This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

1:01 pm

I'm not sure that answered the question, but we could probably try again and get the same non-answer to the core question. Of course the legislation contains none of those safeguards. The legislation just gives a power for registrars to dismiss where there are no reasonable prospects of success. A small subset of those matters may have an objective element to them—like failing to attach the English language certificate. But the legislation is in no way limited to that. The government was unable to provide a draft direction from the principal registrar. When questioned, the principal registrar could provide no clarity on what the principal registrar's thoughts were for a direction. You're just providing this incredibly broad power that, if it's not abused by this principal registrar or this attorney-general, could well be abused by a future one because there are no statutory protections.

The amendments that the Greens are moving here on sheet 4132 are based upon the evidence we got from the Law Council. The Law Council said that they oppose these changes to give registrars these kinds of powers. They were unambiguous about it. They said it's bad—bad for the independence of the tribunal, bad for individual justice—and that registrars are not the right people in the tribunal to have the power. But they then said, 'Well, look, if you are going to insist upon these changes, put some legislative safeguards in.' This is what is picked up in our amendments on sheet 4132.

The Law Council said in their submission that, while they preferred for these changes not to happen, if they do happen, there should be the following: 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-admission experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. We'll just stop there. We got some kind of woolly statement from the minister then that there are some kind of criteria required for registrars in the selection process, but they are not the minimums that the Law Council is calling for. To be clear, that was 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-administration experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. That should be a limitation.

They also said 'a qualification requiring that a registrar be required to consult with a senior member or the relevant jurisdictional area leader where uncertain about a finding before committing to that finding'. So get some advice from someone who knows and who has the qualifications and the independence.

The third point they said was 'ensuring that, if an application is dismissed under this power, this will not prevent an applicant being able to make a request to the media to the minister under section 351 of the Migration Act or for the ART to continue to be able to refer a matter for consideration to the minister under that section'. Lastly, they said 'an express requirement that, before an application is dismissed, the applicant must be given notice that the registrar has formed a view that it may be appropriate to dismiss an application and the applicant be provided an opportunity to be heard specifically on that question'. They continued:

A failure to give notice or to hear the applicant should be expressed as rendering any dismissal to be of no effect.

These are the amendments that are contained in the Greens amendments on sheet 4132. For those reasons, we commend the amendments to the Senate.

Comments

No comments