This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Documents

Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents


Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

3:20 pm

The Prime Minister seems to have a very convenient memory when it comes to explaining how millions of dollars in taxpayer funding ended up in Labor electorates, including $6 million for a golf club in his own backyard. The Senate has repeatedly sought documents relating to the Albanese government's Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program, and the Prime Minister's response has been, 'I was not the decision maker.' Prime Minister, if you weren't the decision maker, who was? Was it the minister for infrastructure? Was it the minister for regional development? Was it someone in the Prime Minister's own department? And since when does not being the decision-maker mean that you don't have to produce relevant documents? These are two entirely different matters, and the Prime Minister knows it.

This is a government that committed up to $570 million in taxpayer funding to 229 community infrastructure projects, and, of those 229, an extraordinary 203 were in Labor-held electorates. That's almost 89 per cent. Meanwhile, 45 federal electorates received absolutely nothing—not $1. The Centre for Public Integrity found that Labor-held electorates received more than $3.20 for every dollar spent in coalition-held electorates, and marginal seats where Labor was competitive received $66.5 million more than a proportional distribution would have predicted. What an extraordinary coincidence! Apparently, the communities most in need of infrastructure funding just happen to be overwhelmingly represented by Labor MPs.

What makes this even worse is that the program wasn't open to competition. It was invitation only. At a recent Senate inquiry hearing, we heard from representatives of Rutherglen Golf Club and Binalong Community Club. Both desperately need funding to upgrade their facilities, but they couldn't even apply because they weren't invited. Yet, somehow, Marrickville Golf Club, in the Prime Minister's own electorate, received $6.05 million. It was the only golf club in Australia to receive funding under this program, and the Prime Minister's explanations about that grant have been nothing short of extraordinary. He told parliament that the funding was needed to stop raw sewage flowing into the Cooks River. He said:

… when it floods in Marrickville raw sewage flows into the Cooks River—that is what the funding is for.

Except that it wasn't. The club's own management has confirmed that the $6.05 million grant was never intended to fund sewerage upgrades. Those works are being funded separately by the New South Wales government.

The Prime Minister has since conceded that his explanation to parliament was wrong. So what exactly is the $6 million paying for? It is paying for clubhouse renovations, improved amenities, community function rooms, outdoor areas, pedestrian and bicycle access and stormwater harvesting to irrigate the golf course. That's a pretty impressive list of improvements for one golf club. During the inquiry, we also learnt that the Prime Minister's honorary membership had a value of $1,100. That's rather different from the impression he gave Australians when he talked about joining the club for just $5.

The questions extend well beyond Marrickville. We know that, during the election campaign, the infrastructure department recorded 136 commitments, worth $356 million. But, following, consultation with the Prime Minister's department, that grew to the 229 projects, the program worth up to $570 million. We also know that program guidelines were developed retrospectively, with organisations asked to submit months after funding had already been announced.

How can Australians have confidence in a grants process where the winners are announced before the applications are even submitted? The coalition has referred this program to the Auditor-General—rightly so—but communities across Australia need better sporting facilities, meeting places and local amenities. There is an expectation that public money is allocated fairly, transparently and according to genuine community need. It should not be allocated according to which electorate might deliver the greatest political advantage to the Labor Party.

Comments

No comments