This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
11:20 am
I rise to speak on the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. I have to say that, sadly, this bill is yet another reminder of the extraordinary incompetence with which the former attorney-general, Mark Dreyfus, approached the reform of Australia's administrative review system. Mr Dreyfus, as we know, was determined to abolish the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Sadly, for the Australian people—and this has now been borne out in the statistics that we will go through shortly—that was a politically driven decision dressed up as administrative reform. But, rather than fixing the existing system, he abolished it and replaced it with an entirely new institution.
At the time, when he was allocating around $1 billion of taxpayers' money to his new politically driven system, he promised Australians a more accessible, efficient and effective system of administrative review. As I said, he had around $1 billion over five years that he utilised to establish and support the new tribunal and address what he said at that time were associated migration related court backlogs—$1 billion of taxpayers' money. I challenge any taxpayer: if you were given $1 billion over a five-year period, what would you do to utilise that? Certainly, it wouldn't be what the former attorney-general ended up doing. With $1 billion of taxpayers' funding, one might say that Australians are entitled to expect a carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented reform. Instead, what have Australians got since this reform took place? Well, it was the most expensive changing of one letter. AAT went to ART—$1 billion of taxpayers' funds. But this has been the result of what the former attorney-general did: growing backlogs, extraordinary delays and a government now repeatedly having to return to the parliament to repair Mr Dreyfus's failed legislative framework. That is now the legacy of the $1 billion reform.
The coalition is going to support this bill. Why? Because we believe that Australians need an administrative review system that works. But our support for this legislation should not be mistaken for approval of the way Labor have sadly handled this exercise. Mr Dreyfus designed the new tribunal, Labor implemented it, and the Albanese government must now answer for its abysmal performance. Sadly, it cannot run away from the figures, and those figures are damning. According to the tribunal's 2025-26 annual report, the ART received 86,980 applications during this year, but it only finalised 65,900. By 30 June 2026, it had 133,749 applications on hand. Remember, this is Mr Dreyfus's new whiz-bang tribunal. That was an increase of over 19 per cent from the previous year. In other words, we're not getting any better. The $1 billion dollars of the taxpayer funding that has been allocated to this disastrous reform is getting worse. That was June—133,749 applications on hand. Worse than that, a few months later, in September—July, August, September, 12 weeks later; you've got to love this—the outstanding caseload has actually risen to 136,236 applications. In other words, this new whizz-bang tribunal meant to go back to what was promised—carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented—has now more than 136,000 matters that are awaiting resolution. You can't run away from that because they're the tribunal's own figures. But that is the reality behind Labor's promise of a faster, more efficient tribunal.
What is even worse—and this should worry all taxpayers—is that the position is particularly alarming on both migration and protection. At the end of September, the tribunal reportedly had 85,221 migration matters and 34,546 protection matters on hand—almost 120,000 outstanding applications, around 88 per cent of the entire backlog—and more than 54,000 student visa review matters alone. As I said, you can't run away from these figures, because they're the tabled figures from the Administrative Review Tribunal. They now expose the enormous pressure of Labor's migration failures. They can only be described as failures. If you were doing something positive, you'd actually be going backwards, heading towards zero, in terms of the figures. Sadly, that is not what is actually occurring.
When it went to a committee, we heard evidence that approximately 90 per cent of protection visa applicants who seek merits review are unsuccessful, while fewer than three per cent of the relevant judicial review applications were allowed in 2024-25. Those figures alone demonstrate why Australians deserve a system capable of resolving matters efficiently and identifying applications without merit. Remember, it's the Australian taxpayer that's paying for these reviews. A review system overwhelmed by delay is failing the people who genuinely need it, but it's also failing the Australian taxpayers, who are paying for it.
Again, the delays are actually staggering. The tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration reviews, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. Multiply that out. It's 136 weeks. There are 52 weeks in a year. That's more than 2½ years for the median family and partner matter. How, when you allocated $1 billion of taxpayers' money over five years, can you describe that as timely access to administrative justice?
So what exactly did Australians receive for the billion dollar redesign? The tribunal's performance against its targets is equally concerning. In 2025-26, it reportedly finalised only 42 per cent of migration and protection matters within 18 months against a target of 75 per cent. So we don't even ask them to reach 100 per cent. We ask them to reach a target of 75 per cent. They miserably failed at that at 42 per cent. Across the tribunal, only 43 per cent of applications finalised during the year were completed within 12 months. The annual report also records that the tribunal was 90.4 full-time-equivalent member positions below its budgeted establishment at 30 June 2026. So you chuck out the system and bring in a new one. You promise the earth to the Australian taxpayers because it's their billion dollars that you're actually utilising. Your completion times go backwards. You have fewer members than you need to actually get the job done. I have to ask the government: how do you expect to reduce the backlog when you've not ensured the tribunal has enough decision-makers to actually make the decisions? Managing demand, recruiting members and ensuring systems are fit for purpose is actually a basic responsibility of government. Sadly, I remember the speeches that were given when the billion dollars of taxpayers' funds were allocated to this new system. The former attorney-general was out there crowing and wanting the political credit for doing this. Well, guess what? If you want the political credit for doing it, the bad news is this: you also have to take the political backlash when the tribunal fails so miserably.
But it's not only that. It gets worse for the Australian taxpayer. After the original billion-dollar commitment, when it started failing almost immediately, the Labor government had to say to the Australian taxpayer: 'Sorry about that. We know it was a billion dollars we allocated. We know it hasn't quite done the job we thought it would do, but what's worse is we're now going to dip back into your pockets.' They actually provided, via the Australian taxpayer, another $69 million of hard-earned taxpayer funds over two years to address what has now become a disgraceful backlog—more money from the Australian taxpayer because the system they implemented was failing. Instead of getting better—we gave you another $69 million—the system has actually got worse. So the Australian taxpayer is quite entitled to ask, when they are under so much financial pressure at the moment, 'What in God's name have we actually received from this government after it expended our funding?' The bad news for the Australian taxpayer is that you actually receive nothing. You've received nothing but a backlog—worse than that, an increasing backlog.
It's a further indictment of this government that they have now had to come back to the parliament. This is the fourth major legislative repair package that we have had to do on behalf of the taxpayer. The government has had to come, cap in hand, to the Senate yet again, for the fourth time, to clean up the mess that Mr Dreyfus created. You had the original establishment and then the consequential legislation. You had the miscellaneous measures legislation. They had to draft it like that because they couldn't actually call it what it was, which was the 'cleaning up Dreyfus' mess' legislation. There were further amendments again, in 2025, to clean up the mess.
The tribunal have now recognised that this is still a mess, and they've had to come to the government to say, 'You've got to draft another piece of legislation,' because this is now out of control because the original legislation was politically drafted not properly drafted. The taxpayer's now paying for it. Now, this attorney-general has had to come to the parliament to say, 'Sorry, I've got another bill to clean up Labor's mess'—another correction, another adjustment and another attempt to make the system function, as we pointed out at the time, sadly. It wasn't like the Labor government weren't told, 'Your legislation is fundamentally flawed. You need to make amendments to it.' But, at the time, oh no, they knew better than us. They knew better than us because it was politically motivated. It wasn't actually drafted to do the job that the new tribunal was meant to do. Sadly, it's the Australian taxpayer who is paying a very, very high price for the Albanese government's incompetence.
That is why, as I said, we are prepared to support this legislation. We are prepared to work with the government to clean up the former attorney-general's disgraceful mess. It was Labor who chose to abolish the AAT. Mr Dreyfus designed, incompetently or for political purposes, its replacement. Labor committed the funding. They oversaw the implementation. They now can't resile from the results that are tabled by the new body. They committed around a billion dollars of taxpayer funding over five years. They then took another $69 million from the taxpayer for backlog measures. We currently have around 136,000 applications outstanding and around 120,000 migration and protection matters awaiting resolution. We are now onto the fourth major legislative package to actually deal with the disaster that this new framework has been.
Sadly, this is the record of the former attorney-general, Mr Dreyfus. As I said, the coalition will support this bill because Australians deserve a tribunal that works. We are pleased the government will put forward amendments suggested by the coalition to make the bill even better. But Labor promised a better tribunal, and sadly, after a billion dollars, all the Australian taxpayer has is growing backlogs and round 4 of fix-up legislation.
Jana Stewart Victoria, Australian Labor Party
11:35 am
I rise today to speak in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. This bill was examined by the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, which I have the privilege of chairing. I want to thank individuals and organisations who contributed to the inquiry. Their evidence and engagement played a really important role in informing the committee's consideration of the bill and its recommendation that this bill be passed. The evidence before the committee reinforced a simple but important point: government decision-makers must make quality decisions, and merits review and judicial review matter. That is why, two years ago, the Albanese government established the Administrative Review Tribunal.
Under the former coalition government, more than 80 Liberal and National associates and failed candidates were appointed to the AAT. An institution that should have stood for merit and independence had become tainted. The Albanese government abolished the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, the AAT, because Australians had lost confidence in it and instead legislated a new merit based appointment process. The ART now independently reviews a broad range of government decisions made under over 400 Commonwealth acts, helping to ensure that government power is exercised lawfully, fairly and transparently. Among the matters that the ART can review are certain decisions about visas made by the Department of Home Affairs, the Minister for Home Affairs or the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship. In certain circumstances, individuals can submit an online application through the tribunal's website and ask for the decision to be independently reconsidered based on its merits. This gives applicants the opportunity to explain their circumstances, to provide relevant information and to have their original decision examined through fresh eyes. Together with the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which hears applications for judicial review, these institutions help ensure government decisions can be reviewed properly. Most importantly, these systems help protect individuals and vulnerable community members against unfair or incorrect decisions. This strengthens accountability and promotes public confidence that Commonwealth laws are administered fairly and transparently.
Recently, there has been an exponential increase in applications to review migration decisions. As this caseload grows, it is especially vital that matters are resolved in a timely and efficient manner. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making and provide genuine applicants with timely outcomes. That is why this bill is about strengthening Australia's merits and judicial review system to support the ART and the Federal Circuit Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to their significant and increasing caseloads.
The first set of reforms in this bill will improve the efficiency and operation of the ART. These reforms include allowing the tribunal to explain their decision orally with written statements of reasons available upon request—notably, this change will exclude reviews of social security, veterans' entitlements, aged-care and National Disability Insurance Scheme matters—requiring applications to review eligible migration or protection decisions to be submitted using an approved form; giving tribunal members greater flexibility to move between salaried or sessional roles; giving additional powers to registrars, including to reinstate applications in certain circumstances or dismiss applications that have no reasonable prospects of success; allowing members to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons made by the registrar; and making other minor technical amendments, including clarifying that the president of the tribunal is assigned to every jurisdictional area, standardising timeframes for review for certain taxation matters and excluding 24 December to 14 January from the calculation of time for original decision-makers to provide certain documents. This matters because it allows the ART to spend less time on unnecessary administrative steps and more time resolving cases. Clearer application requirements, flexible staffing and greater powers for registrars will help matters move through the tribunal more quickly while still preserving written reasons and additional safeguards for reviews involving essential supports such as social security, veterans entitlements, aged care and the NDIS. Put simply, these reforms are about reducing avoidable delay without compromising fairness and quality of decisions. For applicants, that means greater certainty, more timely decisions and a review process that can focus its resources where they are needed most.
Secondly, this bill will strengthen the integrity of Australia's migration review system. It introduces a new power requiring applicants seeking review of certain protection and other migration decisions to verify their identity. At the same time, the bill exempts classes of people or applicants from the verification process. The rationale for this measure is straightforward: it helps ensure the applications are made by people who genuinely intend to engage with the review process and gives the tribunal and the court greater confidence in the integrity of that process. It also encourages active participation from the outset and helps ensure that the scarce resources are directed towards genuine applications.
This bill will also discourage frivolous applications that can consume valuable resources and cause unnecessary delays for applicants who are genuinely seeking review. This measure also complements earlier reforms that allow appropriate migration matters to be considered on the papers, without requiring an oral hearing in every case. Where the relevant information is already before the decision-maker, resolving a matter in this way can reduce unnecessary delay and allow resources to be focused on cases that require more detailed consideration.
Identity verification provides an additional safeguard within that more efficient process by confirming that the applicant is aware of and engaged with the review. For matters before the tribunal, an applicant who is required to verify their identity but does not do so will have their review application dismissed. It is important to note that the bill also includes important safeguards to ensure that fairness remains at the centre of the review process while recognising the distinct role of the courts under our constitutional framework. Applicants who are unable to satisfy identity verification requirements are not left without an option. Mechanisms exist for matters to be reinstated and, where proceedings are before the courts, judicial discretion is preserved so that individual circumstances can be properly considered. This ensures the system remains accessible to genuine applicants while supporting the integrity of Australia's merits and judicial review framework.
Taken together, these reforms reflect the Albanese government's commitment to strong, independent and effective institutions. These reforms will improve efficiency without sacrificing fairness. They will strengthen the integrity of the migration review system and help ensure that Australians have confidence in decisions made by government and the mechanisms available to review them. This practical reform builds on the government's broader work to restore trust in administrative review and ensure our review institutions remain fit for purpose. I commend the bill to the Senate.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
11:44 am
I rise on behalf of the Greens to indicate we have significant concerns about the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026, and we'll be moving amendments to the legislation to seek to address those. If those amendments are not supported—and it seems clear that Labor and coalition senators are on a unity ticket to create unfairness—we will not be supporting this legislation.
The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill seeks to make three major changes to the operation of the Administrative Review Tribunal. All are crafted as producing efficiencies, and we just heard from the government senator, Senator Stewart, the argument that this is all designed for fairness and to ensure people's rights are protected. It's far from it. The entire thrust of this legislation is to take away rights, to take away fair process and to greatly limit the rights of people before the Administrative Review Tribunal, all dressed up by the government and the coalition, who are on a unity ticket here, as efficiency, but what it actually means is meanness and the taking away of people's rights.
We do know how to actually make the system fairer. We do know how to make the system more efficient. The way you do that is by providing legal assistance to genuine applicants, and you do that in the migration stream and across the board in the ART. It's been done before and, each time it's been done before, it's worked. Between 2006 and 2009, there was a pilot program instituted in the then AAT and in the community legal centres that support refugee claims. That was incredibly successful. The community care pilot also saw caseworkers instead of going out to put people in detention who were in breach of their visa conditions who might have overstayed. They sent caseworkers out to work with people and work out what was going on in their lives. It turns out that, when you treat people as people, not problems, you resolve matters. There was a radical improvement in compliance. Many people just had significant financial barriers to getting their visa situation sorted. Some of them just had a financial barrier that meant they couldn't go home. Some of them had children that they needed to stay for in order to be parents. They just needed help. It turned out that, when caseworkers went instead of Border Force, that the compliance rate was in the mid to high 90s. If you treat people like humans, like they matter, and don't punch down on them like Labor, the coalition and One Nation seem to do, it actually works.
We know that, in more recent history, there was a short-lived—should be permanent—program to give legal assistance to people, particularly to legal aid and community legal centres, to provide legal assistance to help people who are otherwise unrepresented bring an asylum claim to the ART. What did you find in that? You again found rapid turnarounds, matters being rapidly resolved instead of hanging around for months or for years, meritorious applications being approved rapidly, people getting their visas sorted, and people who didn't have a meritorious application being told that by a well-qualified, capable lawyer. Those applications just won't run. I really want to commend the work of legal aid and community legal centres across the country who made that project work. Of course, the government then cut the funding, but, if you look, for example, at what Victoria Legal Aid did with that funding, they had that increased funding from July 2024 to June 2025. They assisted 620 unique clients with more than 2,000 legal services provided to them. That provided 800 separate pieces of legal advice and 147 separate representations, and 90 per cent of those matters saw positive outcomes, including decisions refusing protection visas being overturned, matters remitted to the ART for further review and, when they went to the ART—because they'd gone with careful legal advice, they were determined quickly—90 per cent of those protection visa reviews had significant positive feedback from the tribunal.
The tribunal is thankful when this happens. As one tribunal member said: 'Any tribunal member who's presided over a matter with an unrepresented applicant would appreciate the work of lawyers in representing the applicant's case so well.' Hearings were shorter, decisions were made quickly, and, in the majority of times, decisions were delivered in just three weeks after the final hearing because the issues are crystallised, the evidence is narrowed down, and the case is presented. That is the answer to the backlog. Reinstate the legal funding that used to be applied so that meritorious cases are run well and efficiently, that the tribunal is given the assistance they need and that unmeritorious cases are given early legal advice that they just won't get up. But, of course, what does this government do? What does Labor do? They just reject all of that evidence and decide to punch down on migrants, like they do so often.
It's for those reasons that I move the second reading amendment circulated in my name. I move:
At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate acknowledges that:
(a) wait times in visa processing began to increase in 2014 after cuts to legal assistance; and
(b) the way to reduce backlogs and ensure a fair and fast visa processing system is to fully fund legal assistance".
I commend that second reading amendment to the Senate, because that's actually how you fix backlogs and how you produce efficiency.
Instead, what do this government do? They do three things. The first is expanding the registrar's role, and registrars aren't even always legally qualified. They absolutely don't have security of tenure, like permanent members do, and they do not have the security of appointed members. They're basically employees of the executive. They are not full tribunal members. They're employees of the executive open to be hired and fired by the executive. What does this government propose to do? It wants to grant registrars the power to dismiss applications if the registrar is 'satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success'.
Submission after submission to the inquiry said that this was wrong. I want to particularly point out the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre, the Kaldor Centre and the Law Council of Australia. Every submission from a credible entity said don't do this. For example, Carina Ford from the Law Council of Australia said:
I think the difficulty with migration decisions is that they are not generally objective. They do require a level of assessment at the level of a member. There might be some cases that could fall within it. For example, there could be a case where English language testing wasn't attached to a time of application case. But overall there is a level of assessment. A good example is the student visa case load. That has moved to decisions on the papers, and it still requires the criteria to be assessed because it is subjective.
The proposal is we'll give employees of the ART, not tribunal members, the ability to dismiss matters on a subjective test. That's a fundamentally judicial or quasijudicial power, and it should not be exercised by employees who can be hired and fired by the principal registrar.
As the Kaldor Centre noted—here I particularly want to credit the work of Professor Daniel Ghezelbash. They noted:
Not only do these amendments have significant adverse impacts on the ability of applicants to access review of their protection visa applications but they are also likely to generate further litigation and appeals, shifting delays downstream to the Federal Circuit and Family Court rather than resolving them.
That's what we're likely to see here—the ART making decisions, alleging that there are no reasonable prospects for success, making that decision on the papers, having it done by a registrar and then that leading to appeals in the ART and then a raft of separate appeals to the Federal Circuit and Family Court, clogging up the system, costing taxpayers' money and failing to address with the merits of the case. These changes are bad law. They are bad law, and they will undermine the integrity of the ART, and, for those reasons, the Greens will be opposing them, and we're in good company with pretty much every credible legal organisation and advocate in the space saying these laws should not be made.
The second problem with this legislation is about the proposed changes about verification of identity. There is a proposal here for the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet as yet unspecified identity verification requirements. The details of that information on this change are absent from the bill, totally absent, and, instead, the government have claimed that they're going to somehow be implemented through regulations and that, of course, that's sufficient. Regulations have much less parliamentary oversight and less engagement from key stakeholders. This lack of knowledge about how it worked was made clear when we asked, for example, the principal registrar of the ART what the procedures would be like. Mr Hawkins—credit to him—said:
We understand that the applicant will need to present to a tribunal either in person or virtually, the details of which I'm yet to see, their identity.
The tribunal has no idea how it's going to happen. Then he said:
Given that we're dealing with a current caseload, I understand that it's from applications from a particular period in time onwards.
Then, when pressed about it, he said very clearly that the tribunal had no idea how it would work. Then, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department how it worked, this is the exchange we got. I asked Ms Inverarity of the department:
So the Hazara woman has fled with her children to Australia from Afghanistan. She has never had a passport and never had travel documents and has come onshore. The Afghan embassy has shut. She obviously isn't going to go and approach the Taliban in Afghanistan for identity documents because then her family could well be persecuted and killed. What processes will there be in place for a woman in that situation to have her identity verification assessed and not have a mandatory dismissal of her application?
The department said:
I can't give you an answer with the precision that will make you happy other than that I have referred already to the fact that this is an issue that is already well known to the Australian government. The National Identity Proofing Guidelines cover the need for alternative proofing arrangements for people who do not have the traditional suite of identity documents.
There are no answers—no answers to the tribunal and no answers to the parliament—and yet this legislation is being rammed through.
This change disproportionately impacts the most marginalised, such as people experiencing domestic and family violence. It's well documented that control over identification documents is a common form of coercion by abusers. That's true of family abuse as well as abusive employers. And yet this government is pushing through legislation knowing who's going to be harmed by it—the most marginal people—adding that coercive control power to employers and abusive partners, who can just withhold the documents. It's outrageous.
Then the third issue of concern for us is the proposal to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. As the Refugee Council of Australia noted in its submission:
Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the Tribunal's findings, decision making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.
Then there was confusion as to why this was happening between the department and the ART. Again, Mr Hawkins made clear that they weren't expecting to use the power in complex cases, although there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases. As Mr Hawkins explained:
I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.
But there's no limitation in the bill to have it only on successful applications—none at all. Matters can be dismissed with no reasons given and then, if you want reasons, you've got to go through this further complex process to try and get reasons, all while your appeal rights are ticking away and the time limits are ticking away. There's more complication and more bureaucracy. Who's going to be impacted most in this? The most marginal people. Each of these elements punches down on the most marginal people in the system.
Of course, that's what Labor are doing in the migration space because they're not actually chasing fairness. They're not actually chasing efficiency. If they wanted efficiency and fairness, they'd properly fund the legal system. They'd give people actual representation and make it better for the tribunal. They'd make the Department of Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place so they're not constantly being appealed. But they don't want to make the department do their work properly. They don't want to properly fund actual legal representation. They want to chase One Nation. That's what this is about. Again, Labor are chasing One Nation with their meanness, their nastiness and their punching down on migrants. That's what this legislation is. They can speak what they like about efficiency. The only efficiency here is meanness. That's why the Greens will be opposing it.
Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party
11:59 am
I rise in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. Last financial year, the median time to finalise a family or partner visa review was more than 2½ years. For a family living apart, it can mean another birthday over a video call. It can mean telling your children again that you still don't know when you all will be able to live together.
The Albanese Labor government established the Administrative Review Tribunal in October 2024. Political appointments had damaged confidence in the old Administrative Appeals Tribunal. We put transparent, merit based appointments into law so that people could trust that the people hearing their case have been chosen for their expertise. The tribunal gives people an independent place to challenge a range of Commonwealth decisions. It can look at the facts again, consider new evidence and decide on what the correct or preferable outcome is. Through judicial review, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia can examine whether a migration decision was made according to the law. Our government has funded the tribunal to work through older migration and protection cases. The tribunal finalised more than 27,000 of those cases in the first year of that work. But even with that progress, it has almost 134,000 applications on hand at the end of June. Nearly nine in 10 were migration or protection matters. We absolutely owe it to the people waiting to make sure that the tribunal's time goes to where it's needed.
Under this bill, the tribunal's president can authorise a registrar to dismiss an application if there is no reasonable prospect of success. Take a case where the law sets out a clear eligibility requirement and the facts show that the applicant may not meet those requirements. An authorised registrar could deal with that case. The president can set conditions on that authority and it can also authorise registrars to reinstate certain dismissed applications. It gives tribunal members more time for the cases that need it. Someone seeking protection may have to tell the tribunal about some of the most frightening things that have happened to them. That member needs time to hear their account, weigh the evidence and consider what could happen if that person absolutely had to return home.
Earlier reforms gave the tribunal more scope to decide some cases on the papers. This bill gives it more flexibility in how it explains its decisions. In eligible cases, a member can give reasons orally. The parties can still get the outcomes in writing; if a party asks for written reasons within the time allowed, the tribunal must provide them. Where the parties already have the explanations they need, the member can spend that time on the next case. Written reasons will continue to be provided as a matter of course for reviews concerning social security, veterans' entitlements, aged care and the National Disability Insurance Scheme. If you're seeking a review of your NDIS plan, a written explanation gives you something that you can sit down with an advocate or a family member and work through. You can take the time to understand what the decision means for the support that you rely on every single day.
I'd like to extend my thanks to Senator Jana Stewart for chairing the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee's inquiry, and also the secretariat and everyone who gave evidence to this inquiry. We heard how hard it can be to take on a decision and all the reasons in it in one sitting, especially if you're relying on an interpreter or representing just yourself. In a migration review, an applicant would generally have 14 days from an oral decision to ask for written reasons. The usual deadline for seeking judicial review is 35 days from the decision. If you need those reasons to get legal advice, you could still be waiting for them as the court deadline approaches. The Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee recommended that the applicants be given both deadlines in writing and that the tribunal provide any requested reasons as quickly as possible.
This bill will require an approved form for certain migration and protection reviews so that the tribunal can get the information it needs upfront. It will allow tribunal members to correct obvious errors in the registrar's orders. The Immigration Advice and Rights Centre told the inquiry about people who had applications lodged in their names without their knowledge or their consent. It also told us about people who had missed hearings because of unscrupulous operators who had failed to pass on correspondence from the tribunal. The bill introduces identity checks in certain migration and protection matters. These checks give the tribunal and the court a way to confirm who is seeking review and help make sure that people know that an application has been made in their name. Applicants covered by the requirement will be told in writing what they need to do. The tribunal must dismiss an application if the person fails to comply. The person can ask to have their case reinstated, and the tribunal must reinstate it if it considers that it is appropriate. The court can give someone more time, waive the requirement where it's appropriate or give them permission to continue if they haven't met it. Regulations will set out which cases are covered and how the checks will work.
The Attorney-General's Department told us it expects online verification to be a key part of those arrangements. In regional and remote Western Australia, it can spare someone hours of travel for a single appointment. The department also acknowledges the need for other ways to prove identity. Someone who has fled their home may have very little choice about which documents they could bring. The process needs to work for that person too. The committee recommended that this bill pass, and I thank the Attorney-General for bringing these reforms forward. I commend the bill to the Senate.
Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens
12:05 pm
Of course, I listened closely to the contribution from the previous speaker Senator Cox and want to indicate that the Australian Greens do not agree that the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should be passed. This is a fundamentally flawed piece of legislation which will, as is so often the case when the political duopoly in this country gets together, impact on some of the most marginalised people in our community.
The first concerning change in this legislation is the change to expand the registrar's role to include merits assessments. There are multiple issues with this proposal, but chief amongst them is a very basic question of justice. Registrars are employees, not appointed members, and it is proposed they be given powers well beyond their traditional, quite limited role of determining issues of process and procedure. That is the first issue with this legislation. During the inquiry process on this legislation, Mr Strutt from the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said:
You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members. We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.
Clearly, there are concerns centred around the application of justice and, indeed, the provision of natural justice to people who are going through the processes.
Of course, the government is saying that this is all about efficiency. For anyone who needs that translated, that means it's saving money for the government. This is a government that hands out tens of billions of dollars every year to massively profitable, highly polluting corporations to encourage them to keep burning fossil fuels. This is a government that's going to spend $350 billion on AUKUS nuclear submarines that are going to make Australia a more dangerous place to be if we ever get them in the first place, and, if we do get them, they'll not only make us more dangerous but be obsolete by the time that we get them. This is a government that has got plenty of cash to splash on corporate welfare, on subsidising the heating of the planet and on nuclear submarines that we may never see, but somehow they have to find efficiencies by punching down on some of the most marginal people in our community and compromising natural justice in one of our most important judicial institutions.
Another change of concern in this legislation is the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet identity verification requirements. Well, what I'm going to say here is: here we go again. Just about every significant erosion of human rights in the immigration space in this country has been led by the Australian Labor Party—mandatory immigration detention brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons on Manus Island brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons in Naoero brought to Australia and still run, at massive cost to the taxpayer, by the Australian Labor Party. They are a carceral political party. They were a party of White Australia back in the day. They've engaged in a race to the bottom and are still engaged in a race to the bottom on immigration with a coalition that is still desperately trying to outflank the fascists in One Nation on the right. And here we go again, punching down on immigrants.
Let's just imagine a case here. Let's say a woman from Afghanistan, a Hazara woman, has somehow managed to escape the clutches of the Taliban and flee with her children, some of whom are daughters, young girls, and they've managed to get to Australia. She hasn't had a passport. Her immigration documents were confiscated from her while she was escaping Afghanistan. She's come to Australia. The Afghan embassy is shut. Obviously, she can't approach the Taliban for her identity documents because who knows what would happen to the rest of her family that remain in Afghanistan? They could be abducted, tortured, killed or stoned to death. What processes are going to be in place for that woman and her family? Is she going to face a mandatory dismissal of her application because she can't prove her identity to the satisfaction of some bureaucrat in Home Affairs or some appointed official in the tribunal? What is going to happen? When these questions were raised, quite recently, by Senator Shoebridge during the inquiry into this legislation, the best that the respondent could provide was, 'Oh, well, the government's aware of this problem.' Well, that's not very reassuring! The government's aware of the problem, but it's still proceeding with a piece of legislation in the complete and utter absence of a solution. Here we go again.
This country, which used to have a White Australia policy officially and now just runs it unofficially, which exiles black-skinned and brown-skinned people to be tortured in the offshore torture centres in Manus Island and Naoero—there's not a single white-skinned person. And I can tell you, colleagues; I was there. I went to Manus Island many times, and people who've been in this chamber long enough will recall my advocacy for the men who were exiled to Manus Island and my very firm view, supported by Amnesty International, that what was done to those people constitutes the legal definition of 'torture' under international law. And I'm telling you, as someone who went to Manus Island, who was inside the Lombrum detention centre at the time the Australian government—albeit then a Liberal government but with the full support, I might add, of the Australian Labor Party—withdrew the food, the drinking water and the medical supports and cut off the electricity to 650 people who'd been incarcerated there illegally under Australian and international law for years. And do you know how many white-skinned people there were? I'll tell you. None—not a single white-skinned person.
Don't tell me that, if a boatload of South African farmers had arrived on our shores, they would have ended up exiled to Manus Island. We know they would not have, because offshore detention was and remains, today, a racist policy in this country. The impacts of these changes will be racist because they will have greater impact on a larger number of non-white people. Let's name these changes for what they are. But it won't just be about the colour of people's skin. Some of the most marginalised people in our community will fall foul of these changes, including people who are experiencing and trying to flee from domestic or family violence.
The final aspect of concern in this bill that I want to talk about are the proposed changes to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. Senator Bleyer, as a lawyer—I'm going to make an assumption here—will have something to say about these changes. Just imagine this scenario, colleagues, should this legislation pass and there's removal of the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made. Yes, applicants will be able to request written reasons, but that process can take as long as 28 days, when you have an appeal window of 35 days. So, instead of someone getting their written reasons on day one and having seven weeks to consider whether they want to prepare and lodge an appeal, they will now have as little as seven days to do what they previously had seven weeks to do. This is manifestly unfair. It is an absolute abrogation of natural justice.
You can measure a government by the way it looks after some of the most marginalised people it governs. I've been through some of the ancient history of the Australian Labor Party; the recent history of the Australian Labor Party in caring for vulnerable and marginalised people has been abject. Just in the last month, we've seen huge cuts to the National Disability Insurance Scheme that will place the very lives of disabled people at increased risk and mean that large numbers of disabled people in our community will no longer be able to lead lives with a measure of human dignity. Off the back of that, we now have these changes, which, again, are a denial of natural justice and procedural fairness.
It is worth pointing out that most migration applicants appear unrepresented at the ART. For many of them, English is a second, third or fourth language, and their English-language skills may not be of the highest order. Removing the requirement for written reasons when decisions are made means that people who may not have comprehensive English understanding are going to verbally have presented to them a complex rationale for a decision that may ultimately be life or death for them. Then, they'll have to go through the process of requesting a written reason, which, before it gets provided to them, can take four-fifths of their appeal window.
And I'll tell you something else about not having to provide a written reason. It will almost certainly degrade the quality of decision-making. I'll use an example that will be familiar to every single sitting senator in this place, and that is jotting down notes for a speech. The actual act of writing a speech can help you clarify your thinking. We all know that. But, if there's no requirement for written reasons, then decisions will almost inevitably be based on a gut feeling, and then you will find people will reverse engineer an argument if they are required to provide written reasons. That is the problem here. You will get written reasons that are reverse engineered to fit a decision that was made without the person having to sit down and write out the reasons. (Time expired.)
Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens
12:20 pm
The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should not be passed. When I was an immigration lawyer, a young lady, a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, obtained a student visa to come to Australia, to experience another country and to pursue her tertiary education. It was the first time she had ever left home, and it was a very big deal for her and her family. A reason why she decided to take that big step was because her boyfriend, also a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, successfully obtained a student visa to travel to Australia to undertake his tertiary studies.
Sadly for both of them, during their time studying in Australia, they broke up. Like happens sometimes, their break-up was messy. During the course of their break-up, the young man went to the police and had the young lady charged with assault for hitting him with a container of chilli. But through that process the police came to her apartment. The police arrested her. The police took her to the cop shop. They interviewed her. They charged her with assault and then she was released on bail. That was a traumatic experience for her and her family.
She went back home to her apartment in this country and took some time to recover from that terrifying experience she had suffered. Then there was a knock at the door, and who pushed through the door? A number of Border Force officers. They detained her and they put her in immigration detention. Why? Because that criminal offence, despite pleading not guilty to it, was decided by the government to mean that she was a risk to the safety of the Australian community. A 19-year-old Chinese citizen with no prior criminal history in her home country, this country or anywhere else in the world, who was innocently attending this country as an experience to fulfil her tertiary education, was now in immigration detention. She contacted me to act as her immigration lawyer, and, of course, I immediately filed an appeal with the tribunal appealing the decision to cancel her visa.
As a result of that, I was able to participate in an efficient system in the tribunal, a system that says if you are appealing a visa cancellation decision and you are locked up in inhumane immigration detention then within a couple of days you can apply for a bridging visa to be released from immigration detention. We embraced that efficiency. Despite that she was in immigration detention in Melbourne and despite that I was working as an immigration lawyer between Tasmania and Victoria, the first available tribunal member to hear her application to get her out of immigration detention was in Sydney. But that was okay; we would take every opportunity that we could to right this injustice and get her out of jail. So we went to Sydney; Border Force flew her there. She was brought into the tribunal room in shackles—a 19-year-old Chinese citizen who was defending an alleged criminal offence was in shackles. The application for a bridging visa to release this young lady from immigration detention was successful. That is an example of an efficiency rightly placed in favour of a victim of the system.
Let's have a look at what changes this federal Labor government is proposing in a race to the bottom with One Nation and the Liberals on migration. There is a proposal to deny student visa holders to have their family come to Australia to be with them. Had that been the case for this young lady, she would have been deprived of the opportunity to have her family with her when she was going through her first relationship break-up, with her first boyfriend; when she was arrested and interviewed by the police; when she was criminally charged by the police—to which she pleaded not guilty; and when she was released on bail.
Her bridging visa application was granted. She proceeded to defend the criminal charge that she had been confronted with for hitting her then boyfriend with a container of chilli. But, understandably, she left this country, deprived of her opportunity for travel to broaden the mind, by reason of the atrocious experience that she had when she was here.
Again, I'll go back to the good news story in this terrifying set of circumstances, and that is the existing efficiency in the tribunal system that meant she was able to be released from immigration detention within a handful of days.
When I was an immigration lawyer, I acted for a young man who was about 20. He's a New Zealand citizen, and he travelled to Australia. As I expect my colleagues in this chamber are aware, he was naturally granted a temporary 444 visa, as New Zealand citizens are. He came here to fill a labour shortage. Whilst at an Aussie pub, watching an Aussie game of AFL, with a few blokes who'd probably had one too many beers, he engaged in a minor scuffle amongst others at the pub. He was criminally charged for assault. After he was arrested, after he was interviewed by the police and after he was charged with a minor assault and released on bail, what do you know? Border Force officers turned up at his place and dragged him off to immigration detention because he was also suddenly a risk to the safety of the Australian community.
Again, I was able to embrace the efficiency of the tribunal and have an urgent hearing to have him released on a bridging visa. He stayed here and defended the criminal charges. But, before the criminal hearing was determined, we had the tribunal hearing to appeal the visa cancellation decision. To the shock of me and my legal colleagues at the time, we did not succeed, and the visa cancellation decision was upheld. That meant that the bridging visa came to an end and that he could choose to sit in immigration detention while he was waiting for the criminal matter to be dealt with or he could go home to New Zealand, but he was on bail—now what was he going to do? But, in any event, we appealed the unsuccessful visa cancellation decision to the Federal Court system, and we were able to give him sound advice as to whether he had any grounds for appeal and, if so, what his prospects of success were because we had not just the decision but the written reasons for the decision. I can tell you that it would be hard for you to find any competent lawyer in this country that can tell you that they can properly advise their client as to whether they have grounds for appeal and whether those grounds have any prospects of success without having the written reasons of the decision-maker.
This proposed amendment to create an efficiency by enabling tribunal decision-makers to not provide written reasons for decisions will only create inefficiencies later. Let me tell you how. We would have to take a punt and say: 'Well, just like we told you, you should have had prospects of succeeding at the tribunal. We can only tell you again that the decision must be wrong, so you must have prospects of success in the Federal Court system.' We would file an application in the Federal Court, supported by flimsy grounds for appeal, then we'd be requesting the written reasons from the tribunal. We'd have to wait for them. Meanwhile, the Federal Court process would have commenced, then we'd have to cause an inefficiency in the Federal Court, because we'd have to seek leave to amend the grounds for appeal because we would finally have the written reasons.
What if the situation arose where, when we get the written reasons for the decision, we're in a position to advise the client that there aren't really grounds for appeal with prospects of success? We've wasted the time of the Federal Court—further time, because we now need to withdraw the appeal to the Federal Court system. The client has paid the thousands-of-dollars filing fee to the Federal Court, which isn't refundable, and the client has paid the lawyers. I was quite affordable, but who knows how many thousands of dollars the client has paid the lawyer to draft the application and the grounds of appeal—only to have to withdraw it by reason of having to wait for the written reasons for decision.
There is no way that these amendments allowing tribunal members to not provide written reasons for decision when they make their decision will bestow any efficiencies on this system. We have to look at the bigger system—not just the tribunal system but also the court system that can, and often does, follow it. The reason that we have appeal processes is that there are times when decision-makers get things wrong. When decision-makers get things wrong, we need a fair appeal system, and it is not a fair appeal system to give someone a decision without any written reasons, because it sets them up for failure in respect of an unfair appeal system. This bill's attempt at efficiency instead promotes inefficiency and seeks to cut corners at the cost of fairness and people's rights. Our legal system in this country is governed by the principle of procedural fairness. How can we be in this chamber and say that we support our fundamental principle of procedural fairness when we are seeking to pass a bill today that is designed to create an even more unfair system than that which already exists?
As senators, we should be here to make better laws. We should be here to turn unfair systems into fair ones. We are not here and should not be here to make unfair systems more unfair. I don't know what lawyers this federal Labor government might have been talking to when they thought it was a good idea to let tribunal members off the hook and not have to give written reasons for decisions, but it wasn't me. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues that I worked with for plenty of years. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues who I've had the opportunity to consult with over this bill. Every single one of them will tell you what I have said today, and that is that letting tribunal members off the hook and not give written reasons for decisions has an adverse impact on fairness and procedural justice, and interferes with the rights of people who should have an opportunity to participate in a fair justice system. It's our responsibility to make it so. (Time expired)
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:36 pm
The purpose of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is to enhance the efficiency and responsiveness of the Administrative Review Tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to the significant and increasing caseloads. The bill further strengthens the tribunal by empowering it with more tools to make decisions in an efficient and timely manner while ensuring applicants have a meaningful opportunity to present their case to the tribunal. The bill also enhances the operations of the tribunal and the court in relation to migration and protection matters. The bill recognises that merits and judicial review processes should be efficient and proportionate to the complexity of the issues and the importance of what is at stake. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making, provide genuine applicants with the benefit of a timely and effective remedy and strengthen the integrity of the review system.
This bill has been informed by the tribunal's operational experience over almost two years, and the bill makes a range of amendments to ensure the tribunal can make decisions effectively and without delay. In particular, the bill amends the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 and the Migration Act 1958 to enable the ART to give reasons for a decision orally, rather than always in writing, with written statements of reasons to be given at the request of a party. A written record of decision will continue to always be provided to parties. These changes apply to matters in the ART's migration caseload as well as other caseloads where the ART resources could be saved because written reasons may not always be required. The bill provides important safeguards for vulnerable applicants of the ART and will not apply these changes to reviews relating to social security, veterans entitlements, the National Disability Insurance Scheme, aged care and where written reasons may play an important role.
The bill also makes several other efficiency amendments, including to enable the president of the ART to authorise registrars to exercise additional powers, recognising the important role that they play in running the ART smoothly. Registrars will support members to reinstate applications in certain circumstances and to dismiss applications if satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success. We'll also require applicants to seek ART review of a reviewable migration or reviewable protection decision by using an approved form. This ensures the tribunal has relevant information it needs upfront and avoids unnecessary chasing of information when a tribunal could be dedicating its efforts to managing its significant caseload. It will also permit any member or other authorised member of the ART to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons for the decision made by the registrar.
The bill will require the government to take into account the president's advice on more matters when considering the reappointment of a non-judicial member, including on the ART's operational needs and financial capacity. The bill will enable the Governor-General to vary the appointment of a non-judicial member to a salary to sessional or vice versa during the term of their appointment. This creates greater flexibility to respond to change, including in response to varying case load demands. It also specifies when certain documents need to be provided to the tribunal, assigns the president to every jurisdictional area and, subject to the passage of the government's amendments, further streamlines the tribunal appointment processes by creating a new appointment process for suitably qualified and experienced general members to be promoted to senior member before the end of their current term without requiring a full further merit-based recruitment process.
To improve the integrity of the migration review framework, the bill will also introduce a new requirement for the verification of the identity of an applicant and for review of the prescribed reviewable migration or protection decisions. The requirement would apply to applicants seeking merits or judicial review of a prescribed protection or migration decision in the tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2). This would establish a mandatory engagement point with the tribunal and the court to ensure that applicants understand precisely what it is that they are seeking to do and so that the tribunal and the court can have confidence that the applicant is who they say they are. The particulars around when, where and how the identity verification process would operate are intended to be set out in regulations. The regulations would be subject to parliamentary oversight through a disallowance process. The new requirement would not be enlivened without regulations prescribing the case loads to which it would apply.
Where applicants in the tribunal did not comply with the identity verification requirement, it would result in the tribunal being required to dismiss the matter, with its existing reinstatement powers available if necessary. Applicants who failed to comply with the identity verification requirement in the federal court and family court proceedings would require leave of the court to continue proceedings. To ensure consistency and compliance with constitutional limitations relating to the status of the court as a chapter III court, the court, where leave is not granted, may—rather than 'must'—dismiss the proceeding. The court would also be empowered to dispense with, or extend time to satisfy, the identity verification requirement.
The government has considered the report of the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, following its inquiry into the bill. We thank all submitters, witnesses and senators for their participation in the inquiry. The government agrees to the committee's recommendation that applicants who receive oral reasons be provided with clear written notice of the period for requesting written reasons and the applicable judicial review deadline and that the tribunal provide any requested written reasons as expeditiously as possible. The tribunal will provide written advice to parties upon receiving an oral decision, outlining further review rights, how they may seek written reasons and the timeframe in which to do so. As currently occurs, a fact sheet with information about the decision and information about seeking judicial review will be given at the time of written notification of the tribunal's decision. The government also agrees that the timely provision of written reasons following a request is important, and the tribunal must provide written reasons to both parties within 28 days after a request for written reasons is received; within 14 days for reviews subject to the 35-day deadline for seeking judicial review under the Migration Act; or as otherwise prescribed in regulations or practice directions.
The government notes the comments from Senator Cash and coalition senators and the recommendation that the government consider, in consultation with the tribunal and the Department of Home Affairs, a limited reconsideration mechanism under the migration framework to allow clear and objectively identifiable administrative errors or oversights to be returned to the Department of Home Affairs while a review remains on foot. There are bespoke remittal settings that already apply to migration and protection reviews under the Migration Act to preserve the current framework that ensures the certainty of a person's visa status and when an application is considered finally determined. The tribunal has efficient triaging processes in place to identify and remit decisions impacted by an obvious error, such as a decision to refuse a student visa where the original decision-maker overlooked a valid English language test result or where an applicant inadvertently failed to attach an English language test result to their application. Further to recommendation 2 by coalition senators, the government agrees in principle to the recommendation that additional data relating to powers exercised by the tribunal registrars be included in the tribunal's annual report.
The government is committed to ensuring transparency and public accountability in relation to ART operations and the exercise of certain tribunal powers. Accordingly, subject to the passage of government amendments, the president of the tribunal would be required to report every financial year on the following items: the number of applications dismissed by registrars on the basis that they have no reasonable prospects of success, the number of reinstatements following any such dismissal, the number of matters remitted by registrars to a decision-maker for reconsideration under section 85 for each jurisdictional area and the number of those applications subsequently withdrawn by applicants. This would ensure that there is publicly available information relating to the exercise of these powers by registrars, recognising that appropriate accountability and transparency should accompany both existing powers of ART registrars and expanded powers introduced in the bill.
Taken together, these reforms will support a more efficient, effective and robust review system, particularly in relation to the migration system by encouraging active participation in the process and dissuading frivolous applications while ensuring that appropriate balances are in place. The tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia have a crucial role in enabling review of government decisions. The bill will support this role by tailoring procedures and operations to enhance efficiencies and ensure the significant migration caseload pressure can be effectively responded to.
Question negatived.
Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure
12:46 pm
For efficiency, we won't call a division but would like our support for the amendments noted.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
I'm happy to record your support for the amendment.
Question agreed to.
Bill read a second time.