This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents
Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens
3:25 pm
I also rise to take note of Minister Wong's responses. I thank Senator Scarr, David Pocock and Senator McDonald for their contributions, and I associate myself with the guts of what they're saying. This parliament has a fundamental responsibility to scrutinise all government spending, hold ministers accountable and ensure public money is spent in the public interest. That responsibility doesn't disappear just because you've won the election. We shouldn't have to use every tool in the Senate's toolbox—orders for production of documents, ministerial attendance, Senate inquiries—just to get basic answers about how more than half-a-billion dollars of taxpayers' money was allocated.
If Labor has nothing to hide, it should have nothing to fear from scrutiny. It should be forthcoming with these documents. The Albanese government has been extraordinarily reluctant to explain how this program was put together. This is the stuff that makes Australians really angry. It underpins their disengagement from democracy. And it makes public servants really furious as well. There should be a process where need is identified, guidelines are set out, criteria are established and money is allocated according to the published goals of a program.
Instead, we see a program here where Labor has refused to properly answer questions about correspondence between the Prime Minister's Office, departments and grant recipients and has failed to provide a comprehensive account of how projects were selected in the first place. Guidelines were developed after the project list had already been compiled. Communities and organisations across Australia were never given an equal opportunity to put forward projects, and of the $559.2 million in active grant applications examined by the Centre for Public Integrity, $409 million of them, 73 per cent, went to electorates held by Labor. Well, no surprise there. Coalition held electorates received 22.6 per cent and other parties and independents just four per cent. Put simply, for every dollar allocated to a coalition held electorate, more than $3 went to a Labor held electorate, and 45 of Australia's 150 federal electorates received absolutely nothing at all.
The skew was especially pronounced in seats Labor was trying to win. Marginal seats, where Labor has a competitive opportunity, received $66 million—more than a proportional distribution would suggest—and fairly safe Labor seats received another $62 million above their proportional share. Meanwhile, marginal seats where Labor is not competitive alongside fairly safe non-Labor seats received $116 million less than their proportional share. These are not small amounts of money; they're the difference for so many communities between the kinds of facilities that are essential to community activities and not having those activities.
The program was worth up to $560 million, with average grants of $2.47 million and a median of $1.5 million in grants ranging from $35,000 up to $45 million. Which community would not benefit? We need clear guidelines that help prioritise those grants. We don't need political slush funds. The Prime Minister has also got some explaining to do about the $6 million awarded to Marrickville Golf Club in his own electorate. At the recent Senate hearing, the club acknowledged to Senator Hodgins-May that its funding request was based on what was described as 'a guesstimate' of what those renovations would have cost.
Labor was very happy to condemn the Morrison government's sports rorts scandal—which should be condemned—when it was in opposition. But those principles have been very, very rubbery when it comes to their own handing out of money. There's a fundamental difference between assessing a project for viability and value for money and deciding which organisations get the opportunity to apply in the first place. An assessment after invitation cannot establish whether a better project in a community that was never invited could have delivered greater value. This is precisely why grants should be open, competitive and merit based. Every eligible community organisation should have had the opportunity to make their case, with applications assessed against published criteria, including community need, project benefits, deliverability and value for money.
Public money is not Labor Party money; it belongs to Australians. It should be allocated according to community need and merit, not the electoral interests of the government of the day. A community's access to public funding should not depend on whether it happens to be in a marginal seat or whether its local MP is a government member or has been lucky enough to catch the attention of the Prime Minister. Australians deserve a grant system they can trust and a government prepared to explain how it spends their money. Our democracy suffers as long as that is failing.
Question agreed to.
No comments