This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
David Pocock ACT, Independent
1:24 pm
The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is a bill that my team and I have been looking at, grappling with. I had planned to vote in support of this bill until yesterday, with the amendment that was circulated by the government and passed. Clearly there is a real problem with the backlog in the migration case load, and it needs to be addressed. As Senator Cash pointed out in her second reading speech, the tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration matters, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. This should not be allowed to continue. This has a huge impact on people's lives. Visa applicants should not be forced to wait years for an outcome. The cost of those delays is huge.
I accept what the government has said about some applications being made without reasonable prospects of success. The Law Council and others, as has been canvassed in this debate, have talked about the need for greater efficiency—but weighed against real concerns about access to justice and the rule of law. I take seriously the concerns about expanded registrar powers, oral reasons and identity verification. On balance, though, my view had been that the need to fix the backlog outweighed those concerns.
Then, the government circulated the amendment on sheet IE116, which the Senate just agreed to. It lets the minister promote a general member to senior member without the publicly advertised, merit based assessment that the ART Act otherwise requires. The president is asked for advice. There is no advertising, no open competition and no assessment panel. The decision then sits with the minister. I thought this was the whole point of Labor getting rid of the AAT. We heard so much about it when Labor was in opposition—about jobs for mates and all the things that were wrong with the AAT—to the point where it got abolished. The former attorney-general in particular fought very hard to fix the issues, and I commend him for it. Merit based, publicly advertised appointments were the centrepiece of the new tribunal, and this amendment, which the government put forward and the coalition supported, seems to disrespect the work of the Hon. Mark Dreyfus in fighting for a merit based process so that we can have trust in the ART. I'll read a quote from the Prime Minister at a doorstop interview in May 2024, shortly after the AAT was replaced by the ART:
Now, we have replaced the AAT this week. We've gotten rid of it. Gotten rid of it … We've abolished it, gotten rid of it and replaced it with the Administrative Review Tribunal, which will be more rigorous, which will not be full of former party political appointments.
It's amazing what can happen in a couple of years. The amendment that just passed is a step backwards, towards the bad old days, and I suspect many in Labor know that. Before the AAT was abolished, appointments were tarnished by cronyism. There were so many criticisms and allegations about the way that the appointments process worked. Given that, I think this is a poisoned pill in this bill. Canberrans want to see appointments generally, but particularly to our Administrative Review Tribunal, based on merit and merit alone. It is just not good enough for this Labor government to introduce that amendment.
So, Minister, I'd love to hear from you and the government. I certainly didn't see, in any of the submissions or anything put forward by witnesses, suggestions that the government should water down the merit based appointment process. Where has this idea come from, and why is the government watering down the merit based process that was put into place by former attorney-general Mark Dreyfus?
No comments