This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Bills

Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026; Second Reading


Nick McKim

Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens

9:41 am

The rise of AI is a seismic moment in human history. When you look around us at the moment, we are living through a rolling polycrisis made up of war, genocide, climate change, ecosystem collapse and the obscene funnelling of humanity's wealth into the hands of a few and out of the bank accounts of everyday people. AI coming on top of that means that there has rarely been a time in human history when government responses have been so important, and yet there has also rarely been a time in human history when our democratic institutions have been capable of the kind of action that is necessary.

Part of the reason that our democratic institutions—including this parliament, I might add—are not capable of taking the kind of action that is necessary in response to this huge range of challenges facing humanity at the moment is in fact the way that artificial intelligence, in the form of algorithms that drive social media content, has undermined our democracy. We've seen it in the UK with Brexit. We've seen it in the US with the election twice of Trump to the Oval Office. We have seen it repeated around the world, where bad actors, money and power can deliver electoral results through the manipulation of voting systems and the manipulation of algorithms that drive the social media content that so many people use as their primary source of information today.

And now we see the rise of artificial intelligence. It is not overstating what is happening to say that this is a genuine threat to humanity and a genuine threat to our civilisation and the society that we all live in. If you want evidence of that, have a look at the words and actions of the tech bros who are driving this relentless advance in artificial intelligence. The first thing that they've got in common is they're all building bunkers somewhere, folks. Whether it's in New Zealand or an island in Hawaii, wherever it is around the world, these people who are driving the collapse of ecosystems, who are driving the climate crisis, who are driving the exhaustion of the natural resources of the world, who are driving the overloading of this beautiful, complex web of ecosystems that is actually the survival mechanism of every organism on this planet, including human beings, are building themselves refuges for them and their families, because they know what's coming because they are driving it.

If you don't want to look at their actions, look at their words. They acknowledge the existential threat that artificial intelligence is to humanity. On top of climate change, which of course is an existential threat, we have artificial intelligence. And what's the government's response here in Australia? What's Labor's response? Keep approving new coal and gas mines. Keep destroying our native forests and emitting vast amounts of carbon when you burn them. Keep sitting back and abjectly failing to regulate and respond to the challenges of artificial intelligence.

This piece of legislation is a sensible, measured response to one element of artificial intelligence, which is wearable recording devices. Our regulatory response to these devices is lagging so far behind where it needs to be. The European Union 20 years ago was ahead of where Australia is now, let alone where we need to be, in terms of privacy frameworks. This legislation proposes a temporary step to add wearable recording devices to the prohibited imports regulations so that they can only be brought into the country with the written permission of the minister. Instead of adopting that sensible, measured response, we've just listened to a vague word salad from the minister that committed to precisely nothing to protect people from these intrusive devices.

These are pervert glasses, and they are an invasion of privacy. People are being filmed surreptitiously and secretly while they just go about their day-to-day business. Big tech is selling surveillance as fashion. We are seeing end times capitalism in terms of environmental and climate collapse merging with fascist tech bros who are pumping AI and devices like wearable recording glasses into our community. We are seeing the government create a surveillance state because the security industrial complex is demanding it of them, and now we are seeing corporate surveillance, not just in terms of wearable recording devices but in terms of the way that corporations have basically engaged in surveillance of everything we do online. Of course, then they monetise our data, and they sell it to other corporations. It is no wonder young people are struggling with life at the moment. Leave aside the financial pressures that they are facing. There is catastrophe looming everywhere that we look at the moment.

The whole point of wearable recording devices is that people who are being filmed can't tell. I know people say, 'There are little lights on the corner of the glasses, and, when the lights not on, you're not being recorded.' Well, how do you know? We're supposed to trust Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk that they're going to act in good faith and make sure that the only time you're being recorded is when the light comes on? Well, if you're that naive and that stupid to believe that rubbish, then that's on you. That's on you. The whole point about consent is it has to be informed. You should not be able to be secretly and surreptitiously filmed as you go about your day-to-day life without being in a position to give informed consent. If someone's filming you with a phone, you can see them doing it and you can ask them to stop. With glasses or earbuds or any other surreptitious recording devices, there's no cue at all. Maybe there's a tiny light that you can only spot from a close distance if you've got good sight. Maybe that light doesn't come on anyway when you're being recorded. Maybe the person has put a tiny little bit of tape over the light so that you can't see it.

In a 2024 study of Australian adults, 17 per cent of smart glasses owners admitted using them in a prohibited way. That is on a self-admission basis. You can bet your bottom dollar that the actual number is much, much higher. We are seeing these pick-up artist content creators on social media platforms secretly filming as they engage in whatever sort of flirting that they're engaging in. They post those clips for engagement and drive misogynistic comments, all without the consent of the person who was being filmed. Being out in public has never meant that you are agreeing to being secretly filmed and uploaded and monetised by a complete stranger, but that is what the Australian government is allowing to happen. Now put yourself in the position of a parent. You take your kids to the public pool for a day out, a bit of a swim, a few hot chips and tomato sauce. People are rightly asking: 'Is that now a safe place for my kids? Who's going to film my kids at the pool? How am I going to know if they're being filmed?'

When the Greens put forward a sensible pause for 12 months on the importation of these devices, utilising a temporary measure that will put the power to prohibit inputs into the hands of the Minister for Home Affairs, the government is going to vote it down, and they're going to be joined by their colleagues in the opposition. The political duopoly is backing in the tech bros at the expense of the privacy and the legitimate concerns of the overwhelming majority of ordinary Australians. That is what is happening in this place today.

Spare me the argument that this is going to have some kind of impact on disabled people. Spare me that rubbish argument. Some of these devices have a clear benefit for disabled people. The minister would be able to ensure that those—for the right purpose, the right technology, for the right people—can still continue to be imported because, of course, these devices are life-changing for some disabled people. So don't run the argument about disabled people as some kind of proxy argument to justify your opposition to this legislation, and particularly don't run that argument when you, the so-called parties of government in this place, have just colluded to slash funding from the NDIS, which is there to support disabled people. You don't have an argument here, folks. The fact that you will be running that argument just exposes your moral bankruptcy and the weakness of the position that you are trying to take with regard to this legislation.

Make no mistake, artificial intelligence represents an existential threat to humanity. It's end-stage capitalism. It is corporate surveillance. It is the theft of our privacy by companies that, in order to generate artificial intelligence, have basically engaged in the wholesale theft of the entirety of humanity's intellectual, creative and scientific output through human history. They've stolen it, they're corporatising it, and they are monetising it for profit.

Not only have you got psychopaths and sociopaths running fossil fuel companies, making big dollars and doing things that they know will result in billions of people dying this century; you've got psychopaths and sociopaths running big tech companies, making big dollars and doing things that they know put the future of our society and humanity at risk. They themselves are acknowledging that; they're buying bunkers all around the world so that when the collapse comes, they can retreat—themselves and their families—to the bunkers. Well, I'll tell you something, and I'll tell them something. The problem with that scenario is that everyone goes under in the end. Everyone goes under in the end. Yes, they might hold out for a little bit longer in their armed bunkers, but I'll tell you what: they're going to go down in the end, too. And the reason that we're all at risk of going down is the pathetic responses from governments around the world to the existential polycrisis that we are living through. Stop mining coal and gas. Stop destroying nature. Tax the wealthy. Tax the big corporations. Use that revenue to help people who are enduring economic misery in their day-to-day lives at the moment, and be prepared to take on big technology as it robs humanity of its very future.

Comments

No comments