This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Motions

Defence Properties


Jessica Collins

Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party

10:43 am

I seek leave to move a motion relating to the Defence estate divestment program as circulated.

Leave not granted.

Pursuant to contingent notice standing in the name of the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate, I move:

That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the Defence estate divestment program.

Let me tell you why it is so urgent that we need to suspend the standing orders right now. Last night, we had a further hearing into the Defence estate, and it was abundantly clear that the people overseeing the program of flogging off our Defence estate, and especially Victoria Barracks Sydney, had not done the work. They had not asked the questions about the degradation to our capability to defend ourselves should they evict the Army from Victoria Barracks Sydney by early December, which they are doing, and they are doing it at pace. So we are here in the Senate today, and I wish to move a motion relating to Victoria Barracks Sydney, calling on the Labor government to cease the eviction of our troops from their spiritual home, Victoria Barracks Sydney, to guarantee that Victoria Barracks Sydney will remain an operational facility for our military as it has done successfully for 180 years and to immediately halt the Defence estate flog-off to protect other historic and strategically significant sites, including Lancer Barracks in Parramatta, Irwin Barracks in Perth, the Stony Head training area and other important sites around Australia.

We heard from the minister today that we are in the most challenging strategic time since World War II, and they want to put the ADF in the best position to defend and keep Australia safe. I'll tell you what you don't do. If we are in the most strategically challenging times since World War II, you don't move the Army out of Victoria Barracks Sydney into a corporate block in the middle of Pitt Street in Sydney which doesn't have the facilities for them to do their job. That's forcing four out of 10 from Forces Command and Battle Lab to work from home. Fancy that! Our soldiers are having to work from home and not do their job. That's what this government is trying to do in a matter of weeks. They're evicting them from a fit-for-purpose site that has been fit for purpose for 180 years into a building that's not ready to support them to do their secret and top secret work. We established that last night.

The capability risk and the national security risk that this government is creating is on them. I tell you what, everybody else in this chamber—all the other parties in this chamber—are against the flogging off of Victoria Barracks Sydney. Call it what you like—a lease, commercial opportunities, not being sold—they are still flogging off Victoria Barracks Sydney, and they are selling out our troops. We will always stand with our troops on this side of the chamber, and we will fight this.

Let me tell you what's going to happen if you get them out before Christmas. There will be psychosocial harm to our troops if you get them out before Christmas. I encourage the government to go and take a look at the submissions that the troops have made in relation to the psychosocial harm not just from being out before Christmas but from selling the spiritual home of their Army. It's not just the people attached to Victoria Barracks but the troops all around the country too. After everything that this government has put them through all this year—everything that you do to veterans is the same hit. It's the same hit. You look at me with your eyebrows raised. It is the same hit. If you hit our veterans, you're hitting our troops too.

Jenny McAllister

Jenny McAllister NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme

We remember what happened to veterans under your government.

Jessica Collins

Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party

Thank you! So then I encourage you to take this on board. I encourage you to take on board that what you are doing is a national security risk. It is a risk to our capability. The people overseeing this process have not even stopped to ask about the risk to capability and the risk to psychosocial harm. We established that last night.

This independent audit that we have asked for—you know, there are surplus sites out there. There is a list that the Army gave with about 40 of those sites. Not one of them—and Victoria Barracks Sydney would never have been on that list ever. So I encourage you to have a genuine conversation with our serving personnel and ask for the truth, because it is abundantly clear that all of those on the other side either don't have the truth or are complicit.

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

10:49 am

We will not, and do not, support the suspension and do not agree with this upending, again, of the program, as was tried yesterday and no doubt will be dealt with later today and tomorrow as well. On the Defence estate and the program that is underway, I think it is important to actually put the facts on the table. I would remind those, including the Greens political party, who are getting more and more like the Liberal Party every day—I cannot believe that they are supporting the Liberal Party in this.

Here are a few facts. There was an independent audit done. It found that there were a number of sites in Defence ownership that no longer contributed to operational capability—in fact, it was costing Defence to maintain them—and recommended the sale of a number of sites. It also acknowledged that governments, over decades, had failed to deal with this issue and that it was having a financial impact on Defence and was not contributing to the defence force that they needed for current times. That was an independent audit.

The government has taken that audit. We've made a number of decisions. As Minister for Finance, I have a role there to work through each of those sites and work out the appropriate divestment pathway, and that is what we are doing. We are engaging with stakeholders. We are engaging with state governments. We are working through each individual site—including the most appropriate divestment pathway.

I cannot believe that the people in here that lecture us about housing and lecture us about First Nations capability are joining hands with those over there. When we take a decision that Stokes Hill in the Northern Territory—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Hon. Senators:

Honourable senators interjecting—

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

You may not have noticed this, Senator Shoebridge. This is what you're trying to stop—giving it back to the traditional owners, the Larrakia people, who have, through the divestment process, told us that is a sacred site to them. We have taken the decision, for the first time, to provide that land—an unused fuel site in the Northern Territory, on prime waterfront land—back to the traditional owners as the owners of that land. That is what the Greens political party are voting to stop today. I cannot believe it. The land that will be used by state governments for housing—that is what the Greens political party are voting to stop today.

We have taken the decision to retain those facilities—Victoria Barracks, both Sydney and Melbourne, and Penguinin public ownership to allow the Australian public to be a part of that important history of the defence forces of this country; to work with the War Memorial to make sure that the history of those sites is properly recorded, because it hasn't been, in a way that the Australian community is a part of; to allow the community to have access to those sites; and to work out a public activation for those important sites.

On all of the concerns about compromising national security—that is not the advice that has been provided to the government. On all of the concerns that have been made about Defence Plaza Sydney, I would remind Senator Collins that it was a decision of former senator Mathias Cormann to lease that facility and to move Defence staff into that facility and that—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Hon. Senators:

Honourable senators interjecting—

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

We are not doing that. So all of your concerns about the appropriateness of that should be made to Mathias Cormann about the agreement he enlisted then—40 per cent occupied and 60 per cent vacant in that facility—and a much more appropriate office environment for the staff to be in.

So come in here and talk about housing and talk about community access, then vote this way. These sites are not needed for defence capability—that is the clear advice to the government—and the Greens political party are voting today to keep those sites as an operational military facility in the middle of Sydney. That is the Greens political party. No more lectures from you, Senator Shoebridge.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

10:54 am

The Labor Party, who's been spending the last week coming up with a stitch-up job on gas reservation with the coalition, trying to do a job on nature, trying to do a job on First Nations people in the NT to frack their land and destroy their water, and with their minister, Madeleine King, who went on to turn on the fracking in the Beetaloo, coming in here and lecturing us about First Nations rights—you've got to be kidding. You found one site out of the 67 sites in the country. I think the Prime Minister agreed to return a Men's Shed to someone in Tasmania. Well, good on him! Well done, Prime Minister—a Men's Shed going to someone in Tasmania. Apparently, he listened.

Apart from that, you found one site—3.8 hectares in Darwin—that you say you're going to give back to the Larrakia people. Of course you should give land back to Larrakia. Of course you should. But do you know what the Larrakia people have said to you? Do you know what the Larrakia people have said to Labor? 'How dare you? How dare you hand this contaminated land—contaminated with PFAS, contaminated with decades and decades of deep pollution—to the Larrakia people and not remediate it?' They have said to you: 'If you're going to be serious about giving land back to Larrakia people, don't give it back to us poisoned by Defence. Don't give us it back without dealing with the PFAS, without dealing with the contamination.' You have said nothing to them. You are giving poisoned land back to First Nations peoples, and you come here and lecture us on First Nations. You are fracking First Nations land in the Beetaloo. You are destroying country. You are ignoring First Nations peoples, and you dare come in here and lecture us on it. You dare do that—

Leah Blyth

Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure

Senator Ciccone?

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

I just wanted to draw the senator back to why this motion is urgent. He needs to go to the substance about why this is urgent, why we need to deal with the matter, not the other issues that the senator is raising.

Leah Blyth

Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure

Thank you, Senator Ciccone. I am listening. Senator Shoebridge, please.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

I appreciate that. Well, Labor may not think that it's urgent to remediate poisoned land before you hand it back to the Larrakia people, but the Greens believe it's urgent that you remediate poisoned land. You don't come in here, on an important issue like this about you flogging off 67 parcels of public land, and put First Nations rights on the table in circumstances where the only land you're proposing to send back to First Nations is land that you have poisoned with PFAS and contamination and you have no promise, no commitment, to remediate that land for the Larrakia people. If you have a commitment to do it, you get a speaker to come and say it right after me. You get a speaker from Labor to come in here and say right after me that you will remediate that land for the Larrakia people, that you will pay the cost of it and that you'll give them back their land without the poison that you put on it. If you are serious, you come and get a speaker to say that straight after me.

Why is this urgent? This is urgent because, unless we stop the sale, unless we stop this kind of spiv behaviour from Labor, we know what you'll do with this land. You will be finding your well-connected donor mates, your spivs, to flog it off to, just like Labor has done time after time after time. We have asked to see what you're proposing to get for this land. You won't show it to us, and you won't show it to the public because you've got a fire sale planned of public land. When it comes to this motion and to (b)(ii) on this motion about Victoria Barracks, what we heard very clearly, if you listen to Defence, is that they still have a defence purpose for that land. They have no idea where the headquarters command is going to go. They have no idea what's happening to the defence capabilities on that site. You're proposing to send them to Defence Plaza on an insecure site. You've got no idea where you're going to send them. So—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

 where there's no idea, of course it makes no sense to Defence. I want to be clear—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Shoebridge, I've called you to order! I've just come in. I've checked with the Clerk. We are debating a suspension motion, so you need to focus on why the matter is urgent and requires a suspension motion.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Thank you very much for that direction, President. This is urgent because Labor is trying to flog off 67 parcels of public land to their developer spiv mates. That's why it's urgent. The Greens believe public land should remain in public hands. We believe, if you're handing land back to First Nations peoples, you should fix the poison on it before you give it back to them. We believe, when it comes to Victoria Barracks, if Defence have no further purpose for it, then of course it should be used as a community asset. But, if anyone seriously believes that Defence agrees with being evicted by Labor, they haven't been listening. As soon as there's no need for a defence purpose on Victoria Barracks, it should be a magnificent public asset. It should be opened up to the public, if we can put important criteria on it.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Hon. Senators:

Honourable senators interjecting—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

But you know that's not the case, and you know— (Time expired)

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Shoebridge, come to order. The chamber needs to come to order. I'm going to remind the chamber that this is a suspension debate. It is not about the substantive motion. This is a suspension debate and that is what your remarks need to be centred around.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

11:00 am

I am very pleased to make my contribution on the importance of this particular motion, because it's very clear to me from my interactions with my community that the government has no plan for what it wants to do after this flog-off, as it's been so eloquently put by my colleagues. Let's be very clear: this is a flog-off. The decision has already been made. My communities are being told, 'You'll just have to put up with it.' There's no member of the Labor Party in my state who's prepared to say to my communities, 'There's something we can do here.' They're saying: 'You just have to put up with it. This flog-off decision has been made.'

So I urgently want to see some discussion with respect to how this chamber manages this issue, because I can't see the logic in what the government's trying to do in terms of the facilities in my community. Take TS Sheean, Training Ship Sheean. It's a training facility for sea cadets.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Colbeck, I'm going to remind you to speak to the suspension debate.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

Yes, I'm very cognisant of your instruction, President.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Thank you, Senator.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

TS Sheeanis to be closed. I don't see why it should be closed. I think it's urgent that this chamber considers that process, because they have to be out straightaway. They're gone by the end of this month. So I think it's important that we deal with this right now. TS Sheean is named in honour of Teddy Sheean, a Victoria Cross recipient. It was important enough for the Chief of Navy to come down just two years ago to rename it 'TS Sheean'. At the end of this month, if we don't intervene through this process urgently, TS Sheean is a shot duck. It will be gone. Navy want to dispense with it. Why? If two years ago it was important enough for the Chief of Navy to come down to rename TS Mersey to TS Sheean, why isn't it important enough to have a proper conversation about what will happen to this site? The defence minister talks about this being important in terms of doing the job of actually defending the country. Well, what about recruitment? That's what TS Sheean is about. It's a site where we recruit young Australians to the Defence Force. We could incorporate in Devonport urgently. We could incorporate the Navy cadets, the Army cadets, the Air Force cadets and the 44th Transport Squadron onto the TS Sheean site. We could make that decision if we're prepared to have a sensible conversation in this chamber urgently.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Colbeck, I am going to remind you that you have drifted away from the suspension motion and why it is so urgent that the business of the chamber has to be dispensed with. That's the focus of this debate.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

I was just about to say that very thing, President.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

I'm sure you were.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

I was just about to say that very thing, because TS Sheean disappears in two weeks. So, unless this chamber can urgently deal with this matter, that facility, renamed in honour of Teddy Sheean, a Victoria Cross recipient, by the Chief of Navy just two years ago, will disappear. That's why this is urgent, because my community wants to understand what's going on. They have been told nothing. They have been told nothing, and they should understand. This chamber should have to go through a process to allow my community to understand what's going on so that they can understand before TS Sheean disappears at the end of this month what's going to happen to the 44th Transport Squadron. Where are they going? Where are the recruiting agencies and facilities for cadets for Army, Air Force and Navy going to be in my community? Is it going to be available locally? It's important that we urgently understand that, and it's important that this chamber deals with it so that we can.

But this government isn't interested in having those conversations. They've already made the decision that they are going to desert regional communities in Tasmania. They've already made the decision that there will be no live firing training facilities in Tasmania when Stony Head goes and Brighton goes. They've already made those decisions, yet they won't allow this chamber to participate in a debate that allows those conversations to occur, and they should. And Stony Head is not just about Army. SOG, police and emergency services all use Stony Head for training purposes, and those facilities in Tasmania will be gone. So we need to understand, as soon as we possibly can, what the alternatives might be or what the government intends to do about providing those facilities and those training capacities in Tasmania. I don't want the police force in Tasmania to have to go to Victoria to do their live firing training. We need to understand that now, before this process— (Time expired)

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

11:06 am

There is an urgent need to suspend standing orders to hold the Albanese Labor government to account over its disgraceful Defence Estate fire sale. The arrogance of this government in hiding these documents—documents which reveal their true motivations, documents which say to the Australian people, 'We are not prepared to be accountable and we are not prepared to be transparent.' This motion includes the provision of condemnation of the Albanese Labor government 'for proceeding with the removal of Defence personnel from Victoria Barracks Sydney in the lead up to Christmas'. There are weeks to go before everyone is going to be moved out under the Albanese Labor government, despite the decision—the humiliating backflip—to retain the site in public ownership.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Henderson, I am also going to remind you that we are not debating the substantive motion. We are debating the motion to suspend, and that is where your comments need to align—with why it is so urgent that the Senate needs to suspend.

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

Madam President, that's exactly what I was referring to—why it's so urgent—and it's so urgent—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Henderson, you were quoting from the substantive motion. I'm reminding you that this is a debate about a suspension.

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

That's right. And the reason it is so urgent to suspend is that what's at stake here is that the government is proposing to make decisions within weeks, and it is critical that the independent audit of the Defence Estate be provided to this parliament. We deserve the transparency. We deserve to know what's really going on. I can tell you what's going on in my community. At a community meeting to discuss the opposition to the sale of Fort Queenscliff a local resident stood up and said, 'Mr Marles told me, when I called his office, that the government wants to sell Fort Queenscliff to the highest bidder.' It does not care about the future of our country, about preserving this land, about our defence heritage. That is why it's so important to suspend standing orders.

This is urgent. We have committed to keep Swan Island in Commonwealth hands. That is a very important decision in the interests of our national security, yet the government has been silent. So we need to suspend standing orders so we can debate the importance of getting access to the independent audit of the Defence Estate—which of course, as we know, was done by people with no defence experience. What a disgrace. This is a sorry episode for this government, and it is so urgent to suspend standing orders because for months and months this government has tried to hide behind a failure to be transparent, a failure to be accountable. That is simply not good enough. The Senate has made this order; there is no public interest immunity claim. These documents must be provided to the Senate, and it is a disgrace that they are not being handed over. It is an order of the Senate; the government has no choice. But we know the government is so desperate because this economy is running off the rails. The Albanese government is sending our country to economic ruin, and now they are clawing for money.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

You've drifted from the suspension motion; I'll draw you back to the suspension motion.

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

The reason it is so urgent to suspend standing orders is that this government is dramatically driving our nation economically off a cliff, and they are now grabbing for every dollar they can get and putting the lives of our country, of our veterans and of our serving personnel at risk. What the government has tried to do is an absolute joke, and it has taken an enormous national campaign for the government to backflip on the sale of four Defence estates. Thank goodness. People from every part of this community—every political party. including New South Wales Labor—all joined forces to say that we are not going to stand by and allow you to sell off our precious Defence estates like Victoria Barracks in Sydney. This is urgent. This matter must get precedence in this parliament and in this Senate. The Senate has made its order, and we will not stand by and allow this government to put our national security and our serving Defence personnel at risk by selling off these precious Defence sites.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

11:11 am

Look, with the greatest respect to my colleagues on the other side, this is the greatest stunt that I've seen in this place in my time. Talk about wasting Senate business time when we have such important government business like counterterrorism bills, like Senator Nita Green has just reminded me of. You would think that this Senate president did not have an active inquiry into the matter that is apparently so damn urgent that we've got to deal with it today. We have an active inquiry. In fact, we had a hearing last night, here in Parliament House, dealing with this very matter. In fact, this matter has been on the books since the start of the year. It was extended in May and re-extended in September. We have already had an interim report handed down, and we are due to report by February next year. You would think that, from all the contributions from those opposite, that this parliament has not had an inquiry into this matter. We have. We've been travelling around the country, listening to people and listening to communities. This is why this matter is not urgent. We have an active Senate inquiry at the moment.

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

Point of order: I would ask that you draw the senator back to the purpose of this debate, which is the urgency of the standing orders.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Ciccone is being relevant. He is outlining why he believes there is no suspension required. He is being relevant to the matter.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

I appreciate your ruling. It just shows how sensitive they are on the other side. They are just politicising this issue. You'd think that, if it was so damn important, the shadow minister for defence would be here arguing about this. But where is he? He's busy in Victoria supporting his state colleagues for the state election campaign.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Ciccone—

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

I know that point is not relevant, but it is damn relevant to the motion before us.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The time for the debate has expired. The question is that the suspension motion as moved by Senator Collins be agreed to.

Jessica Collins

Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party

11:20 am

I move:

That a motion relating to the Defence estate divestment program may be moved immediately, have precedence over all other business and be determined without amendment or debate.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the motion as moved by Senator Collins be agreed to.

Jessica Collins

Jessica Collins NSW, Liberal Party

11:24 am

I move:

I move that the Senate:

(a) notes that:

i. in February 2026 the Albanese Labor Government announced plans to divest historic and operationally significant Defence sites, including Victoria Barracks Sydney, at market value;

ii. on 8 November 2026, following widespread opposition from veterans, serving personnel and the community, the Government announced that Victoria Barracks Sydney would remain in public ownership, but confirmed that Defence personnel would continue to be evicted from the site;

iii. despite retaining the site in public ownership, the Government intends to transfer Victoria Barracks Sydney out of the Defence estate, with all but a handful of Defence personnel expected to be evicted by the end of 2026;

iv. Victoria Barracks Sydney has been an Army barracks for more than 180 years and remains an operational Defence facility pending the planned relocation of personnel; and

v. the Senate Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee's interim report of 16 September 2026 recommended an immediate halt to the Defence estate divestment program;

(b) calls on the Albanese Labor Government to:

i. immediately cease the eviction of Defence personnel from Victoria Barracks Sydney;

ii. guarantee that Victoria Barracks Sydney remains an operational military facility within the Defence estate, rather than merely retaining the site in public ownership;

iii. immediately halt the Defence estate divestment program, consistent with the Senate committee's recommendation; and

iv. protect other historic and strategically significant Defence sites, including Lancer Barracks, Parramatta, Stony Head Training Area, Tasmania and Irwin Barracks, Perth, and preserve their capacity for current and future Defence use;

(c) condemns the Albanese Labor Government for proceeding with the removal of Defence personnel from Victoria Barracks Sydney in the lead up to Christmas despite its decision to retain the site in public ownership and the continuing opposition of veterans, serving personnel and the community;

(d) calls on the Albanese Labor Government to release the 'independent audit of the Defence estate' as provided to the Government in December 2023; and

(e) directs that this resolution be communicated by message to the House of Representatives.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the motion as moved by Senator Collins be agreed to.