This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

11:44 am

I rise on behalf of the Greens to indicate we have significant concerns about the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026, and we'll be moving amendments to the legislation to seek to address those. If those amendments are not supported—and it seems clear that Labor and coalition senators are on a unity ticket to create unfairness—we will not be supporting this legislation.

The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill seeks to make three major changes to the operation of the Administrative Review Tribunal. All are crafted as producing efficiencies, and we just heard from the government senator, Senator Stewart, the argument that this is all designed for fairness and to ensure people's rights are protected. It's far from it. The entire thrust of this legislation is to take away rights, to take away fair process and to greatly limit the rights of people before the Administrative Review Tribunal, all dressed up by the government and the coalition, who are on a unity ticket here, as efficiency, but what it actually means is meanness and the taking away of people's rights.

We do know how to actually make the system fairer. We do know how to make the system more efficient. The way you do that is by providing legal assistance to genuine applicants, and you do that in the migration stream and across the board in the ART. It's been done before and, each time it's been done before, it's worked. Between 2006 and 2009, there was a pilot program instituted in the then AAT and in the community legal centres that support refugee claims. That was incredibly successful. The community care pilot also saw caseworkers instead of going out to put people in detention who were in breach of their visa conditions who might have overstayed. They sent caseworkers out to work with people and work out what was going on in their lives. It turns out that, when you treat people as people, not problems, you resolve matters. There was a radical improvement in compliance. Many people just had significant financial barriers to getting their visa situation sorted. Some of them just had a financial barrier that meant they couldn't go home. Some of them had children that they needed to stay for in order to be parents. They just needed help. It turned out that, when caseworkers went instead of Border Force, that the compliance rate was in the mid to high 90s. If you treat people like humans, like they matter, and don't punch down on them like Labor, the coalition and One Nation seem to do, it actually works.

We know that, in more recent history, there was a short-lived—should be permanent—program to give legal assistance to people, particularly to legal aid and community legal centres, to provide legal assistance to help people who are otherwise unrepresented bring an asylum claim to the ART. What did you find in that? You again found rapid turnarounds, matters being rapidly resolved instead of hanging around for months or for years, meritorious applications being approved rapidly, people getting their visas sorted, and people who didn't have a meritorious application being told that by a well-qualified, capable lawyer. Those applications just won't run. I really want to commend the work of legal aid and community legal centres across the country who made that project work. Of course, the government then cut the funding, but, if you look, for example, at what Victoria Legal Aid did with that funding, they had that increased funding from July 2024 to June 2025. They assisted 620 unique clients with more than 2,000 legal services provided to them. That provided 800 separate pieces of legal advice and 147 separate representations, and 90 per cent of those matters saw positive outcomes, including decisions refusing protection visas being overturned, matters remitted to the ART for further review and, when they went to the ART—because they'd gone with careful legal advice, they were determined quickly—90 per cent of those protection visa reviews had significant positive feedback from the tribunal.

The tribunal is thankful when this happens. As one tribunal member said: 'Any tribunal member who's presided over a matter with an unrepresented applicant would appreciate the work of lawyers in representing the applicant's case so well.' Hearings were shorter, decisions were made quickly, and, in the majority of times, decisions were delivered in just three weeks after the final hearing because the issues are crystallised, the evidence is narrowed down, and the case is presented. That is the answer to the backlog. Reinstate the legal funding that used to be applied so that meritorious cases are run well and efficiently, that the tribunal is given the assistance they need and that unmeritorious cases are given early legal advice that they just won't get up. But, of course, what does this government do? What does Labor do? They just reject all of that evidence and decide to punch down on migrants, like they do so often.

It's for those reasons that I move the second reading amendment circulated in my name. I move:

At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate acknowledges that:

(a) wait times in visa processing began to increase in 2014 after cuts to legal assistance; and

(b) the way to reduce backlogs and ensure a fair and fast visa processing system is to fully fund legal assistance".

I commend that second reading amendment to the Senate, because that's actually how you fix backlogs and how you produce efficiency.

Instead, what do this government do? They do three things. The first is expanding the registrar's role, and registrars aren't even always legally qualified. They absolutely don't have security of tenure, like permanent members do, and they do not have the security of appointed members. They're basically employees of the executive. They are not full tribunal members. They're employees of the executive open to be hired and fired by the executive. What does this government propose to do? It wants to grant registrars the power to dismiss applications if the registrar is 'satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success'.

Submission after submission to the inquiry said that this was wrong. I want to particularly point out the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre, the Kaldor Centre and the Law Council of Australia. Every submission from a credible entity said don't do this. For example, Carina Ford from the Law Council of Australia said:

I think the difficulty with migration decisions is that they are not generally objective. They do require a level of assessment at the level of a member. There might be some cases that could fall within it. For example, there could be a case where English language testing wasn't attached to a time of application case. But overall there is a level of assessment. A good example is the student visa case load. That has moved to decisions on the papers, and it still requires the criteria to be assessed because it is subjective.

The proposal is we'll give employees of the ART, not tribunal members, the ability to dismiss matters on a subjective test. That's a fundamentally judicial or quasijudicial power, and it should not be exercised by employees who can be hired and fired by the principal registrar.

As the Kaldor Centre noted—here I particularly want to credit the work of Professor Daniel Ghezelbash. They noted:

Not only do these amendments have significant adverse impacts on the ability of applicants to access review of their protection visa applications but they are also likely to generate further litigation and appeals, shifting delays downstream to the Federal Circuit and Family Court rather than resolving them.

That's what we're likely to see here—the ART making decisions, alleging that there are no reasonable prospects for success, making that decision on the papers, having it done by a registrar and then that leading to appeals in the ART and then a raft of separate appeals to the Federal Circuit and Family Court, clogging up the system, costing taxpayers' money and failing to address with the merits of the case. These changes are bad law. They are bad law, and they will undermine the integrity of the ART, and, for those reasons, the Greens will be opposing them, and we're in good company with pretty much every credible legal organisation and advocate in the space saying these laws should not be made.

The second problem with this legislation is about the proposed changes about verification of identity. There is a proposal here for the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet as yet unspecified identity verification requirements. The details of that information on this change are absent from the bill, totally absent, and, instead, the government have claimed that they're going to somehow be implemented through regulations and that, of course, that's sufficient. Regulations have much less parliamentary oversight and less engagement from key stakeholders. This lack of knowledge about how it worked was made clear when we asked, for example, the principal registrar of the ART what the procedures would be like. Mr Hawkins—credit to him—said:

We understand that the applicant will need to present to a tribunal either in person or virtually, the details of which I'm yet to see, their identity.

The tribunal has no idea how it's going to happen. Then he said:

Given that we're dealing with a current caseload, I understand that it's from applications from a particular period in time onwards.

Then, when pressed about it, he said very clearly that the tribunal had no idea how it would work. Then, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department how it worked, this is the exchange we got. I asked Ms Inverarity of the department:

So the Hazara woman has fled with her children to Australia from Afghanistan. She has never had a passport and never had travel documents and has come onshore. The Afghan embassy has shut. She obviously isn't going to go and approach the Taliban in Afghanistan for identity documents because then her family could well be persecuted and killed. What processes will there be in place for a woman in that situation to have her identity verification assessed and not have a mandatory dismissal of her application?

The department said:

I can't give you an answer with the precision that will make you happy other than that I have referred already to the fact that this is an issue that is already well known to the Australian government. The National Identity Proofing Guidelines cover the need for alternative proofing arrangements for people who do not have the traditional suite of identity documents.

There are no answers—no answers to the tribunal and no answers to the parliament—and yet this legislation is being rammed through.

This change disproportionately impacts the most marginalised, such as people experiencing domestic and family violence. It's well documented that control over identification documents is a common form of coercion by abusers. That's true of family abuse as well as abusive employers. And yet this government is pushing through legislation knowing who's going to be harmed by it—the most marginal people—adding that coercive control power to employers and abusive partners, who can just withhold the documents. It's outrageous.

Then the third issue of concern for us is the proposal to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. As the Refugee Council of Australia noted in its submission:

Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the Tribunal's findings, decision making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.

Then there was confusion as to why this was happening between the department and the ART. Again, Mr Hawkins made clear that they weren't expecting to use the power in complex cases, although there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases. As Mr Hawkins explained:

I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.

But there's no limitation in the bill to have it only on successful applications—none at all. Matters can be dismissed with no reasons given and then, if you want reasons, you've got to go through this further complex process to try and get reasons, all while your appeal rights are ticking away and the time limits are ticking away. There's more complication and more bureaucracy. Who's going to be impacted most in this? The most marginal people. Each of these elements punches down on the most marginal people in the system.

Of course, that's what Labor are doing in the migration space because they're not actually chasing fairness. They're not actually chasing efficiency. If they wanted efficiency and fairness, they'd properly fund the legal system. They'd give people actual representation and make it better for the tribunal. They'd make the Department of Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place so they're not constantly being appealed. But they don't want to make the department do their work properly. They don't want to properly fund actual legal representation. They want to chase One Nation. That's what this is about. Again, Labor are chasing One Nation with their meanness, their nastiness and their punching down on migrants. That's what this legislation is. They can speak what they like about efficiency. The only efficiency here is meanness. That's why the Greens will be opposing it.

Comments

No comments