This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Documents
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; Order for the Production of Documents
Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness
9:06 am
I move:
That the Senate take note of the explanation.
In rising to take note of the minister's nonexplanation here, I make the point that, as part of being the worst government this country has had in 50 years, they've also become the worst government in terms of their commitment to transparency. It took them three months to provide a few pieces of paper from APRA that they already had. And the minister comes into this chamber today to say that she's done a great service to the nation by giving us these bits of paper after all those months. Now, the pieces of paper they provided—many are deeply blacked out and redacted, and make no sense—actually make the point that APRA has said that the expansion of the five per cent scheme has led to a material increase in high LVR lending amongst first home buyers. High LVR lending means there are more risky loans. And the problem with this for this government is they've peddled this scheme to all and sundry. They said there was no risk, and then they came along and launched the world's biggest taxation job on them, which has smashed the value of a lot of these houses. There are many Australians today living in negative equity, not because of their own actions but because these products were peddled to them by this Prime Minister. He didn't say that he was going to break his promise and then launch a taxation strike on their houses that they'd just bought. The definition of negative equity—in case the member for Kingsford Smith is listening to this Senate broadcast, given he used to be a member of this chamber—is the loan is worth more than your house. And that is a very, very bad situation to be in. So that is why we have been probing this scheme and have been probing these documents. Three months is not a good standard to provide basic information from APRA.
That is not about contact details, I should say. The minister says that contact details are blacked out. Most of the documents are blacked out in a substantive way, which is in keeping with the general approach to transparency of this government. As the Centre for Public Integrity has said, this is the worst government on transparency since the Keating government some 30-plus years ago.
If you look at this issue of the five per cent scheme—it has been a very wasteful scheme. Why is the government giving free insurance to people earning more than $600,000? The Australian people ask why the government is spending $27 billion this year on interest repayments. It's because the budget is buggered. This is one of the reasons. Waste, corruption—it stinks. Why do people who are earning more than half a million dollars need free welfare from the government? It is just an absolute disgrace. This scheme is out of control, and, what's more, they've also given it to many, many people who are not even citizens of this country. I can't think of any other country around the world that would give away, from their national government, free insurance to people who don't even commit to citizenship of the country. I think it's just extraordinary waste and largesse. We know the government have wasted $8 million of taxpayer funds advertising this scheme in a dozen different languages.
This scheme is completely out of control, and, as I say, the greatest crime of all here is that they pushed and peddled this scheme without any disclosure as to the risk and then came along and launched the taxation strike which has pushed so many people into negative equity. According to Cotality, more than 300 suburbs in Melbourne and Sydney are currently occupied by many, many people in negative equity. Seven months from the budget, you can look at the scoreboard on this budget, and it's very clear that, on the three key tests—supply, rents and loans—it fails.
We see 30,000 fewer houses a year already under this government. This budget will collapse housing supply by 75,000 over the next 10 years. Why on earth would the government have deliberate design features to collapse housing supply? Why does the government hate housing? Why does the government hate small businesses, and why does it hate investors more than it wants to house Australians? Why? These are the great questions. If Kamahl were here, he would say: 'Why are people so unkind? Why is this government so unkind to people who just want a house?' That's what he would say.
Then, in terms of rents, the budget papers say two bucks a week in rent increases, but a number of economists are predicting more than $150 a week in rent increases. In some cases, REA data say, rent could be going up 200 bucks a week in Sydney. The last time Labor fiddled around with negative gearing, in 1985, they had to restore it—in 1987—because rents soared in Perth and Sydney. We're about to see the same film here; the government is going to have to pedal back on these taxes because they have been a disaster. We have higher rents, we have lower levels of supply, and we have vastly fewer loans for the people—first home buyers—who are supposed to be helped by this scheme. They were eight per cent down in the last quarter—eight per cent fewer loans to first home buyers. There are fewer first home buyers because of these taxes, not more. This has been an absolute failure and a disgrace, and it should be repealed.
No comments