This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


Jana Stewart

Jana Stewart Victoria, Australian Labor Party

11:35 am

I rise today to speak in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. This bill was examined by the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, which I have the privilege of chairing. I want to thank individuals and organisations who contributed to the inquiry. Their evidence and engagement played a really important role in informing the committee's consideration of the bill and its recommendation that this bill be passed. The evidence before the committee reinforced a simple but important point: government decision-makers must make quality decisions, and merits review and judicial review matter. That is why, two years ago, the Albanese government established the Administrative Review Tribunal.

Under the former coalition government, more than 80 Liberal and National associates and failed candidates were appointed to the AAT. An institution that should have stood for merit and independence had become tainted. The Albanese government abolished the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, the AAT, because Australians had lost confidence in it and instead legislated a new merit based appointment process. The ART now independently reviews a broad range of government decisions made under over 400 Commonwealth acts, helping to ensure that government power is exercised lawfully, fairly and transparently. Among the matters that the ART can review are certain decisions about visas made by the Department of Home Affairs, the Minister for Home Affairs or the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship. In certain circumstances, individuals can submit an online application through the tribunal's website and ask for the decision to be independently reconsidered based on its merits. This gives applicants the opportunity to explain their circumstances, to provide relevant information and to have their original decision examined through fresh eyes. Together with the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which hears applications for judicial review, these institutions help ensure government decisions can be reviewed properly. Most importantly, these systems help protect individuals and vulnerable community members against unfair or incorrect decisions. This strengthens accountability and promotes public confidence that Commonwealth laws are administered fairly and transparently.

Recently, there has been an exponential increase in applications to review migration decisions. As this caseload grows, it is especially vital that matters are resolved in a timely and efficient manner. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making and provide genuine applicants with timely outcomes. That is why this bill is about strengthening Australia's merits and judicial review system to support the ART and the Federal Circuit Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to their significant and increasing caseloads.

The first set of reforms in this bill will improve the efficiency and operation of the ART. These reforms include allowing the tribunal to explain their decision orally with written statements of reasons available upon request—notably, this change will exclude reviews of social security, veterans' entitlements, aged-care and National Disability Insurance Scheme matters—requiring applications to review eligible migration or protection decisions to be submitted using an approved form; giving tribunal members greater flexibility to move between salaried or sessional roles; giving additional powers to registrars, including to reinstate applications in certain circumstances or dismiss applications that have no reasonable prospects of success; allowing members to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons made by the registrar; and making other minor technical amendments, including clarifying that the president of the tribunal is assigned to every jurisdictional area, standardising timeframes for review for certain taxation matters and excluding 24 December to 14 January from the calculation of time for original decision-makers to provide certain documents. This matters because it allows the ART to spend less time on unnecessary administrative steps and more time resolving cases. Clearer application requirements, flexible staffing and greater powers for registrars will help matters move through the tribunal more quickly while still preserving written reasons and additional safeguards for reviews involving essential supports such as social security, veterans entitlements, aged care and the NDIS. Put simply, these reforms are about reducing avoidable delay without compromising fairness and quality of decisions. For applicants, that means greater certainty, more timely decisions and a review process that can focus its resources where they are needed most.

Secondly, this bill will strengthen the integrity of Australia's migration review system. It introduces a new power requiring applicants seeking review of certain protection and other migration decisions to verify their identity. At the same time, the bill exempts classes of people or applicants from the verification process. The rationale for this measure is straightforward: it helps ensure the applications are made by people who genuinely intend to engage with the review process and gives the tribunal and the court greater confidence in the integrity of that process. It also encourages active participation from the outset and helps ensure that the scarce resources are directed towards genuine applications.

This bill will also discourage frivolous applications that can consume valuable resources and cause unnecessary delays for applicants who are genuinely seeking review. This measure also complements earlier reforms that allow appropriate migration matters to be considered on the papers, without requiring an oral hearing in every case. Where the relevant information is already before the decision-maker, resolving a matter in this way can reduce unnecessary delay and allow resources to be focused on cases that require more detailed consideration.

Identity verification provides an additional safeguard within that more efficient process by confirming that the applicant is aware of and engaged with the review. For matters before the tribunal, an applicant who is required to verify their identity but does not do so will have their review application dismissed. It is important to note that the bill also includes important safeguards to ensure that fairness remains at the centre of the review process while recognising the distinct role of the courts under our constitutional framework. Applicants who are unable to satisfy identity verification requirements are not left without an option. Mechanisms exist for matters to be reinstated and, where proceedings are before the courts, judicial discretion is preserved so that individual circumstances can be properly considered. This ensures the system remains accessible to genuine applicants while supporting the integrity of Australia's merits and judicial review framework.

Taken together, these reforms reflect the Albanese government's commitment to strong, independent and effective institutions. These reforms will improve efficiency without sacrificing fairness. They will strengthen the integrity of the migration review system and help ensure that Australians have confidence in decisions made by government and the mechanisms available to review them. This practical reform builds on the government's broader work to restore trust in administrative review and ensure our review institutions remain fit for purpose. I commend the bill to the Senate.

Comments

No comments