This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Documents

Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

10:25 am

Well, this is what you get from Labor. They are worse at secrecy than the previous Morrison government was. I had thought that the Morrison government had set a new low bar for secrecy—secret ministries, secret this, secret that. I thought no government could be worse than the Morrison government on secrecy. I thought the coalition had taken us to new depths. Well, the Labor Party have worked out how to plumb even deeper the ugly dark recesses of secrecy—every little nook and cranny they could hide in, every document they could put a secrecy stamp on, every opportunity to find a new way to prevent telling the parliament or the Australian public what they're doing. That's what Labor does. Remember what they did on FOI—that hatchet job they tried to do to make it even harder to get documents out of FOI? And for how many orders to produce documents have they hidden the documents, edited the documents or claimed public interest immunity? The number of claims of public interest immunity we've got out of Labor makes a joke of any efforts to have open government.

Democracy works when the executive is held to account, when they're forced to explain their actions and when parliament actually oversights the actions. That's what's at stake here. Labor is again hiding the truth—and not just hiding the truth from the Senate but also hiding the truth from the public, because you know what's there: a grubby, dirty land deal from Labor. You want to privatise public land because you've got all your developer spiv mates lined up and you want to flog off public land at a discount. That's why you won't tell us the prices. This is the big Labor fire sale, the giveaway to your developer spivs, who you constantly want to deliver to, and you don't care if the public estate is sold to them in a fire sale.

The Greens have a very clear position about public land. Public land should remain in public hands for public purposes. I'll say it again: public land should remain in public hands for public purposes. And there are so many public purposes we should be putting this land to, such as public housing. We have a national housing crisis, and the core part of the economy that's not leaning in to build housing is the Commonwealth government. Labor's response to housing has been this thing called the HAFF. Does anyone remember the HAFF, that kind of magical thinking that Labor had in the last parliament? It's been in the field now for, what, three years? How many houses have been built by the HAFF? None of them have actually been built by the Commonwealth; it is always through some tax incentive, some proxy, some crappy kind of thing. How many houses have they built? I think it is 1,700 houses. That's enough houses to deal with the housing crisis in west Bathurst; it's not a response to a national housing crisis.

So when we see 67 parcels of public land, instead of agreeing with Labor's privatisation fire sale—trying to give it to one of their developer spivs—we say, 'Build public housing on it.' When we see critical heritage assets on the chopping block, we don't see another Labor-Meriton deal for a luxury boutique hotel that some retired Labor member can become the director of to have a post-retirement career. We see important heritage assets that could be used for public purposes. And it is the way Labor went about this fire sale—pretending it was an audit. They call it an audit. But when we asked the two authors of the audit, in the very first opening rounds of questions in the Senate inquiry, 'Are you auditors?' they ducked and they weaved. We said again, 'Are you auditors?' and they said, 'No, we're not auditors.' We said, 'Well, is that an audit?' and they said, 'Well, we're not auditors.' And they call it an audit! It's a lie from the very first word. The very first word of this was a lie. It's not an audit; it's a hatchet job. It's a hatchet job for Labor to find a way to do a fire sale of public assets to their developer spiv mates—all to pay for what? The rudder on one of your AUKUS submarines—that's what you get out of this sale or maybe half the propeller on one of your bizarre planned nuclear submarines. Maybe this is why you want it. You can flog it off and maybe you can pay to send the Prime Minister on another one of your photo ops with Trump. It's a disgrace.

Comments

No comments