This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents
David Pocock ACT, Independent
3:16 pm
Very well said, Senator Scarr. The Albanese government disrespected Australians with this pork-barrelling at the last election, and they're now disrespecting the Senate wanting to get to the bottom of it and Senator Payman's OPD. Australians rightly expect better of a government that promised so much. Back in 2020, the now prime minister called on Senator McKenzie to resign over sports rorts. In his words:
This is just a rort. It fails the pub test. It fails every test.
In 2021, Labor actually brought its own antirorting bill to this place. They ended up voting against that bill when I moved it as an amendment in the last parliament, so clearly things changed from opposition to government. I'm obviously not defending sports rort. It was a terrible program and deserves to be called out. The point is that Australians were told a Labor government would do better, but clearly they have failed time and time again.
The Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program is just the most recent case in point. It's $560 million worth of taxpayer money—invitation only, though; there's no competition in this program—with 73.2 per cent or $409 million going to Labor seats, while 45 electorates get nothing. Seats where Labor was competitive got disproportionately more. Most Australians understand this as pork-barrelling, and they don't like it. They want governments to do better. They want elected representatives to do better. Senator Scarr quoted the Centre for Public Integrity and the great work that they have done on this. They found no clear link between where the money went and community need. This is pork-barrelling, pure and simple.
Marrickville Golf Club in the Prime Minister's electorate got six million bucks. As Senator Scarr talked about, they were the only golf course in the country that had the ability to, because they were asked to—they were promised the money in advance—then apply for the $6 million that they were promised at the election. That is farcical. The PM then holds an undeclared membership. When he's quizzed about it he says: 'Don't worry about that $5 membership. I forgot to declare it.' It turns out it was a $1,100 membership. That's probably something that should be declared. It's far more than the $300 threshold for things that don't need to be declared. We also heard then about the sewage flowing into the Cooks River. That's why they needed the six million bucks. That's not true.
The thing that I think a lot of Australians are concerned about is that we keep getting different answers to this, and the Prime Minister only admitted his explanation was wrong long after he'd been found out. He didn't come to parliament and actually correct the record. Someone in his office clearly knew. Professor Anne Twomey calls this grey corruption. When she speaks about these matters, we should be listening. There is a way to rebuild public trust to actually deal with this and to ensure that after elections we're not having this ridiculous debate about pork-barrelling and about whether or not election commitments were based on merit, and that is by actually passing the bill of the member for Indi, Dr Helen Haines.
In 2024, she introduced the Accountability of Grants, Investment Mandates and Use of Public Resources Amendment (End Pork Barrelling) Bill. Under the bill, every grant would need clear selection criteria, and a parliamentary joint committee would oversee grant administration. I backed it then and I back it now. This is urgent for the parliament to do. The government doesn't need to invent anything new. They can simply lift up the great work that Dr Haines has done on her end pork barrelling bill and implement it. She's led on the establishment of a National Anti-Corruption Commission. She's leading in the ending of pork barrelling, and the parliament should get behind those efforts. That's an opportunity for all of us, and I would urge Senate colleagues to consider supporting that bill.
No comments