This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Documents

Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents


Tim Ayres

Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation

12:01 pm

Like all of us, I'm delighted to be here this week and particularly delighted to be here at this moment in the chamber to make precisely the same points that I've made before in relation to order No. 27, relating to Treasury advice concerning first home buyers. In previous Senate proceedings I've advised the Senate that the Minister for Housing made a valid claim of public interest immunity over documents within the scope of this order—documents that clearly and unambiguously are directly related to the deliberations of cabinet. Yet here we are again, in another puerile exercise of abuse of the Senate processes, for a kind of base partisan reason, that says much more about where Senator Bragg and the Liberals are on housing than it does about anything else.

Of course, breaching cabinet confidentiality would do serious harm not to the government but to the ability of any future cabinet of any persuasion to conduct the business of government. It would constrain the briefings that are provided to ministers—the material that is assembled for cabinet deliberations. It would completely constrict all of those things. That would not be in the public interest. But Senator Bragg knows that. He knows that pressing this order is an exercise in futility. It's not a new concept in proper understanding of the Westminster system of government. What is really going on here is a campaign against the five per cent deposit scheme and the government's decision to make that work for all Australians. That's what's really going on here. In Senator Bragg's world view, if you don't have the bank of mum and dad on your side, if you don't grow up with a silver spoon in your mouth—or a silver foot, as the case may be—then you don't get a home. You don't get a home. You don't get access to a five per cent deposit—to the benefits that that offers people in terms of earlier access to their own home—and to your own capacity to have lower mortgage insurance costs over the whole life of your mortgage.

If you want to have that argument, have the courage not to have it in here; have it with the 290,000 young Australians who have benefited from that scheme, who are proud homeowners now and who are meeting their mortgage payments and working to meet their mortgage payments. The truth is that Senator Bragg will never meet those people, because he operates in his own rarefied atmosphere of the fossils who inhabit Liberal Party branches these days and elements of the community who will never have to think about how hard it is to save for a deposit and never be troubled in the way that most Australians are by the struggle that they feel to meet their mortgage payments. People like Olivia—

I know you're not interested in her circumstances. She's a first home buyer in Gymea in New South Wales, a single mum in her 40s. She has said that this has delivered a massive change to her outlook and her sense of security. Go and argue to Olivia. Go and argue to the 76,285 constituents of yours—

Comments

No comments