This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; Order for the Production of Documents
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
9:01 am
I thank the Senate for the opportunity to attend and update it on this OPD. The Treasurer has replied to and complied with the OPD request, in particular with OPD 573, which this motion relates to. He wrote on 16 November 2026 and provided a number of documents related to the OPD—in particular, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, APRA, and the government's successful five per cent deposit scheme. I provided those documents on the same day to the President.
As outlined in the letter from the Treasurer, there were some redactions, which is the normal process, including the removal of personal information for employees below SES level and their contact details. But this is just another opportunity for Senator Bragg to get on his anti-housing soapbox. Despite the fact that the government complied with the OPD motion and provided the documents, Senator Bragg comes here claiming the government has not complied. If we look at the facts—even if Senator Bragg doesn't like them—the government has provided the documents to the Senate. We know that Senator Bragg never misses an opportunity to talk down the housing policies that the government is implementing, while at the same time offering no policy solutions that he can land inside his party room to help people get into homeownership except for a persistent thought bubble to raid people's retirement savings. We know there is now significant pushback in his own party against those failed policies.
I know Senator Bragg doesn't like the facts when it comes to our housing policies. They are working, and they are supporting thousands of Australians to buy their own home and realise the dream of homeownership. I met yesterday with the YWCA, who were talking to me about a successful project they have underway, funded through the HAFF. They were talking to me about how to ensure the HAFF has an ongoing role in the delivery of social housing in this country, and I was able to draw to their attention that the coalition is going to abolish all that if they come to government. They're about to open a very successful housing project in a regional area of Australia which will support women leaving violence to actually have appropriate accommodation. These are the projects that Senator Bragg wants to cancel—the ones that will actually make a real difference for people who—
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Opposition Senator:
An opposition senator interjecting—
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
So you think what the HAFF is doing is okay—just not the HAFF itself? Right. Well, that's a new development.
In relation to the five per cent deposit scheme, the Albanese government has supported 290,000 people to buy a home with that scheme, saving them $2.7 billion in lenders mortgage insurance. Now, I cannot see why Senator Bragg rails against this program. When you look at the numbers, including in his state of New South Wales, 76,639 people have been supported through the five per cent deposit in your own state, Senator Bragg, with 91,188 in Victoria, 63,384 in Queensland, 10,878 in South Australia, almost 33,000 in WA, 4½ thousand in Tasmania, 2,161 in the Northern Territory and 7,444 in my home town here. So that is the success of the scheme. The banks have told us that 99 per cent of borrowers are ahead or on track with their repayments. The scheme is operating very well. It's very popular.
I know Senator Bragg hates it and wants to abolish it, but 290,000 people entering the housing market, supported by this scheme, shows just how important it is. Now we know that they are going to abolish. They're going to do what they did when they were last in government. They won't do anything on housing. They'll abolish the Housing Australia Future Fund, Help to Buy Scheme, build-to-rent—all on the chopping block if Senator Bragg ever gets the opportunity to serve in that role.
Our housing programs are performing very strongly. We have complied with the OPD; we have provided the information Senator Bragg wants. Just because he doesn't like the fact doesn't mean that we have failed to comply with the OPD.
Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness
9:06 am
I move:
That the Senate take note of the explanation.
In rising to take note of the minister's nonexplanation here, I make the point that, as part of being the worst government this country has had in 50 years, they've also become the worst government in terms of their commitment to transparency. It took them three months to provide a few pieces of paper from APRA that they already had. And the minister comes into this chamber today to say that she's done a great service to the nation by giving us these bits of paper after all those months. Now, the pieces of paper they provided—many are deeply blacked out and redacted, and make no sense—actually make the point that APRA has said that the expansion of the five per cent scheme has led to a material increase in high LVR lending amongst first home buyers. High LVR lending means there are more risky loans. And the problem with this for this government is they've peddled this scheme to all and sundry. They said there was no risk, and then they came along and launched the world's biggest taxation job on them, which has smashed the value of a lot of these houses. There are many Australians today living in negative equity, not because of their own actions but because these products were peddled to them by this Prime Minister. He didn't say that he was going to break his promise and then launch a taxation strike on their houses that they'd just bought. The definition of negative equity—in case the member for Kingsford Smith is listening to this Senate broadcast, given he used to be a member of this chamber—is the loan is worth more than your house. And that is a very, very bad situation to be in. So that is why we have been probing this scheme and have been probing these documents. Three months is not a good standard to provide basic information from APRA.
That is not about contact details, I should say. The minister says that contact details are blacked out. Most of the documents are blacked out in a substantive way, which is in keeping with the general approach to transparency of this government. As the Centre for Public Integrity has said, this is the worst government on transparency since the Keating government some 30-plus years ago.
If you look at this issue of the five per cent scheme—it has been a very wasteful scheme. Why is the government giving free insurance to people earning more than $600,000? The Australian people ask why the government is spending $27 billion this year on interest repayments. It's because the budget is buggered. This is one of the reasons. Waste, corruption—it stinks. Why do people who are earning more than half a million dollars need free welfare from the government? It is just an absolute disgrace. This scheme is out of control, and, what's more, they've also given it to many, many people who are not even citizens of this country. I can't think of any other country around the world that would give away, from their national government, free insurance to people who don't even commit to citizenship of the country. I think it's just extraordinary waste and largesse. We know the government have wasted $8 million of taxpayer funds advertising this scheme in a dozen different languages.
This scheme is completely out of control, and, as I say, the greatest crime of all here is that they pushed and peddled this scheme without any disclosure as to the risk and then came along and launched the taxation strike which has pushed so many people into negative equity. According to Cotality, more than 300 suburbs in Melbourne and Sydney are currently occupied by many, many people in negative equity. Seven months from the budget, you can look at the scoreboard on this budget, and it's very clear that, on the three key tests—supply, rents and loans—it fails.
We see 30,000 fewer houses a year already under this government. This budget will collapse housing supply by 75,000 over the next 10 years. Why on earth would the government have deliberate design features to collapse housing supply? Why does the government hate housing? Why does the government hate small businesses, and why does it hate investors more than it wants to house Australians? Why? These are the great questions. If Kamahl were here, he would say: 'Why are people so unkind? Why is this government so unkind to people who just want a house?' That's what he would say.
Then, in terms of rents, the budget papers say two bucks a week in rent increases, but a number of economists are predicting more than $150 a week in rent increases. In some cases, REA data say, rent could be going up 200 bucks a week in Sydney. The last time Labor fiddled around with negative gearing, in 1985, they had to restore it—in 1987—because rents soared in Perth and Sydney. We're about to see the same film here; the government is going to have to pedal back on these taxes because they have been a disaster. We have higher rents, we have lower levels of supply, and we have vastly fewer loans for the people—first home buyers—who are supposed to be helped by this scheme. They were eight per cent down in the last quarter—eight per cent fewer loans to first home buyers. There are fewer first home buyers because of these taxes, not more. This has been an absolute failure and a disgrace, and it should be repealed.
Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens
9:12 am
I think we are in a real crisis here, in the Senate, in relation to housing and the information we get and the way we get it. Housing is the major component of a cost-of-living crisis for millions of Australians out there. So many people are scratching together, out of their pay packet, to try and reach the rent that they face—$700 now, on average, is the rent that Australians are paying. So much evidence given to inquiries run out of this Senate tells us that they—young people, older women—are in deep financial distress through the rental crisis that we are in. Then there are those first home buyers who watch their hard-earned savings chasing upwards house prices, which we've seen increase by 400 per cent since 1999. It's a crisis for first home buyers, a crisis for renters and a crisis for thousands of Australians homeless in the parklands in my city and across our cities and regional towns. People are sleeping rough and homelessness services are in deep distress. And here we come, as senators, over and over again, to say to the Labor government, 'Please give us data,' and the data we get is slow, sluggish and out of date and doesn't deal, in many cases, with the detail that we need to evaluate the government's policies.
Today, we've heard how many people in which states have received assistance through the five per cent deposit scheme. Where is the information available to us in an accessible form, in a timely way, that tells us how schemes like this are working? To make sense of the HAFF is like pulling teeth. We heard last week that 2,199 homes of the 40,000 promised under the HAFF have so far been put into the system—2,000 out of 40,000 promised. It's way below, and we know that the 40,000 is well, well short of the number of new builds that are affordable for Australians. We've got over 200,000 on waitlists for public housing across our country and 640,000 Australians in deep, dire financial trouble—housing trouble—and at risk of homelessness. That's too many of them. They are in mortgage and rental stress.
We need a timely and efficient response to our requests for data, and we should be able to get it. It should be properly provided through a properly structured governance department. In this government, there is no department of housing. We do not have proper policy data and analysis capacity in the government. So we come in and spend a great deal of time here in the Senate trying to find out what's going on with this show so that the biggest crisis facing Australians can be properly responded to. The Senate that is responding to the biggest challenge for so many Australian households. It is not good enough that the information we get is too slow and that it is imperfect. But, most importantly, beyond that, the programs that are in place are episodic, inadequate and far from what is needed for a crisis in this country that is the biggest in my lifetime and is driving outcomes of enormous stress for so many Australians.
I used to think, when I was a labour economist analysing employment, the biggest and most important thing to get your life sorted was to have a decent job. It's not true. Jobs are really important. But what's really important is actually having somewhere to lay your head, having a home, somewhere where an employer can contact you, an address you can actually apply jobs to jobs from. There are now so many homeless Australians. There's been a 10 per cent growth in homelessness on Labor's watch. That's a shame. We are a wealthy country. We need to do better.
Part of doing better is responding to this Senate and giving us the data we need in a timely way from a properly structured, properly governed housing department that sees policy and data as an important cornerstone of decent policy and a proper response to the crisis that millions of Australians are dealing with every day.
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
9:16 am
I have to say, yet again, the minister has come in here and made every excuse in the world as to why the government will not comply with an order of the Senate. All we want to see, as Senator Bragg has articulated, is what the independent banking regulator has said about the risks of this scheme. Sadly, yet again, Labor say that they have provided the documents. They say that the minister has complied. Well, as Senator Bragg held up, documents have been provided to the Senate, but sadly the detail in those documents has been blacked out.
Australians deserve to know what is actually going on with the five per cent deposit scheme. Why? Because Labor's housing record is an absolute disgrace. We have broken promises. We have substantially missed targets. We have—worse than that—fewer homebuyers. For those poor homebuyers who actually did take advantage of the five per cent deposit scheme, prior to the election Mr Albanese promised them over 50 times that he would not change negative gearing and capital gains in Australia, and then he did. In other words, 50 times he misled the Australian people. As Senator Bragg has now articulated, those poor first home buyers are now in negative equity because of the policies of the Albanese government. What does that mean in plain English? It means they believed what Mr Albanese said. They bought a home after accessing the five per cent deposit scheme. Mr Albanese backflipped or, to quote him, changed his position on the 50 times that he told Australians that he would not change negative gearing and capital gains. The housing market crashed. They bought their house at this price. They owe the bank money. That amount is here. Their housing price has now dropped to here. In other words, this gap is a loss for these poor first home buyers, and that sits squarely at the feet of the Albanese government. All we want to know is what is going on with this scheme.
We also want to know, though, why the Albanese government expanded this scheme to noncitizens. I don't think a lot of Australians understand that Mr Albanese turned his back on Australians and expanded the scheme to noncitizens. This scheme, which was set up for Australians—in particular, young Australians—has now been accessed by more than 54,000 non-Australian citizens. More than 54,000 people who have not pledged allegiance to our country have accessed Labor's five per cent deposit scheme. That is approximately one in six people who are not Australians who have accessed the five per cent deposit scheme, and that is at the same time that young Australians are struggling to get a foot on the housing ladder. What part of 'housing crisis' does the Albanese government not understand—opening up a scheme meant for Australian citizens to non-Australians and then having over 54,000 non-Australian citizens access the scheme?
The minister also said to Senator Bragg, 'Well, where are your policy solutions?' Well, I'll tell you. We have policy solutions. They're set out in the coalition's plan to fix the economy and protect our way of life. The first thing we're going to do is slash migration down to 100,000 a year, because the population, under Labor, has grown by 1.9 million people. In other words, there has been mass migration to this country. Turn to pages 24 and 25 of our plan. Guess what it clearly sets out—how we will build more homes. The first thing we'll do? The five per cent scheme will be reserved for Australian citizens only. That's right. Non-Australian citizens, you're not getting it, because we're going to back Australians to get into homes. We're also going to axe Labor's toxic taxes. It is set out clearly in our plan. If you hate what Albanese's done to negative gearing, vote Liberal—vote coalition. We're going to reverse it. If you hate what Albanese's done to capital gains, vote Liberal—vote coalition. We are going to scrap those toxic taxes. (Time expired)
Ellie Whiteaker WA, Australian Labor Party
9:21 am
Let's not pretend that this is about transparency or documents. This is about the Liberal Party standing in the way of first home buyers buying a home of their own. Let's not forget how we ended up in this mess. When the coalition were in government, they were negligent bystanders when it came to housing. When we came to government, we had to fix the housing mess that the Liberal Party and the coalition government had left Australians in. They have continued to demonstrate, time and time again, that they're not interested in helping Australians get into a home of their own, because they have stood in the way of every effort that our government has taken to help Australians buy a home of their own.
I challenge Senator Cash and Senator Bragg to say to the nearly 300,000 Australians who have been able to buy a home of their own thanks to our five per cent deposit scheme since we came to government—I dare them to tell those first home buyers that they don't believe they should have been able to buy a home of their own. I'm pretty confident that those Australians feel pretty good about the fact that they're finally out of the rental market, that they're finally not having to give money to the Liberals' property investor mates and that, instead, they have a home of their own.
Dean Smith WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister to the Shadow Treasurer
They're forced into higher interest rates.
Ellie Whiteaker WA, Australian Labor Party
I'll take the interjection from Senator Smith. I think that the 31,828 Western Australians are pretty happy to finally be in a home of their own and not be giving money to the Liberal Party's property investor mates. The opposition have not done a single thing to help Australians get into a home of their own. Their track record on housing is abhorrent. They've promised to cut more than $4 billion from housing. Senator Cash says, 'Vote for the Liberal Party.' Okay. What would the Liberal Party being in government mean? It would mean $4 billion ripped out of housing. They'd scrap the HAFF, they'd scrap Help to Buy, they'd scrap Build to Rent. Fewer homes would be built. They'd tell almost 300,000 Australians that the scheme hasn't worked. Those are Australians that would otherwise be paying money to property investors instead of investing in a home of their own.
This is a scheme that has saved Australians more than $2.5 billion in lenders mortgage insurance. That's a saving of about $23,700 for first home buyers that they would have paid in lenders mortgage insurance, and that's if they'd even been able to afford to save up what they needed. These are generational changing reforms to help Australians buy a home of their own. I understand that the Liberal Party and their property investor mates probably don't understand. Most Australians are not buying a home to sell it and buy another one. Most Australians want to buy a home so that they have the safety and security of being able to live in a home that is their own, to be proud of the home that they live in, maybe to bang a nail into the wall so they can hang a picture on the wall. That's what Australians want, that is what Labor has promised and that is what Labor is delivering. We are committed to helping Australians buy a home of their own, and we do not apologise for it.
But I at least give the Liberal Party points for consistency. They weren't interested in helping Aussies buy their first home when they were in government. They're certainly not interested in helping Australians buy their first home now, and I don't expect that we'll see that change any time soon. But Labor will continue to back Australians who do want to buy their own home by helping them out to do it with our five per cent home deposit scheme.
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
9:26 am
The Labor Party has put a wrecking ball through the housing market in this country. We have never seen anything like it during my lifetime in terms of the catastrophic fall in home prices. We've never seen anything like it. Speaking to people in the property industry in my home state of Queensland, they're laying off people. People in construction are facing all sorts of impediments put in their way by this Labor Party, preventing them from building the homes that Australia needs.
Senator Whiteaker talks about the Labor government backing first home buyers. How are you backing first home buyers when we've got the official cash rate at 4.85 per cent? It's extraordinary. It's a direct result of the government's exorbitant spending—out-of-control government spending. We also have a situation where the government has moved the goalposts in relation to matters such as taxation policy and imposed undue regulation on the construction industry. Sixty thousand construction small businesses are being impacted by the government's changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts. Those 60,000 construction businesses should be focused on building the homes that Australia needs, but instead they're forced to deal with a regulatory restructuring nightmare imposed upon them because the Labor government broke its promise, which it made 50 times, that it wouldn't change the taxation of trusts. That promise was made 50 times before the last election and it was broken by the Prime Minister and broken by the Labor government.
What this resolution seeks is an explanation as to why the government did not provide in unredacted form the warnings that were given by APRA, our prudential regulator, with respect to this five per cent home deposit scheme. That's what this resolution was seeking. The Australian Senate, as the house of review, sought the advice that was given from APRA, our prudential regulator, with respect to lending. We sought the advice given from APRA to the government with respect to the impact of this five per cent home deposit scheme. That's what the Senate was seeking. A majority of the Senate, not just the Liberal Party, requested that information. But the Labor government has refused the order for the production of documents which was made by a majority of this Senate on behalf of the Australian people.
Why are those documents important? They are important because all the warnings were there from economists in terms of the impact of this five per cent deposit scheme—that it would have an impact on entry point prices and that there was a risk first home buyers would be pushed into negative equity. At a 4.85 per cent cash rate, interest rate, and with market prices falling, as Senator Cash said, those first home buyers are now entering into the territory of negative equity. All this Senate wanted to see was the advice from APRA received by the government before it introduced that scheme, and that's been denied by the Labor government.
The Centre for Public Integrity has issued a report card with respect to transparency and integrity of this Labor government and has found that the Labor government is not responding to orders for production of documents and to FOI requests in the manner expected of an open and transparent government. By not providing that information to the Australian people, they are frustrating the ability of the Senate to perform its role, to discharge its obligations as a house of review, and, through us, they are denying the Australian people the information they deserve to have. We expect better. If a majority of senators in this place request information that is of particular interest to the Australian people, the government should provide it. If you've got nothing to fear, why not provide the information?
The fact of the matter is, with the changes to the taxation system in relation to capital gains tax and negative gearing, the taxation of discretionary trusts and profligate government spending leading to an interest rate of 4.85 per cent—an outrageously high interest rate when you add the margin which is imposed by the banks—our first home buyers are doing it really, really tough.
Question agreed to.