This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Documents

Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents


Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

10:11 am

I attend in place of Senator Wong. Australia faces the most challenges strategic circumstances since the Second World War. We need to be doing everything that we can to ensure that the ADF is in the best position to defend Australia and our national interests. The Defence estate audit report represents the biggest reform to the Defence estate in Australian history. It is to ensure that our Australian Defence Force has access to the fit-for-purpose facilities it needs to keep Australians safe. The independent Defence estate audit found that a number of sites across the country are vacant or underutilised and have no direct contribution to current or future capability outcomes for the ADF. It also found that those opposite did not make the hard decisions required to provide Defence with the capability and facilities to keep Australians safe.

As the Deputy Prime Minister outlined in his letter of 5 May 2026, the primary basis of the public interest immunity claim is that the report contains sensitive national security information, including classified information about Defence bases and their importance to Defence capability. The information, if disclosed, would be of value to potential adversaries, negatively impact the operational effectiveness of Australia's defence capabilities and likely prejudice national security objectives. This threat was articulated in the Australian Director-General of Security Mike Burgess's 2026 annual threat assessment on 24 June 2026. The director-general outlined the key security threats facing Australia in this assessment, highlighting the increasingly interconnected nature of threats, including terrorism, sabotage, espionage and foreign interference.

As Mr Burgess noted, Australia's defence capabilities and AUKUS remain priority targets for foreign intelligence services. The government released a public version of this report. It is available online and will not jeopardise the operational effectiveness of Australia's defence capabilities. For these reasons, the government continues to claim public interest immunity over the document. It is disappointing that, presented with this information, the opposition aligned themselves with the Greens political party to demand the release of information which would benefit foreign adversaries. We expect this from the Greens political party. Under Senator Shoebridge, they have abandoned basic principles of humanity by adopting a policy of ceasing military assistance to Ukraine in its fight against Russia's illegal war. Defence officials at Senate estimates confirmed that such a policy 'would have a serious impact on Ukraine's ability to defend itself if countries began to reduce their assistance'. But, in joining with the Greens political party in this campaign, the opposition have confirmed that Labor is the only party that is serious about defence and national security. The Albanese Labor government is orienting Defence to do everything it can to defend our nation. This should be the position of any party seeking the responsibility of government.

We know why the opposition are doing this. It is purely for political purposes. It is not in the national interest. As the coalition's own track record shows, defence estate divestments are a necessary part of ensuring defence remains fit for purpose. To claim otherwise is dishonest and irresponsible and puts Australia's national security at risk.

Jacqui Lambie

Jacqui Lambie Tasmania, Jacqui Lambie Network

10:15 am

I move:

That the Senate take note of the explanation.

When the Australian government were thinking about selling off Australian domestic defence sites either fully or partially, they commissioned an independent audit. Senator Shoebridge first asked for a copy during estimates in October 2025. The secretary took that on notice and then responded, 'Questions on notice are for the provision of information, not requests for production of documents,' which is absolute rubbish. When you go through the variety of ways the government and Defence have found a way to say no to handing over this document, it forces the Senate to treat any claims with suspicion. There was no claim of public interest immunity, not even a hint that one might be relevant.

In February 2026, the Senate issued an order for the production of documents for the complete, unedited version of the report to be laid on the table by 4 March 2026. March and April came and went. There was still no document. Then the minister said that, now, there was a claim of public interest immunity after all. How about that! This claim was put to the test by senators during the inquiry and was rejected by the Senate. The OPD was reaffirmed on 10 September. Later, in October, the minister advised that the OPD was being actively progressed and that he would respond as soon as practicable once the necessary steps were complete. Then, in November, that response was the same public interest immunity claim that the Senate had already rejected.

The Senate is an oversight body. Besides making bills better, oversight is the main part of our job. Looking at the original document that apparently guided Defence's decision on what or what not to sell of Australia's defence estate is absolutely the right of the Senate, but it's being obstructed by Defence and the minister. Anyone who has been paying particular attention knows that there are very serious concerns about the performance and effectiveness of the defence estate and security group, but what senators on the committee are seeing are decisions being made that are based on flawed and incomplete information, like sites that are identified by Defence as being surplus—that is, we don't apparently really need them—but they're being left on Defence's books with taxpayer money forked out for no apparent reason. Defence has been unable to answer questions about the annual maintenance, repair and upkeep costs of specific sites, yet, supposedly, there will be about $100 million saved in maintenance annually. Show us the figures. Show us the numbers. That's got nothing to do with national security. It's got nothing to do with national security, so stop claiming it.

The committee was told that works are under way to remove asbestos from buildings earmarked for disposal, but Defence has stated sites will be sold on an as-is where-is basis. The tap dancing in the inquiry and the refusal to answer questions properly and accurately on top of suspect performance are totally, totally unacceptable—absolutely unacceptable. Defence is asking for taxpayer money to build new facilities, to move personnel and to buy new equipment. The question has to be asked: if the organisation cannot effectively manage property assets, how can taxpayers truly trust it to properly manage procurement and sustainment of nuclear powered submarines, especially when the price tag is $360 billion of taxpayers' money? That ends up being $33 million a day for the next 30 years. Imagine how many houses that could build for Australians!

The defence asset sell-off includes both of Tasmania's live-firing ranges—we'll have nothing left—and reserve bases with no appropriate storage for their equipment, weapons or ammunition, and there is no real understanding of the likely impact on recruiting. None of that has been done whatsoever. There has been no modelling done on all that—on what it is going to do in that area at all by putting a lot less into Tasmania and taking it all away. Tasmania may have the smallest population or one of the smallest populations of any Australian state, but we have one of the highest recruitment rates in the country per capita. Don't forget that. We carry it round.

The Defence estate sale dumps eight out of nine cadet sites in Tasmania. Tasmanian cadets feel betrayed, the veterans feel betrayed, and Australia will be betrayed because our defence capabilities won't be meeting the challenges of the 21st century. I can assure you, Australians, that, between the top end of the Defence—the Minister for Defence, whenever you see him—and the top end of the Public Service, this has been nothing but a dog's breakfast from the start. It's about as loose as a goose. To the top end of Defence and the public service in this area: you should be utterly ashamed of yourselves.

Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

10:20 am

What an extraordinary display of arrogance, yet again, from the Albanese government! We had Senator Ayres in here yesterday, basically denying, yet again, the orders for the production of documents—orders that, as Senator Lambie has been pointing out, have been made by the Senate itself after serious consideration time and time again. Yet we had the minister, yet again, come in here today and blatantly state to the Senate that they are not going to honour the order for the production of documents about which the Senate itself has said: 'We reject your claims, Labor. We reject them, we don't believe them, and we want to see the documents.' The Senate has been very clear to the Albanese government. We have rejected the claim of public interest immunity.

The question the Australian people need to ask themselves is: why is this happening time and time again? This is a government that loves to stand up and talk transparency. Well, they are just words; you need to be judged by your actions. What we have just seen from the Albanese government is a failure, yet again, to produce documents that the Senate itself, not just the coalition—the coalition, the crossbench and the Australian Greens have all said we reject your stated reasons of public interest immunity because we believe those documents are in the public interest. This is not the first time we've done it. Three years ago, the independent audit was provided to the government—in December 2023. Time and time again, the Senate has listened to the government's claims. The Senate has joined together and rejected the government's claims and said, 'Please produce the documents.'

Why do we want the documents? Well, there is a particularly serious reason, given what the Albanese government is disgustingly doing to Australia's Defence estate. Let me make very clear, on behalf of the coalition, that the coalition stands with the men and women of Australia's Defence Force. We stand with the serving personnel, the reservists, the veterans and their families. We, unlike the government, believe our Defence Force must have the facilities, the infrastructure and the operational capability that it needs to defend our nation. Quite frankly, as we have made clear since Labor made this disgraceful announcement, we will not stand by and watch while the Albanese Labor government strips away important Defence assets.

I think the Australian people have made their position pretty clear as well. These are not simply parcels of land on a government balance sheet. That's what the government's doing. Because they have an insatiable appetite for spending—because they have run out of money—they are now looking for any possible touchpoint that they can sell off in order to somehow get some funds. That is the Labor government. Just look at what they did to the veterans and their allied health—to the men and women of Australia who put their lives on the line so we can stand here today and have the freedoms that our forefathers fought for. What does Labor do? Labor looks at them and says: 'You're an item on a balance sheet, nothing more and nothing less, and we are going to put in place a financial cap of $5,000. That's as much as we will allow you to claim when it comes to your allied health.' What an absolute disgrace. Yet again, though, it was the Senate that came together—the Greens, the crossbench and the coalition. We were the ones that demanded the Albanese government reverse that disgraceful decision, and, in the end, they had to capitulate to us.

Well, yet again we are here, giving a very clear message to the Albanese government. These are military facilities that have served our nation for generations. You want to flog them off to pay your bills. We say: once they are sold off they will be lost forever. Just look at Victoria Barracks in Sydney. That is a military facility that has served the Australian Army for more than 180 years, and you want to flog off that site because you can't control your spending. Show some respect for the men and women of Australia's Defence Force—and, quite frankly, also for the Australian Senate—and produce the document.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

10:25 am

Well, this is what you get from Labor. They are worse at secrecy than the previous Morrison government was. I had thought that the Morrison government had set a new low bar for secrecy—secret ministries, secret this, secret that. I thought no government could be worse than the Morrison government on secrecy. I thought the coalition had taken us to new depths. Well, the Labor Party have worked out how to plumb even deeper the ugly dark recesses of secrecy—every little nook and cranny they could hide in, every document they could put a secrecy stamp on, every opportunity to find a new way to prevent telling the parliament or the Australian public what they're doing. That's what Labor does. Remember what they did on FOI—that hatchet job they tried to do to make it even harder to get documents out of FOI? And for how many orders to produce documents have they hidden the documents, edited the documents or claimed public interest immunity? The number of claims of public interest immunity we've got out of Labor makes a joke of any efforts to have open government.

Democracy works when the executive is held to account, when they're forced to explain their actions and when parliament actually oversights the actions. That's what's at stake here. Labor is again hiding the truth—and not just hiding the truth from the Senate but also hiding the truth from the public, because you know what's there: a grubby, dirty land deal from Labor. You want to privatise public land because you've got all your developer spiv mates lined up and you want to flog off public land at a discount. That's why you won't tell us the prices. This is the big Labor fire sale, the giveaway to your developer spivs, who you constantly want to deliver to, and you don't care if the public estate is sold to them in a fire sale.

The Greens have a very clear position about public land. Public land should remain in public hands for public purposes. I'll say it again: public land should remain in public hands for public purposes. And there are so many public purposes we should be putting this land to, such as public housing. We have a national housing crisis, and the core part of the economy that's not leaning in to build housing is the Commonwealth government. Labor's response to housing has been this thing called the HAFF. Does anyone remember the HAFF, that kind of magical thinking that Labor had in the last parliament? It's been in the field now for, what, three years? How many houses have been built by the HAFF? None of them have actually been built by the Commonwealth; it is always through some tax incentive, some proxy, some crappy kind of thing. How many houses have they built? I think it is 1,700 houses. That's enough houses to deal with the housing crisis in west Bathurst; it's not a response to a national housing crisis.

So when we see 67 parcels of public land, instead of agreeing with Labor's privatisation fire sale—trying to give it to one of their developer spivs—we say, 'Build public housing on it.' When we see critical heritage assets on the chopping block, we don't see another Labor-Meriton deal for a luxury boutique hotel that some retired Labor member can become the director of to have a post-retirement career. We see important heritage assets that could be used for public purposes. And it is the way Labor went about this fire sale—pretending it was an audit. They call it an audit. But when we asked the two authors of the audit, in the very first opening rounds of questions in the Senate inquiry, 'Are you auditors?' they ducked and they weaved. We said again, 'Are you auditors?' and they said, 'No, we're not auditors.' We said, 'Well, is that an audit?' and they said, 'Well, we're not auditors.' And they call it an audit! It's a lie from the very first word. The very first word of this was a lie. It's not an audit; it's a hatchet job. It's a hatchet job for Labor to find a way to do a fire sale of public assets to their developer spiv mates—all to pay for what? The rudder on one of your AUKUS submarines—that's what you get out of this sale or maybe half the propeller on one of your bizarre planned nuclear submarines. Maybe this is why you want it. You can flog it off and maybe you can pay to send the Prime Minister on another one of your photo ops with Trump. It's a disgrace.

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

10:30 am

The sheer arrogance of the Albanese Labor government in refusing to be accountable to this parliament and to the Australian people over its disgraceful Defence estate fire sale is breathtaking. This is a government which announced in February that it would sell off, in whole or in part, 67 Defence sites across the country without proper transparency, without genuine community consultation and with an appalling disregard for our nation's military history. Yet, when the Senate seeks to scrutinise the very audit on which these decisions were based, the government hides behind improper claims of public interest immunity. What has Labor got to hide? These assets do not belong to the Labor Party. They do not belong to Mr Marles. They do not belong to the Prime Minister. They belong to the Australian people.

In my home region, the proposed sale of the historic Fort Queenscliff was a disgraceful betrayal of our community by Defence minister Richard Marles and the member for Corangamite, Ms Coker. Established in the 1860s to defend the entrance to Port Phillip Bay, Fort Queenscliff is one of Australia's most significant coastal artillery forts. Under its command, guns at Fort Nepean fired what are widely regarded as Australia's first artillery shots of both world wars. The fort continues to support defence functions and is home to a wonderful military museum that attracts thousands of visitors including schoolchildren who learn about our nation's proud defence history. It is a very special place—the service, sacrifice and national memory. Yet Mr Marles saw little more than seven hectares of prime coastal real estate with multimillion-dollar ocean views that he wanted to sell off, disgracefully, to the highest bidder, locking our community out of this precious part of our history. And, rather than stand up for her community, Libby Coker—the member for Corangamite—took her marching orders from Mr Marles. In April, the member for Corangamite even accused opponents of spreading misinformation about the future of the fort—what an insult to our community, such a pathetic failure of representation.

From the outset, the coalition made an unequivocal commitment to keep Fort Queenscliff and Swan Island in Commonwealth hands. Together with local residents, veterans and heritage groups, we fought this shocking fire sale every step of the way, organising community meetings, rallies and a petition and securing a Senate inquiry hearing at the Queenscliff Town Hall. More than 2,000 people signed our local petition, with almost 125,000 signing the coalition's national petition. After nine months of fierce community opposition, the Prime Minister was forced into a humiliating backflip, abandoning plans to sell four of our most historic Defence sites: Fort Queenscliff; Victoria Barracks in Melbourne and Sydney; and RAAF Williams at Point Cook, the birthplace of the Royal Australian Air Force. This was an incredible victory for our community and a humiliating defeat for Mr Marles and Ms Coker.

But the devil is in the detail. Labor has committed to retaining the historical and heritage parts of Fort Queenscliff in public ownership, but, as it is, it is still proceeding with plans to remove Defence personnel at Victoria Barracks in Sydney and Melbourne, which is a disgrace. This is a shocking reflection on the Albanese government's support for our nation. Who could forget Mr Marles's extraordinary remark about Victoria Barracks in Sydney? He said:

It's not my priority to see Defence manage the oldest wine cellar in Australia.

What a pathetic and disrespectful thing for an Australian defence minister to say. I want to commend my colleagues, including Senator James Paterson and Senator Collins, for their relentless pursuit. Labor must be accountable. Labor must be accountable for this shocking fire sale. The documents must be produced. The message from us is our defence heritage is not for sale.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

10:35 am

It's great to be here in the Senate again to see the coalition working alongside their new coalition partners, the Greens, in making a mockery of an issue that has been politicised and is doing absolutely nothing for the defence of this country. The coalition, working with the Greens, should know better. They are ignoring the strategic reality that we are facing as a nation. Australia faces the most challenging strategic circumstances since the Second World War, but Senator Henderson—through you, Chair—would not even acknowledge that point in her opening remarks.

Every single dollar and every single decision in Defence that has been taken so far serves one purpose. It is about putting the ADF in the best possible position to defend our country. But you don't say that, Senator Henderson. You don't say that, but you're happy to swan around in Corangamite, attacking the local member, the very hardworking local member for Corangamite, Libby Coker, who's a wonderful local member. Senator Henderson cannot let go of the very fact that she used to represent the local members down there—

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

And I stopped the sale! When Defence wanted to sell Fort Queenscliff, I stood up.

Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

I think the Acting Deputy President is trying to get your attention, Senator Henderson.

Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

Senator Henderson, thank you. Senator Ciccone, please continue.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

Thank you. As I was saying before I was rudely interrupted by interjections from the senator across the aisle, the independent Defence audit that undertook this process found that, across the country, there are several vacant and underutilised defence sites. That is an absolute fact that needs to be acknowledged. They contribute nothing to current or future capability, yet the cost is so significant to our defence forces, and that is what we as a government are trying to address—something that, when you were last in government, Senator Henderson, you also tried to address but failed to do. You did nothing in the last nine years. It would be irresponsible to keep spending taxpayers' money on sites that are not central to keeping Australians safe—

Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

Senator Henderson! Senator Grogan, point of order?

Karen Grogan

Karen Grogan SA, Australian Labor Party

It goes to the disorderly conduct occurring. There's not one break in the interjection from the senator opposite.

Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

Thank you, Senator Grogan. Senator Henderson, please assist Senator Ciccone so that he may be heard in silence.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

This is why the government is continuing to invest in our defence forces, but part of that investment also means that governments have to be responsible for how we manage taxpayers' dollars and taxpayers' assets that belong to the public. The government is divesting 67 sites and modernising the estate. As the Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Defence confirmed on 8 November, 11 sites have already transferred to the Department of Finance, with the rest on track.

As a proud senator for the state of Victoria, I know that some of these places actually do mean a great deal to our people. Victoria Barracks in Melbourne, the fort at Queenscliff and the RAAF bases at Williams and Point Cook are woven into our story as Victorians and that of our nation. They matter because they matter to the people who currently serve in the uniform, Senator Henderson, as you know, and to the veterans and to their families. As a member of the Committees on Foreign Affairs and Defence and Trade, which is actively having an inquiry into this matter, I have visited these sites. It has been great to engage with the local community, listen to their feedback and make recommendations to government. I look forward to the report next year. It was interesting that we already have an interim report, but I do look forward to the final report early next year.

But it's why these historic elements of these sites also need to be retained and remain in public hands. That is why the government has made the announcement that it has. We are protecting the heritage, and we are also going to involve the Australian War Memorial, who will help us tell that story, because one of the things that is important is that, once these sites are locked away, they need to be locked away for the public good and for decades ahead. Right now, most Australians sadly cannot walk through many of these sites. Opening them is a better heritage outcome than keeping them behind Defence sites.

The history does belong to all Australians, particularly the Victoria Barracks in Melbourne. I think some of us were fortunate enough to go through the cabinet war room. Quite frankly, the first time I walked through it I was actually gobsmacked about how significant the heritage of those rooms was and the very fact that it wasn't even open to the public. I am looking forward to opening that so that every single Victorian and Australian is able to walk through there and understand our Defence history.

CG

Chris Gatenby Tasmania, Liberal Party

10:41 am

Another day, another situation where information demanded by the Senate is ignored by this government. This time it's on the Defence estate. This is meant to be the most transparent government ever. This is incredibly serious. The Albanese Labor government's planned fire sale of the Defence assets across the country, particularly in northern Tasmania, raises serious questions about our defence readiness and the future of these facilities. Defence has announced community information sessions in Devonport and St Helens, yet facilities at Youngtown, Scottsdale, George Town and Stony Head are on the chopping block. Where's the genuine consultation with the communities who are directly affected? People in Launceston, George Town and Scottsdale should not have to travel to the other side of the state on a Tuesday night simply to have their voices heard.

Youngtown is not just another piece of Commonwealth real estate. It supports the army reservists, their training and their equipment. If Labor sells Youngtown, where is the credible plan for those reservists? The same question must be asked about Stony Head and Buckland. If these military training assets are sold, where in Tasmania will our soldiers undertake live fire training? Where will our cadets, again, gain that important experience? At a time of growing international uncertainty, Australians expect their government to be strengthening the Defence estate, not selling our valuable defence assets without clearly explaining what will replace them. Scottsdale also deserves better. Its defence, food science and nutrition capabilities represent an opportunity, not something to be simply sold and flung away. We should be looking at how to strengthen that capability, not abandon it, and the government must pause the fire sale, provide credible plans for the Army reserve and live fire training, and reinvest in Scottsdale's defence capability.

Australians and Tasmanians deserve answers through the Senate. They deserve adequate representation from their federal member, and, above all, Tasmanians deserve a defence policy focused on capability, readiness and Australia's national interest. This whole sorry saga is another example of an out-of-touch government that will sell the defence of our country rather than cut spending. The government must provide the information on the independent audit of the Defence estate like they have been asked to do. Our Defence estate is not for sale.

Question agreed to.