This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
12:27 pm
I seek leave to move a motion relating to the Albanese Labor government's proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts as circulated.
Leave not granted.
Under contingent notice standing in my name, I move:
That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the Albanese Labor government's proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts.
The Senate must suspend standing orders today because the Albanese government is yet again pursuing another multibillion dollar tax impost on Australian businesses in the last 48 hours. What has now been established demands, immediately, the suspension of our normal business. This is a matter of urgency on behalf of the Australian people, on behalf of the farmers who are going to be affected and on behalf of the small businesses across Australia who have been told, in compliance costs alone, you could now be spending billions and billions of dollars. That is why the ordinary business in relation to the Senate must give way.
We seek to suspend because, in the last 48 hours devastating new information has emerged in relation to the impact that this proposed trust change will have, as I said, on farmers and on small businesses. In particular, the urgency arises because we now know what the price Australian Greens are saying the government needs to pay to actually get the Greens to vote for this legislation. If you are a charity, if you are a private school, if you are a sporting body, be very, very worried if the government proceeds with this legislation.
These developments make this suspension necessary today. Worse than that, we now know that the urgency of this suspension goes to the fact that the Business Council of Australia now estimates that Australian businesses could face an additional $1.73 billion in taxation each and every year. Sadly, when compliance and implementation costs are included, five-year costs could reach—wait for it; this is why the matter is urgent—$4.14 billion. That is more than $4 billion. If you are a business in Australia, yes, we hear you. We will axe Labor's toxic taxes. We hear you, and that is why suspending the ordinary course of business today is so important. If the Labor Party does proceed with the Australian Greens in putting this toxic tax through, businesses have been pretty clear that they will have to close, and Australian people understand what happens when a business closes. A business that has to close employs no-one. In other words, the business is closed. I can no longer go there to get a service.
But what is worse and why this is so urgent is that those employees of that business, because of the actions of the Albanese government not being able to rein in its own spending and going after other people's money, will not have jobs. That is precisely why this Senate must consider the matter immediately before any further concessions are agreed to. We have five major business organisations now formally writing to this chamber and saying, 'For God's sakes, do you understand? Do you understand the consequences of Labor and the Greens doing this deal for family businesses.' Family businesses are businesses that are mum-and-dad Australians and the farmers who produce our food. We want the farmers to get on with their life, not actually have to restructure their businesses at a cost and potentially close down the farm. The impact on jobs, the impact on housing—the warnings have been heard loud and clear.
Negotiations are currently on foot with the Australian Greens, the Albanese government wants this legislation passed before the parliament rises, and that is why the Senate simply cannot proceed with business as usual. Without suspending standing orders, quite frankly, this is likely to go through under a guillotine. What that means for the Australian people is we will not have time to properly look at the legislation, to understand the legislation and to explain to you why it should not go through. That is why we are seeking now the immediate opportunity to consider these new developments rather than allowing the government and the Greens to do a dirty deal that is going to impact businesses across Australia, businesses that are already struggling under the weight of bad decisions of the Albanese government. Worse than that, it will impact the employees who will lose their jobs because of Labor.
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
12:33 pm
We are not supporting the suspension motion today. I acknowledge the political points Senator Cash was making, but I don't think her argument about urgency was made to the satisfaction of the getting the support of this chamber. To use a political argument and a political opposition to a piece of legislation as a way of arguing urgency, I think, is insufficient. The chamber needs to be convinced why the program that's been circulated and agreed should be upended, because the opposition wants to make a political point. We understand that the opposition oppose the tax reform that we have been pursuing and—
I listened in silence to your presentation. I understand that you are making a political argument, but what you're using here is a standing order to make an argument about urgency. When I read the suspension notice—there is nothing in the motion that can be dealt with today in a way that justifies up-ending all of the important legislation that we have on: the counterterrorism legislation, the defence legislation and the administrative and judicial review legislation that we're partway through. We also know we only get about an hour of government business on a Tuesday, so essentially what you're arguing is to deal with none of those important pieces.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
You guillotine everything through!
Deborah O'Neill NSW, Australian Labor Party
Senator Cash, you were listened to in silence. Please respect the standing orders.
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
In relation to the program, we want the program dealt with. I think there was a lot of hyperbole in Senator Cash's presentation on the substantive argument around trusts which I know doesn't relate to the matter that the chamber's currently dealing with, which is the suspension. To correct some of what was being argued, farm income will be exempt from the changes that have been proposed under tax reform. There were a number of other things, but I won't go through them. But just to come in here and argue that farmers will be put out of business when their farm income is actually exempt from the legislation does need to be corrected. And I also think it's important for people to understand that the vast majority, 95 per cent, of tax filers don't receive discretionary trust distributions. It is a very small percentage of tax filers that do. And we are making some modest reforms to those arrangements to ensure that the wages for workers who earn their income through labour, through wages, are not treated unfairly when compared to some of the arrangements that exist against other structures. And that is why we are seeking to make those reforms.
We don't support the suspension. The Senate's got a lot of work to do this week. We made small progress yesterday. We would like to make some more progress today, and I move:
That the question be now put.
Sue Lines President
12:44 pm
The question is that the urgency motion moved by Senator Cash be agreed to.