This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading
Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens
12:20 pm
The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should not be passed. When I was an immigration lawyer, a young lady, a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, obtained a student visa to come to Australia, to experience another country and to pursue her tertiary education. It was the first time she had ever left home, and it was a very big deal for her and her family. A reason why she decided to take that big step was because her boyfriend, also a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, successfully obtained a student visa to travel to Australia to undertake his tertiary studies.
Sadly for both of them, during their time studying in Australia, they broke up. Like happens sometimes, their break-up was messy. During the course of their break-up, the young man went to the police and had the young lady charged with assault for hitting him with a container of chilli. But through that process the police came to her apartment. The police arrested her. The police took her to the cop shop. They interviewed her. They charged her with assault and then she was released on bail. That was a traumatic experience for her and her family.
She went back home to her apartment in this country and took some time to recover from that terrifying experience she had suffered. Then there was a knock at the door, and who pushed through the door? A number of Border Force officers. They detained her and they put her in immigration detention. Why? Because that criminal offence, despite pleading not guilty to it, was decided by the government to mean that she was a risk to the safety of the Australian community. A 19-year-old Chinese citizen with no prior criminal history in her home country, this country or anywhere else in the world, who was innocently attending this country as an experience to fulfil her tertiary education, was now in immigration detention. She contacted me to act as her immigration lawyer, and, of course, I immediately filed an appeal with the tribunal appealing the decision to cancel her visa.
As a result of that, I was able to participate in an efficient system in the tribunal, a system that says if you are appealing a visa cancellation decision and you are locked up in inhumane immigration detention then within a couple of days you can apply for a bridging visa to be released from immigration detention. We embraced that efficiency. Despite that she was in immigration detention in Melbourne and despite that I was working as an immigration lawyer between Tasmania and Victoria, the first available tribunal member to hear her application to get her out of immigration detention was in Sydney. But that was okay; we would take every opportunity that we could to right this injustice and get her out of jail. So we went to Sydney; Border Force flew her there. She was brought into the tribunal room in shackles—a 19-year-old Chinese citizen who was defending an alleged criminal offence was in shackles. The application for a bridging visa to release this young lady from immigration detention was successful. That is an example of an efficiency rightly placed in favour of a victim of the system.
Let's have a look at what changes this federal Labor government is proposing in a race to the bottom with One Nation and the Liberals on migration. There is a proposal to deny student visa holders to have their family come to Australia to be with them. Had that been the case for this young lady, she would have been deprived of the opportunity to have her family with her when she was going through her first relationship break-up, with her first boyfriend; when she was arrested and interviewed by the police; when she was criminally charged by the police—to which she pleaded not guilty; and when she was released on bail.
Her bridging visa application was granted. She proceeded to defend the criminal charge that she had been confronted with for hitting her then boyfriend with a container of chilli. But, understandably, she left this country, deprived of her opportunity for travel to broaden the mind, by reason of the atrocious experience that she had when she was here.
Again, I'll go back to the good news story in this terrifying set of circumstances, and that is the existing efficiency in the tribunal system that meant she was able to be released from immigration detention within a handful of days.
When I was an immigration lawyer, I acted for a young man who was about 20. He's a New Zealand citizen, and he travelled to Australia. As I expect my colleagues in this chamber are aware, he was naturally granted a temporary 444 visa, as New Zealand citizens are. He came here to fill a labour shortage. Whilst at an Aussie pub, watching an Aussie game of AFL, with a few blokes who'd probably had one too many beers, he engaged in a minor scuffle amongst others at the pub. He was criminally charged for assault. After he was arrested, after he was interviewed by the police and after he was charged with a minor assault and released on bail, what do you know? Border Force officers turned up at his place and dragged him off to immigration detention because he was also suddenly a risk to the safety of the Australian community.
Again, I was able to embrace the efficiency of the tribunal and have an urgent hearing to have him released on a bridging visa. He stayed here and defended the criminal charges. But, before the criminal hearing was determined, we had the tribunal hearing to appeal the visa cancellation decision. To the shock of me and my legal colleagues at the time, we did not succeed, and the visa cancellation decision was upheld. That meant that the bridging visa came to an end and that he could choose to sit in immigration detention while he was waiting for the criminal matter to be dealt with or he could go home to New Zealand, but he was on bail—now what was he going to do? But, in any event, we appealed the unsuccessful visa cancellation decision to the Federal Court system, and we were able to give him sound advice as to whether he had any grounds for appeal and, if so, what his prospects of success were because we had not just the decision but the written reasons for the decision. I can tell you that it would be hard for you to find any competent lawyer in this country that can tell you that they can properly advise their client as to whether they have grounds for appeal and whether those grounds have any prospects of success without having the written reasons of the decision-maker.
This proposed amendment to create an efficiency by enabling tribunal decision-makers to not provide written reasons for decisions will only create inefficiencies later. Let me tell you how. We would have to take a punt and say: 'Well, just like we told you, you should have had prospects of succeeding at the tribunal. We can only tell you again that the decision must be wrong, so you must have prospects of success in the Federal Court system.' We would file an application in the Federal Court, supported by flimsy grounds for appeal, then we'd be requesting the written reasons from the tribunal. We'd have to wait for them. Meanwhile, the Federal Court process would have commenced, then we'd have to cause an inefficiency in the Federal Court, because we'd have to seek leave to amend the grounds for appeal because we would finally have the written reasons.
What if the situation arose where, when we get the written reasons for the decision, we're in a position to advise the client that there aren't really grounds for appeal with prospects of success? We've wasted the time of the Federal Court—further time, because we now need to withdraw the appeal to the Federal Court system. The client has paid the thousands-of-dollars filing fee to the Federal Court, which isn't refundable, and the client has paid the lawyers. I was quite affordable, but who knows how many thousands of dollars the client has paid the lawyer to draft the application and the grounds of appeal—only to have to withdraw it by reason of having to wait for the written reasons for decision.
There is no way that these amendments allowing tribunal members to not provide written reasons for decision when they make their decision will bestow any efficiencies on this system. We have to look at the bigger system—not just the tribunal system but also the court system that can, and often does, follow it. The reason that we have appeal processes is that there are times when decision-makers get things wrong. When decision-makers get things wrong, we need a fair appeal system, and it is not a fair appeal system to give someone a decision without any written reasons, because it sets them up for failure in respect of an unfair appeal system. This bill's attempt at efficiency instead promotes inefficiency and seeks to cut corners at the cost of fairness and people's rights. Our legal system in this country is governed by the principle of procedural fairness. How can we be in this chamber and say that we support our fundamental principle of procedural fairness when we are seeking to pass a bill today that is designed to create an even more unfair system than that which already exists?
As senators, we should be here to make better laws. We should be here to turn unfair systems into fair ones. We are not here and should not be here to make unfair systems more unfair. I don't know what lawyers this federal Labor government might have been talking to when they thought it was a good idea to let tribunal members off the hook and not have to give written reasons for decisions, but it wasn't me. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues that I worked with for plenty of years. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues who I've had the opportunity to consult with over this bill. Every single one of them will tell you what I have said today, and that is that letting tribunal members off the hook and not give written reasons for decisions has an adverse impact on fairness and procedural justice, and interferes with the rights of people who should have an opportunity to participate in a fair justice system. It's our responsibility to make it so. (Time expired)
No comments