This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Senate debates Bills
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
6:24 pm
The Hansard will speak to the truth or otherwise of those pretty outrageous assertions by the minister. Of course, whether the government want to answer a simple question with a simple answer is up to the government. I'm going to take from the minister's various iterations of an answer to the question that I put about the government consulting the Law Council, which you'd think would be a fairly straightforward answer for a minister to give in relation to a bill on the administrative and judicial review legislation, that the answer is, no, they didn't consult with the Law Council. And we know why. It is because no lawyer who had integrity, no organisation that had integrity and no organisation that wanted an independent ART would ever agree to this, for the reasons we've made clear.
I pointed out the salary increase. That comes from the schedule published by the Remuneration Tribunal. When we point out the figures on the schedule coming from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get the allegation from Labor that that's some kind of post-truth world. We read out the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal that show how they're going to be bumping up the salary, and we got this kind of Trumpian response from Labor. When we're talking evidence and we're putting the actual figures from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get a Trumpian response from Labor: 'There's nothing here you should believe.' This is the post-truth world that Labor lives in. They think that they can just fool the public with their messaging.
They had a second reading contribution on this that said that this legislation was all about improving people's rights and increasing integrity. Nothing could be further from the truth. When they get speaker after speaker doing what the minister is doing now or they get their drones coming forward with whatever speaking notes have been given to them by the Attorney-General and pretending that a bill that is taking away people's rights to written decisions, procedural fairness and an actual hearing is actually about improving people's rights or they stand up here and say black is white like this, is it any wonder people are losing faith in the Labor government and in government more generally? When we come and point out that the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal mean that the Attorney-General is going to be able to bump up someone's salary from 250 kay to 408 kay without going to an independent review process, which would undermine the integrity of the ART, we get this Trumpian kind of response from Labor that says that nothing we say is based in evidence. It's based on the schedule in the Remuneration Tribunal.
This kind of vacuous political messaging that's coming from the government—that war is peace, that taking away rights is improving rights, that referencing actual schedules is somehow not relying on evidence—is why people are losing faith. Every time Labor comes and does this, people know the truth. They can feel it. Their rights are being eroded. This government keeps doing this. They say, 'Watch my hand,' about one hand, and then they're taking away rights and taking away things from people with the other hand. That's why people are just so put off by the very project of government and by what this government is doing, exactly as we heard from the minister then.
This is an amendment the Greens will be opposing, and we'll be opposing it because it's bad. It's bad for the independence of the tribunal. It's bad for government. It's bad for people's rights when they come before the ART. It's bad for those members of the ART who will have to be looking over their shoulder with one eye to see what the government's going to say about their performance and see whether or not they might get a promotion from member to senior member. It's bad on all grounds. This Trumpian, post-truth stuff that's coming from you, Labor, does you absolutely no credit. You can't deal with the substance of the arguments. That's why you do it.
No comments