This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
3:04 pm
The order refers to commitments made in the 2025 election. Australians elected Labor on the promise of delivering our commitments, and we are delivering on those commitments with proper process. The government's Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program was designed specifically to deliver the government's election commitments and designed in line with the requirements of the Australian National Audit Office; the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act; the Commonwealth Grants Rules and Principles; and the recommendations of the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit's inquiry into Commonwealth grants administration. It is a one-off, closed, non-competitive program specifically established to deliver the Albanese government's 2025 election commitments. Program guidelines have been available for over a year. These guidelines make clear who can apply for funding and the eligibility and assessment criteria they must meet to successfully receive funding. They also clearly state that applications which do not meet these benchmarks will not be considered value for money and will not be awarded funding. This is what the proper delivery of election commitments looks like.
The Prime Minister is not the decision-maker for grants awarded under this program, so this order would rightly be directed to the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government as the minister responsible for the program. Actually, Senator Payman already knows this. She did, in fact, direct an order to the minister, order for the production of documents 617, and, in response to this order, the minister tabled the decision brief for the program, and this shows that proper process was followed. The Albanese government made election commitments. We are delivering on our election commitments. We are doing so through proper process, as the Australian people would expect of us.
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
3:05 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of the explanation.
The use of taxpayers' money for political purposes must stop. Whether it's a $500 million slush fund for projects in target seats or using the power to allocate personal staff as a bargaining chip to pass unsupportable legislation, it needs to be recognised that this is not Labor's money to do with as they wish. This is money that Australians have worked hard for. It needs to be respected as such. We are here not only because there has been a failure of process when it comes to these grants but because there has been a failure to be transparent about the entire process.
This Senate, as a collective decision-making body elected by the Australian people, voted to require the production of documents that the Prime Minister and his office hold relating to the Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program and the decision to provide a grant to the Marrickville Golf Club. This is the same Marrickville Golf Club that the Prime Minister is a member of. The Prime Minister told the other place that the Marrickville Golf Club received the grant for sewerage works, but his own department contradicted him at estimates last month, and he was forced to admit that what he said was not correct. He also said that a membership costs $5, but the kind of membership he has in fact costs $1,100. It's an easy mistake to make, right? It's a rounding error, really. 'It's all within the rules,' the government says. Then change the rules. Constitutional expert Anne Twomey has described this grants process as 'grey corruption'.
Western Australians hear a lot of lip-service about how much this government loves WA, but when it comes to commitments, we have been left behind. This isn't just a pork-barrelling program; it's a pork-barrelling program for the eastern states. Let me talk about just one example. At the last election, the government committed to investing $5 million into a new early childhood education and care centre in the Wheatbelt town of Mukinbudin. The election came and, despite this promise, Labor was not elected in the seat of Durack, which covers Mukinbudin. Bad luck! It was time to honour the commitment, right? It's been a year and a half since that commitment was made. The shire of Mukinbudin had radio silence from the government on this issue for months, until the Department of Education told them they wouldn't be honouring the commitment because of 'lack of demonstrated demand'.
Well, let me tell you about the demand in Mukinbudin. This is a growing town of 600 people, with a new subdivision on the way, bucking the Wheatbelt trend while the neighbours shrink. The only early learning centre in town opens four days a week, and the workers who keep that service running are sharing shire housing. As the CEO, Tanika McLennan, put it, 'The promise looks like it was just made to make the government look good.' Now, when this broken promise received media coverage, the government changed its tune and insisted that the investment was still under consideration. This commitment has been under consideration for more than a year. Do you know what hasn't been stuck in limbo for a year? The Marrickville Golf Club. Over east, they're scheduled to start construction in two months, while in the Wheatbelt they haven't even agreed to do what they said they would to honour this commitment.
It's no wonder then that the Prime Minister has failed to comply with this order of the Senate. His response to this order was to say, 'I didn't make the decision, so I don't have to produce anything.' This is not how this works. The Senate orders documents to be produced; you produce them. If you don't want to produce them, you have to explain why it is not in the Australian public's best interest, not just your political interests, for them to be produced. That has not happened here and that is really concerning in terms of transparency. The Senate has rejected the 'go ask someone else' excuse and rightly so. On Monday, a response was tabled which continued to refuse to table these documents despite the Senate rejecting the explanation that's been provided. It refers to scrutiny that has occurred through the committee process as if that somehow exempts the government from producing these documents. That's simply not good enough.
I want to thank all senators and, particularly, Senator McKenzie for their work in holding the Prime Minister and the government to account on this issue. We hear a lot from the Prime Minister on social cohesion. If we do not improve trust in our institutions, social cohesion will continue to suffer. This sort of pork-barrelling is toxic to social cohesion. It's time to start doing better.
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
3:10 pm
Deputy President, this stinks. This absolutely stinks. What we're talking about here, for those in the public gallery and those listening, is this Senate trying to get documents in relation to the grant program under which there was only one golf club in Australia that had the right to apply for taxpayer funds to undertake renovations, stormwater harvesting and not sewerage works—just one golf club in Australia. Out of 1,400 golf clubs, one golf club in Australia had the right to make an application for those taxpayer funds. Where was that golf club? The Marrickville Golf Club in the Prime Minister's electorate. This Senate is seeking documents in relation to this matter, and, as Senator Payman has said, the Labor government refuses to provide those documents to the Australian Senate so that we can undertake the scrutiny processes that a house of review should undertake for the benefit of the Australian people.
This community grants program introduced by the Labor government stinks. It stinks for the people of Queensland. Why? Because Queensland received $64 million less than it should have received if that money were equitably distributed across the whole of Australia on the basis of population. It stinks because there are 45 federal electorates containing a population of approximately eight million people who didn't receive a brass razoo—not a single dollar. Yet there are Labor federal electorates which received 10 projects, eight projects and four projects. I've got councils in south-west Queensland, one of the most remote and difficult places to live in the whole of Australia, who didn't receive a brass razoo. You can't tell me, as a Queensland senator, that their need for community infrastructure is any less than that of the federal electorates in inner-city Sydney, such as the one inhabited by our prime minister. It stinks because this isn't the Labor government's money; this is taxpayer money. How can a process be fit and proper and how can it be ethical, efficient and value for money when there's only one project that's able to apply for this $6 million grant? How's that ethical? How's that giving a fair go?
At the committee hearing last week, which I participated in, we heard from members of other golf clubs across Australia who came to this place, paying their own way, because they were so aggrieved by this process. Those were representatives from the Rutherglen Golf Club and the Binalong Golf Club. I asked them, 'Do you think this process was ethical, efficient and effective, as the Commonwealth grant program rules say it should be?' They said no, no, no and then the fourth witness said everyone should have had a right to make an application. Everyone should have gotten a fair go, but they were denied that fair go by the Labor government. This program stinks, and it stinks even more that the Labor government refuses to provide documents in response to an order for production of documents made by this Senate. It absolutely stinks.
I believe every Australian, every single community group and every region across the whole of Australia should have had a right to participate in this community infrastructure program, because their community infrastructure is just as important as the community infrastructure in the Prime Minister's electorate. Every Australian should have had an equal right to participate in this $560 million grant program. It's not just me saying that. The chair of the Centre for Public Integrity, an outstanding organisation seeking integrity and transparency in government, the Hon. Anthony Whealy KC, said:
Public grants should be allocated according to community need, not political advantage. Without transparency about who gets invited to apply, Australians cannot be confident that public money is going where it is needed most.
That's all we're asking for. We're asking for transparency, and we're asking for taxpayer funds to be spent where they are needed most. We're asking for a fair go for all of the communities across Australia, whatever the brand of their political representative. Every Australian deserves a fair go.
David Pocock ACT, Independent
3:16 pm
Very well said, Senator Scarr. The Albanese government disrespected Australians with this pork-barrelling at the last election, and they're now disrespecting the Senate wanting to get to the bottom of it and Senator Payman's OPD. Australians rightly expect better of a government that promised so much. Back in 2020, the now prime minister called on Senator McKenzie to resign over sports rorts. In his words:
This is just a rort. It fails the pub test. It fails every test.
In 2021, Labor actually brought its own antirorting bill to this place. They ended up voting against that bill when I moved it as an amendment in the last parliament, so clearly things changed from opposition to government. I'm obviously not defending sports rort. It was a terrible program and deserves to be called out. The point is that Australians were told a Labor government would do better, but clearly they have failed time and time again.
The Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program is just the most recent case in point. It's $560 million worth of taxpayer money—invitation only, though; there's no competition in this program—with 73.2 per cent or $409 million going to Labor seats, while 45 electorates get nothing. Seats where Labor was competitive got disproportionately more. Most Australians understand this as pork-barrelling, and they don't like it. They want governments to do better. They want elected representatives to do better. Senator Scarr quoted the Centre for Public Integrity and the great work that they have done on this. They found no clear link between where the money went and community need. This is pork-barrelling, pure and simple.
Marrickville Golf Club in the Prime Minister's electorate got six million bucks. As Senator Scarr talked about, they were the only golf course in the country that had the ability to, because they were asked to—they were promised the money in advance—then apply for the $6 million that they were promised at the election. That is farcical. The PM then holds an undeclared membership. When he's quizzed about it he says: 'Don't worry about that $5 membership. I forgot to declare it.' It turns out it was a $1,100 membership. That's probably something that should be declared. It's far more than the $300 threshold for things that don't need to be declared. We also heard then about the sewage flowing into the Cooks River. That's why they needed the six million bucks. That's not true.
The thing that I think a lot of Australians are concerned about is that we keep getting different answers to this, and the Prime Minister only admitted his explanation was wrong long after he'd been found out. He didn't come to parliament and actually correct the record. Someone in his office clearly knew. Professor Anne Twomey calls this grey corruption. When she speaks about these matters, we should be listening. There is a way to rebuild public trust to actually deal with this and to ensure that after elections we're not having this ridiculous debate about pork-barrelling and about whether or not election commitments were based on merit, and that is by actually passing the bill of the member for Indi, Dr Helen Haines.
In 2024, she introduced the Accountability of Grants, Investment Mandates and Use of Public Resources Amendment (End Pork Barrelling) Bill. Under the bill, every grant would need clear selection criteria, and a parliamentary joint committee would oversee grant administration. I backed it then and I back it now. This is urgent for the parliament to do. The government doesn't need to invent anything new. They can simply lift up the great work that Dr Haines has done on her end pork barrelling bill and implement it. She's led on the establishment of a National Anti-Corruption Commission. She's leading in the ending of pork barrelling, and the parliament should get behind those efforts. That's an opportunity for all of us, and I would urge Senate colleagues to consider supporting that bill.
Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia
3:20 pm
The Prime Minister seems to have a very convenient memory when it comes to explaining how millions of dollars in taxpayer funding ended up in Labor electorates, including $6 million for a golf club in his own backyard. The Senate has repeatedly sought documents relating to the Albanese government's Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program, and the Prime Minister's response has been, 'I was not the decision maker.' Prime Minister, if you weren't the decision maker, who was? Was it the minister for infrastructure? Was it the minister for regional development? Was it someone in the Prime Minister's own department? And since when does not being the decision-maker mean that you don't have to produce relevant documents? These are two entirely different matters, and the Prime Minister knows it.
This is a government that committed up to $570 million in taxpayer funding to 229 community infrastructure projects, and, of those 229, an extraordinary 203 were in Labor-held electorates. That's almost 89 per cent. Meanwhile, 45 federal electorates received absolutely nothing—not $1. The Centre for Public Integrity found that Labor-held electorates received more than $3.20 for every dollar spent in coalition-held electorates, and marginal seats where Labor was competitive received $66.5 million more than a proportional distribution would have predicted. What an extraordinary coincidence! Apparently, the communities most in need of infrastructure funding just happen to be overwhelmingly represented by Labor MPs.
What makes this even worse is that the program wasn't open to competition. It was invitation only. At a recent Senate inquiry hearing, we heard from representatives of Rutherglen Golf Club and Binalong Community Club. Both desperately need funding to upgrade their facilities, but they couldn't even apply because they weren't invited. Yet, somehow, Marrickville Golf Club, in the Prime Minister's own electorate, received $6.05 million. It was the only golf club in Australia to receive funding under this program, and the Prime Minister's explanations about that grant have been nothing short of extraordinary. He told parliament that the funding was needed to stop raw sewage flowing into the Cooks River. He said:
… when it floods in Marrickville raw sewage flows into the Cooks River—that is what the funding is for.
Except that it wasn't. The club's own management has confirmed that the $6.05 million grant was never intended to fund sewerage upgrades. Those works are being funded separately by the New South Wales government.
The Prime Minister has since conceded that his explanation to parliament was wrong. So what exactly is the $6 million paying for? It is paying for clubhouse renovations, improved amenities, community function rooms, outdoor areas, pedestrian and bicycle access and stormwater harvesting to irrigate the golf course. That's a pretty impressive list of improvements for one golf club. During the inquiry, we also learnt that the Prime Minister's honorary membership had a value of $1,100. That's rather different from the impression he gave Australians when he talked about joining the club for just $5.
The questions extend well beyond Marrickville. We know that, during the election campaign, the infrastructure department recorded 136 commitments, worth $356 million. But, following, consultation with the Prime Minister's department, that grew to the 229 projects, the program worth up to $570 million. We also know that program guidelines were developed retrospectively, with organisations asked to submit months after funding had already been announced.
How can Australians have confidence in a grants process where the winners are announced before the applications are even submitted? The coalition has referred this program to the Auditor-General—rightly so—but communities across Australia need better sporting facilities, meeting places and local amenities. There is an expectation that public money is allocated fairly, transparently and according to genuine community need. It should not be allocated according to which electorate might deliver the greatest political advantage to the Labor Party.
Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens
3:25 pm
I also rise to take note of Minister Wong's responses. I thank Senator Scarr, David Pocock and Senator McDonald for their contributions, and I associate myself with the guts of what they're saying. This parliament has a fundamental responsibility to scrutinise all government spending, hold ministers accountable and ensure public money is spent in the public interest. That responsibility doesn't disappear just because you've won the election. We shouldn't have to use every tool in the Senate's toolbox—orders for production of documents, ministerial attendance, Senate inquiries—just to get basic answers about how more than half-a-billion dollars of taxpayers' money was allocated.
If Labor has nothing to hide, it should have nothing to fear from scrutiny. It should be forthcoming with these documents. The Albanese government has been extraordinarily reluctant to explain how this program was put together. This is the stuff that makes Australians really angry. It underpins their disengagement from democracy. And it makes public servants really furious as well. There should be a process where need is identified, guidelines are set out, criteria are established and money is allocated according to the published goals of a program.
Instead, we see a program here where Labor has refused to properly answer questions about correspondence between the Prime Minister's Office, departments and grant recipients and has failed to provide a comprehensive account of how projects were selected in the first place. Guidelines were developed after the project list had already been compiled. Communities and organisations across Australia were never given an equal opportunity to put forward projects, and of the $559.2 million in active grant applications examined by the Centre for Public Integrity, $409 million of them, 73 per cent, went to electorates held by Labor. Well, no surprise there. Coalition held electorates received 22.6 per cent and other parties and independents just four per cent. Put simply, for every dollar allocated to a coalition held electorate, more than $3 went to a Labor held electorate, and 45 of Australia's 150 federal electorates received absolutely nothing at all.
The skew was especially pronounced in seats Labor was trying to win. Marginal seats, where Labor has a competitive opportunity, received $66 million—more than a proportional distribution would suggest—and fairly safe Labor seats received another $62 million above their proportional share. Meanwhile, marginal seats where Labor is not competitive alongside fairly safe non-Labor seats received $116 million less than their proportional share. These are not small amounts of money; they're the difference for so many communities between the kinds of facilities that are essential to community activities and not having those activities.
The program was worth up to $560 million, with average grants of $2.47 million and a median of $1.5 million in grants ranging from $35,000 up to $45 million. Which community would not benefit? We need clear guidelines that help prioritise those grants. We don't need political slush funds. The Prime Minister has also got some explaining to do about the $6 million awarded to Marrickville Golf Club in his own electorate. At the recent Senate hearing, the club acknowledged to Senator Hodgins-May that its funding request was based on what was described as 'a guesstimate' of what those renovations would have cost.
Labor was very happy to condemn the Morrison government's sports rorts scandal—which should be condemned—when it was in opposition. But those principles have been very, very rubbery when it comes to their own handing out of money. There's a fundamental difference between assessing a project for viability and value for money and deciding which organisations get the opportunity to apply in the first place. An assessment after invitation cannot establish whether a better project in a community that was never invited could have delivered greater value. This is precisely why grants should be open, competitive and merit based. Every eligible community organisation should have had the opportunity to make their case, with applications assessed against published criteria, including community need, project benefits, deliverability and value for money.
Public money is not Labor Party money; it belongs to Australians. It should be allocated according to community need and merit, not the electoral interests of the government of the day. A community's access to public funding should not depend on whether it happens to be in a marginal seat or whether its local MP is a government member or has been lucky enough to catch the attention of the Prime Minister. Australians deserve a grant system they can trust and a government prepared to explain how it spends their money. Our democracy suffers as long as that is failing.
Question agreed to.