This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
1:05 pm
The coalition will not be supporting the amendments moved by the Australian Greens. It is our belief that these amendments would impose additional procedural requirements and restrictions that risk undermining the very efficiencies that the legislation was indeed drafted to address.
As we know, and it was again confirmed with us at the most recent Senate estimates hearing, the Administrative Review Tribunal is already facing extraordinary pressures. In fact, in 2024-25, the tribunal received more than 83,000 applications with almost 80 per cent relating to migration and protection matters. We also know that the Federal Circuit and Family Court is also experiencing significant pressure from increasing migration litigation. The actual stated purpose of the bill—certainly, this was the evidence that was elicited by many witnesses, including the tribunal's head at the hearing into the bill—is to address those pressures by reducing unnecessary administrative burdens, streamlining decision-making and allowing tribunal members to concentrate on what are substantive matters. Yet the Greens are proposing amendments—and Senator Shoebridge just outlined what they would be—that we believe risk making these processes and procedures more complicated.
Their amendments to expand the registrar powers would introduce additional statutory procedures, including mandatory written notices, a minimum 14-day period for submissions and further restrictions on which registrars may exercise dismissal powers. Of course, the coalition supports appropriate safeguards, but these proposals risk adding unnecessary delays to decisions about applications that have no reasonable prospect of success. We believe the tribunal must retain the flexibility to determine where appropriately qualified and experienced registrars should exercise these powers, rather than having unnecessarily prescriptive requirements imposed by legislation. That's what would happen if the Australian Greens amendments did indeed pass the Senate.
The Greens also propose restricting the use of oral decisions and oral reasons to circumstances where a decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. Again, the coalition believes that this would substantially undermine what is actually one of the bill's central efficiency measures. We recognise that written reasons are important, particularly where an applicant is considering whether or not to take a further step in the process and apply for judicial review; however, the bill as drafted will actually preserve the ability of the applicants to request written reasons.
The Senate committee has also recommended that applicants receive clear written notice of the relevant timeframes for requesting reasons and seeking judicial review, and we believe that the recommendation coming out of the Senate committee in that regard is a more proportionate approach than effectively reinstating the existing requirement for written reasons in every unsuccessful application. On that basis, as I said, we believe that the priority must be to ensure that Australia's administrative and judicial review systems operate efficiently, that unmeritorious applications do not unnecessarily consume resources and that genuine applicants receive timely decisions. We won't support amendments that risk increasing delays, adding administrative burdens and frustrating the practical improvements that this bill seeks to deliver. As I said, for those reasons, the coalition will not be supporting the amendments put forward by the Australian Greens.
No comments