This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents
Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme
10:11 am
I attend in place of Senator Wong. Australia faces the most challenges strategic circumstances since the Second World War. We need to be doing everything that we can to ensure that the ADF is in the best position to defend Australia and our national interests. The Defence estate audit report represents the biggest reform to the Defence estate in Australian history. It is to ensure that our Australian Defence Force has access to the fit-for-purpose facilities it needs to keep Australians safe. The independent Defence estate audit found that a number of sites across the country are vacant or underutilised and have no direct contribution to current or future capability outcomes for the ADF. It also found that those opposite did not make the hard decisions required to provide Defence with the capability and facilities to keep Australians safe.
As the Deputy Prime Minister outlined in his letter of 5 May 2026, the primary basis of the public interest immunity claim is that the report contains sensitive national security information, including classified information about Defence bases and their importance to Defence capability. The information, if disclosed, would be of value to potential adversaries, negatively impact the operational effectiveness of Australia's defence capabilities and likely prejudice national security objectives. This threat was articulated in the Australian Director-General of Security Mike Burgess's 2026 annual threat assessment on 24 June 2026. The director-general outlined the key security threats facing Australia in this assessment, highlighting the increasingly interconnected nature of threats, including terrorism, sabotage, espionage and foreign interference.
As Mr Burgess noted, Australia's defence capabilities and AUKUS remain priority targets for foreign intelligence services. The government released a public version of this report. It is available online and will not jeopardise the operational effectiveness of Australia's defence capabilities. For these reasons, the government continues to claim public interest immunity over the document. It is disappointing that, presented with this information, the opposition aligned themselves with the Greens political party to demand the release of information which would benefit foreign adversaries. We expect this from the Greens political party. Under Senator Shoebridge, they have abandoned basic principles of humanity by adopting a policy of ceasing military assistance to Ukraine in its fight against Russia's illegal war. Defence officials at Senate estimates confirmed that such a policy 'would have a serious impact on Ukraine's ability to defend itself if countries began to reduce their assistance'. But, in joining with the Greens political party in this campaign, the opposition have confirmed that Labor is the only party that is serious about defence and national security. The Albanese Labor government is orienting Defence to do everything it can to defend our nation. This should be the position of any party seeking the responsibility of government.
We know why the opposition are doing this. It is purely for political purposes. It is not in the national interest. As the coalition's own track record shows, defence estate divestments are a necessary part of ensuring defence remains fit for purpose. To claim otherwise is dishonest and irresponsible and puts Australia's national security at risk.
No comments