This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

1:17 pm

by leave—I move Greens amendments (1), (2) and (3) on sheet 4133 together:

(1) Schedule 1, item 35, page 17 (lines 12 to 19), omit paragraphs 111(2)(a) and (b), substitute:

(a) the Tribunal's decision:

(i) in writing; or

(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant—orally, and later in writing;

(b) reasons for the Tribunal's decision:

(i) in the form of a statement of reasons; or

(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant—orally, and later in the form of a statement of reasons if the party requests a statement of reasons under subsection (4);

(2) Schedule 1, item 38, page 19 (line 11), omit "paragraph 111(2)(b)", substitute "subparagraph 111(2)(b)(ii)".

(3) Schedule 1, item 58, page 24 (line 4), after "orally to the applicant", insert "if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant".

One of the key proposals in this bill is to remove the obligation to provide written decisions to applicants, and, of course, pretty much every submission we received included deep concern about what that would mean in practice. As the Refugee Council of Australia said in its submission:

Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the tribunal's findings, decision-making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.

Witnesses also raised concerns that the absence of the need to put pen to paper and commit reasons to writing would seriously degrade the quality of decision-making and that removing the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made also seriously impacts people's ability to file appeals of decisions of the ART. If you haven't got the reasons in front of you, how do you formulate the basis on which you seek to appeal or review them?

This bill just creates more complexity. It provides that, where a decision is made orally, applicants may then request written reasons. Well, first of all, the most marginalised applicants—the ones for whom English is a second language or who may not have English language skills at all; people who are economically disempowered; women fleeing violence—are the types of applicants that the evidence said will be most disadvantaged by this. They haven't got the legal resources. They haven't got the cultural resources. They don't understand the complexities of administrative review. Yet the government says, 'Don't you worry about that'—people without those resources and without those cultural assets will somehow magically know that they can request written decisions. And providing the written decisions could take up to 28 days, eating into the 35-day appeal period, making it even harder for the most marginalised people to exercise their rights.

Perhaps that's what Labor's intent was here. Labor knows who this is going to have the biggest impact on, and that's why they're doing it—people without economic power, people without cultural power. Labor says they'll take rights away from those people, because then they won't kick up a stink; they won't be able to build the movement to challenge Labor's decision to take away their rights. That's why Labor is focusing these changes on taking rights away from the most marginalised people. And of course the coalition cheers this in every time, because they want to take rights away from the same people; that's in their political DNA.

Watching Labor and the coalition do this—craft amendments that are designed expressly to have the greatest impact on the people with the least ability to resist—is exactly why people are looking at the way Labor and the coalition exercise government, are looking at the way they exercise their political powers and are increasingly revolted by it. They can see that you'll take every opportunity you get to punch down on ordinary Australians, the most marginalised. You want to punch down on pensioners, punch down on people on the NDIS, punch down on migrants and punch down on people seeking asylum. And you do that because you know they've got less capacity to politically resist. Instead of making the hard decisions and maybe taxing the one per cent to get the funding to properly resource the ART so that they've got the members they need in order to make decisions, or having Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place and resource that, no, no, no—Labor and the coalition want to punch down on marginalised people, because they think there'll be no resistance. Well, the Greens are resisting it, on behalf of all those Australians who need someone in their corner—because they sure as hell don't have Labor or the coalition in their corner.

And of course there was incredible confusion in the rationale from the Attorney-General's Department on the proposed extent to which they intend to use this power. The chief executive officer and principal registrar of the ART, Mr Hawkins, made clear that they don't expect to use the power in complex cases, so of course there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases, as, again, Mr Hawkins explained, because no-one from the Attorney-General's Department could explain when they wanted to use this power to get rid of the need for written reasons. Mr Hawkins said:

I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.

Well, we're going to take Mr Hawkins up on that suggestion, and that's exactly what the Greens amendments do. They do this because we're going in to bat for people who have less power. These amendments say that the only circumstances in which the tribunal cannot provide written decisions are when the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. For the reasons put forward by Mr Hawkins, the principal registrar, and for the reasons put forward in so many submissions to the tribunal—and just for basic decency—we commend these amendments to the Senate.

Comments

No comments