This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Bills

Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026; Second Reading


Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

9:16 am

():  The coalition recognises the serious privacy concerns arising from the growing availability of smart glasses and other wearable recording devices that allow individuals to film people discreetly and without their knowledge. Australians have a reasonable expectation that they should not be secretly filmed or subjected to inappropriate surveillance while going about their everyday lives. Women and children are particularly vulnerable to the misuse of this technology including covert filming, harassment, stalking and the potential distribution of intimate or otherwise inappropriate footage. We need to ensure the law keeps pace with technology.

Whether Australians are at the beach, shopping, travelling on public transport or attending their children's schools, they deserve appropriate protections against intrusive and unauthorised recording. Rapid advances in technology have outpaced existing privacy protections, creating legitimate concerns about whether Australian laws are equipped to address the misuse of increasingly sophisticated recording devices.

While the coalition acknowledges these concerns, we do not believe the Greens' proposed 12-month import prohibition represents an appropriate or sufficiently comprehensive response. Banning the importation of smart glasses will not address the underlying problem: the misuse of recording technology by individuals who disregard the privacy of others. Smart glasses are already widely available in Australia, and preventing further imports will do nothing to address the devices already in circulation. The Greens' legislation would impose substantial restrictions on legitimate technology users without directly addressing the inappropriate conduct that has given rise to public concern.

The Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026 goes considerably further than smart glasses, capturing a broad range of wearable recording devices including certain watches, earbuds, jewellery, badges and other accessories capable of discreet visual recording. There are legitimate uses for wearable recording devices including assisting people with disabilities, capturing sporting activities, documenting incidents and undertaking professional activities. Although the bill provides a ministerial permission pathway, including consideration of disability related uses, it does not create an automatic exemption for all legitimate users. The Greens have failed to adequately explain why an import prohibition is preferable to appropriately targeted restrictions on covert recording, on misuse of footage and on the manufacture and sale of devices without adequate privacy safeguards.

The coalition believes the focus should be on preventing harmful conduct rather than indiscriminately restricting access to emerging technology. A temporary import prohibition that automatically expires after 12 months risks creating uncertainty for consumers and businesses without delivering a permanent solution to the underlying privacy concerns. The coalition is particularly concerned that the Albanese government has been too slow to respond to the rapidly evolving privacy risks associated with wearable recording technology. The Attorney-General has already written to the Australian Privacy Commissioner, requesting consideration of the privacy implications of smart glasses, including the risks of inappropriate recording, harassment and surveillance.

However, referring the issue to the Privacy Commissioner is not, by itself, a substitute for taking concrete action to address gaps in Australian law. Australians concerned about being secretly filmed deserve more than another referral, another review or another round of bureaucratic consideration. The Commonwealth Privacy Act 1988 generally regulates government agencies and businesses but does not comprehensively regulate private individuals recording other people for personal business. Compounding this problem, surveillance and listening device legislation differs considerably between the states and territories, creating uncertainty about the protections available to Australians.

The Albanese government must urgently work with state and territory governments to identify these regulatory gaps and develop a consistent and effective response. The government should examine whether stronger protections are required against covert recording in sensitive locations, particularly in schools, changing rooms, public amenities and other locations where individuals have heightened expectations of privacy. It should also consider whether enforceable privacy and safety standards are required for wearable recording devices sold in Australia, including clear recording indicators and protections against unauthorised surveillance. Manufacturing and technology companies should be expected to consider privacy and safety when designing and distributing these products, rather than leaving consumers to manage the risks themselves. Any legislative response must be sufficiently flexible to accommodate technological developments rather than target a particular product that may soon be superseded by more sophisticated technology.

The coalition expects the Albanese government to treat this issue with urgency and bring forward a proportionate, practical and technologically neutral regulatory response. The coalition does not dismiss the privacy concerns that have prompted the Greens to introduce this legislation. However, legitimate concerns do not automatically justify broad import restrictions that fail to address the underlying problem. We need laws that protect Australians against covert surveillance, harassment and inappropriate recording, regardless of which device is being used. We must also ensure that legitimate uses of technology, including by Australians with disabilities, are not unnecessarily restricted. The coalition will not support the Greens' proposed import ban, but we will continue to press the Albanese government to act urgently to ensure Australia's privacy protections keep pace with emerging technology.

Comments

No comments