This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Bills

Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026; Second Reading


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

9:01 am

I rise to speak to the Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026. This could be one of those rare moments that parliament actually gets ahead of a wave of technology, a wave of change, and puts the protection of Australians—our privacy, and our right not to be covertly recorded, for once, could get ahead of that wave and the protection of millions and millions of Australians could be put ahead of the profits of big tech. That's what this bill is designed to do. The Greens are bringing this bill to parliament because Australians are being secretly filmed by people wearing what look like ordinary glasses, and our laws are doing nothing to stop. it. Women and girls, in particular, are being recorded without their knowledge at the beach, on the street, at the gym and while they're going about their business shopping, engaging with their family, friends and perhaps their work colleagues, and the footage is being posted online for clicks and engagement and sometimes for intentional humiliation.

These videos are disturbing. They have no place, and the Greens say that they are utterly unacceptable. It is not good enough for this parliament just to put this in the too-hard basket and step aside. This year the problem has exploded. Kmart's $89 camera glasses sold out across the country in a week. It was a cheap stunt by a retailer, but it sent cheaper copies of these Meta glasses flooding through our society. And it wasn't just Kmart. Once Kmart built the hype, we saw even cheaper copies flooding through online market places, with prices as low as $45. You can get them today online.

Of course, Meta is pushing to add facial recognition to its glasses, so wearers can identify strangers in real time—scan the strangers and others they meet with real-time facial recognition. Footage from these devices recorded here covertly of our friends, our families and ourselves has been shipped overseas and watched by contract workers who are training AI. Covert recordings have been fed overseas and are training AI models, with no meaningful control for the wearer or the people that they film.

Let's be clear about this. These devices are not just a privacy risk for the people that are being observed and recorded without their consent. They are an even larger privacy risk for the wearers. Amazon in the US is already forcing thousands of its workers to wear these devices for their entire work day to track their movements, to grade their performance and to monitor every action they take. These devices are a privacy disaster on all grounds—for wearers and for those that are being covertly recorded—and our laws have zero answer to them.

The Albanese government's Attorney-General has written some letters. Well, whoopee! They've written some letters. I think the Attorney-General wrote a letter to the Privacy Commissioner. Well, whoopee! What did that do? Nothing. They've launched consultations. We have the Attorney-General's Department and the Attorney-General saying to local councils: 'You should go and sort this out yourselves if you've got issues with privacy at your local swimming pool or your local library. The Commonwealth government's not here to help you. The Albanese government is not here to help you. Go and sort it out yourselves. Come up with your own little local bans or local policies across the country because, sure as heck, the Albanese government is not going to help you. Labor's not here to help you.' They've said the same to small businesses—'Go and sort it out yourselves. Government's not here to help.' How wrong that is. What a complete denial of responsibility and leadership we've seen in this space.

I want to be clear. A letter from the Attorney-General to the Privacy Commissioner is not how you sort out this privacy mess. It's not how you protect Australians and their privacy. The government's draft privacy laws are months away, after years of delay already. And, when you read them, they don't even pretend to deal with covert devices directly. At best, they've got some kind of obligation on entities that gather information on how they store it. If a corporate entity stores the information, then there are some privacy obligations on it. But there's nothing to stop people wearing these devices and recording without consent in gyms, in restaurants and on beaches—nothing. There's not a word in Labor's proposed privacy laws to take any step. That, of course, leaves a major privacy gap. It's a privacy gulf. Every week it stays open, more and more of these devices are being imported into our country and more and more of these devices are ending up in circulation. You're much more likely every week that we get no action to be covertly recorded as you go about your business. More and more Australians are having their privacy breached because this government is a do-nothing government when it comes to privacy. It's a do-nothing government.

Our bill, the Greens bill, closes that gap with a simple temporary step. It adds wearable recording devices to the Customs (Prohibited Imports) Regulations so that they can only be brought into the country with written permission from the Minister for Home Affairs. It covers videorecording devices worn on the body or carried as an accessory, including glasses, earbuds, watches, pins and pendants, while leaving audio-only devices and standard cameras, including phone cameras, alone and untouched. There is a clear pathway through this bill for the importation of wearable recording devices which would otherwise be banned when they are to be used as disability aids. We've spoken to the disability community. We've heard their very real views on this and how, for some in our community, these wearable devices can be really important. People with visual impairment can find barriers broken with these devices, and there needs to be an import pathway so that the legitimate uses of the devices can be allowed and permitted. That is why we are giving, in this bill, the Minister for Home Affairs the capacity to allow importation for those legitimate uses of the device. Why are we doing this? Why the 12-month freeze? We say that this gives this parliament a chance to fill the privacy gap. The one-year freeze on imports gives parliaments—and it may well be state and territory parliaments grappling with this as well as the federal parliament—experts and civil society the space needed to build lasting privacy protections so that, when the freeze lifts in 12 months time, Australians will be able to go about their lives without wondering who is secretly filming them and without checking the glasses or the lapel pins of the person they're sharing a space with to see if they're covertly recording them or not.

We want to ensure that consent is a fundamental part of the laws. Absent consent, there should be no covert recording. That should be how the law operates. They're fundamentally giving the rights of Australians away in places like this—women, in particular, but not just women. It's all of us. The law needs to be the right to say 'no consent, no covert recording'. Big tech is selling surveillance as fashion, and they know what these devices will provide for them: a new, rich stream of data. For big tech, the data about the wearer is perhaps the most valuable part of this. Monitoring every movement, hearing every conversation, seeking every interaction.

Think about it for Coles and Woolies for a moment. If you've got a livestream of your customers walking down the aisle, you not only see what they purchase—you can already track that!—but you see what other products they look at, how long they linger on that and which part of the shelves they look at. You build this complete data profile of individuals who are wearing these devices, and then they monetise and weaponise it. There are no constraints on it under current law. Of course we need to press pause on this and give parliament and civil society the chance to put some constraints around this technology, to point out that we're not going to permit the covert surveillance not just of people who are being observed but the 24/7 data collection of Australians who are wearing these devices. At the moment, people are buying these devices from $45, they're connecting them online, and they have no idea where their data is going. Is it going off to a server in China? Is it going off to that nice Mr Musk in the US? Is it being fed into Meta's global servers to build this picture about everything you do, every conversation you have and everywhere you look? The answer to that is probably, 'Yes, all of that, all at once, all happening now.' This government is doing absolutely nothing to put controls in place. It is extraordinary. For once, let's step up. For once, let's put the public interest ahead of big tech's profits. For once, let's act before the wave of harm has washed across this country, and let's act to prevent it rather than cleaning it up afterwards.

There's much more that could be said about the gaps in our privacy laws these glasses have so clearly identified. I think the core thing is the absence of the requirement for consent. Of course there is a legitimate place for public recordings. We need to be able to record things in public—you're going on a holiday, you're out interacting with your friends, or a media outlet is there in a public space—where a camera is set up or a phone's up and you're recording. People can see what's happening. That's quite a legitimate part of how we interact. If you're at a protest and the police are behaving badly, you can record that happening. You put your phone up and you record it.

For many people, the ability to put your phone up and record in public places is a shield because other people can see that they're recording them. The police can see they're being recorded. Someone behaving badly can see they're being recorded and can see what's happening; they're not being covertly filmed. And there's clear acknowledgement of what is happening. That's what happens when you do it with a phone, and that's what happens when you do it with a news camera or a traditional camera. People can see what's happening.

But it is fundamentally different if somebody's standing there, you're going about your business and they're covertly recording you with a wearable device. You have no idea if it's happening, and they may entrap you. We see these videos of men entrapping young women, in particular, engaging and secretly recording the interaction and then posting it online to humiliate or belittle. It's happening already. That's the fundamental difference. And that is why consent is critical when the device is covert. Our privacy law does nothing in that. In fact, a 2024 study of Australian adults, before this technology went wild, had 17 per cent of smart glasses owners admitting using them in a prohibited way, recording others without consent. This is the reality. The Greens are bringing this bill as a way of protecting Australians, and we would urge other parties in this chamber to join with us and, for once, get it right. (Time expired)

Comments

No comments