This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Documents
Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents
Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party
12:22 pm
What are you hiding? I forecast things would get worse for first home buyers. Now we can see the results, and I was right. On 10 May 2017, I first warned about first home buyers purchasing with five per cent deposits. I pointed out the heavy financial burden of mortgage insurance and argued that government concessions fail to fix underlying land release and tax constraints. On 14 October 2019, I again warned against the five per cent deposit guarantee model, during the second reading debate on the National Housing Finance and Investment Corporation Amendment Bill 2019. This is the bill which established the original First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, under the coalition government. At the time, I argued that guaranteeing the difference between a five per cent and a 20 per cent deposit would inflate property prices; encourage irresponsible bank lending—because taxpayers wear the risk; and prop up the housing bubble ahead of a potential market downturn. On 4 February 2026, I again warned that pumping more low-deposit buyers into a supply constrained market would drive up prices for entry-level homes.
Speaking to the Housing Australia Amendment (Accountability) Bill 2025 last year, I argued that removing income caps and place limits would worsen affordability by forcing buyers to take on larger, 95 per cent, mortgages while triggering RBA interest rate hikes. I warned that borrowing with only a five per cent buffer will leave buyers exposed to negative equity if property values dip or interest rates rise. He described the policy as turning young Australians into 'debt slaves' to the banks. That's what I described as well. In September 2024 and February 2026, I advocated for a One Nation alternative that pairs a five per cent deposit and five per cent fixed rate people's bank loan with sharp cuts to immigration, allowing buyers to use their own superannuation for deposits and removing GST on new building materials—comprehensive. This is still our policy, one which clearly saw the pitfalls of Liberal and Labor policies and advanced a comprehensive solution. If Australia had adopted One Nation policy, we would not be where we are today, in the mess that buyers are facing. With home prices falling nationally this year by six per cent, many of these first home buyers are in negative equity, meaning they owe more than the value of their house.
Sydney has fallen by 10 per cent. The ANZ bank reports that 2.3 per cent of their mortgage holders are in negative equity, with more than a third of homeowners stressed about repayments. APRA is reporting non-performing home loans at one per cent and growing. A low deposit scheme can work. One Nation's will work, when complemented by reductions in government spending and a thoughtful taxation policy. Treasurer Chalmers's tax changes have driven one of the fastest and worst fall in home prices in the 40 years accurate data has been kept. Excessive government spending is fuelling interest rate hikes, which also depress home prices while driving up interest rates and repayments. This is in the open.
The Weekend Australian, just last Saturday, shows graphs and a wonderful article packed with data. Repayments, on average, for first home buyer discounted variable rate loan, as a percentage of full-time earnings for 25- to 34-year-olds has gone from 35 per cent in Labor's first year to 53 per cent and now to 55 per cent. More than half the money that young people are spending goes on their repayments. This perfect storm of stupidity was started under the Liberal Party and made much worse by this Labor government. It's no longer hidden; it's in the public, as we can see. The failure and the pain are now out in the open, plus energy prices rising, plus the cost of living and plus government waste. Only a One Nation government can provide professional government to the people of Australia.
Question agreed to.
No comments