This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

12:47 pm

by leave—I move government amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 and amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 together:

SHEET IE114

(1) Schedule 1, page 4 (after line 4), before item 1, insert:

1A After paragraph 242(2)(g)

Insert:

(ga) the number of applications dismissed by registrars under paragraph 101(1)(b) (no reasonable prospects of success) during that year; and

(gb) the number of applications reinstated under section 102 of this Act, or section 368C of the Migration Act 1958, during that year after having been dismissed, at any time, by a registrar under paragraph 101(1)(b) of this Act; and

(gc) the number of decisions remitted to decision-makers under section 85 by registrars during that year in each jurisdictional area; and

(gd) in relation to decisions remitted to decision-makers, at any time, under section 85 by registrars—the number of applications withdrawn by applicants under section 95 during that year in each jurisdictional area; and

(2) Schedule 1, page 4 (after line 13), before item 3, insert:

2A Annual report — application of amendment

The amendment of section 242 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 made by Division 1 of this Part applies in relation to an application made to the Tribunal on or after 1 July 2028.

_____

SHEET IE116

(1) Schedule 1, page 10 (after line 19), after item 18, insert:

18A After subsection 208(4)

Insert:

Promotion of general member to senior member

(4A) Paragraph (2)(b) does not apply in relation to the appointment of a person as a senior member if:

(a) immediately before the start of the appointment as a senior member:

(i) the person holds office as a general member; and

(ii) the person has served at least 2 years of the person's appointment as a general member; and

(b) the Minister has sought, and taken into account, the advice of the President in relation to:

(i) the person's performance against the performance standard; and

(ii) the person's compliance with the code of conduct; and

(iii) the person's leadership and management skills, at an appropriate level for the appointment as a senior member.

(2) Schedule 1, page 11 (after line 10), after item 21, insert:

21A At the end of section 208

Add:

Effect of promotion

(11) If a person is appointed as a senior member as mentioned in subsection (4A):

(a) the person's appointment as a general member is, by force of this subsection, terminated immediately before the start of the person's appointment as a senior member; and

(b) the Remuneration Tribunal (Compensation for Loss of Office for Holders of Certain Public Offices) Determination 2018 does not apply in relation to the termination of the person's appointment as a general member.

(3) Schedule 1, item 23, page 12 (line 25), omit "The amendments", substitute "(1) Subject to subitem (2), the amendments".

(4) Schedule 1, item 23, page 12 (after line 28), at the end of the item, add:

(2) Subsections 208(4A) and (11) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024, as inserted by Division 1 of this Part, apply in relation to the appointment of a senior member made on or after the commencement of this item.

I also table two supplementary explanatory memoranda relating to the government amendments to be moved to this bill.

Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

12:48 pm

On the amendments moved by the government, the coalition will support the government's amendments to the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. In particular, the government has brought forward an amendment to strengthen the tribunal's annual reporting requirements. This was actually a recommendation made by the coalition during the Senate committee process, and it was the coalition that identified the need for greater transparency about the exercise of powers by tribunal registrars. It was the coalition that argued parliament should have access to better information about applications dismissed on the grounds that they had no reasonable prospects of success. We also identified that there be greater scrutiny of applications subsequently reinstated, decisions remitted to original decision-makers and applications withdrawn following those remittals. These, of course, are not insignificant matters, which is why we proposed the amendment. We are pleased that the government has accepted the coalition's amendment to the bill. The amendments go directly to the fairness, accountability and integrity of the administrative review system. The amendment will provide additional information in the tribunal's annual report, allowing greater scrutiny of how these powers are exercised.

The government is also proposing amendments to the arrangements for promoting existing general members of the tribunal to senior member positions. These amendments will allow suitably experienced general members who have served at least two years to be promoted through an alternative appointment pathway. The minister will be required to seek and consider advice from the tribunal president concerning the member's performance and compliance with the code of conduct and leadership and management skills. The coalition considers these to be sensible administrative arrangements that recognise experience while retaining important safeguards. As I said, the coalition will support these amendments because they improve accountability and strengthen the operation of the ART.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

12:50 pm

I have some questions for the minister. During the course of the inquiry associated with this bill, the Greens repeatedly asked what the identity verification requirements are, and we were told time and time again that they would be made on the regulations. Now, lawyers and migration agents still have no idea what they are. Can you please let us know what the identity verification requirements are?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

12:51 pm

Thanks very much for the question. As you know, the bill provides for those requirements to be made through regulation, and they will be prescribed through regulation. It is set out in the bill how they will be made and what they will cover in terms of requiring someone to present in person or also online, and, as I said in my speech, those regulations will be disallowable.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

12:52 pm

On the identity verification, what ID will be required for the identity verification process? Surely, some work has been undertaken around ID requirements. For example, is an Australian driver's licence required? For example, would a passport be required? Would identification verification be conducted through non-photo ID? Surely, some work must have been done around what ID will be required. This is not the first time in a legislative scheme that there have been ID verification processes. Plenty of lawyers and migration agents are asking us. Please tell us what ID will be required.

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

12:53 pm

It's the same question that I just previously answered in that the government's intent is that the new requirements will ensure that applicants are actively engaging with the review process in early stages of the proceeding, and the regulations will provide the identity documents that must be provided to comply with that requirement. As has been stated already through the committee process, the government's intention is for the substantive identity verification component to be a straightforward requirement that can be met by applicants who are subject to the requirement. The National Identity Proofing Guidelines were updated in 2025 to provide best practice guidance on how to conduct identity proofing both for people with a full suite of traditional types of identity documents and also for alternative proofing arrangements for people who do not have those types of identity documents, and the regulation-making power enables the government to be responsive and provides flexibility to adapt that process.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

12:54 pm

What will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID? I'll give you an example of where it really can be problematic. My sister has Down syndrome. She does not have a driver's licence. She does not have photographic ID. There are occasions where people just don't have the ID that is required under verification-of-identity schemes. In other legislative fields—look at, for example, electronic conveyancing—there are very strict ID verification processes. I know, from my time as a property lawyer and from having run a conveyancing practice for many years, that there were occasions when people did not have the ID required to meet the verification process. So what will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID? Surely this federal Labor government would have undertaken some work on the ID verification process and will not just simply stand here today and push it off to regulations that we have to only guess what they will contain, particularly in circumstances where plenty of lawyers and migration agents are trying their best to help their clients, trying their best to help people who need access to justice and trying their best to spend the money they can find to implement these new and drastically different systems within their businesses? Surely this government can give us an idea of what will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

12:56 pm

I think the question goes to two issues that I'm very happy to address. In the first instance, I think the question is around vulnerable people who might have diverse needs or perhaps even people who are in rural or remote areas and may not have a particular type of identity verification. I can address in the first instance what safeguards will apply.

The identity verification requirement is intended to ensure that applicants seeking review of certain migration and protection decisions actively engage with the tribunal or the court in the early stages of seeking that review. The government acknowledges that some applicants, subject to this new requirement, may be vulnerable, have diverse needs or live in regional or remote communities. The identity verification requirement provides certain certainty and consistency as to the steps applicants must take in reviews to which the requirement is to apply, while there is also flexibility for the tribunal and the court to dispense of the requirement where appropriate.

The details of the steps an applicant must take to satisfy the identity verification is going to be set out in regulation. The regulations will be designed so as not to disadvantage vulnerable applicants. The bill enables regulations to provide for both in-person and virtual identity verification processes to ensure access for people with diverse needs and people who live in rural and remote areas. Regulations could also provide for classes of applicants that the requirement would not apply to. If an application is dismissed in either the tribunal or the court, as a safeguard, the applicant could seek to have their application reinstated and could explain their circumstances and why they were unable to attend. This would ensure that the tribunal and the court are able to dispense with the requirement where an applicant, through no fault of their own, is not able to satisfy the requirement.

The court is also able to, by application or on its own motion, dispense with the requirement at any time, not only as part of an application for reinstatement. Applicants will also be supported to understand options to seek reinstatement if they do not meet the identity verification requirements. For example, at the tribunal, when an applicant is notified of the dismissal decision, the notification letter includes information about applying for reinstatement and generally advises the date by which the applicant must seek reinstatement. If applicants have questions about the proceedings or processes of the tribunal or the court, they can use the translating and interpreting services to speak to registry staff in their own language.

The second issue which I think is being raised is essentially what will happen if someone is unable to meet the identity verification requirement. Putting aside the issue around vulnerable people, which I've spoken to, in practice, the requirement is intended to ensure that applicants are genuinely engaging. We wanted to ensure that key features of the new requirements specific to the tribunal would include mandatory dismissal of the application if the applicant fails to satisfy the requirements in accordance with the notice. As a safeguard, as I said, the tribunal would be able to reinstate an application dismissed for failure to satisfy the identity verification requirement where an applicant applies for reinstatement, if it considers it appropriate to do so.

In terms of the court's practices, there is a requirement for leave for the court be granted to continue proceedings if the applicant fails to satisfy the requirement in accordance with the notice, and, where leave is not granted, the court may, rather than must, dismiss the proceedings. As a safeguard, the court would also be able to reinstate proceedings which had been dismissed for failure to satisfy the requirement if it considers it appropriate to do so. The court, of course, can also reschedule or extend time for satisfying the requirement and dispense with the requirement altogether at any point where appropriate.

Just to reiterate and go back to the purpose of these changes, it is to ensure that applicants are genuinely engaging with the review process, that they are aware of the application that's being made in their name and to ensure that that happens in a timely manner. The bill sets out the procedures that would occur, and the regulations will set out not only the details around what types of identity requirements will be used but also how people can appear in person or online. The regulations will also set out where there might be certain types of cases that are excluded from the process.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:02 pm

In your answer, you spent some time talking about what can happen if ID verification is not met, so I find it difficult to understand how work has not been done by this federal Labor government around what identification documents would be required to meet the verification process. Will overseas identity documents be accepted? For example, there may be an occasion where someone does not meet a points test for identity verification from a photographic perspective, but they might be residing in a rental property where they have an energy bill with their name on it or an internet service provider bill with their name on it. Will overseas identity documents be accepted and will non-photographic identity documents of the kind that I just mentioned be accepted?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:03 pm

The question goes to what's in the regulations, so I refer to my previous answer.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

It's disappointing that the work hasn't been done or the work that has been done isn't capable or that this federal Labor government isn't prepared to share with us and all of those in the community who will be impacted by the identity verification process—that we can't be told anything more about what that ID verification process will entail. I'll accept that either you don't know, and that's a grave day for the making of new legislation in this chamber, or you're refusing to tell us more of what you do know, which, again, is a grave day for new legislation being passed in this chamber having regard to the millions of people who will be impacted by it. But I'll move on.

In amendments on sheet IE116, you have put forward changes to membership recruitment that were never flagged in the inquiry or referenced in the bill. They seem to be completely irrelevant to the legislation. Why has the government attached these changes to streamline recruitment of members without flagging at any point—during what was a very lengthy inquiry—that this is something you were considering? It would have been appropriate to raise it earlier, because an inquiry is the opportune time for amendments of that nature to be properly explored in the interests of justice and in the interests of the community. Was it an afterthought? Or was it a strategic decision by this government to hold out on it until the last moment?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:05 pm

():  In the Senate it is not unusual for Senate inquiries—the good ones—to make recommendations and to ventilate issues and for the government to consider amendments and bring those amendments forward to the chamber. That is a usual practice that occurs, and it is also the case that if the government seeks to do that then we are informing the chamber in two ways: through a supplementary explanatory memorandum, about changes that are in government amendments, and here at the in-committee stage, answering your questions. So I reject your characterisation in regard to transparency and categorically say that your accusation is untrue.

But I can talk to those amendments in detail, particularly those on sheet IE116, the government amendments around promotions and appointments. These amendments would further streamline tribunal appointment processes by creating a new process for promotion from general member to senior member. This would allow the Attorney-General to respond more quickly to changing operational needs of the tribunal while maintaining merit based appointment processes at appropriate times. Under the proposed process, a general member of the tribunal could be promoted to senior member before the end of their current term without requiring a full panel process where the Attorney-General is satisfied that the person is a suitable candidate for appointment as a senior member, the person meets existing eligibility and qualification requirements for senior members, and consultation has occurred with the president of the tribunal. Consultation would include consideration of the general member's performance against the performance standard, their compliance with the Code of Conduct, and whether their leadership and management skills are at an appropriate level for the appointment of a senior members. This is consistent with the current appointment framework in the ART Act, and the Attorney-General would seek approval from the Prime Minister for a member's promotion to senior member before making a recommendation to the Governor-General.

The amendments streamline administration without reducing the rigour of the appointment framework. That is incredibly important to this government. There are two things that we seek to balance when it comes to the effective management of the ART: having a system with fully qualified, merit assessed members who are capable of delivering administrative justice as well as making sure that that can happen in a timely way, to manage the case load of the ART. That is why the government is proceeding with these amendments. Nothing that is being proposed by the government with respect to appointments would change the fundamental precondition to be considered—that an applicant is assessed as meritorious by an independent assessment panel. The proposals included in the original bill and those proposed in the government amendments seek to streamline that appointment process and make it more efficient. It is a fact that the tribunal needs more members, and the government is working to do that in an orderly way. We'll make further announcements in due course about its membership.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:09 pm

All this talk about the identity verification process that we have had some exchange on this afternoon has caused a lot of interest from the community. I've just been asked by a person who is scared—that's the word they used, 'scared'—about what this new identity verification process is. One example I'm reminded of that was raised at the inquiry and that went unanswered was the following:

So the Hazara woman has fled with her children to Australia from Afghanistan. She has never had a passport and never had travel documents and has come onshore. The Afghan embassy has shut. She obviously isn't going to go and approach the Taliban in Afghanistan for identity documents because then her family could well be persecuted and killed. What processes will there be in place for a woman in that situation to have her identity verification assessed and not have a mandatory dismissal of her application?

Just before you answer that question, which remained unanswered at the inquiry, the department did actually reply to my colleague, the Leader of the Australian Greens, Senator Shoebridge, and say:

I can't give you an answer with the precision that will make you happy …

Putting aside whether that kind of an answer is an appropriate answer from a public servant who is being paid by public money to answer questions for the public, putting aside for a minute whether that's an appropriate answer, now that you've had the time to sit with that question, can you now fulfil your duties to the public and answer that question?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:12 pm

First of all, I can repeat the answers that I've given before about the impact that these changes may have on vulnerable cohorts. I've already answered that question. The details will be in the regulation. But the government recognises that in some circumstances an applicant may have a legitimate reason for why they are unable to verify their identity, including not having access to certain documents. While the mandatory dismissal procedures apply to all applicants to ensure a consistent approach, nothing in this proposal removes the ability for an applicant to seek reinstatement of their matter through an existing reinstatement process. In these circumstances, an applicant would have the opportunity to explain why they were unable to complete their identity verification, and the tribunal would have the discretion to determine whether to reinstate their matters with or without the identity verification requirement.

The bill also expressly contemplates that both in-person and virtual verification may be features of the new regulation, and the government will work closely with the tribunal in the development of the regulations to ensure the process is streamlined, accessible and fair. I don't seek to repeat the answers I've given before about how that will or won't impact. I also won't go to individual matters. Of course, I won't be giving advice about individual matters. I also reject the characterisation of the Greens in relation to public servants. I think it's pretty disgraceful that the Greens have now become anti public servant and seek to minimise the work they do. I think that answer, although you're not happy with it, is the appropriate one to give where the making of regulations is prescribed in the bill, and that is exactly what the government will do.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:14 pm

Since this bill was introduced, the Albanese government has quietly started charging people seeking asylum more than $1,800 to appeal their visas up-front at the tribunal.

It seems that this government's got a bit of a habit of making changes to the way that it operates or proposing new laws before having consulted or communicated with those parts of the community that are going to be impacted by those changes. Look, for example, at what occurred with the promised cuts to backpackers. We had the National Farmers' Federation and the Australian Tourism Industry Council running around saying that they had not been consulted in advance. The same thing has happened here, where people—including migrant resource centres who exist to help these people, most often for free or on a shoestring—were not told that people seeking asylum would be paying more than $1,800 upfront to appeal their visa decisions at the tribunal.

Why did the government not tell the sector about this change? What was going on at the governmental level that it thought that it was okay to impose upon part of the community who are among those who struggle most a requirement to come up with such a large amount of money, over $1,800, to exercise their rights to review in a tribunal a decision made by a government that is making decisions on visas that are designed to cut the net overseas migration rate? This government is putting the politics of migration before the real impact that those politics of migration are having on people. Why did the government not tell the sector about this change?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:16 pm

I may be wrong, but I think the question is irrelevant to the bill. It goes outside issues raised in the bill. It relates to the Home Affairs portfolio, I believe. I am very happy to have that redirected in a different way. If there's a question relating to the provisions of the bill or the consultation around this particular bill, I'm happy to answer that question, but I think this question goes to a policy area outside of this bill—although related, given that 88 per cent of matters considered in the ART relate to migration. It is not something we can discuss in this committee process today.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:17 pm

Thank you very much for pointing that out. I do have a question on that topic which I believe is related to the bill, but please help me out again if it's not. This bill allows registrars—so not necessarily people with a strong legal background—to throw out applications that are made to the tribunal to review government decisions on visa applications, although the people who are seeking asylum have to pay $1,800-plus. So the government's made a decision. If a person is lucky enough to have a lawyer, the lawyer has said: 'That's a bad decision. I think that's a decision that's wrong at law. I recommend that you appeal that decision to the tribunal, and I believe that you have prospects of success on those grounds of appeal.' This person is fleeing persecution or death. They now have to pay $1,800-plus to make that application. Then, without a proper or fair hearing, a registrar can throw out that application. What happens then to the $1,800? Is it like with the backpackers who, it has been promised, will have to go into a ballot and pay $1,000 for a lotto ticket, with a slim chance, or no chance, of having their name pulled out of the box? Is it like that, where they surrender their $1,000 to the coffers of the federal government? What happens to that $1,800 they have paid if a registrar, without even a fair hearing, throws out their application to review the government's decision to refuse asylum to someone fleeing death?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:19 pm

Just to reiterate, the changes that the government are proposing are about ensuring that genuine applicants have an opportunity to have their matter considered in a timely and efficient way. That is exactly what we are seeking to do. Many of the changes we are discussing today seek to ensure that people who have a genuine application and seek judicial review receive that review. That is what the ART are required to do, and they do that in the context of the right that people have to seek review of those types of decisions. The context of these changes is to ensure that those people, no matter what type of visa decision it is, are given an opportunity to have that decision considered.

I want to address some of the comments around registrars. We don't want to get into a legal qualification debate, but, suffice to say, I think that registrars are highly qualified appointees. Most are legally qualified or have experience in dispute resolution or experience related to the functions of the tribunal. It's incredibly important that that is respected. The power—that is, the power that we are considering—being performed by registrars can adequately be performed by an authorised registrar and would enhance the efficiency of the tribunal process. For example, the power is routinely exercised where an applicant fails to meet an objective visa criterion which requires them to be onshore in Australia at the time that the application is made because they are outside of Australia. The president would be able to issue directions in relation to the exercise of this power by a registrar—for example, that the power may only be exercised when based on clear objective criteria.

Some of the examples of dismissal based on failure to satisfy an objective criteria include where an applicant is required to be onshore in Australia at the time the application is made but they are in fact not in Australia; where an applicant must be below a certain age when the application is made to the original decision-maker and they are older than that age; where an applicant is required to have a nomination in place at the time of their visa application to the decision-maker and the nomination has not been approved; and where an applicant is required to provide evidence when making their visa application that they have undertaken an English language test and achieved a specified score but they have not done so.

Under the ART Act, a person cannot be appointed as a registrar unless they have a degree or similar educational qualification of law, as I said earlier, and qualifications or training experience relating to dispute resolution. A comparable power to issue summary judgements, including on the ground that an applicant has no reasonable prospects of success prosecuting the proceeding, is delegated to registrars in the general federal law jurisdiction of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

To reiterate, if those objective criteria are not met, it would mean that that application is dealt with quicker and in a more efficient way, allowing genuine applications to be considered in full by a member in a timely manner. That is exactly why the government is seeking to make these changes.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:23 pm

When we look at what the bill says about registrars being able to throw out applications, it seems a lot broader, to me, than what the chief executive officer and principal registrar of the ART, Mr Hawkins, said. He made clear that the tribunal doesn't expect to use this power in complex cases. That's the first limitation that he was expecting to apply to the power for the tribunal to just throw out an application without a full and fair hearing. There's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided by him was for its use in successful cases. Mr Hawkins explained:

I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons.

It all strikes me as odd that this is what Mr Hawkins would say. When you look at what Mr Hawkins says on the one hand, and then you look at what the bill says on the other, you just can't see how they can peacefully coexist in practice at all.

If this is the example provided by the tribunal, why isn't the government only applying this change to successful applications? Why has the government gone along and given a broad and open power to the tribunal, without a fair and proper hearing, to just decide to throw out applications, instead of the having more refined way that the CEO and principal registrar of the tribunal himself expected to be the case?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

1:26 pm

Thank you. I'm just checking, but I think the answer you are referring to from the President relates to the use of the tribunal from oral reasons. I'm assuming that your question actually goes to registrar powers. Okay, I'm getting some nods from your advisers. We can deal with the registrar powers and possibly the safeguards that are in place on that. I'm sure you'll have questions about oral reasons as well. But, just to be clear, and to be fair to Mr Hawkins, we don't want to take his comments out of context. He wasn't talking about registrar powers; he was talking about the use of oral reasons, which is a different power that is being considered under this bill.

I will go to the safeguards that are in place to ensure that registrars exercise these powers appropriately, because, of course, I'm sure that is of interest to the Senate. The President may issue directions in relation to the authorisation given to registrars to exercise the power to dismiss an application for review or make an order requiring an application to seek leave of the tribunal. The President may, for example, issue a direction that a registrar can only exercise the dismissal power in certain circumstances, for example where the basis of the dismissal is a failure to satisfy an objective criterion, which I took you through in my previous answer. This will ensure that an appropriate level of discretion is exercised. As a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal will write to an applicant to seek their submissions before using the dismissal power, and the tribunal can also reinstate an application which has been dismissed for no reasonable prospect of success under either the ART Act or the Migration Act. Depending on the act, an application may be reinstated where an application has been dismissed in error or where the tribunal considers it appropriate to reinstate the application. Under the ART Act, a person cannot be appointed as a registrar unless they have those qualifications that I took you to earlier. That deals with the safeguards that are in place under decisions made by the registrar. We will work with the tribunal in terms of their development of any directions. But that is what is anticipated in practice by the use of these powers.

VB

Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens

1:30 pm

When moving this bill under the guise of efficiencies by denying someone an immediate right to written reasons for a decision, when the actual decision is made in circumstances where the government complains about an increase in appeals following the government's decision on visa applications, did the government look at the increase in visa decision appeals coinciding with the government refusing more visa applications to artificially decrease the net overseas migration rate?

Progress reported.

Dave Sharma

Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

We will now move to senators' statements.