This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:10 pm

I can recall the government, Labor, getting up and attacking the coalition for, I think, more than 80 political appointments to the AAT and saying that there needs to be something other than just a politician—in this case, the Attorney-General—making appointments to the tribunal. I think that they were well-made arguments—you shouldn't just have a politician bumping people up in seniority or appointing people to the tribunal, and, if you're going to have integrity in the ART, there needs to be an external vetting process which needs to have integrity and not just include the Attorney-General of the day. Of course, the coalition fought tooth-and-nail against that because the coalition wanted to have the political power in the Attorney-General just to appoint whoever the Attorney-General wanted. I understand their political point.

But, now, Labor is obviously drinking at the same well. When it comes to some of the most senior positions in the ART, putting people in as senior members, Labor's now junking the external review, junking that merits review, and saying that the Attorney can get some advice from the president, that they are not bound by it. You don't have to follow the president's advice; you can just get some advice from the president about the person's performance against performance standards, whether they've complied with the code of conduct or not—they don't have to have complied; you just get advice about it—and the person's leadership and management skills and whether or not they might be appropriate. You get the president's advice about it. The president might say, 'Actually, they haven't met the performance standard, they've breached the code of conduct, and I don't think they're right.' But, under this legislation, the Attorney can just bump them up anyhow—no merits review, no external restraint; exactly what you were complaining that the coalition were doing, with their political appointments and giving all the power to the Attorney. You're replicating it here because you've got to deal with the coalition on this. It's a quid pro quo with the coalition on this. There is no doubt the coalition will come in and vote and back you in on this, because it's what they want. They want to have this power in the Attorney unfettered by any external reference or integrity process. This is what the coalition have wanted all along, and you're giving it to them.

Of course, it gets even worse, doesn't it? If you think about it, if you've got a member in the ART who is independently holding the government to account and making hard calls against the government time after time after time, you could see how that might agitate the government's Attorney-General. You could see how the Attorney-General may not like that. What you're doing here is saying to any member: 'If you want to become a senior member—no external review for you. You better toe the line and do what the government wants. Don't annoy the government. Don't piss the Attorney-General off, because it's solely the Attorney-General who's going to be making a decision about whether you become a senior member or not.' You are eroding the independence of the ART, and you are just becoming what the coalition were before. The whole rationale for independence and independent review is being undermined because you've got this grubby deal with the coalition now.

It is no wonder you're trying to sneak it in at the last minute—no wonder you didn't put this in the original bill—because you know what the law council would have said about it. You know what the law societies and the bar associations and anyone watching would have said about it. They would have said you're undermining the independence of the ART. And so what do you do? You sneak it in. You wrap it up with a little amendment to the explanatory memorandum, and you sneak it in at midnight just before we're here to debate it, because you know you can't defend it. You can't defend your grubby deal with the coalition on this, to undermine the ART. It is extraordinary how quickly you have changed from being a government that said you wanted an independent tribunal, from saying how important external merit review was, from saying how important it was that just the Attorney doesn't have the call and can't just make political appointments. How quickly you've turned. You're now playing to the coalition's fiddle on this. Is this part of a deal with the coalition? Are these two amendments that have come in at the last minute a deal you've done with the coalition? You're both going to vote them up. Is that what's happened here, Minister?

Comments

No comments