This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading
Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism
12:36 pm
The purpose of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is to enhance the efficiency and responsiveness of the Administrative Review Tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to the significant and increasing caseloads. The bill further strengthens the tribunal by empowering it with more tools to make decisions in an efficient and timely manner while ensuring applicants have a meaningful opportunity to present their case to the tribunal. The bill also enhances the operations of the tribunal and the court in relation to migration and protection matters. The bill recognises that merits and judicial review processes should be efficient and proportionate to the complexity of the issues and the importance of what is at stake. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making, provide genuine applicants with the benefit of a timely and effective remedy and strengthen the integrity of the review system.
This bill has been informed by the tribunal's operational experience over almost two years, and the bill makes a range of amendments to ensure the tribunal can make decisions effectively and without delay. In particular, the bill amends the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 and the Migration Act 1958 to enable the ART to give reasons for a decision orally, rather than always in writing, with written statements of reasons to be given at the request of a party. A written record of decision will continue to always be provided to parties. These changes apply to matters in the ART's migration caseload as well as other caseloads where the ART resources could be saved because written reasons may not always be required. The bill provides important safeguards for vulnerable applicants of the ART and will not apply these changes to reviews relating to social security, veterans entitlements, the National Disability Insurance Scheme, aged care and where written reasons may play an important role.
The bill also makes several other efficiency amendments, including to enable the president of the ART to authorise registrars to exercise additional powers, recognising the important role that they play in running the ART smoothly. Registrars will support members to reinstate applications in certain circumstances and to dismiss applications if satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success. We'll also require applicants to seek ART review of a reviewable migration or reviewable protection decision by using an approved form. This ensures the tribunal has relevant information it needs upfront and avoids unnecessary chasing of information when a tribunal could be dedicating its efforts to managing its significant caseload. It will also permit any member or other authorised member of the ART to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons for the decision made by the registrar.
The bill will require the government to take into account the president's advice on more matters when considering the reappointment of a non-judicial member, including on the ART's operational needs and financial capacity. The bill will enable the Governor-General to vary the appointment of a non-judicial member to a salary to sessional or vice versa during the term of their appointment. This creates greater flexibility to respond to change, including in response to varying case load demands. It also specifies when certain documents need to be provided to the tribunal, assigns the president to every jurisdictional area and, subject to the passage of the government's amendments, further streamlines the tribunal appointment processes by creating a new appointment process for suitably qualified and experienced general members to be promoted to senior member before the end of their current term without requiring a full further merit-based recruitment process.
To improve the integrity of the migration review framework, the bill will also introduce a new requirement for the verification of the identity of an applicant and for review of the prescribed reviewable migration or protection decisions. The requirement would apply to applicants seeking merits or judicial review of a prescribed protection or migration decision in the tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2). This would establish a mandatory engagement point with the tribunal and the court to ensure that applicants understand precisely what it is that they are seeking to do and so that the tribunal and the court can have confidence that the applicant is who they say they are. The particulars around when, where and how the identity verification process would operate are intended to be set out in regulations. The regulations would be subject to parliamentary oversight through a disallowance process. The new requirement would not be enlivened without regulations prescribing the case loads to which it would apply.
Where applicants in the tribunal did not comply with the identity verification requirement, it would result in the tribunal being required to dismiss the matter, with its existing reinstatement powers available if necessary. Applicants who failed to comply with the identity verification requirement in the federal court and family court proceedings would require leave of the court to continue proceedings. To ensure consistency and compliance with constitutional limitations relating to the status of the court as a chapter III court, the court, where leave is not granted, may—rather than 'must'—dismiss the proceeding. The court would also be empowered to dispense with, or extend time to satisfy, the identity verification requirement.
The government has considered the report of the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, following its inquiry into the bill. We thank all submitters, witnesses and senators for their participation in the inquiry. The government agrees to the committee's recommendation that applicants who receive oral reasons be provided with clear written notice of the period for requesting written reasons and the applicable judicial review deadline and that the tribunal provide any requested written reasons as expeditiously as possible. The tribunal will provide written advice to parties upon receiving an oral decision, outlining further review rights, how they may seek written reasons and the timeframe in which to do so. As currently occurs, a fact sheet with information about the decision and information about seeking judicial review will be given at the time of written notification of the tribunal's decision. The government also agrees that the timely provision of written reasons following a request is important, and the tribunal must provide written reasons to both parties within 28 days after a request for written reasons is received; within 14 days for reviews subject to the 35-day deadline for seeking judicial review under the Migration Act; or as otherwise prescribed in regulations or practice directions.
The government notes the comments from Senator Cash and coalition senators and the recommendation that the government consider, in consultation with the tribunal and the Department of Home Affairs, a limited reconsideration mechanism under the migration framework to allow clear and objectively identifiable administrative errors or oversights to be returned to the Department of Home Affairs while a review remains on foot. There are bespoke remittal settings that already apply to migration and protection reviews under the Migration Act to preserve the current framework that ensures the certainty of a person's visa status and when an application is considered finally determined. The tribunal has efficient triaging processes in place to identify and remit decisions impacted by an obvious error, such as a decision to refuse a student visa where the original decision-maker overlooked a valid English language test result or where an applicant inadvertently failed to attach an English language test result to their application. Further to recommendation 2 by coalition senators, the government agrees in principle to the recommendation that additional data relating to powers exercised by the tribunal registrars be included in the tribunal's annual report.
The government is committed to ensuring transparency and public accountability in relation to ART operations and the exercise of certain tribunal powers. Accordingly, subject to the passage of government amendments, the president of the tribunal would be required to report every financial year on the following items: the number of applications dismissed by registrars on the basis that they have no reasonable prospects of success, the number of reinstatements following any such dismissal, the number of matters remitted by registrars to a decision-maker for reconsideration under section 85 for each jurisdictional area and the number of those applications subsequently withdrawn by applicants. This would ensure that there is publicly available information relating to the exercise of these powers by registrars, recognising that appropriate accountability and transparency should accompany both existing powers of ART registrars and expanded powers introduced in the bill.
Taken together, these reforms will support a more efficient, effective and robust review system, particularly in relation to the migration system by encouraging active participation in the process and dissuading frivolous applications while ensuring that appropriate balances are in place. The tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia have a crucial role in enabling review of government decisions. The bill will support this role by tailoring procedures and operations to enhance efficiencies and ensure the significant migration caseload pressure can be effectively responded to.
Question negatived.
No comments