This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Documents

Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; Order for the Production of Documents


Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

9:26 am

The Labor Party has put a wrecking ball through the housing market in this country. We have never seen anything like it during my lifetime in terms of the catastrophic fall in home prices. We've never seen anything like it. Speaking to people in the property industry in my home state of Queensland, they're laying off people. People in construction are facing all sorts of impediments put in their way by this Labor Party, preventing them from building the homes that Australia needs.

Senator Whiteaker talks about the Labor government backing first home buyers. How are you backing first home buyers when we've got the official cash rate at 4.85 per cent? It's extraordinary. It's a direct result of the government's exorbitant spending—out-of-control government spending. We also have a situation where the government has moved the goalposts in relation to matters such as taxation policy and imposed undue regulation on the construction industry. Sixty thousand construction small businesses are being impacted by the government's changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts. Those 60,000 construction businesses should be focused on building the homes that Australia needs, but instead they're forced to deal with a regulatory restructuring nightmare imposed upon them because the Labor government broke its promise, which it made 50 times, that it wouldn't change the taxation of trusts. That promise was made 50 times before the last election and it was broken by the Prime Minister and broken by the Labor government.

What this resolution seeks is an explanation as to why the government did not provide in unredacted form the warnings that were given by APRA, our prudential regulator, with respect to this five per cent home deposit scheme. That's what this resolution was seeking. The Australian Senate, as the house of review, sought the advice that was given from APRA, our prudential regulator, with respect to lending. We sought the advice given from APRA to the government with respect to the impact of this five per cent home deposit scheme. That's what the Senate was seeking. A majority of the Senate, not just the Liberal Party, requested that information. But the Labor government has refused the order for the production of documents which was made by a majority of this Senate on behalf of the Australian people.

Why are those documents important? They are important because all the warnings were there from economists in terms of the impact of this five per cent deposit scheme—that it would have an impact on entry point prices and that there was a risk first home buyers would be pushed into negative equity. At a 4.85 per cent cash rate, interest rate, and with market prices falling, as Senator Cash said, those first home buyers are now entering into the territory of negative equity. All this Senate wanted to see was the advice from APRA received by the government before it introduced that scheme, and that's been denied by the Labor government.

The Centre for Public Integrity has issued a report card with respect to transparency and integrity of this Labor government and has found that the Labor government is not responding to orders for production of documents and to FOI requests in the manner expected of an open and transparent government. By not providing that information to the Australian people, they are frustrating the ability of the Senate to perform its role, to discharge its obligations as a house of review, and, through us, they are denying the Australian people the information they deserve to have. We expect better. If a majority of senators in this place request information that is of particular interest to the Australian people, the government should provide it. If you've got nothing to fear, why not provide the information?

The fact of the matter is, with the changes to the taxation system in relation to capital gains tax and negative gearing, the taxation of discretionary trusts and profligate government spending leading to an interest rate of 4.85 per cent—an outrageously high interest rate when you add the margin which is imposed by the banks—our first home buyers are doing it really, really tough.

Question agreed to.

Comments

No comments