This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:58 pm
I'm happy to speak to the amendments put forward by the Greens before going to the substantive question. Firstly, the government will not be supporting these amendments. The proposal under the bill is appropriately designed to balance enhanced efficiencies in the tribunal processes with strong safeguards that exist. The function of the tribunal to dismiss an application if satisfied the application has no reasonable prospects of success is intended to be exercised by registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature and can be adequately performed by an authorised registrar. As a safeguard, the president would be able to issue directions in relation to registrars' use of the dismissal power for no reasonable prospects of success, and registrars would be obliged to comply with any directions when they exercised that power. The ART Act already requires the tribunal to provide each party with a reasonable opportunity to present their case, and, as a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal will write to an applicant to seek their submissions before dismissing an application for no reasonable prospects of success. Under the act, there's a requirement that a person cannot be appointed a registrar unless they have certain qualifications, so they're not just nice people; they are qualified people.
The question that Senator Shoebridge put was discussed yesterday during debate. Rather than refer to the entire answer I gave in full, I'll just provide the example that I gave. The power to dismiss applications for no reasonable prospects of success, as I said, is intended for registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature where clear and objective criteria demonstrate that an application is bound to fail. What that means is that it would be appropriate for a registrar to dismiss an application where the applicant fails to meet an objective visa criteria, for example, where the applicant is required to be onshore in Australia at the time the application is made, but they are in fact outside Australia. Another example might be where they must be below a certain age when the application is made by the original decision-maker and they are older than that age. Perhaps they've been required to have a nomination in place at the time of their visa application, but the decision-maker and the nomination have not been approved. Finally, one that we often see come through the ART system is that the applicants are required to provide evidence when making their visa application that they have undertaken an English language test and achieved a specified score, but they have not been able to do so. As I said previously, as a safeguard, the president would be able to issue these directions to ensure the powers of dismissal for no reasonable prospects of success are complied with, and they would set out circumstances in which it would be appropriate for the registrar to exercise this dismissal of power.
No comments