This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Documents
Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents
Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation
12:01 pm
Like all of us, I'm delighted to be here this week and particularly delighted to be here at this moment in the chamber to make precisely the same points that I've made before in relation to order No. 27, relating to Treasury advice concerning first home buyers. In previous Senate proceedings I've advised the Senate that the Minister for Housing made a valid claim of public interest immunity over documents within the scope of this order—documents that clearly and unambiguously are directly related to the deliberations of cabinet. Yet here we are again, in another puerile exercise of abuse of the Senate processes, for a kind of base partisan reason, that says much more about where Senator Bragg and the Liberals are on housing than it does about anything else.
Of course, breaching cabinet confidentiality would do serious harm not to the government but to the ability of any future cabinet of any persuasion to conduct the business of government. It would constrain the briefings that are provided to ministers—the material that is assembled for cabinet deliberations. It would completely constrict all of those things. That would not be in the public interest. But Senator Bragg knows that. He knows that pressing this order is an exercise in futility. It's not a new concept in proper understanding of the Westminster system of government. What is really going on here is a campaign against the five per cent deposit scheme and the government's decision to make that work for all Australians. That's what's really going on here. In Senator Bragg's world view, if you don't have the bank of mum and dad on your side, if you don't grow up with a silver spoon in your mouth—or a silver foot, as the case may be—then you don't get a home. You don't get a home. You don't get access to a five per cent deposit—to the benefits that that offers people in terms of earlier access to their own home—and to your own capacity to have lower mortgage insurance costs over the whole life of your mortgage.
If you want to have that argument, have the courage not to have it in here; have it with the 290,000 young Australians who have benefited from that scheme, who are proud homeowners now and who are meeting their mortgage payments and working to meet their mortgage payments. The truth is that Senator Bragg will never meet those people, because he operates in his own rarefied atmosphere of the fossils who inhabit Liberal Party branches these days and elements of the community who will never have to think about how hard it is to save for a deposit and never be troubled in the way that most Australians are by the struggle that they feel to meet their mortgage payments. People like Olivia—
I know you're not interested in her circumstances. She's a first home buyer in Gymea in New South Wales, a single mum in her 40s. She has said that this has delivered a massive change to her outlook and her sense of security. Go and argue to Olivia. Go and argue to the 76,285 constituents of yours—
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
Senator Ayres, it is helpful if you direct your remarks through the chair.
Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation
Well, I don't know how many constituents in Western Australia have benefited from five per cent deposits, Deputy President—
Slade Brockman Deputy-President
That is not entirely my problem, Senator Ayres.
Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation
but there would be many. There would be many tens of thousands, and Senator Bragg should go and argue to them, too, that this is a bad idea. This is an utterly reasonable position that the government's taken here, and we'll continue to take it— (Time expired)
Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness
12:07 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of the explanation.
I take note of the minister's non-explanation here. I make the point here that the minister says these are cabinet documents. It is not a cabinet document if it is a piece of modelling produced by the Treasury and which was only produced by the Treasury after the election—after the election in which the government announced the abolition of means testing and place caps on this scheme. This was a scheme that was designed for lower income earners, and they made it a free-for-all for people earning up to $650,000 or maybe even more; we don't know, because the government don't give us basic information that the Australian people expect the opposition and the parliament to be able to inspect for public consideration.
They've given it to people who don't need it. They've given it to noncitizens. We have no idea of the basis upon which the modelling by the Treasury was done before cabinet made these judgements. Our job is to come here and get to the bottom of things. The government's view of this parliament and the Australian people, as a consequence, is that they are of no importance to this government. They don't care about the effective role of this parliament, which is to hold this government to account for the judgements it makes.
This scheme is out of control. It is going to people who do not need it. It is going to people who aren't even citizens of this country. It is extraordinary that the government has now spent over 12 months of this parliament's time denying access to this modelling. What are they covering up? What are they hiding? Why can't they just show us the modelling done by the Treasury? It's not a cabinet document. It is not a cabinet document. It is an input to a cabinet debate that should be disclosed for the public to see.
Since 1 October last year, 102,000 people have used this scheme. Many of them today are in negative equity because Mr Albanese encouraged people to take up this scheme and then hit them like a ton of bricks with new taxes, which pushed the value of their properties down. There would be people in hundreds of suburbs, especially in Melbourne and Sydney, who are today in negative equity. That means the loan that you have is worth more than the house that you own. No-one would believe that a prime minister of this country would hate Australians so much as to—as this man has done—encourage people, peddle this scheme, say, 'There are no risks, nothing to worry about,' and then hit them with taxes which drive down the value of their properties. It is extraordinary, to me, that that has happened.
APRA, the prudential regulator, is now saying that there is a material increase in the amount of low-value loans, and that is a big problem here, because we know that people who are exposed to low levels of equity could be in big trouble, as we have seen with these taxes. The lending data we've seen in the last week from the ABS shows that there are fewer loans going to owner-occupiers and fewer loans going to first home buyers because of these taxes. These taxes, combined with this terrible, maladministered scheme, which was originally designed for low-income earners, have been a toxic mix of housing policies which add to the government's terrible record on supply, where we've seen the government spend billions of dollars to get fewer homes.
As I said, no-one would believe the cruel hoax which has been perpetrated here—that the government would cover up the basic information about this scheme, would then encourage people to go into the scheme and hit them with higher taxes and that, meanwhile, those taxes would also damage the ability of first home buyers and owner-occupiers to enter the market. We are in a situation today where it has never been harder for people to get into the housing market, because of the high interest rates, the high levels of red tape and costs in the housing system and the high taxes that have been faced by all Australians. This five per cent scheme is a cruel hoax. It is a gimmick that has been developed by the Labor Party and which was once a policy designed and carefully calibrated for lower income earners. If you're wondering why the government's budget has its backside out of its pants and you're looking at 10 years of deficits, this is one of the reasons. They are giving this scheme to people who do not need it. It is another reason that we have a mass of waste and corruption in this country. The government doesn't care about taxpayer funds. They wouldn't treat their own money like this, but they're happy to use taxpayer funds in this very reckless way.
This attendance is all about getting to the bottom of why the government decided to do this policy in the way that they did. It is all about the modelling that was done by the Treasury that was commissioned as an afterthought after the policy was announced during the election campaign as a bribery scheme. All we want to see is the basic modelling, and we won't give up, because that's our job.
Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens
12:12 pm
I also rise to take note of Minister Ayres's response on behalf of the Minister for Housing. I notice he calls his attendance here and the requirement of the chamber that he be here and respond to the request for information about his housing policy 'puerile' and a base waste of Senate resources, yet here we are, in a housing crisis, with inquiries going around our country and surfacing, every day, the nature of the impact of the government's failure on housing policy. The minister has multiple overdue orders for the production of documents and, yet again, is hiding behind public interest immunity. We need access to who is getting what levels of support, including the uncapped deposit subsidies, and their circumstances. This is a valid request for information about the most significant driver of the cost-of-living crisis affecting millions of Australians every day.
The minister asked, 'What is really going on here?' We want information. We have real concern about the failure of the government's housing policies. Its central policy, the Housing Australia Future Fund, is too complex, too slow and too small. The risks associated with achieving any of its goals have been pointed to by the ANAO very clearly, and we have to rely on the kind of work done by the ANAO to get some basic data about what's going on with programs like the HAFF. Why is this housing crisis, which affects every town, every regional city and every big city in our country, being met with episodic, complex programs without a long pipeline of supply of the kind we know we need?
At 7.30 yesterday morning, I met with the Australian Community Housing organisation and the many, many community housing providers across our country who are looking for a well-developed, well-planned, properly funded pipeline of ongoing programs to support the housing outcomes Australians need. Where is it? It's not there, and community housing providers, along with many Australians, are asking why there is not a more concerted response to the housing crisis.
Some of us in this chamber are participants at the moment in an inquiry into social housing through the Senate Economics References Committee. We are finding in panel after panel of individual women and men and young people affected by the housing crisis an absence to provide over the last 30 years the kind of investment in social housing that this country used to do last century. It has failed in the last three decades to do so. The Housing Australia Future Fund is expected to provide 40,000 homes by June 2029. Well, in your dreams! Last week, during the social housing inquiry hearing, Treasury told us that only 2,199 of those homes have been delivered through the HAFF so far, and the people before us from government could not tell us how many of those homes are available in perpetuity and how many of them are actually now in the public housing stock. These are very important basic questions that a government should be able to answer about a major crisis affecting Australians.
There are close to 640,000 Australians living in extreme housing stress at the moment. They are in real pain. They are in real danger of being kicked out of where they're living now, because of rents going up, onto the streets of Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney, Renmark and our country towns. It's predicted that this number of really at-risk Australians is going to grow to close to a million by 2041. These numbers are appalling. We are the third-richest country on the planet. We should be able to put a roof over everybody's head, and we should have a government that comes to this chamber and gives us the data and information we need to evaluate what this government is doing. We need to know who exactly is benefiting from what, with what impact on them and how their circumstances are affected by finding themselves with a very large housing loan and the prospect of going underwater.
We heard evidence last week from single mothers, older women and young people who have faced huge barriers to getting into any housing. Certainly one of them with three children with disabilities told us that she could be dead before she'd get up the list into social housing. This is unacceptable. We need an emergency response, and we need data that tells us how we're going to get there. We also heard from Elise, who'd been on a public housing waiting list for 22 years. We need solutions. We need information. It's time the government brought it to us in a timely way.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
12:17 pm
This is just a basic question today in relation to transparency. We saw the minister's performance, yet again coming into this place and treating the Senate with contempt, treating the Australian people with contempt and, more than that, seeking those who are trying to get into their first home with complete, total and utter contempt. He continues to use the excuse of cabinet confidentiality. But, as we know, these documents were not part of the cabinet process. These documents are input documents to a document that may have gone to cabinet. So the question that the Australian people should be asking themselves is: what has the Albanese government actually got to hide in relation to its five per cent deposit scheme if it's so sure about the success—or, should I say, so-called success?—of this scheme?
Sadly we know that, because of the government's housing policies, a number of young people did access in good faith the five per cent deposit scheme on the basis of the 50 promises that were made prior to the election. Mr Albanese said, 'For the 50th time, if I am elected, I am not going to touch negative gearing and I am not going to touch capital gains.' And then what did he do? He said to the Australian people—and has now become famous for saying—'I changed my mind.' Well, that is little comfort, Mr Albanese, to those young people who in good faith took you at your word not once, not twice, not three times, not even 10 times, 20 times, 30 times or 40 times but 50 times when you said, 'If I am re-elected, I will not change.' And then you did.
Do you know what the reality is now for so many of those young people? They are now in what is called negative equity. That is where the value of their home has now dropped because of the Albanese government's disastrous housing policies that have crashed the housing market. The value of their home, thanks to Mr Albanese, has dropped, and, sadly, what they owe the bank remains high. In other words, God help those young Australians. If the bank has to step in and take their home, they should squarely blame Mr Albanese (a) for the fact that he misled them over 50 times prior to the election and (b) because his housing policies are crashing the housing market.
The reason we got here as well is that the Senate, on 24 July, took the extraordinary step—in other words, senators across all parts of this chamber voted together—to say to the government, 'We actually order you now to produce the Treasury advice concerning first home buyers.' The Senate did not accept the claims made by the government of cabinet in confidence. As I said, here's the document. Do you see that? It's all blacked out. That is not a cabinet document, despite what the government would say. The Senate then took the further extraordinary step, on 27 August 2025—not 2026 but 2025—and ordered the production of modelling relating to the financial risks and budgetary costs of Labor's expanded home guarantee scheme. More than a year ago, the Australian Senate—cross-parties and the coalition—ordered the government to produce the modelling in relation to this scheme, because we do not accept their claim of cabinet confidentiality. Yet again an Albanese government minister has come in here today and has treated with disrespect not just the Australian Senate but the Australian people.
You are spending billions of dollars in relation to your housing. You are crashing the housing market because of your policies. The five per cent scheme is failing Australians, and you have the audacity to come into this place and refuse to produce the documents. (Time expired)
Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party
12:22 pm
What are you hiding? I forecast things would get worse for first home buyers. Now we can see the results, and I was right. On 10 May 2017, I first warned about first home buyers purchasing with five per cent deposits. I pointed out the heavy financial burden of mortgage insurance and argued that government concessions fail to fix underlying land release and tax constraints. On 14 October 2019, I again warned against the five per cent deposit guarantee model, during the second reading debate on the National Housing Finance and Investment Corporation Amendment Bill 2019. This is the bill which established the original First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, under the coalition government. At the time, I argued that guaranteeing the difference between a five per cent and a 20 per cent deposit would inflate property prices; encourage irresponsible bank lending—because taxpayers wear the risk; and prop up the housing bubble ahead of a potential market downturn. On 4 February 2026, I again warned that pumping more low-deposit buyers into a supply constrained market would drive up prices for entry-level homes.
Speaking to the Housing Australia Amendment (Accountability) Bill 2025 last year, I argued that removing income caps and place limits would worsen affordability by forcing buyers to take on larger, 95 per cent, mortgages while triggering RBA interest rate hikes. I warned that borrowing with only a five per cent buffer will leave buyers exposed to negative equity if property values dip or interest rates rise. He described the policy as turning young Australians into 'debt slaves' to the banks. That's what I described as well. In September 2024 and February 2026, I advocated for a One Nation alternative that pairs a five per cent deposit and five per cent fixed rate people's bank loan with sharp cuts to immigration, allowing buyers to use their own superannuation for deposits and removing GST on new building materials—comprehensive. This is still our policy, one which clearly saw the pitfalls of Liberal and Labor policies and advanced a comprehensive solution. If Australia had adopted One Nation policy, we would not be where we are today, in the mess that buyers are facing. With home prices falling nationally this year by six per cent, many of these first home buyers are in negative equity, meaning they owe more than the value of their house.
Sydney has fallen by 10 per cent. The ANZ bank reports that 2.3 per cent of their mortgage holders are in negative equity, with more than a third of homeowners stressed about repayments. APRA is reporting non-performing home loans at one per cent and growing. A low deposit scheme can work. One Nation's will work, when complemented by reductions in government spending and a thoughtful taxation policy. Treasurer Chalmers's tax changes have driven one of the fastest and worst fall in home prices in the 40 years accurate data has been kept. Excessive government spending is fuelling interest rate hikes, which also depress home prices while driving up interest rates and repayments. This is in the open.
The Weekend Australian, just last Saturday, shows graphs and a wonderful article packed with data. Repayments, on average, for first home buyer discounted variable rate loan, as a percentage of full-time earnings for 25- to 34-year-olds has gone from 35 per cent in Labor's first year to 53 per cent and now to 55 per cent. More than half the money that young people are spending goes on their repayments. This perfect storm of stupidity was started under the Liberal Party and made much worse by this Labor government. It's no longer hidden; it's in the public, as we can see. The failure and the pain are now out in the open, plus energy prices rising, plus the cost of living and plus government waste. Only a One Nation government can provide professional government to the people of Australia.
Question agreed to.