised concerns that the absence of the need to put pen to paper and commit reasons to writing would seriously degrade the quality of decision-making and that removing the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made also seriously impacts people's ability to file appeals of decisions of the ART. If you haven't got the reasons in front of you, how do you formulate the basis on which you seek to appeal or review them?
This bill just creates more complexity. It provides that, where a decision is made orally, applicants may then request written reasons. Well, first of all, the most marginalised applicants—the ones for whom English is a second language or who may not have English language skills at all; people who are economically disempowered; women fleeing violence—are the types of applicants that the evidence said will be most disadvantaged by this. They haven't got the legal resources. They haven't got the cultural resources. They don't understand the complexities of administrative review. Yet the government says, 'Don't you worry about that'—people without those resources and without those cultural assets will somehow magically know that they can request written decisions. And providing the written decisions could take up to 28 days, eating into the 35-day appeal period, making it even harder for the most marginalised people to exercise their rights.
Perhaps that's what Labor's intent was here. Labor knows who this is going to have the biggest impact on, and that's why they're doing it—people without economic power, people without cultural power. Labor says they'll take rights away from those people, because then they won't kick up a stink; they won't be able to build the movement to challenge Labor's decision to take away their rights. That's why Labor is focusing these changes on taking rights away from the most marginalised people. And of course the coalition cheers this in every time, because they want to take rights away from the same people; that's in their political DNA.
Watching Labor and the coalition do this—craft amendments that are designed expressly to have the greatest impact on the people with the least ability to resist—is exactly why people are looking at the way Labor and the coalition exercise government, are looking at the way they exercise their political powers and are increasingly revolted by it. They can see that you'll take every opportunity you get to punch down on ordinary Australians, the most marginalised. You want to punch down on pensioners, punch down on people on the NDIS, punch down on migrants and punch down on people seeking asylum. And you do that because you know they've got less capacity to politically resist. Instead of making the hard decisions and maybe taxing the one per cent to get the funding to properly resource the ART so that they've got the members they need in order to make decisions, or having Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place and resource that, no, no, no—Labor and the coalition want to punch down on marginalised people, because they think there'll be no resistance. Well, the Greens are resisting it, on behalf of all those Australians who need someone in their corner—because they sure as hell don't have Labor or the coalition in their corner.
And of course there was incredible confusion in the rationale from the Attorney-General's Department on the proposed extent to which they intend to use this power. The chief executive officer and principal registrar of the ART, Mr Hawkins, made clear that they don't expect to use the power in complex cases, so of course there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases, as, again, Mr Hawkins explained, because no-one from the Attorney-General's Department could explain when they wanted to use this power to get rid of the need for written reasons. Mr Hawkins said:
I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.
Well, we're going to take Mr Hawkins up on that suggestion, and that's exactly what the Greens amendments do. They do this because we're going in to bat for people who have less power. These amendments say that the only circumstances in which the tribunal cannot provide written decisions are when the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. For the reasons put forward by Mr Hawkins, the principal registrar, and for the reasons put forward in so many submissions to the tribunal—and just for basic decency—we commend these amendments to the Senate.
David Pocock ACT, Independent
1:24 pm
The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is a bill that my team and I have been looking at, grappling with. I had planned to vote in support of this bill until yesterday, with the amendment that was circulated by the government and passed. Clearly there is a real problem with the backlog in the migration case load, and it needs to be addressed. As Senator Cash pointed out in her second reading speech, the tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration matters, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. This should not be allowed to continue. This has a huge impact on people's lives. Visa applicants should not be forced to wait years for an outcome. The cost of those delays is huge.
I accept what the government has said about some applications being made without reasonable prospects of success. The Law Council and others, as has been canvassed in this debate, have talked about the need for greater efficiency—but weighed against real concerns about access to justice and the rule of law. I take seriously the concerns about expanded registrar powers, oral reasons and identity verification. On balance, though, my view had been that the need to fix the backlog outweighed those concerns.
Then, the government circulated the amendment on sheet IE116, which the Senate just agreed to. It lets the minister promote a general member to senior member without the publicly advertised, merit based assessment that the ART Act otherwise requires. The president is asked for advice. There is no advertising, no open competition and no assessment panel. The decision then sits with the minister. I thought this was the whole point of Labor getting rid of the AAT. We heard so much about it when Labor was in opposition—about jobs for mates and all the things that were wrong with the AAT—to the point where it got abolished. The former attorney-general in particular fought very hard to fix the issues, and I commend him for it. Merit based, publicly advertised appointments were the centrepiece of the new tribunal, and this amendment, which the government put forward and the coalition supported, seems to disrespect the work of the Hon. Mark Dreyfus in fighting for a merit based process so that we can have trust in the ART. I'll read a quote from the Prime Minister at a doorstop interview in May 2024, shortly after the AAT was replaced by the ART:
Now, we have replaced the AAT this week. We've gotten rid of it. Gotten rid of it … We've abolished it, gotten rid of it and replaced it with the Administrative Review Tribunal, which will be more rigorous, which will not be full of former party political appointments.
It's amazing what can happen in a couple of years. The amendment that just passed is a step backwards, towards the bad old days, and I suspect many in Labor know that. Before the AAT was abolished, appointments were tarnished by cronyism. There were so many criticisms and allegations about the way that the appointments process worked. Given that, I think this is a poisoned pill in this bill. Canberrans want to see appointments generally, but particularly to our Administrative Review Tribunal, based on merit and merit alone. It is just not good enough for this Labor government to introduce that amendment.
So, Minister, I'd love to hear from you and the government. I certainly didn't see, in any of the submissions or anything put forward by witnesses, suggestions that the government should water down the merit based appointment process. Where has this idea come from, and why is the government watering down the merit based process that was put into place by former attorney-general Mark Dreyfus?
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
1:28 pm
Thank you, Senator Pocock. We did answer questions extensively on this yesterday, but I can rephrase or summarise those for you. Firstly, we agree that the AAT did require reform, and we thank the Senate for its support, in the previous term of this parliament, in abolishing the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal. It had been stacked with around 80 former political MPs, candidates, staffers and supporters and didn't have an established merits review as part of the appointment process. It's really important that appointments undergo rigorous arms-length assessments before serving on the tribunal. That's exactly what the government has been progressing. I think you will be fully aware that the government has appointed 114 new general members, 18 new senior members, five judicial deputy presidents and four non-judicial deputy presidents. That's an equivalent of 94.3 FTE—
Progress reported.