This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Bills

Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee


David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

6:18 pm

Let's be clear to anyone who's trying to follow along outside of this chamber about what the gift is that the government's proposing for their good little compliant members in the tribunal who don't rock the boat, who don't upset the government and who don't get the Attorney-General offside. If you're appointed as a general member of the ART, your salary is $251,000. Then you do two years under the new regime of the current Labor's attorney-general—you do two good years not rocking the boat, being a good little general member, don't upset the government and sign off on whatever Home Affairs has put in front of you on migration; whatever you do, don't make the government unhappy—and, after two good years as a general member, if you've got the nod of the Attorney-General and you haven't upset the government, then that attorney-general might be able to bounce you up to being a senior member on a $408,000 salary. There's a lot of self-interest there, isn't there? Don't rock the boat, agree with what the government does, and the Attorney might in his or her munificence, bounce your salary up from $250,000 to $408,000. And good news: under the new arrangements being put in by Labor, that won't have to go out to any inefficient independent panel. That's a political gift the Attorney can give to a member of the tribunal if they're good, they don't rock the boat, they support the government and they don't create too much fuss.

This is what the coalition have always wanted—these powers in the Attorney-General. The coalition wanted unfettered political power to appoint whoever they wanted without going to external review, and they did, and they stacked the AAT with political appointments. Now Labor's doing it through the back door here, allowing the Attorney to bump up someone's salary from $250,000 to $408,000 in what's meant to be an independent tribunal, without having to go to any external review process. That's the reality of this—undermining the integrity of the ART, the thing you said it was worthwhile to spend hundreds of millions of dollars reforming. Hundreds of millions of dollars were spent getting rid of the old AAT, getting the new ART in, doing all the organisational change and changing all the premises, apparently to create integrity, and then, the first chance you get, you cut a deal with the coalition to undermine it.

Is it any wonder you're trying to sneak it in at midnight like this, and is it any wonder you didn't want the law societies or the Law Council to have a look at this? It's a grubby political deal, and I'll tell you who will end up paying the cost: Australians across the board will end up paying the cost, not only through having to pay the salaries of whoever, politically, the Attorney wants to bump up the salary for but also through the undermining of the integrity of the ART. People will see these appointments for what they are: political appointments. This is what the coalition's wanted. They'll be grinning like a Cheshire cat. You're delivering their AAT through the back door for them. No wonder you're backing each other in with this.

Did the government seek the advice of the Law Council before putting these amendments through?

Comments

No comments