This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading
Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens
12:05 pm
Of course, I listened closely to the contribution from the previous speaker Senator Cox and want to indicate that the Australian Greens do not agree that the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should be passed. This is a fundamentally flawed piece of legislation which will, as is so often the case when the political duopoly in this country gets together, impact on some of the most marginalised people in our community.
The first concerning change in this legislation is the change to expand the registrar's role to include merits assessments. There are multiple issues with this proposal, but chief amongst them is a very basic question of justice. Registrars are employees, not appointed members, and it is proposed they be given powers well beyond their traditional, quite limited role of determining issues of process and procedure. That is the first issue with this legislation. During the inquiry process on this legislation, Mr Strutt from the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said:
You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members. We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.
Clearly, there are concerns centred around the application of justice and, indeed, the provision of natural justice to people who are going through the processes.
Of course, the government is saying that this is all about efficiency. For anyone who needs that translated, that means it's saving money for the government. This is a government that hands out tens of billions of dollars every year to massively profitable, highly polluting corporations to encourage them to keep burning fossil fuels. This is a government that's going to spend $350 billion on AUKUS nuclear submarines that are going to make Australia a more dangerous place to be if we ever get them in the first place, and, if we do get them, they'll not only make us more dangerous but be obsolete by the time that we get them. This is a government that has got plenty of cash to splash on corporate welfare, on subsidising the heating of the planet and on nuclear submarines that we may never see, but somehow they have to find efficiencies by punching down on some of the most marginal people in our community and compromising natural justice in one of our most important judicial institutions.
Another change of concern in this legislation is the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet identity verification requirements. Well, what I'm going to say here is: here we go again. Just about every significant erosion of human rights in the immigration space in this country has been led by the Australian Labor Party—mandatory immigration detention brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons on Manus Island brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons in Naoero brought to Australia and still run, at massive cost to the taxpayer, by the Australian Labor Party. They are a carceral political party. They were a party of White Australia back in the day. They've engaged in a race to the bottom and are still engaged in a race to the bottom on immigration with a coalition that is still desperately trying to outflank the fascists in One Nation on the right. And here we go again, punching down on immigrants.
Let's just imagine a case here. Let's say a woman from Afghanistan, a Hazara woman, has somehow managed to escape the clutches of the Taliban and flee with her children, some of whom are daughters, young girls, and they've managed to get to Australia. She hasn't had a passport. Her immigration documents were confiscated from her while she was escaping Afghanistan. She's come to Australia. The Afghan embassy is shut. Obviously, she can't approach the Taliban for her identity documents because who knows what would happen to the rest of her family that remain in Afghanistan? They could be abducted, tortured, killed or stoned to death. What processes are going to be in place for that woman and her family? Is she going to face a mandatory dismissal of her application because she can't prove her identity to the satisfaction of some bureaucrat in Home Affairs or some appointed official in the tribunal? What is going to happen? When these questions were raised, quite recently, by Senator Shoebridge during the inquiry into this legislation, the best that the respondent could provide was, 'Oh, well, the government's aware of this problem.' Well, that's not very reassuring! The government's aware of the problem, but it's still proceeding with a piece of legislation in the complete and utter absence of a solution. Here we go again.
This country, which used to have a White Australia policy officially and now just runs it unofficially, which exiles black-skinned and brown-skinned people to be tortured in the offshore torture centres in Manus Island and Naoero—there's not a single white-skinned person. And I can tell you, colleagues; I was there. I went to Manus Island many times, and people who've been in this chamber long enough will recall my advocacy for the men who were exiled to Manus Island and my very firm view, supported by Amnesty International, that what was done to those people constitutes the legal definition of 'torture' under international law. And I'm telling you, as someone who went to Manus Island, who was inside the Lombrum detention centre at the time the Australian government—albeit then a Liberal government but with the full support, I might add, of the Australian Labor Party—withdrew the food, the drinking water and the medical supports and cut off the electricity to 650 people who'd been incarcerated there illegally under Australian and international law for years. And do you know how many white-skinned people there were? I'll tell you. None—not a single white-skinned person.
Don't tell me that, if a boatload of South African farmers had arrived on our shores, they would have ended up exiled to Manus Island. We know they would not have, because offshore detention was and remains, today, a racist policy in this country. The impacts of these changes will be racist because they will have greater impact on a larger number of non-white people. Let's name these changes for what they are. But it won't just be about the colour of people's skin. Some of the most marginalised people in our community will fall foul of these changes, including people who are experiencing and trying to flee from domestic or family violence.
The final aspect of concern in this bill that I want to talk about are the proposed changes to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. Senator Bleyer, as a lawyer—I'm going to make an assumption here—will have something to say about these changes. Just imagine this scenario, colleagues, should this legislation pass and there's removal of the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made. Yes, applicants will be able to request written reasons, but that process can take as long as 28 days, when you have an appeal window of 35 days. So, instead of someone getting their written reasons on day one and having seven weeks to consider whether they want to prepare and lodge an appeal, they will now have as little as seven days to do what they previously had seven weeks to do. This is manifestly unfair. It is an absolute abrogation of natural justice.
You can measure a government by the way it looks after some of the most marginalised people it governs. I've been through some of the ancient history of the Australian Labor Party; the recent history of the Australian Labor Party in caring for vulnerable and marginalised people has been abject. Just in the last month, we've seen huge cuts to the National Disability Insurance Scheme that will place the very lives of disabled people at increased risk and mean that large numbers of disabled people in our community will no longer be able to lead lives with a measure of human dignity. Off the back of that, we now have these changes, which, again, are a denial of natural justice and procedural fairness.
It is worth pointing out that most migration applicants appear unrepresented at the ART. For many of them, English is a second, third or fourth language, and their English-language skills may not be of the highest order. Removing the requirement for written reasons when decisions are made means that people who may not have comprehensive English understanding are going to verbally have presented to them a complex rationale for a decision that may ultimately be life or death for them. Then, they'll have to go through the process of requesting a written reason, which, before it gets provided to them, can take four-fifths of their appeal window.
And I'll tell you something else about not having to provide a written reason. It will almost certainly degrade the quality of decision-making. I'll use an example that will be familiar to every single sitting senator in this place, and that is jotting down notes for a speech. The actual act of writing a speech can help you clarify your thinking. We all know that. But, if there's no requirement for written reasons, then decisions will almost inevitably be based on a gut feeling, and then you will find people will reverse engineer an argument if they are required to provide written reasons. That is the problem here. You will get written reasons that are reverse engineered to fit a decision that was made without the person having to sit down and write out the reasons. (Time expired.)
No comments