This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Documents

Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents


Fatima Payman

Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice

3:05 pm

I move:

That the Senate take note of the explanation.

The use of taxpayers' money for political purposes must stop. Whether it's a $500 million slush fund for projects in target seats or using the power to allocate personal staff as a bargaining chip to pass unsupportable legislation, it needs to be recognised that this is not Labor's money to do with as they wish. This is money that Australians have worked hard for. It needs to be respected as such. We are here not only because there has been a failure of process when it comes to these grants but because there has been a failure to be transparent about the entire process.

This Senate, as a collective decision-making body elected by the Australian people, voted to require the production of documents that the Prime Minister and his office hold relating to the Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program and the decision to provide a grant to the Marrickville Golf Club. This is the same Marrickville Golf Club that the Prime Minister is a member of. The Prime Minister told the other place that the Marrickville Golf Club received the grant for sewerage works, but his own department contradicted him at estimates last month, and he was forced to admit that what he said was not correct. He also said that a membership costs $5, but the kind of membership he has in fact costs $1,100. It's an easy mistake to make, right? It's a rounding error, really. 'It's all within the rules,' the government says. Then change the rules. Constitutional expert Anne Twomey has described this grants process as 'grey corruption'.

Western Australians hear a lot of lip-service about how much this government loves WA, but when it comes to commitments, we have been left behind. This isn't just a pork-barrelling program; it's a pork-barrelling program for the eastern states. Let me talk about just one example. At the last election, the government committed to investing $5 million into a new early childhood education and care centre in the Wheatbelt town of Mukinbudin. The election came and, despite this promise, Labor was not elected in the seat of Durack, which covers Mukinbudin. Bad luck! It was time to honour the commitment, right? It's been a year and a half since that commitment was made. The shire of Mukinbudin had radio silence from the government on this issue for months, until the Department of Education told them they wouldn't be honouring the commitment because of 'lack of demonstrated demand'.

Well, let me tell you about the demand in Mukinbudin. This is a growing town of 600 people, with a new subdivision on the way, bucking the Wheatbelt trend while the neighbours shrink. The only early learning centre in town opens four days a week, and the workers who keep that service running are sharing shire housing. As the CEO, Tanika McLennan, put it, 'The promise looks like it was just made to make the government look good.' Now, when this broken promise received media coverage, the government changed its tune and insisted that the investment was still under consideration. This commitment has been under consideration for more than a year. Do you know what hasn't been stuck in limbo for a year? The Marrickville Golf Club. Over east, they're scheduled to start construction in two months, while in the Wheatbelt they haven't even agreed to do what they said they would to honour this commitment.

It's no wonder then that the Prime Minister has failed to comply with this order of the Senate. His response to this order was to say, 'I didn't make the decision, so I don't have to produce anything.' This is not how this works. The Senate orders documents to be produced; you produce them. If you don't want to produce them, you have to explain why it is not in the Australian public's best interest, not just your political interests, for them to be produced. That has not happened here and that is really concerning in terms of transparency. The Senate has rejected the 'go ask someone else' excuse and rightly so. On Monday, a response was tabled which continued to refuse to table these documents despite the Senate rejecting the explanation that's been provided. It refers to scrutiny that has occurred through the committee process as if that somehow exempts the government from producing these documents. That's simply not good enough.

I want to thank all senators and, particularly, Senator McKenzie for their work in holding the Prime Minister and the government to account on this issue. We hear a lot from the Prime Minister on social cohesion. If we do not improve trust in our institutions, social cohesion will continue to suffer. This sort of pork-barrelling is toxic to social cohesion. It's time to start doing better.

Comments

No comments