This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
1:09 pm
The Law Council, law societies, people appearing before the ART and people who have applications before the ART do not consider things like natural justice, the right to be heard and having your matter decided by a tribunal member who actually has tenure and who is not an employee who can be hired and fired by the government of the day to be additional procedural requirements. They consider those rights a fundamental part of a fair tribunal and the rule of law.
But we hear the coalition's views. They believe procedural fairness and the rule of law are just additional procedural requirements that can be just cast aside at any moment. Of course, they're in good company there, because the Labor Party believes the same thing. Natural justice and the rule of law—they're simply additional procedural requirements on which the coalition and Labor, as always, can team up to take away basic rights from Australians, basic rights from applicants and basic rights from people appearing before a tribunal whose whole purpose is to hold the government to account and challenge the decisions made by the executive. That's the whole purpose of the ART—to challenge decisions made by the executive. Now, Labor and the coalition want critical decisions in that tribunal to be made by members of the executive not members of the tribunal with protected statutory tenure—have the executive passed judgement on the executive. That's how little you care about independence or basic legal structures and basic concepts.
We can see the stitch up is in, because this is how both Labor and the coalition—there's so little between you. There is so little between the Labor Party and the coalition. Every time they see a chance to pump up executive power and to push down against rights, Labor and the coalition join together, like you're doing today. You may as well just get a merger happening here. When it comes to national security and when it comes to basic rights in our legal system, why don't the Labor Party and the coalition just do a joint ticket on this stuff, like you're doing today?
No comments