This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Documents

Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents


Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

12:17 pm

This is just a basic question today in relation to transparency. We saw the minister's performance, yet again coming into this place and treating the Senate with contempt, treating the Australian people with contempt and, more than that, seeking those who are trying to get into their first home with complete, total and utter contempt. He continues to use the excuse of cabinet confidentiality. But, as we know, these documents were not part of the cabinet process. These documents are input documents to a document that may have gone to cabinet. So the question that the Australian people should be asking themselves is: what has the Albanese government actually got to hide in relation to its five per cent deposit scheme if it's so sure about the success—or, should I say, so-called success?—of this scheme?

Sadly we know that, because of the government's housing policies, a number of young people did access in good faith the five per cent deposit scheme on the basis of the 50 promises that were made prior to the election. Mr Albanese said, 'For the 50th time, if I am elected, I am not going to touch negative gearing and I am not going to touch capital gains.' And then what did he do? He said to the Australian people—and has now become famous for saying—'I changed my mind.' Well, that is little comfort, Mr Albanese, to those young people who in good faith took you at your word not once, not twice, not three times, not even 10 times, 20 times, 30 times or 40 times but 50 times when you said, 'If I am re-elected, I will not change.' And then you did.

Do you know what the reality is now for so many of those young people? They are now in what is called negative equity. That is where the value of their home has now dropped because of the Albanese government's disastrous housing policies that have crashed the housing market. The value of their home, thanks to Mr Albanese, has dropped, and, sadly, what they owe the bank remains high. In other words, God help those young Australians. If the bank has to step in and take their home, they should squarely blame Mr Albanese (a) for the fact that he misled them over 50 times prior to the election and (b) because his housing policies are crashing the housing market.

The reason we got here as well is that the Senate, on 24 July, took the extraordinary step—in other words, senators across all parts of this chamber voted together—to say to the government, 'We actually order you now to produce the Treasury advice concerning first home buyers.' The Senate did not accept the claims made by the government of cabinet in confidence. As I said, here's the document. Do you see that? It's all blacked out. That is not a cabinet document, despite what the government would say. The Senate then took the further extraordinary step, on 27 August 2025—not 2026 but 2025—and ordered the production of modelling relating to the financial risks and budgetary costs of Labor's expanded home guarantee scheme. More than a year ago, the Australian Senate—cross-parties and the coalition—ordered the government to produce the modelling in relation to this scheme, because we do not accept their claim of cabinet confidentiality. Yet again an Albanese government minister has come in here today and has treated with disrespect not just the Australian Senate but the Australian people.

You are spending billions of dollars in relation to your housing. You are crashing the housing market because of your policies. The five per cent scheme is failing Australians, and you have the audacity to come into this place and refuse to produce the documents. (Time expired)

Comments

No comments