This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents
Jacqui Lambie Tasmania, Jacqui Lambie Network
10:15 am
I move:
That the Senate take note of the explanation.
When the Australian government were thinking about selling off Australian domestic defence sites either fully or partially, they commissioned an independent audit. Senator Shoebridge first asked for a copy during estimates in October 2025. The secretary took that on notice and then responded, 'Questions on notice are for the provision of information, not requests for production of documents,' which is absolute rubbish. When you go through the variety of ways the government and Defence have found a way to say no to handing over this document, it forces the Senate to treat any claims with suspicion. There was no claim of public interest immunity, not even a hint that one might be relevant.
In February 2026, the Senate issued an order for the production of documents for the complete, unedited version of the report to be laid on the table by 4 March 2026. March and April came and went. There was still no document. Then the minister said that, now, there was a claim of public interest immunity after all. How about that! This claim was put to the test by senators during the inquiry and was rejected by the Senate. The OPD was reaffirmed on 10 September. Later, in October, the minister advised that the OPD was being actively progressed and that he would respond as soon as practicable once the necessary steps were complete. Then, in November, that response was the same public interest immunity claim that the Senate had already rejected.
The Senate is an oversight body. Besides making bills better, oversight is the main part of our job. Looking at the original document that apparently guided Defence's decision on what or what not to sell of Australia's defence estate is absolutely the right of the Senate, but it's being obstructed by Defence and the minister. Anyone who has been paying particular attention knows that there are very serious concerns about the performance and effectiveness of the defence estate and security group, but what senators on the committee are seeing are decisions being made that are based on flawed and incomplete information, like sites that are identified by Defence as being surplus—that is, we don't apparently really need them—but they're being left on Defence's books with taxpayer money forked out for no apparent reason. Defence has been unable to answer questions about the annual maintenance, repair and upkeep costs of specific sites, yet, supposedly, there will be about $100 million saved in maintenance annually. Show us the figures. Show us the numbers. That's got nothing to do with national security. It's got nothing to do with national security, so stop claiming it.
The committee was told that works are under way to remove asbestos from buildings earmarked for disposal, but Defence has stated sites will be sold on an as-is where-is basis. The tap dancing in the inquiry and the refusal to answer questions properly and accurately on top of suspect performance are totally, totally unacceptable—absolutely unacceptable. Defence is asking for taxpayer money to build new facilities, to move personnel and to buy new equipment. The question has to be asked: if the organisation cannot effectively manage property assets, how can taxpayers truly trust it to properly manage procurement and sustainment of nuclear powered submarines, especially when the price tag is $360 billion of taxpayers' money? That ends up being $33 million a day for the next 30 years. Imagine how many houses that could build for Australians!
The defence asset sell-off includes both of Tasmania's live-firing ranges—we'll have nothing left—and reserve bases with no appropriate storage for their equipment, weapons or ammunition, and there is no real understanding of the likely impact on recruiting. None of that has been done whatsoever. There has been no modelling done on all that—on what it is going to do in that area at all by putting a lot less into Tasmania and taking it all away. Tasmania may have the smallest population or one of the smallest populations of any Australian state, but we have one of the highest recruitment rates in the country per capita. Don't forget that. We carry it round.
The Defence estate sale dumps eight out of nine cadet sites in Tasmania. Tasmanian cadets feel betrayed, the veterans feel betrayed, and Australia will be betrayed because our defence capabilities won't be meeting the challenges of the 21st century. I can assure you, Australians, that, between the top end of the Defence—the Minister for Defence, whenever you see him—and the top end of the Public Service, this has been nothing but a dog's breakfast from the start. It's about as loose as a goose. To the top end of Defence and the public service in this area: you should be utterly ashamed of yourselves.
No comments