This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
12:53 pm
by leave—I move the amendments on sheet 4132 together:
(1) Schedule 1, page 4 (before line 5), before item 1, insert:
1A After section 101
Insert
101A Dismissal by registrars where no reasonable prospects of success
(1) Before a registrar exercises a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) in relation to an application for a proceeding, the registrar must:
(a) if the registrar is not certain it is appropriate to exercise the power—consult a senior member in the relevant jurisdictional area; and
(b) give written notice to each party to the proceeding that the registrar is considering exercising the power and invite the parties to make submissions in response to the notice by a day specified in the notice (which must be no less than 14 days after the notice is given); and
(c) consider any submissions made in response to the notice before the day specified in the notice.
Note: A registrar may be authorised by the President to perform or exercise certain functions or powers of the Tribunal (see section 285).
(2) The exercise of a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) by a registrar is not valid if the registrar fails to comply with subsection (1).
(2) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), omit "this Act.", substitute "this Act; and".
(3) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), at the end of the item, add:
(d) a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) must not be exercised by a registrar unless:
(i) the registrar has obtained a degree from a university, or an educational qualification of a similar standing, in the field of law; and
(ii) in the opinion of the President, the registrar has sufficient experience in the field of law to exercise the power.
Labor and the coalition have done a stitch-up job here, as they usually do. They have come up with a process where whereby registrars will now be empowered to dismiss matters where a registrar forms the view that there are no reasonable prospects of success.
Now, let's say a couple of things. I'm sure registrars are all very nice. I'm sure that they're all people largely trying to do the right thing. But they do not have tenure of appointment. They're just members of the executive. They're not members of the tribunal; they're members of the executive and can be hired and fired by the principal registrar without any statutory protection. They don't even have to have the legal qualifications of a member, and they're being given the power to dismiss matters, when they have a subjective view about whether or not the matter has reasonable prospects of success.
As the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said in their submission to the inquiry on this bill—a neat summary of their position is: this is a dumb idea, it undermines the independence of the tribunal, and registrars are not the right people to make that decision. I will just read into the record some of what Joshua Strutt from IARC said:
You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members.
Members and senior members are not registrars. Members and senior members are statutory appointments, they have statutory protections, and they're there to make the decisions. Registrars are just employees. Mr Strutt went further:
We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.
When we asked the Attorney-General's Department about this, they asserted that registrars would be using this power only in 'objective circumstances'. When we asked them how tests such as reasonableness could be objective—reasonableness is the quintessential subjective test. From a legal perspective, the test that is so obviously subjective, that doesn't actually have objective parameters that you look to, is reasonableness. So, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department, 'How could you say that giving registrars the ability to knock off matters where there are no reasonable prospects of success would be an exercise of objective decision-making against objective criteria?' they just floundered and failed to even address the issue.
Now, maybe that's the advice that the government's been getting. I'd be interested to know from the minister: does the Attorney-General accept the position from the Attorney-General's Department that a test of whether or not a matter has reasonable prospects for success is an objective test? Does the Attorney-General adopt that evidence from the Attorney-General's Department?
No comments