This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Bills
Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026; Second Reading
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
9:29 am
I rise to support the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026, and I thank Senator Shoebridge for bringing it into the chamber for us all to discuss. Let me start by saying what I said when recording a video for my socials on this very topic:
Now introducing a revolutionary new device for your eyes: pervert glasses.
I know that this is not the title on the bill, but it is an honest description of a pair of glasses that look like glasses, behave like glasses but quietly film the person sitting across from you. This is not science fiction. Cheap versions have been on the shelves of major retailers and have sold out. Some can be bought online for less than hundreds of dollars. I think Senator Shoebridge mentioned that they are out there for 45 bucks. Senator Shoebridge also pointed to research from Monash University finding that a disturbing number of owners admitted to using them to secretly record people, including in places like change rooms and at the beach. I wouldn't call that innovation and neither would you. It's a surveillance device with a fashion label, and it's advertised as such.
Over the last three months, I've sat in school halls talking to students from all walks of life across Western Australia. I've been asked about everything, from housing to HECS, the NDIS, why politics is so divisive and AI. AI has definitely been a common thread in almost every session. Young people want to know why the technology reshaping their lives is being regulated after the damage is done, not before. They asked me why AI will affect their jobs and why this government is not regulating it. They asked why the social media ban was rushed through with so little say from the people it affects. They asked what I think about AI and drones. They asked whether anyone in this place is actually keeping up. The government sits there saying that we're doing so much about these glasses in particular. Why don't you just pause it then? Pause the import of them so that regulation can keep up and get on track.
This generation has grown up with a camera in their pockets. They know better than anyone in this chamber what it means to have your image taken, clipped, shared, circulated and sometimes faked without your say. Schools have already banned these glasses from classrooms because deep fakes and live streaming were posing great risks. Students didn't need a royal commission to work out the problem; they saw it coming. If teenagers can see it coming, why aren't we doing something about it in this place? Why isn't the parliament acting on this?
Because I've seen a lot of confusion and a fair bit of spin, let's iron out some things about this bill. This bill amends the Customs (Prohibited Imports) Regulations to prohibit the import of wearable recording devices unless the minister or an authorised departmental officer grants permission. It lasts 12 months and then lapses automatically. A wearable recording device is one that can make a visual recording, is designed to be worn or carried on the body and is something an ordinary person could not easily identify as a camera—think glasses, earbuds, pins, pendants and watches. That's the bill.
Now let's look at some of the myths or misconceptions that have been spreading. There's a misconception that this is a ban on cameras. It's not. Phones are not covered. Hand-held cameras are not covered. The explanatory memorandum is explicit that existing camera technology, like a GoPro, which is plainly a camera, is not intended to be captured. Audio-only devices are not covered. There is nothing here that stops a journalist, an artist or even members of your family filming a birthday party. What it targets is covert recording, where the person being filmed has no way of knowing that they're being recorded.
Misconception No. 2 is that this is a permanent ban. Again, that's not the case. It is a pause. The prohibition repeals itself 12 months after it starts. That is a deliberate design choice. It gives government a window to do the work it should already be doing: building proper permanent privacy protections. And there's a third misconception: that this harms people with disability. It's important to look at the fact that people who have vision or hearing impairments rely on wearing technology to assist them in their day-to-day functionality, and I will not support any law that locks them out. The bill requires the minister or authorised officer to consider whether a device is intended as a disability aid, using the definition in the Disability Discrimination Act. That is built into the decision. It is a permission pathway, not a blanket wall. So if anyone wants to strengthen the pathway in committee, I'm definitely open to conversation. But I implore everyone to back this bill in the first place.
There's a fourth misconception: that it will take your glasses away. This bill will not do that. The bill applies to goods imported on or after it commences, so it does not reach devices that are already in Australia. Nobody is knocking on doors and confiscating glasses you already own. Misconception No. 5 is that a little light on the frame will solve all the problems. Well, some devices have an indicator light when they record. But Senator Shoebridge has said, rightly, that these are far from any real protection. A tiny LED light during daytime on a crowded beach, in a gym or on a train is not consent, and many devices have no warning at all. So there is definitely something to look into there.
Misconception No. 6 is that the government has this covered. The Attorney-General has opened consultation on privacy law reform. And the reform is welcome. I will say that plainly and give credit where it's due. But the Attorney-General has also said that the consultation is not about an import ban, pointing to consequences across trade and foreign affairs. Senator Shoebridge has also noted that glasses that identify a stranger, their job and their social media history can still sit outside of the reforms, unless the wearer is doing it for work. So here is the gap: people are being filmed now, the reforms are coming very slowly and, in between, thousands of devices are arriving on our shores.
I support this bill, because a pause is a sensible response to a fast-moving harm as we can see it. When you're in a hole, you stop digging. But if I'm absolutely honest with the chamber, I have to say I feel that an import pause is not a sustainable plan. Yes, it buys time, but it does not use it. This is the pattern I keep seeing. Pervert glasses today, AI deepfakes yesterday, data harvesting, identity theft—every time, this government responds after the headline, after the harm, after the victim. It's very reactive—every single time. That whack-a-mole attitude towards fixing problems needs to go, because it's not helping anybody. It's definitely not serving Australians. So my ask of the government is very simple: support this bill, or come back with your own interim measure of equal strength. Don't tell Australians you're not ruling anything out while thousands of devices arrive on our shores.
Second, use the 12 months. Extend privacy law so that the filming, storing or sharing of footage from these devices without consent is a clear breach, whether the wearer is at work or just being nosey at the pool. Require clear outward signs of recording as a floor, not a ceiling. And close the loophole on devices that pull up information about the strangers they look at.
Third, I would implore the government to deliver a comprehensive AI regulatory framework, not the patchwork that we've heard of and not a new response each time a product goes viral. Again, I implore them to deliver not those reactive types of measures but a framework that anticipates the next device before it's on the shelf and being sold to everyday Australians. It would ensure that companies that are selling them are held to account. This is because big tech will not police itself. It never has and it never will.
When I was at one of those schools, one of the students asked me whether politics is designed to keep young people out. I think a better question is: why are the people who understand this technology best the ones we listen to the least? These young people are engaging. They are watching their privacy get treated as a product to be sold. They're asking for something simple: the right to walk down a street, sit in a classroom or swim at the beach without wondering whether the person next to them is quietly filming. Again, it's not a radical ask. It's not controversial. It shouldn't be controversial. It's just the basic expectation of living in a free society. So let's press pause, let's use the time and let's, for once, get ahead of the technology, instead of chasing it. I commend the bill to the Senate.
No comments