This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

6:05 pm

The committee is considering the government amendments on sheets IE114 and IE116.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:06 pm

We have been delivered very late amendments on this legislation that include provisions proposed by the government—perhaps with the agreement of the coalition—to allow for members to become senior members without a full external recruitment process. Could I first ask the government, given they don't have any background in the explanatory memorandum or in the history of this, where these amendments came from?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

I answered questions of your colleague in regard to this in this debate previously. These amendments, as I set out, are something the government is putting forward to streamline tribunal appointment processes. As you know, the government's been working incredibly hard to appoint members. This is one of the ways that the government has identified it can make that process smoother. It will allow the Attorney-General to respond more quickly to the changing operational needs of the tribunal while still maintaining merit based appointment processes at appropriate times.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:07 pm

One of the key reasons the government gave for putting in the ART and replacing the AAT was to ensure that there was full merits review before there was any appointment. If you want to have external merits review, that should apply across the board. As I understand it, the proposal here is to allow for a quick and dirty rise in seniority from 'member' to 'senior member' after the member has been there for at least two years—to avoid the external merits review, to avoid all that which the government said was essential to put integrity into the ART, and instead have this quick and dirty process whereby you can bump someone up from being a member to being a senior member without going through the external integrity processes. Minister, why has the government so rapidly moved from the position that positions, particularly important positions like 'senior member', require external vetting and integrity? Why have you moved so quickly from that? Is it because you've done a deal with the coalition?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

6:09 pm

There's nothing quick about requiring someone to be a member for two years before this is able to be considered. Just to reiterate, because your characterisation is that this has not been made clear, those members would have already undergone a full merits review process before being appointed in the first place. This change essentially means that they won't go through two of those processes when they have already met those criteria. Of course, the Attorney-General must seek and consider advice from the tribunal on a number of matters, including the member's performance against things like the performance standards and code of conduct. All of those issues will be considered at the time of the appointment. But the member would have already undergone the full merits independent assessment panel consideration.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:10 pm

I can recall the government, Labor, getting up and attacking the coalition for, I think, more than 80 political appointments to the AAT and saying that there needs to be something other than just a politician—in this case, the Attorney-General—making appointments to the tribunal. I think that they were well-made arguments—you shouldn't just have a politician bumping people up in seniority or appointing people to the tribunal, and, if you're going to have integrity in the ART, there needs to be an external vetting process which needs to have integrity and not just include the Attorney-General of the day. Of course, the coalition fought tooth-and-nail against that because the coalition wanted to have the political power in the Attorney-General just to appoint whoever the Attorney-General wanted. I understand their political point.

But, now, Labor is obviously drinking at the same well. When it comes to some of the most senior positions in the ART, putting people in as senior members, Labor's now junking the external review, junking that merits review, and saying that the Attorney can get some advice from the president, that they are not bound by it. You don't have to follow the president's advice; you can just get some advice from the president about the person's performance against performance standards, whether they've complied with the code of conduct or not—they don't have to have complied; you just get advice about it—and the person's leadership and management skills and whether or not they might be appropriate. You get the president's advice about it. The president might say, 'Actually, they haven't met the performance standard, they've breached the code of conduct, and I don't think they're right.' But, under this legislation, the Attorney can just bump them up anyhow—no merits review, no external restraint; exactly what you were complaining that the coalition were doing, with their political appointments and giving all the power to the Attorney. You're replicating it here because you've got to deal with the coalition on this. It's a quid pro quo with the coalition on this. There is no doubt the coalition will come in and vote and back you in on this, because it's what they want. They want to have this power in the Attorney unfettered by any external reference or integrity process. This is what the coalition have wanted all along, and you're giving it to them.

Of course, it gets even worse, doesn't it? If you think about it, if you've got a member in the ART who is independently holding the government to account and making hard calls against the government time after time after time, you could see how that might agitate the government's Attorney-General. You could see how the Attorney-General may not like that. What you're doing here is saying to any member: 'If you want to become a senior member—no external review for you. You better toe the line and do what the government wants. Don't annoy the government. Don't piss the Attorney-General off, because it's solely the Attorney-General who's going to be making a decision about whether you become a senior member or not.' You are eroding the independence of the ART, and you are just becoming what the coalition were before. The whole rationale for independence and independent review is being undermined because you've got this grubby deal with the coalition now.

It is no wonder you're trying to sneak it in at the last minute—no wonder you didn't put this in the original bill—because you know what the law council would have said about it. You know what the law societies and the bar associations and anyone watching would have said about it. They would have said you're undermining the independence of the ART. And so what do you do? You sneak it in. You wrap it up with a little amendment to the explanatory memorandum, and you sneak it in at midnight just before we're here to debate it, because you know you can't defend it. You can't defend your grubby deal with the coalition on this, to undermine the ART. It is extraordinary how quickly you have changed from being a government that said you wanted an independent tribunal, from saying how important external merit review was, from saying how important it was that just the Attorney doesn't have the call and can't just make political appointments. How quickly you've turned. You're now playing to the coalition's fiddle on this. Is this part of a deal with the coalition? Are these two amendments that have come in at the last minute a deal you've done with the coalition? You're both going to vote them up. Is that what's happened here, Minister?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

6:15 pm

Senator Shoebridge is misleading the chamber. He is—

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

Senator Shoebridge, on a point of order?

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

I ask the minister to withdraw that.

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

On what basis?

The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The minister has the call.

Senator Shoebridge, the chair is fully aware of the context of these provisions and the fact that a member who is then appointed as a senior member under these amendments would already have gone through a merits selection process in the normal way. Currently, general members who wish to be promoted to a senior member have to participate in a fully fresh merit-based assessment process even if they have already undergone that same merits based assessment process. The characterisations that Senator Shoebridge has just given fly in the face of the facts of the legislation and the amendment. Clearly, he is seeking to make political points to delay this legislation. I refer to my previous answers on the intent of the provision, and I make two points. Firstly, it is certainly not the government's intention to water down the integrity of the ART. That's exactly why we implemented it in the first place. This provision does not do that, no matter how many speeches Senator Shoebridge gives tonight about this. That will not be the case. The second point I'd make is, in reaching these conclusions, which are not based on fact, Senator Shoebridge has done exactly what he has protested against earlier in this debate. The tone is completely inappropriate, and we would draw the senator to the previous answers that I gave to his colleague earlier this evening.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:18 pm

Let's be clear to anyone who's trying to follow along outside of this chamber about what the gift is that the government's proposing for their good little compliant members in the tribunal who don't rock the boat, who don't upset the government and who don't get the Attorney-General offside. If you're appointed as a general member of the ART, your salary is $251,000. Then you do two years under the new regime of the current Labor's attorney-general—you do two good years not rocking the boat, being a good little general member, don't upset the government and sign off on whatever Home Affairs has put in front of you on migration; whatever you do, don't make the government unhappy—and, after two good years as a general member, if you've got the nod of the Attorney-General and you haven't upset the government, then that attorney-general might be able to bounce you up to being a senior member on a $408,000 salary. There's a lot of self-interest there, isn't there? Don't rock the boat, agree with what the government does, and the Attorney might in his or her munificence, bounce your salary up from $250,000 to $408,000. And good news: under the new arrangements being put in by Labor, that won't have to go out to any inefficient independent panel. That's a political gift the Attorney can give to a member of the tribunal if they're good, they don't rock the boat, they support the government and they don't create too much fuss.

This is what the coalition have always wanted—these powers in the Attorney-General. The coalition wanted unfettered political power to appoint whoever they wanted without going to external review, and they did, and they stacked the AAT with political appointments. Now Labor's doing it through the back door here, allowing the Attorney to bump up someone's salary from $250,000 to $408,000 in what's meant to be an independent tribunal, without having to go to any external review process. That's the reality of this—undermining the integrity of the ART, the thing you said it was worthwhile to spend hundreds of millions of dollars reforming. Hundreds of millions of dollars were spent getting rid of the old AAT, getting the new ART in, doing all the organisational change and changing all the premises, apparently to create integrity, and then, the first chance you get, you cut a deal with the coalition to undermine it.

Is it any wonder you're trying to sneak it in at midnight like this, and is it any wonder you didn't want the law societies or the Law Council to have a look at this? It's a grubby political deal, and I'll tell you who will end up paying the cost: Australians across the board will end up paying the cost, not only through having to pay the salaries of whoever, politically, the Attorney wants to bump up the salary for but also through the undermining of the integrity of the ART. People will see these appointments for what they are: political appointments. This is what the coalition's wanted. They'll be grinning like a Cheshire cat. You're delivering their AAT through the back door for them. No wonder you're backing each other in with this.

Did the government seek the advice of the Law Council before putting these amendments through?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

6:21 pm

I'll just point out that nothing that Senator Shoebridge said prior to the question that he asked is supported by any of the facts in front of the chamber. I've made that point before—not to go over that again. None of it is—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

You said the salaries aren't correct?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

Senator Shoebridge, you live in a post-truth world where you are able to make up anything you like about any of the institutions in our democracy in an effort to tear them down, and that is your prerogative. That's the world that the Greens political party now lives in. There are words for it. I won't use them in this chamber, but it doesn't really matter to you what the truth is. It's really just about the political points, and you get so convinced of your own reality that you make it true. You can't actually admit that you are drawing conclusions from facts that don't exist.

That being said, amendments like this, as they would be, are informed by operational experience. We've been going through a process of appointing members over the last two years. We have improved that system. We have only today appointed new senior members, and we will continue to do that to make sure that the ART is effective and operational and that it has the members at the FTE level that it requires. This is one of the things that will assist that in occurring.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:23 pm

I listened carefully to the minister's word salad there. The question was simple: did you seek the advice of the Law Council, the peak body representing the profession? Did you consult with them in any way before putting this amendment through?

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

I've answered the question. If the senator is going to use every single contribution to make personal insults towards me, that's fine, but I'm not going to keep reiterating all of the—

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Hansard will speak to the truth.

Nita Green

Nita Green Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Assistant Minister for Tourism

Well, interjections are pretty disorderly, but they come from that side of the chamber a lot down there, particularly when I'm speaking. I am not going to continue to reiterate the previous evidence that I've given. It's clear that Senator Shoebridge is in here tonight to make sure that we don't vote on this legislation, and that is his decision. But what we would like to do is ensure that the ART does have these streamlined processes to ensure that the administrative review system operates and provides the opportunity for people to get the judicial review that they are owed.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:24 pm

The Hansard will speak to the truth or otherwise of those pretty outrageous assertions by the minister. Of course, whether the government want to answer a simple question with a simple answer is up to the government. I'm going to take from the minister's various iterations of an answer to the question that I put about the government consulting the Law Council, which you'd think would be a fairly straightforward answer for a minister to give in relation to a bill on the administrative and judicial review legislation, that the answer is, no, they didn't consult with the Law Council. And we know why. It is because no lawyer who had integrity, no organisation that had integrity and no organisation that wanted an independent ART would ever agree to this, for the reasons we've made clear.

I pointed out the salary increase. That comes from the schedule published by the Remuneration Tribunal. When we point out the figures on the schedule coming from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get the allegation from Labor that that's some kind of post-truth world. We read out the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal that show how they're going to be bumping up the salary, and we got this kind of Trumpian response from Labor. When we're talking evidence and we're putting the actual figures from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get a Trumpian response from Labor: 'There's nothing here you should believe.' This is the post-truth world that Labor lives in. They think that they can just fool the public with their messaging.

They had a second reading contribution on this that said that this legislation was all about improving people's rights and increasing integrity. Nothing could be further from the truth. When they get speaker after speaker doing what the minister is doing now or they get their drones coming forward with whatever speaking notes have been given to them by the Attorney-General and pretending that a bill that is taking away people's rights to written decisions, procedural fairness and an actual hearing is actually about improving people's rights or they stand up here and say black is white like this, is it any wonder people are losing faith in the Labor government and in government more generally? When we come and point out that the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal mean that the Attorney-General is going to be able to bump up someone's salary from 250 kay to 408 kay without going to an independent review process, which would undermine the integrity of the ART, we get this Trumpian kind of response from Labor that says that nothing we say is based in evidence. It's based on the schedule in the Remuneration Tribunal.

This kind of vacuous political messaging that's coming from the government—that war is peace, that taking away rights is improving rights, that referencing actual schedules is somehow not relying on evidence—is why people are losing faith. Every time Labor comes and does this, people know the truth. They can feel it. Their rights are being eroded. This government keeps doing this. They say, 'Watch my hand,' about one hand, and then they're taking away rights and taking away things from people with the other hand. That's why people are just so put off by the very project of government and by what this government is doing, exactly as we heard from the minister then.

This is an amendment the Greens will be opposing, and we'll be opposing it because it's bad. It's bad for the independence of the tribunal. It's bad for government. It's bad for people's rights when they come before the ART. It's bad for those members of the ART who will have to be looking over their shoulder with one eye to see what the government's going to say about their performance and see whether or not they might get a promotion from member to senior member. It's bad on all grounds. This Trumpian, post-truth stuff that's coming from you, Labor, does you absolutely no credit. You can't deal with the substance of the arguments. That's why you do it.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

The question is that amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 and amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 be agreed to.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Can the question on the amendments on sheet IE114 be put separately to that on the amendments on sheet IE116, please?

Nick McKim

Nick McKim Tasmania, Australian Greens

To support Senator Shoebridge's request and to ensure that you and the chamber understand, we will be voting differently on those two amendments.

The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The question is that amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 be agreed to.

Question agreed to.

The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The question is that amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 be agreed to. A division is required. It being past 6.30, the bill cannot proceed until votes can be taken. I shall report progress to the Senate.

Progress reported.

Further consideration of the bill in Committee of the Whole made an order of the day for the next day of sitting.