This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
11:20 am
I rise to speak on the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. I have to say that, sadly, this bill is yet another reminder of the extraordinary incompetence with which the former attorney-general, Mark Dreyfus, approached the reform of Australia's administrative review system. Mr Dreyfus, as we know, was determined to abolish the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Sadly, for the Australian people—and this has now been borne out in the statistics that we will go through shortly—that was a politically driven decision dressed up as administrative reform. But, rather than fixing the existing system, he abolished it and replaced it with an entirely new institution.
At the time, when he was allocating around $1 billion of taxpayers' money to his new politically driven system, he promised Australians a more accessible, efficient and effective system of administrative review. As I said, he had around $1 billion over five years that he utilised to establish and support the new tribunal and address what he said at that time were associated migration related court backlogs—$1 billion of taxpayers' money. I challenge any taxpayer: if you were given $1 billion over a five-year period, what would you do to utilise that? Certainly, it wouldn't be what the former attorney-general ended up doing. With $1 billion of taxpayers' funding, one might say that Australians are entitled to expect a carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented reform. Instead, what have Australians got since this reform took place? Well, it was the most expensive changing of one letter. AAT went to ART—$1 billion of taxpayers' funds. But this has been the result of what the former attorney-general did: growing backlogs, extraordinary delays and a government now repeatedly having to return to the parliament to repair Mr Dreyfus's failed legislative framework. That is now the legacy of the $1 billion reform.
The coalition is going to support this bill. Why? Because we believe that Australians need an administrative review system that works. But our support for this legislation should not be mistaken for approval of the way Labor have sadly handled this exercise. Mr Dreyfus designed the new tribunal, Labor implemented it, and the Albanese government must now answer for its abysmal performance. Sadly, it cannot run away from the figures, and those figures are damning. According to the tribunal's 2025-26 annual report, the ART received 86,980 applications during this year, but it only finalised 65,900. By 30 June 2026, it had 133,749 applications on hand. Remember, this is Mr Dreyfus's new whiz-bang tribunal. That was an increase of over 19 per cent from the previous year. In other words, we're not getting any better. The $1 billion dollars of the taxpayer funding that has been allocated to this disastrous reform is getting worse. That was June—133,749 applications on hand. Worse than that, a few months later, in September—July, August, September, 12 weeks later; you've got to love this—the outstanding caseload has actually risen to 136,236 applications. In other words, this new whizz-bang tribunal meant to go back to what was promised—carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented—has now more than 136,000 matters that are awaiting resolution. You can't run away from that because they're the tribunal's own figures. But that is the reality behind Labor's promise of a faster, more efficient tribunal.
What is even worse—and this should worry all taxpayers—is that the position is particularly alarming on both migration and protection. At the end of September, the tribunal reportedly had 85,221 migration matters and 34,546 protection matters on hand—almost 120,000 outstanding applications, around 88 per cent of the entire backlog—and more than 54,000 student visa review matters alone. As I said, you can't run away from these figures, because they're the tabled figures from the Administrative Review Tribunal. They now expose the enormous pressure of Labor's migration failures. They can only be described as failures. If you were doing something positive, you'd actually be going backwards, heading towards zero, in terms of the figures. Sadly, that is not what is actually occurring.
When it went to a committee, we heard evidence that approximately 90 per cent of protection visa applicants who seek merits review are unsuccessful, while fewer than three per cent of the relevant judicial review applications were allowed in 2024-25. Those figures alone demonstrate why Australians deserve a system capable of resolving matters efficiently and identifying applications without merit. Remember, it's the Australian taxpayer that's paying for these reviews. A review system overwhelmed by delay is failing the people who genuinely need it, but it's also failing the Australian taxpayers, who are paying for it.
Again, the delays are actually staggering. The tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration reviews, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. Multiply that out. It's 136 weeks. There are 52 weeks in a year. That's more than 2½ years for the median family and partner matter. How, when you allocated $1 billion of taxpayers' money over five years, can you describe that as timely access to administrative justice?
So what exactly did Australians receive for the billion dollar redesign? The tribunal's performance against its targets is equally concerning. In 2025-26, it reportedly finalised only 42 per cent of migration and protection matters within 18 months against a target of 75 per cent. So we don't even ask them to reach 100 per cent. We ask them to reach a target of 75 per cent. They miserably failed at that at 42 per cent. Across the tribunal, only 43 per cent of applications finalised during the year were completed within 12 months. The annual report also records that the tribunal was 90.4 full-time-equivalent member positions below its budgeted establishment at 30 June 2026. So you chuck out the system and bring in a new one. You promise the earth to the Australian taxpayers because it's their billion dollars that you're actually utilising. Your completion times go backwards. You have fewer members than you need to actually get the job done. I have to ask the government: how do you expect to reduce the backlog when you've not ensured the tribunal has enough decision-makers to actually make the decisions? Managing demand, recruiting members and ensuring systems are fit for purpose is actually a basic responsibility of government. Sadly, I remember the speeches that were given when the billion dollars of taxpayers' funds were allocated to this new system. The former attorney-general was out there crowing and wanting the political credit for doing this. Well, guess what? If you want the political credit for doing it, the bad news is this: you also have to take the political backlash when the tribunal fails so miserably.
But it's not only that. It gets worse for the Australian taxpayer. After the original billion-dollar commitment, when it started failing almost immediately, the Labor government had to say to the Australian taxpayer: 'Sorry about that. We know it was a billion dollars we allocated. We know it hasn't quite done the job we thought it would do, but what's worse is we're now going to dip back into your pockets.' They actually provided, via the Australian taxpayer, another $69 million of hard-earned taxpayer funds over two years to address what has now become a disgraceful backlog—more money from the Australian taxpayer because the system they implemented was failing. Instead of getting better—we gave you another $69 million—the system has actually got worse. So the Australian taxpayer is quite entitled to ask, when they are under so much financial pressure at the moment, 'What in God's name have we actually received from this government after it expended our funding?' The bad news for the Australian taxpayer is that you actually receive nothing. You've received nothing but a backlog—worse than that, an increasing backlog.
It's a further indictment of this government that they have now had to come back to the parliament. This is the fourth major legislative repair package that we have had to do on behalf of the taxpayer. The government has had to come, cap in hand, to the Senate yet again, for the fourth time, to clean up the mess that Mr Dreyfus created. You had the original establishment and then the consequential legislation. You had the miscellaneous measures legislation. They had to draft it like that because they couldn't actually call it what it was, which was the 'cleaning up Dreyfus' mess' legislation. There were further amendments again, in 2025, to clean up the mess.
The tribunal have now recognised that this is still a mess, and they've had to come to the government to say, 'You've got to draft another piece of legislation,' because this is now out of control because the original legislation was politically drafted not properly drafted. The taxpayer's now paying for it. Now, this attorney-general has had to come to the parliament to say, 'Sorry, I've got another bill to clean up Labor's mess'—another correction, another adjustment and another attempt to make the system function, as we pointed out at the time, sadly. It wasn't like the Labor government weren't told, 'Your legislation is fundamentally flawed. You need to make amendments to it.' But, at the time, oh no, they knew better than us. They knew better than us because it was politically motivated. It wasn't actually drafted to do the job that the new tribunal was meant to do. Sadly, it's the Australian taxpayer who is paying a very, very high price for the Albanese government's incompetence.
That is why, as I said, we are prepared to support this legislation. We are prepared to work with the government to clean up the former attorney-general's disgraceful mess. It was Labor who chose to abolish the AAT. Mr Dreyfus designed, incompetently or for political purposes, its replacement. Labor committed the funding. They oversaw the implementation. They now can't resile from the results that are tabled by the new body. They committed around a billion dollars of taxpayer funding over five years. They then took another $69 million from the taxpayer for backlog measures. We currently have around 136,000 applications outstanding and around 120,000 migration and protection matters awaiting resolution. We are now onto the fourth major legislative package to actually deal with the disaster that this new framework has been.
Sadly, this is the record of the former attorney-general, Mr Dreyfus. As I said, the coalition will support this bill because Australians deserve a tribunal that works. We are pleased the government will put forward amendments suggested by the coalition to make the bill even better. But Labor promised a better tribunal, and sadly, after a billion dollars, all the Australian taxpayer has is growing backlogs and round 4 of fix-up legislation.
No comments