This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026; Second Reading
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
9:01 am
I rise to speak to the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026. This could be one of those rare moments that parliament actually gets ahead of a wave of technology, a wave of change, and puts the protection of Australians—our privacy, and our right not to be covertly recorded, for once, could get ahead of that wave and the protection of millions and millions of Australians could be put ahead of the profits of big tech. That's what this bill is designed to do. The Greens are bringing this bill to parliament because Australians are being secretly filmed by people wearing what look like ordinary glasses, and our laws are doing nothing to stop. it. Women and girls, in particular, are being recorded without their knowledge at the beach, on the street, at the gym and while they're going about their business shopping, engaging with their family, friends and perhaps their work colleagues, and the footage is being posted online for clicks and engagement and sometimes for intentional humiliation.
These videos are disturbing. They have no place, and the Greens say that they are utterly unacceptable. It is not good enough for this parliament just to put this in the too-hard basket and step aside. This year the problem has exploded. Kmart's $89 camera glasses sold out across the country in a week. It was a cheap stunt by a retailer, but it sent cheaper copies of these Meta glasses flooding through our society. And it wasn't just Kmart. Once Kmart built the hype, we saw even cheaper copies flooding through online market places, with prices as low as $45. You can get them today online.
Of course, Meta is pushing to add facial recognition to its glasses, so wearers can identify strangers in real time—scan the strangers and others they meet with real-time facial recognition. Footage from these devices recorded here covertly of our friends, our families and ourselves has been shipped overseas and watched by contract workers who are training AI. Covert recordings have been fed overseas and are training AI models, with no meaningful control for the wearer or the people that they film.
Let's be clear about this. These devices are not just a privacy risk for the people that are being observed and recorded without their consent. They are an even larger privacy risk for the wearers. Amazon in the US is already forcing thousands of its workers to wear these devices for their entire work day to track their movements, to grade their performance and to monitor every action they take. These devices are a privacy disaster on all grounds—for wearers and for those that are being covertly recorded—and our laws have zero answer to them.
The Albanese government's Attorney-General has written some letters. Well, whoopee! They've written some letters. I think the Attorney-General wrote a letter to the Privacy Commissioner. Well, whoopee! What did that do? Nothing. They've launched consultations. We have the Attorney-General's Department and the Attorney-General saying to local councils: 'You should go and sort this out yourselves if you've got issues with privacy at your local swimming pool or your local library. The Commonwealth government's not here to help you. The Albanese government is not here to help you. Go and sort it out yourselves. Come up with your own little local bans or local policies across the country because, sure as heck, the Albanese government is not going to help you. Labor's not here to help you.' They've said the same to small businesses—'Go and sort it out yourselves. Government's not here to help.' How wrong that is. What a complete denial of responsibility and leadership we've seen in this space.
I want to be clear. A letter from the Attorney-General to the Privacy Commissioner is not how you sort out this privacy mess. It's not how you protect Australians and their privacy. The government's draft privacy laws are months away, after years of delay already. And, when you read them, they don't even pretend to deal with covert devices directly. At best, they've got some kind of obligation on entities that gather information on how they store it. If a corporate entity stores the information, then there are some privacy obligations on it. But there's nothing to stop people wearing these devices and recording without consent in gyms, in restaurants and on beaches—nothing. There's not a word in Labor's proposed privacy laws to take any step. That, of course, leaves a major privacy gap. It's a privacy gulf. Every week it stays open, more and more of these devices are being imported into our country and more and more of these devices are ending up in circulation. You're much more likely every week that we get no action to be covertly recorded as you go about your business. More and more Australians are having their privacy breached because this government is a do-nothing government when it comes to privacy. It's a do-nothing government.
Our bill, the Greens bill, closes that gap with a simple temporary step. It adds wearable recording devices to the Customs (Prohibited Imports) Regulations so that they can only be brought into the country with written permission from the Minister for Home Affairs. It covers videorecording devices worn on the body or carried as an accessory, including glasses, earbuds, watches, pins and pendants, while leaving audio-only devices and standard cameras, including phone cameras, alone and untouched. There is a clear pathway through this bill for the importation of wearable recording devices which would otherwise be banned when they are to be used as disability aids. We've spoken to the disability community. We've heard their very real views on this and how, for some in our community, these wearable devices can be really important. People with visual impairment can find barriers broken with these devices, and there needs to be an import pathway so that the legitimate uses of the devices can be allowed and permitted. That is why we are giving, in this bill, the Minister for Home Affairs the capacity to allow importation for those legitimate uses of the device. Why are we doing this? Why the 12-month freeze? We say that this gives this parliament a chance to fill the privacy gap. The one-year freeze on imports gives parliaments—and it may well be state and territory parliaments grappling with this as well as the federal parliament—experts and civil society the space needed to build lasting privacy protections so that, when the freeze lifts in 12 months time, Australians will be able to go about their lives without wondering who is secretly filming them and without checking the glasses or the lapel pins of the person they're sharing a space with to see if they're covertly recording them or not.
We want to ensure that consent is a fundamental part of the laws. Absent consent, there should be no covert recording. That should be how the law operates. They're fundamentally giving the rights of Australians away in places like this—women, in particular, but not just women. It's all of us. The law needs to be the right to say 'no consent, no covert recording'. Big tech is selling surveillance as fashion, and they know what these devices will provide for them: a new, rich stream of data. For big tech, the data about the wearer is perhaps the most valuable part of this. Monitoring every movement, hearing every conversation, seeking every interaction.
Think about it for Coles and Woolies for a moment. If you've got a livestream of your customers walking down the aisle, you not only see what they purchase—you can already track that!—but you see what other products they look at, how long they linger on that and which part of the shelves they look at. You build this complete data profile of individuals who are wearing these devices, and then they monetise and weaponise it. There are no constraints on it under current law. Of course we need to press pause on this and give parliament and civil society the chance to put some constraints around this technology, to point out that we're not going to permit the covert surveillance not just of people who are being observed but the 24/7 data collection of Australians who are wearing these devices. At the moment, people are buying these devices from $45, they're connecting them online, and they have no idea where their data is going. Is it going off to a server in China? Is it going off to that nice Mr Musk in the US? Is it being fed into Meta's global servers to build this picture about everything you do, every conversation you have and everywhere you look? The answer to that is probably, 'Yes, all of that, all at once, all happening now.' This government is doing absolutely nothing to put controls in place. It is extraordinary. For once, let's step up. For once, let's put the public interest ahead of big tech's profits. For once, let's act before the wave of harm has washed across this country, and let's act to prevent it rather than cleaning it up afterwards.
There's much more that could be said about the gaps in our privacy laws these glasses have so clearly identified. I think the core thing is the absence of the requirement for consent. Of course there is a legitimate place for public recordings. We need to be able to record things in public—you're going on a holiday, you're out interacting with your friends, or a media outlet is there in a public space—where a camera is set up or a phone's up and you're recording. People can see what's happening. That's quite a legitimate part of how we interact. If you're at a protest and the police are behaving badly, you can record that happening. You put your phone up and you record it.
For many people, the ability to put your phone up and record in public places is a shield because other people can see that they're recording them. The police can see they're being recorded. Someone behaving badly can see they're being recorded and can see what's happening; they're not being covertly filmed. And there's clear acknowledgement of what is happening. That's what happens when you do it with a phone, and that's what happens when you do it with a news camera or a traditional camera. People can see what's happening.
But it is fundamentally different if somebody's standing there, you're going about your business and they're covertly recording you with a wearable device. You have no idea if it's happening, and they may entrap you. We see these videos of men entrapping young women, in particular, engaging and secretly recording the interaction and then posting it online to humiliate or belittle. It's happening already. That's the fundamental difference. And that is why consent is critical when the device is covert. Our privacy law does nothing in that. In fact, a 2024 study of Australian adults, before this technology went wild, had 17 per cent of smart glasses owners admitting using them in a prohibited way, recording others without consent. This is the reality. The Greens are bringing this bill as a way of protecting Australians, and we would urge other parties in this chamber to join with us and, for once, get it right. (Time expired)
Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia
9:16 am
(): The coalition recognises the serious privacy concerns arising from the growing availability of smart glasses and other wearable recording devices that allow individuals to film people discreetly and without their knowledge. Australians have a reasonable expectation that they should not be secretly filmed or subjected to inappropriate surveillance while going about their everyday lives. Women and children are particularly vulnerable to the misuse of this technology including covert filming, harassment, stalking and the potential distribution of intimate or otherwise inappropriate footage. We need to ensure the law keeps pace with technology.
Whether Australians are at the beach, shopping, travelling on public transport or attending their children's schools, they deserve appropriate protections against intrusive and unauthorised recording. Rapid advances in technology have outpaced existing privacy protections, creating legitimate concerns about whether Australian laws are equipped to address the misuse of increasingly sophisticated recording devices.
While the coalition acknowledges these concerns, we do not believe the Greens' proposed 12-month import prohibition represents an appropriate or sufficiently comprehensive response. Banning the importation of smart glasses will not address the underlying problem: the misuse of recording technology by individuals who disregard the privacy of others. Smart glasses are already widely available in Australia, and preventing further imports will do nothing to address the devices already in circulation. The Greens' legislation would impose substantial restrictions on legitimate technology users without directly addressing the inappropriate conduct that has given rise to public concern.
The Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026 goes considerably further than smart glasses, capturing a broad range of wearable recording devices including certain watches, earbuds, jewellery, badges and other accessories capable of discreet visual recording. There are legitimate uses for wearable recording devices including assisting people with disabilities, capturing sporting activities, documenting incidents and undertaking professional activities. Although the bill provides a ministerial permission pathway, including consideration of disability related uses, it does not create an automatic exemption for all legitimate users. The Greens have failed to adequately explain why an import prohibition is preferable to appropriately targeted restrictions on covert recording, on misuse of footage and on the manufacture and sale of devices without adequate privacy safeguards.
The coalition believes the focus should be on preventing harmful conduct rather than indiscriminately restricting access to emerging technology. A temporary import prohibition that automatically expires after 12 months risks creating uncertainty for consumers and businesses without delivering a permanent solution to the underlying privacy concerns. The coalition is particularly concerned that the Albanese government has been too slow to respond to the rapidly evolving privacy risks associated with wearable recording technology. The Attorney-General has already written to the Australian Privacy Commissioner, requesting consideration of the privacy implications of smart glasses, including the risks of inappropriate recording, harassment and surveillance.
However, referring the issue to the Privacy Commissioner is not, by itself, a substitute for taking concrete action to address gaps in Australian law. Australians concerned about being secretly filmed deserve more than another referral, another review or another round of bureaucratic consideration. The Commonwealth Privacy Act 1988 generally regulates government agencies and businesses but does not comprehensively regulate private individuals recording other people for personal business. Compounding this problem, surveillance and listening device legislation differs considerably between the states and territories, creating uncertainty about the protections available to Australians.
The Albanese government must urgently work with state and territory governments to identify these regulatory gaps and develop a consistent and effective response. The government should examine whether stronger protections are required against covert recording in sensitive locations, particularly in schools, changing rooms, public amenities and other locations where individuals have heightened expectations of privacy. It should also consider whether enforceable privacy and safety standards are required for wearable recording devices sold in Australia, including clear recording indicators and protections against unauthorised surveillance. Manufacturing and technology companies should be expected to consider privacy and safety when designing and distributing these products, rather than leaving consumers to manage the risks themselves. Any legislative response must be sufficiently flexible to accommodate technological developments rather than target a particular product that may soon be superseded by more sophisticated technology.
The coalition expects the Albanese government to treat this issue with urgency and bring forward a proportionate, practical and technologically neutral regulatory response. The coalition does not dismiss the privacy concerns that have prompted the Greens to introduce this legislation. However, legitimate concerns do not automatically justify broad import restrictions that fail to address the underlying problem. We need laws that protect Australians against covert surveillance, harassment and inappropriate recording, regardless of which device is being used. We must also ensure that legitimate uses of technology, including by Australians with disabilities, are not unnecessarily restricted. The coalition will not support the Greens' proposed import ban, but we will continue to press the Albanese government to act urgently to ensure Australia's privacy protections keep pace with emerging technology.
Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water
9:24 am
The government's priority is always to keep Australians safe and secure, and, as technology changes, our approach to safety and security must also change. We want to keep Australians safe from those who want to use wearable devices in a way that violates privacy, especially that of women and children, who could disproportionately experience targeting for inappropriate recording, harassment, surveillance or other harmful conduct. We also recognise that wearable devices, such as what are known as smart glasses, have legitimate uses—for example, for people with disabilities, who have a better quality of life because of technological aids. Vision Australia has described the responsible use of smart glasses as 'absolutely life changing' and said, 'A ban would be the absolute wrong answer,' and yet the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026 proposes an import ban of that nature.
The existing border controls framework states:
Border controls are not the default option for managing regulatory needs, particularly when domestic controls and/or regulations are more appropriate or effective …
That's obviously a statement around products in general, but it has some application here as well. It's because of that emphasis on the need for domestic controls and regulations, rather than only resorting to border controls, that we've seen local governments around the country take action already and ban the use of smart glasses in environments that are clearly inappropriate—in gyms, at pools, in childcare centres and at playgrounds. It's hard to think of a situation in which the use of smart glasses in those types of environments could be justified, and, of course, the safety and security risks that flow from it are obvious. That, again, is why we have seen local governments around the country appropriately take action to ban the use of smart glasses in those sorts of environments. Having said that, the government continues to assess the controls around smart devices to ensure the safety of the community is protected.
The government is also targeting these devices in terms of cybersecurity and safety to ensure they are secure and meet legislative requirements. The Department of Home Affairs has commenced a campaign to assess the compliance of smart glasses against the security standards set out in the Cyber Security Act 2024. Consumer-grade smart devices must meet mandatory security standards, such as 'no universal default passwords'; manufacturers must publish a means to report security issues; and manufacturers must publish information about how long the device will be supported for. The Department of Home Affairs has contacted retailers of smart glasses and asked them to inform their suppliers and manufacturers about the applicable Australian requirements and the work to assess compliance.
Notwithstanding the various measures that we've taken, like those that I've just run through, the Albanese government understand that Australians have genuine concerns about the privacy implications of smart glasses and other emerging technologies. That's exactly why the government is focused on strengthening privacy protections. We're currently consulting on major Privacy Act reforms to ensure that Australia's laws keep pace with emerging technologies, such as smart glasses. Our priority is getting the settings right through evidence, expert advice and public consultation.
The Privacy Commissioner is actively examining the privacy risks associated with smart glasses. In August, the Attorney-General requested that the commissioner give priority consideration to these issues. The government welcomes the Privacy Commissioner's investigation into the maker of the HeyCyan smart glasses application and supports efforts to determine whether privacy laws have been breached. As a result of the commissioner's investigation, many retailers have pulled these products from their shelves.
More than 90 per cent of Australians say that protecting personal information is important to them, yet almost four in five Australians report having little or no control over how their personal information is collected and used. Our government's proposed privacy reforms would introduce a fair-and-reasonable test so organisations could not collect more information than they needed or use it in ways that Australians would not expect. The reforms would strengthen consent requirements and introduce a right to erasure, allowing people to request the deletion of personal information held by large digital platforms. These reforms are technology neutral and would apply to emerging technologies, including smart glasses and AI.
The government's focus is on strong, futureproof privacy protections that work across all technologies. We'll continue listening to experts, advocates, industry and the community through this process to ensure we deliver stronger privacy protections without unintended consequences.
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
9:29 am
I rise to support the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026, and I thank Senator Shoebridge for bringing it into the chamber for us all to discuss. Let me start by saying what I said when recording a video for my socials on this very topic:
Now introducing a revolutionary new device for your eyes: pervert glasses.
I know that this is not the title on the bill, but it is an honest description of a pair of glasses that look like glasses, behave like glasses but quietly film the person sitting across from you. This is not science fiction. Cheap versions have been on the shelves of major retailers and have sold out. Some can be bought online for less than hundreds of dollars. I think Senator Shoebridge mentioned that they are out there for 45 bucks. Senator Shoebridge also pointed to research from Monash University finding that a disturbing number of owners admitted to using them to secretly record people, including in places like change rooms and at the beach. I wouldn't call that innovation and neither would you. It's a surveillance device with a fashion label, and it's advertised as such.
Over the last three months, I've sat in school halls talking to students from all walks of life across Western Australia. I've been asked about everything, from housing to HECS, the NDIS, why politics is so divisive and AI. AI has definitely been a common thread in almost every session. Young people want to know why the technology reshaping their lives is being regulated after the damage is done, not before. They asked me why AI will affect their jobs and why this government is not regulating it. They asked why the social media ban was rushed through with so little say from the people it affects. They asked what I think about AI and drones. They asked whether anyone in this place is actually keeping up. The government sits there saying that we're doing so much about these glasses in particular. Why don't you just pause it then? Pause the import of them so that regulation can keep up and get on track.
This generation has grown up with a camera in their pockets. They know better than anyone in this chamber what it means to have your image taken, clipped, shared, circulated and sometimes faked without your say. Schools have already banned these glasses from classrooms because deep fakes and live streaming were posing great risks. Students didn't need a royal commission to work out the problem; they saw it coming. If teenagers can see it coming, why aren't we doing something about it in this place? Why isn't the parliament acting on this?
Because I've seen a lot of confusion and a fair bit of spin, let's iron out some things about this bill. This bill amends the Customs (Prohibited Imports) Regulations to prohibit the import of wearable recording devices unless the minister or an authorised departmental officer grants permission. It lasts 12 months and then lapses automatically. A wearable recording device is one that can make a visual recording, is designed to be worn or carried on the body and is something an ordinary person could not easily identify as a camera—think glasses, earbuds, pins, pendants and watches. That's the bill.
Now let's look at some of the myths or misconceptions that have been spreading. There's a misconception that this is a ban on cameras. It's not. Phones are not covered. Hand-held cameras are not covered. The explanatory memorandum is explicit that existing camera technology, like a GoPro, which is plainly a camera, is not intended to be captured. Audio-only devices are not covered. There is nothing here that stops a journalist, an artist or even members of your family filming a birthday party. What it targets is covert recording, where the person being filmed has no way of knowing that they're being recorded.
Misconception No. 2 is that this is a permanent ban. Again, that's not the case. It is a pause. The prohibition repeals itself 12 months after it starts. That is a deliberate design choice. It gives government a window to do the work it should already be doing: building proper permanent privacy protections. And there's a third misconception: that this harms people with disability. It's important to look at the fact that people who have vision or hearing impairments rely on wearing technology to assist them in their day-to-day functionality, and I will not support any law that locks them out. The bill requires the minister or authorised officer to consider whether a device is intended as a disability aid, using the definition in the Disability Discrimination Act. That is built into the decision. It is a permission pathway, not a blanket wall. So if anyone wants to strengthen the pathway in committee, I'm definitely open to conversation. But I implore everyone to back this bill in the first place.
There's a fourth misconception: that it will take your glasses away. This bill will not do that. The bill applies to goods imported on or after it commences, so it does not reach devices that are already in Australia. Nobody is knocking on doors and confiscating glasses you already own. Misconception No. 5 is that a little light on the frame will solve all the problems. Well, some devices have an indicator light when they record. But Senator Shoebridge has said, rightly, that these are far from any real protection. A tiny LED light during daytime on a crowded beach, in a gym or on a train is not consent, and many devices have no warning at all. So there is definitely something to look into there.
Misconception No. 6 is that the government has this covered. The Attorney-General has opened consultation on privacy law reform. And the reform is welcome. I will say that plainly and give credit where it's due. But the Attorney-General has also said that the consultation is not about an import ban, pointing to consequences across trade and foreign affairs. Senator Shoebridge has also noted that glasses that identify a stranger, their job and their social media history can still sit outside of the reforms, unless the wearer is doing it for work. So here is the gap: people are being filmed now, the reforms are coming very slowly and, in between, thousands of devices are arriving on our shores.
I support this bill, because a pause is a sensible response to a fast-moving harm as we can see it. When you're in a hole, you stop digging. But if I'm absolutely honest with the chamber, I have to say I feel that an import pause is not a sustainable plan. Yes, it buys time, but it does not use it. This is the pattern I keep seeing. Pervert glasses today, AI deepfakes yesterday, data harvesting, identity theft—every time, this government responds after the headline, after the harm, after the victim. It's very reactive—every single time. That whack-a-mole attitude towards fixing problems needs to go, because it's not helping anybody. It's definitely not serving Australians. So my ask of the government is very simple: support this bill, or come back with your own interim measure of equal strength. Don't tell Australians you're not ruling anything out while thousands of devices arrive on our shores.
Second, use the 12 months. Extend privacy law so that the filming, storing or sharing of footage from these devices without consent is a clear breach, whether the wearer is at work or just being nosey at the pool. Require clear outward signs of recording as a floor, not a ceiling. And close the loophole on devices that pull up information about the strangers they look at.
Third, I would implore the government to deliver a comprehensive AI regulatory framework, not the patchwork that we've heard of and not a new response each time a product goes viral. Again, I implore them to deliver not those reactive types of measures but a framework that anticipates the next device before it's on the shelf and being sold to everyday Australians. It would ensure that companies that are selling them are held to account. This is because big tech will not police itself. It never has and it never will.
When I was at one of those schools, one of the students asked me whether politics is designed to keep young people out. I think a better question is: why are the people who understand this technology best the ones we listen to the least? These young people are engaging. They are watching their privacy get treated as a product to be sold. They're asking for something simple: the right to walk down a street, sit in a classroom or swim at the beach without wondering whether the person next to them is quietly filming. Again, it's not a radical ask. It's not controversial. It shouldn't be controversial. It's just the basic expectation of living in a free society. So let's press pause, let's use the time and let's, for once, get ahead of the technology, instead of chasing it. I commend the bill to the Senate.
Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens
9:41 am
The rise of AI is a seismic moment in human history. When you look around us at the moment, we are living through a rolling polycrisis made up of war, genocide, climate change, ecosystem collapse and the obscene funnelling of humanity's wealth into the hands of a few and out of the bank accounts of everyday people. AI coming on top of that means that there has rarely been a time in human history when government responses have been so important, and yet there has also rarely been a time in human history when our democratic institutions have been capable of the kind of action that is necessary.
Part of the reason that our democratic institutions—including this parliament, I might add—are not capable of taking the kind of action that is necessary in response to this huge range of challenges facing humanity at the moment is in fact the way that artificial intelligence, in the form of algorithms that drive social media content, has undermined our democracy. We've seen it in the UK with Brexit. We've seen it in the US with the election twice of Trump to the Oval Office. We have seen it repeated around the world, where bad actors, money and power can deliver electoral results through the manipulation of voting systems and the manipulation of algorithms that drive the social media content that so many people use as their primary source of information today.
And now we see the rise of artificial intelligence. It is not overstating what is happening to say that this is a genuine threat to humanity and a genuine threat to our civilisation and the society that we all live in. If you want evidence of that, have a look at the words and actions of the tech bros who are driving this relentless advance in artificial intelligence. The first thing that they've got in common is they're all building bunkers somewhere, folks. Whether it's in New Zealand or an island in Hawaii, wherever it is around the world, these people who are driving the collapse of ecosystems, who are driving the climate crisis, who are driving the exhaustion of the natural resources of the world, who are driving the overloading of this beautiful, complex web of ecosystems that is actually the survival mechanism of every organism on this planet, including human beings, are building themselves refuges for them and their families, because they know what's coming because they are driving it.
If you don't want to look at their actions, look at their words. They acknowledge the existential threat that artificial intelligence is to humanity. On top of climate change, which of course is an existential threat, we have artificial intelligence. And what's the government's response here in Australia? What's Labor's response? Keep approving new coal and gas mines. Keep destroying our native forests and emitting vast amounts of carbon when you burn them. Keep sitting back and abjectly failing to regulate and respond to the challenges of artificial intelligence.
This piece of legislation is a sensible, measured response to one element of artificial intelligence, which is wearable recording devices. Our regulatory response to these devices is lagging so far behind where it needs to be. The European Union 20 years ago was ahead of where Australia is now, let alone where we need to be, in terms of privacy frameworks. This legislation proposes a temporary step to add wearable recording devices to the prohibited imports regulations so that they can only be brought into the country with the written permission of the minister. Instead of adopting that sensible, measured response, we've just listened to a vague word salad from the minister that committed to precisely nothing to protect people from these intrusive devices.
These are pervert glasses, and they are an invasion of privacy. People are being filmed surreptitiously and secretly while they just go about their day-to-day business. Big tech is selling surveillance as fashion. We are seeing end times capitalism in terms of environmental and climate collapse merging with fascist tech bros who are pumping AI and devices like wearable recording glasses into our community. We are seeing the government create a surveillance state because the security industrial complex is demanding it of them, and now we are seeing corporate surveillance, not just in terms of wearable recording devices but in terms of the way that corporations have basically engaged in surveillance of everything we do online. Of course, then they monetise our data, and they sell it to other corporations. It is no wonder young people are struggling with life at the moment. Leave aside the financial pressures that they are facing. There is catastrophe looming everywhere that we look at the moment.
The whole point of wearable recording devices is that people who are being filmed can't tell. I know people say, 'There are little lights on the corner of the glasses, and, when the lights not on, you're not being recorded.' Well, how do you know? We're supposed to trust Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk that they're going to act in good faith and make sure that the only time you're being recorded is when the light comes on? Well, if you're that naive and that stupid to believe that rubbish, then that's on you. That's on you. The whole point about consent is it has to be informed. You should not be able to be secretly and surreptitiously filmed as you go about your day-to-day life without being in a position to give informed consent. If someone's filming you with a phone, you can see them doing it and you can ask them to stop. With glasses or earbuds or any other surreptitious recording devices, there's no cue at all. Maybe there's a tiny light that you can only spot from a close distance if you've got good sight. Maybe that light doesn't come on anyway when you're being recorded. Maybe the person has put a tiny little bit of tape over the light so that you can't see it.
In a 2024 study of Australian adults, 17 per cent of smart glasses owners admitted using them in a prohibited way. That is on a self-admission basis. You can bet your bottom dollar that the actual number is much, much higher. We are seeing these pick-up artist content creators on social media platforms secretly filming as they engage in whatever sort of flirting that they're engaging in. They post those clips for engagement and drive misogynistic comments, all without the consent of the person who was being filmed. Being out in public has never meant that you are agreeing to being secretly filmed and uploaded and monetised by a complete stranger, but that is what the Australian government is allowing to happen. Now put yourself in the position of a parent. You take your kids to the public pool for a day out, a bit of a swim, a few hot chips and tomato sauce. People are rightly asking: 'Is that now a safe place for my kids? Who's going to film my kids at the pool? How am I going to know if they're being filmed?'
When the Greens put forward a sensible pause for 12 months on the importation of these devices, utilising a temporary measure that will put the power to prohibit inputs into the hands of the Minister for Home Affairs, the government is going to vote it down, and they're going to be joined by their colleagues in the opposition. The political duopoly is backing in the tech bros at the expense of the privacy and the legitimate concerns of the overwhelming majority of ordinary Australians. That is what is happening in this place today.
Spare me the argument that this is going to have some kind of impact on disabled people. Spare me that rubbish argument. Some of these devices have a clear benefit for disabled people. The minister would be able to ensure that those—for the right purpose, the right technology, for the right people—can still continue to be imported because, of course, these devices are life-changing for some disabled people. So don't run the argument about disabled people as some kind of proxy argument to justify your opposition to this legislation, and particularly don't run that argument when you, the so-called parties of government in this place, have just colluded to slash funding from the NDIS, which is there to support disabled people. You don't have an argument here, folks. The fact that you will be running that argument just exposes your moral bankruptcy and the weakness of the position that you are trying to take with regard to this legislation.
Make no mistake, artificial intelligence represents an existential threat to humanity. It's end-stage capitalism. It is corporate surveillance. It is the theft of our privacy by companies that, in order to generate artificial intelligence, have basically engaged in the wholesale theft of the entirety of humanity's intellectual, creative and scientific output through human history. They've stolen it, they're corporatising it, and they are monetising it for profit.
Not only have you got psychopaths and sociopaths running fossil fuel companies, making big dollars and doing things that they know will result in billions of people dying this century; you've got psychopaths and sociopaths running big tech companies, making big dollars and doing things that they know put the future of our society and humanity at risk. They themselves are acknowledging that; they're buying bunkers all around the world so that when the collapse comes, they can retreat—themselves and their families—to the bunkers. Well, I'll tell you something, and I'll tell them something. The problem with that scenario is that everyone goes under in the end. Everyone goes under in the end. Yes, they might hold out for a little bit longer in their armed bunkers, but I'll tell you what: they're going to go down in the end, too. And the reason that we're all at risk of going down is the pathetic responses from governments around the world to the existential polycrisis that we are living through. Stop mining coal and gas. Stop destroying nature. Tax the wealthy. Tax the big corporations. Use that revenue to help people who are enduring economic misery in their day-to-day lives at the moment, and be prepared to take on big technology as it robs humanity of its very future.
Penny Allman-Payne Queensland, Australian Greens
9:56 am
I want to thank my colleague Senator Shoebridge for introducing the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control Bill) 2026, and I'd like to associate myself with both his comments and the comments of my colleague Senator McKim. I want to start off by addressing the use of these devices for people with a disability. As my colleagues have made clear, this bill provides a clear mechanism for people with a disability to access wearable recording devices. For many blind and low-vision Australians, we know that these glasses have been life-changing. They can read menus. They can find their luggage at the airport. They can get around independently. Vision Australia has said that the glasses make it much easier for people with sight impairments to take part in daily life.
But here's the problem: these glasses have got a reputation. They're being called pervert glasses. They're being called that because people are finding themselves in situations where they are being recorded and are unaware of it. That is creating stigma around them. If the government doesn't regulate these properly, it actually leaves people with a disability with the very real threat of a backlash and of them being turned away at the door from places that are banning these devices because governments won't act to protect all of us. In order for there to be a social licence for people with a disability to use what is life-changing technology, the government needs to take the lead and step in so that everyone is protected.
We are seeing, around the world, other jurisdictions being far more proactive in this space than our government here. We've got restrictions spreading fast right around the world, in the US, in the UK, in Europe, in Canada and in Asia. Punjab in Pakistan has, in November 2026, already imposed a ban on importing these glasses. The UK Home Office has said that it's looking at restricting sales to certain users. Norway's digitisation minister has proposed temporary bans, taking the lead at a national level around banning them from parks, beaches, gyms and schools, and they want to ban facial recognition features as well. Dutch eyewear chain Hans Anders suspended sales of META's glasses in the Netherlands and Belgium in October, and Kmart stopped online sales here after the Privacy Commissioner launched her investigation. There is a patchwork of councils around the country banning smart glasses from places like swimming pools. But it's not enough for individual councils to have to fill the gaps where the government is refusing to lead.
We've heard the issues around consent. We have an epidemic of family and domestic violence in this country. Women and girls experience family and domestic violence at shocking rates in this country, and we know that the harms of using smart glasses without people's consent are going to fall disproportionately on women and girls—and on young children.
This bill is a sensible measure. It acknowledges that the government needs time to bring regulation of these devices to the parliament. What it is simply saying is, 'While you do that, let's pause bringing them in.' Saying that there are many of them already here is not a reason to stop more of them. We've heard the argument that they've got lights on them so you can tell when they're recording, but that is not the case for every device, and it doesn't prevent people taking steps to mask that little light. Governments have been so slow to act time and time again on things that threaten people's safety and security, and this is another example of that. The Greens are providing a temporary solution to give the government time to act.
People are concerned about this. The idea that somebody can be recording you without your knowledge is anxiety-inducing. Women already have to worry about whether they need to have their keys in their hands when they're walking to their car in the dark. Women already have to worry about, when they're walking home from their workplace late at night, keeping their eyes open and making sure there's no-one following them; they have to check across the street. Women know what it's like living with the daily reality of having to check on whether they feel safe. And now there's another thing they have to be worried about: whether they're being covertly filmed by someone and then having that used to humiliate or degrade them online.
The Greens are giving the government and the opposition the opportunity to vote with us to press pause, to give us time to regulate a device that threatens people's safety. We know that it's not just people being filmed by these devices who are at risk.; they also risk the safety and privacy of the people wearing them. We know that, in February 2026, Swedish journalists revealed that footage from META's Ray-Ban glasses was being reviewed by contract workers in Nairobi, Kenya, to train META's AI. Workers describe seeing people in bathrooms, undressing and having sex, as well as seeing people's bank cards. They said that the automatic face blurring didn't reliably work. Meta is now facing a US class action alleging that it marketed the glasses as 'built for your privacy' while users couldn't opt out of human review. So this bill doesn't just protect the people being covertly filmed; it protects wearers too. Someone filming their morning routine, time with their kids or time with their family deserves to know if a stranger overseas might be watching.
Meta was also reported in February 2026 to be planning facial recognition for its glasses, letting people wearing them identify strangers in real time. More than 70 civil society groups, including the ACLU, have warned that this would hand stalkers and predators a tool to identify women on the street. Surely that is something that we should be reducing the ability for people to do? Pressing pause on the import of these devices would be another tool in the toolkit to make sure that they don't find their way into the hands of stalkers and predators. If this happens, it means every pair of glasses will become a roaming facial recognition camera owned by a US tech billionaire, and we know from their actions that these tech bros have no regard for women's safety. They demonstrate it through their words and their actions, the way that they allow their platforms to be used, their recklessness and their lack of care about the harms that their technology is causing. Surely we should be putting a pause on this so that we can get the rules in place to stop them getting that kind of access?
We also know that people's data potentially has no level of protection. Footage and audio from these glasses is routinely uploaded overseas to company servers. That's out of the reach of Australian privacy law. People have no recourse. Honestly, most Australians who are wearing these glasses would have absolutely no idea which country their footage is sitting in, who can access it and how long it's kept there for, and they have no recourse, potentially, to have it erased. This industry is unregulated, and that means that there are no safety controls over how this data is used and stored. That is just another reason why this pause makes sense.
A one-year freeze on imports would give the parliament, experts and civil society the space to build lasting privacy protections, something that the federal government should be actively working towards and taking the lead on, not leaving it to councils to ban them at pools or in school classrooms. Australians should have the benefit. Australians should be able to be guaranteed that they can go about their lives without being secretly filmed. This bill is a sensible way forward, and I encourage the government and the coalition to support it.
Vanessa Bleyer Tasmania, Australian Greens
10:09 am
I don't know if I have been filmed without my consent because of wearable recording devices worn as glasses. As we've just heard from this federal Labor government, there are not laws in place in this country to deal with the adverse impact of these wearable recording devices. What we have here today is a bill being moved by the Australian Greens that seeks to make laws that can immediately and properly address the absence of these laws that we so desperately need to protect our privacy. Not only do we not have statutory laws in place but there also aren't laws that are sufficiently developed through the justice system. The tort of serious breach of privacy is only just starting to evolve in the justice system. In the United States, there is currently a class action utilising the courts in an effort to protect the privacy of women whose privacy has been breached by wearable recording devices worn as glasses. We, as women in this country, would struggle to be able to protect our rights using the justice system.
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
The time for this debate has expired. You will be in continuation.