This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

11:59 am

I rise in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. Last financial year, the median time to finalise a family or partner visa review was more than 2½ years. For a family living apart, it can mean another birthday over a video call. It can mean telling your children again that you still don't know when you all will be able to live together.

The Albanese Labor government established the Administrative Review Tribunal in October 2024. Political appointments had damaged confidence in the old Administrative Appeals Tribunal. We put transparent, merit based appointments into law so that people could trust that the people hearing their case have been chosen for their expertise. The tribunal gives people an independent place to challenge a range of Commonwealth decisions. It can look at the facts again, consider new evidence and decide on what the correct or preferable outcome is. Through judicial review, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia can examine whether a migration decision was made according to the law. Our government has funded the tribunal to work through older migration and protection cases. The tribunal finalised more than 27,000 of those cases in the first year of that work. But even with that progress, it has almost 134,000 applications on hand at the end of June. Nearly nine in 10 were migration or protection matters. We absolutely owe it to the people waiting to make sure that the tribunal's time goes to where it's needed.

Under this bill, the tribunal's president can authorise a registrar to dismiss an application if there is no reasonable prospect of success. Take a case where the law sets out a clear eligibility requirement and the facts show that the applicant may not meet those requirements. An authorised registrar could deal with that case. The president can set conditions on that authority and it can also authorise registrars to reinstate certain dismissed applications. It gives tribunal members more time for the cases that need it. Someone seeking protection may have to tell the tribunal about some of the most frightening things that have happened to them. That member needs time to hear their account, weigh the evidence and consider what could happen if that person absolutely had to return home.

Earlier reforms gave the tribunal more scope to decide some cases on the papers. This bill gives it more flexibility in how it explains its decisions. In eligible cases, a member can give reasons orally. The parties can still get the outcomes in writing; if a party asks for written reasons within the time allowed, the tribunal must provide them. Where the parties already have the explanations they need, the member can spend that time on the next case. Written reasons will continue to be provided as a matter of course for reviews concerning social security, veterans' entitlements, aged care and the National Disability Insurance Scheme. If you're seeking a review of your NDIS plan, a written explanation gives you something that you can sit down with an advocate or a family member and work through. You can take the time to understand what the decision means for the support that you rely on every single day.

I'd like to extend my thanks to Senator Jana Stewart for chairing the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee's inquiry, and also the secretariat and everyone who gave evidence to this inquiry. We heard how hard it can be to take on a decision and all the reasons in it in one sitting, especially if you're relying on an interpreter or representing just yourself. In a migration review, an applicant would generally have 14 days from an oral decision to ask for written reasons. The usual deadline for seeking judicial review is 35 days from the decision. If you need those reasons to get legal advice, you could still be waiting for them as the court deadline approaches. The Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee recommended that the applicants be given both deadlines in writing and that the tribunal provide any requested reasons as quickly as possible.

This bill will require an approved form for certain migration and protection reviews so that the tribunal can get the information it needs upfront. It will allow tribunal members to correct obvious errors in the registrar's orders. The Immigration Advice and Rights Centre told the inquiry about people who had applications lodged in their names without their knowledge or their consent. It also told us about people who had missed hearings because of unscrupulous operators who had failed to pass on correspondence from the tribunal. The bill introduces identity checks in certain migration and protection matters. These checks give the tribunal and the court a way to confirm who is seeking review and help make sure that people know that an application has been made in their name. Applicants covered by the requirement will be told in writing what they need to do. The tribunal must dismiss an application if the person fails to comply. The person can ask to have their case reinstated, and the tribunal must reinstate it if it considers that it is appropriate. The court can give someone more time, waive the requirement where it's appropriate or give them permission to continue if they haven't met it. Regulations will set out which cases are covered and how the checks will work.

The Attorney-General's Department told us it expects online verification to be a key part of those arrangements. In regional and remote Western Australia, it can spare someone hours of travel for a single appointment. The department also acknowledges the need for other ways to prove identity. Someone who has fled their home may have very little choice about which documents they could bring. The process needs to work for that person too. The committee recommended that this bill pass, and I thank the Attorney-General for bringing these reforms forward. I commend the bill to the Senate.

Comments

No comments