This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
3:10 pm
Deputy President, this stinks. This absolutely stinks. What we're talking about here, for those in the public gallery and those listening, is this Senate trying to get documents in relation to the grant program under which there was only one golf club in Australia that had the right to apply for taxpayer funds to undertake renovations, stormwater harvesting and not sewerage works—just one golf club in Australia. Out of 1,400 golf clubs, one golf club in Australia had the right to make an application for those taxpayer funds. Where was that golf club? The Marrickville Golf Club in the Prime Minister's electorate. This Senate is seeking documents in relation to this matter, and, as Senator Payman has said, the Labor government refuses to provide those documents to the Australian Senate so that we can undertake the scrutiny processes that a house of review should undertake for the benefit of the Australian people.
This community grants program introduced by the Labor government stinks. It stinks for the people of Queensland. Why? Because Queensland received $64 million less than it should have received if that money were equitably distributed across the whole of Australia on the basis of population. It stinks because there are 45 federal electorates containing a population of approximately eight million people who didn't receive a brass razoo—not a single dollar. Yet there are Labor federal electorates which received 10 projects, eight projects and four projects. I've got councils in south-west Queensland, one of the most remote and difficult places to live in the whole of Australia, who didn't receive a brass razoo. You can't tell me, as a Queensland senator, that their need for community infrastructure is any less than that of the federal electorates in inner-city Sydney, such as the one inhabited by our prime minister. It stinks because this isn't the Labor government's money; this is taxpayer money. How can a process be fit and proper and how can it be ethical, efficient and value for money when there's only one project that's able to apply for this $6 million grant? How's that ethical? How's that giving a fair go?
At the committee hearing last week, which I participated in, we heard from members of other golf clubs across Australia who came to this place, paying their own way, because they were so aggrieved by this process. Those were representatives from the Rutherglen Golf Club and the Binalong Golf Club. I asked them, 'Do you think this process was ethical, efficient and effective, as the Commonwealth grant program rules say it should be?' They said no, no, no and then the fourth witness said everyone should have had a right to make an application. Everyone should have gotten a fair go, but they were denied that fair go by the Labor government. This program stinks, and it stinks even more that the Labor government refuses to provide documents in response to an order for production of documents made by this Senate. It absolutely stinks.
I believe every Australian, every single community group and every region across the whole of Australia should have had a right to participate in this community infrastructure program, because their community infrastructure is just as important as the community infrastructure in the Prime Minister's electorate. Every Australian should have had an equal right to participate in this $560 million grant program. It's not just me saying that. The chair of the Centre for Public Integrity, an outstanding organisation seeking integrity and transparency in government, the Hon. Anthony Whealy KC, said:
Public grants should be allocated according to community need, not political advantage. Without transparency about who gets invited to apply, Australians cannot be confident that public money is going where it is needed most.
That's all we're asking for. We're asking for transparency, and we're asking for taxpayer funds to be spent where they are needed most. We're asking for a fair go for all of the communities across Australia, whatever the brand of their political representative. Every Australian deserves a fair go.
No comments