This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Committees

Selection of Bills Committee; Report


Karen Grogan

Karen Grogan SA, Australian Labor Party

11:18 am

At the request of the Chair of the Selection of Bills Committee, I present the 14th report of 2026 of the Selection of Bills Committee. I seek leave to have the report incorporated in Hansard.

Leave granted.

The report read as follows—

Selection of Bills Committee

REPORT NO. 14 OF 2026

19 November 2026

MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE

Senator Tony Sheldon (Government Whip, Chair)

Senator Maria Kovacic (Opposition Whip)

Senator Sean Bell (One Nation Whip)

Senator Nick McKim (Australian Greens Whip)

Senator Ralph Babet

Senator Ross Cadell (The Nationals Whip)

Senator the Hon. Anthony Chisholm

Senator Chris Gatenby

Senator the Hon. Katy Gallagher

Senator Jacqui Lambie

Senator Kerrynne Liddle

Senator Fatima Payman

Senator David Pocock

Senator Lidia Thorpe

Secretary: Tim Bryant

02 6277 3020

SELECTION OF BILLS COMMITTEE REPORT NO. 14 OF 2026

1. The committee met in private session on Wednesday, 18 November 2026 at 7.09 pm.

2. The committee recommends that—

(a) the provisions of the Competition and Consumer Amendment (AER Inquiry Powers) Bill 2026 be referred immediately to the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 26 February 2027 (see appendix 1 for statement of reasons for referral), and

(b) the provisions of the Health Legislation Amendment (Improved Medicare Integrity and Other Measures) Bill 2026 be referred immediately to the Community Affairs Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 26 February 2027 (see appendix 2 for statement of reasons for referral).

3. The committee deferred consideration of the following bills to its next meeting:

                                                                                                                    4. The committee considered the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 but could not reach agreement.

                                                                                                                    (Tony Sheldon)

                                                                                                                    Chair

                                                                                                                    19 November 2026

                                                                                                                    Appendix 1

                                                                                                                    SELECTION OF BILLS COMMITTEE

                                                                                                                    Proposal to refer a bill to a committee

                                                                                                                    Name of bill: Competition and Consumer Amendment (AER Inquiry Powers) Bill 2026

                                                                                                                    Reasons for referral/principal issues for consideration: Scrutiny of legislation

                                                                                                                    Possible submissions or evidence from: Relevant stakeholders

                                                                                                                    Committee to which bill is to be referred: Environment & Communications

                                                                                                                    Possible hearing date(s): November-February

                                                                                                                    Possible reporting date: 26 February 20

                                                                                                                    (signed)

                                                                                                                    Maria Kovacic

                                                                                                                    Appendix 2

                                                                                                                    SELECTION OF BILLS COMMITTEE

                                                                                                                    Proposal to refer a bill to a committee

                                                                                                                    Name of bill: Health Legislation Amendment (Improved Medicare Integrity and Other Measures) Bill 2026

                                                                                                                    Reasons for referral/principal issues for consideration: Consideration of key measures and consultation with stakeholders

                                                                                                                    Possible submissions or evidence from: Government departments, health professionals and representative organisations, consumer organisations, regulators

                                                                                                                    Committee to which bill is to be referred: Community Affairs Legislation Committee

                                                                                                                    Possible hearing date(s): 1-2 hearings in late Jan, early Feb

                                                                                                                    Possible reporting date: Feb 26 2027

                                                                                                                    (signed)

                                                                                                                    Nick McKim

                                                                                                                    I move:

                                                                                                                    That the report be adopted.

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

11:19 am

I move:

At the end of the motion, add "and the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 not be referred to a committee".

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

At the request of Senator McKim, I move:

At the end of the motion, add:

"and, in respect of the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026, the bill be referred immediately to the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 1 March 2027".

The reason we're moving this amendment is that the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 got sent through this stitch-up of the so-called Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence, chaired by Labor and populated only by Labor and the Liberal Party. Get this: the committee went out for submissions—that stitch-up committee that you expressly said you would not permit even a member of the Nats on, let alone a member of the crossbench—

Dave Sharma

Dave Sharma NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

There's a Nat on it!

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Okay, so there's a rogue Nat on it. I accept that interjection. That won't last long.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

Something slipped through the system!

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

Yes, something slipped through the system. How did that happen—this stitch-up between the coalition and Defence? Consciously, when you set up this committee, you said you didn't want anyone on that committee who is critical of AUKUS. You don't want any dissenting voice on the obscene misdirection of defence funds. You don't want anyone testing the narrative that you've established that our only way of dealing with defence is to double down with Donald Trump, double down with AUKUS, give the military whatever they want, appoint another one-star, two-star or three-star general, give the brass what they want, ignore what the troops on the ground are saying and ignore the way the world is moving. You don't want anyone to point that out.

What did you do with this? When this bill went to the joint defence committee, there were submissions from civil society. There was a submission from the Hunter trades hall, from the union movement. What did Labor do with the submission from the Hunter trades hall, from the union movement? You ignored it. You wouldn't even let them come in and speak to the committee. There were submissions from civil society and from legal groups. There were submissions from human rights groups, and they said this bill was dangerous. You're giving extreme wartime powers to the minister during times when there's no conflict. They said you are putting in place these extreme penalties of up to seven years in jail without any due process. You're potentially giving foreign military officers police powers over Australia. You're proposing to give police powers, potentially, to employees of Lockheed Martin or of other US or UK defence primes, and they said, 'This is not right.' Civil society group after civil society group said this. Unions said this.

What did the defence committee do? They didn't call a single one of them. The only non-government witnesses that were called came from two defence corporations, DroneShield and Leidos. The only witnesses you heard from in this committee were from the defence industry, and the defence industry said: 'Yes, absolutely, jail Australians. Jail protesters. Give the minister these extreme powers. Potentially, give us, the defence industry'—those corporate aphids that are sucking on the defence budget—'police powers to stop, arrest and search people.' They said yes and cheered it in.

When you established this so-called joint defence committee, we said that it would be a stitch-up for the ADF, for the defence department and for your mates in the defence industry—the kinds of industries where former defence ministers, whether it's Beazley or Pyne, are ministers of defence one minute and directors of Lockheed Martin the next. One minute they're the minister of defence, and the next you've got Christopher Pyne going out and selling weapons for the UAE or Saudi Arabia or going off and flogging weapons for some French government owned weapons manufacturer. We said that's who you're going to be delivering for, and that's who you did deliver for. We can see that you want to guillotine this bill. You even want to prevent the Senate having a debate about it. We say no to the guillotine, and we say, 'Send it off to the standard place where bills of this nature are actually meant to be considered—the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Legislation Committee.' If you can't face the scrutiny, pull the bloody bill.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

I'm aware there are a number of amendments already moved. I'm going to deal with these ones, then I will go to Senator O'Sullivan and then you, Senator David Pocock. The question is that the amendment standing in the name of Senator McKim and moved by Senator Shoebridge be agreed to.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

11:30 am

Senators, unless there's debate on particular amendments, I intend to have one-minute bells. The question is that the amendment moved by Minister Gallagher be agreed to.

Question agreed to.

Matt O'Sullivan

Matt O'Sullivan WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Choice in Childcare and Early Learning

11:31 am

I move:

At the end of the motion, add: "and, in respect of:

(a) the Private Health Insurance Amendment (Modernising the Private Health Insurance Rebate) Bill 2026 [No. 2], the provisions of the bill be referred immediately to the Community Affairs Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 16 December 2026; and

(b) the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026, the bill be referred immediately to the Economics Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 26 February 2027."

Anne Ruston

Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care

I'd like to speak to the amendment that's been moved by Senator O'Sullivan, please. I just want to be really clear that the coalition wants this bill referred to a committee, not deferred and not parked until it suits the government. This is a bill whose substance was announced in a National Press Club speech. There was never any press release. It was never taken to the election. It was a policy that was written on the back of an envelope, and the government still will not show us that envelope.

The government told us that 44,000 people would drop their cover. Its own modelling, revealed under freedom of information, shows that that number is closer to 80,000. Just yesterday, we learned independently that more than 330,000 Australians will drop or downgrade their cover altogether. Parliamentary Budget Office analysis shows that $1.6 billion of this save comes directly from aged pensioners. Every one of those numbers had to be dragged out of the government. Just last week, the minister wouldn't even say whether he would exempt pensioners or whether he is looking for other savings.

When the Senate discharged this bill, the minister called it an absolute travesty. The real travesty is that the government is trying to make savings out of older Australians, forcing them out of private health insurance and into long hospital queues. We know that, for every dollar Mr Butler says he's saving, it'll cost the health system $1.20. Mr Butler said he was open to debate in the parliament and ready to engage constructively. Today we offer scrutiny, and you are intending to say no.

On 14 October, this Senate voted 38 to 23 to discharge the bill. Twenty-four hours later, the minister puts it back in the other place. As I said, 3.2 million older Australians will pay more, and, of them, 1.2 million at least will be aged pensioners. Every state and territory around the nation has condemned this legislation because they know it will cost more in their public hospital systems and make their waitlists longer.

We're really hopeful the Greens will support us in having this bill referred, because they know, too, that it is aged pensioners who will pick up the lion's share. I acknowledge the Greens leader himself said he would not allow Labor to 'punch down on pensioners for quick cash'. He also said:

None of the money planned from rolling back the rebate is slated to go into healthcare …

He said that he heard in the inquiry that people are planning to cut back on essentials like heating, cooling and putting food on the table just to keep their cover. He also said:

That is the reality that we need to face.

So we hope the Greens will support our referral so we can again try to get the facts, the truth, and understand the real impact of this legislation. Deferring this bill does not end it; it just drags it out. Older Australians are already dealing with cost-of-living pressures and an aged-care system that this government keeps on getting wrong. Health funds are setting premiums for next year. They need certainty. They have no idea what's going on. I say refer this bill—better still, why don't we scrap it altogether? Older Australians did the right thing for decades. It's about time this government did the right thing, too.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the amendment as moved by Senator O'Sullivan to the motion that the selection of bills committee report be adopted be agreed to.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

11:41 am

I move my amendment to the motion that the report be adopted, as circulated in my name:

At the end of the motion, add:

"and, in respect of the Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026, the bill be referred immediately to the Finance and Public Administration Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by the first sitting day of March 2027".

We've also just learned that the major parties have stitched up a deal on a guillotine for today. I fear that this is terrible for public trust in our democracy, at a time where we're seeing more and more Australians losing faith in democracy and we're seeing declining trust in the major parties—and it's no surprise why, because I think there are two bills in particular in this guillotine that absolutely deserve scrutiny. The Albanese government promised so much when it comes to transparency and have failed to deliver on that. They have been disappointing—one of the most secretive governments on record.

The Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill should, at the very least, go through a short Senate inquiry to look at some of the details in this bill. Last year, Labor and the coalition stitched up Australia's electoral laws to make it much harder for minor parties, for Independents—for new entrants into our democracy—at a time where we're seeing declining primary vote for and declining trust in the major parties. It was a cynical play, where they have given themselves an estimated additional $60 million in taxpayer funding every election cycle. They've ensured that they have more money to spend—that they can outspend any new entrant, any minor party, that wants to get in front of electors at an election.

One of the things that they now are doing with our electoral reform is to ensure that the huge war chests that they have that go into these new electoral reforms aren't counted—that, as to the $100 million in Labor holdings in Queensland, or the $80 million in the Liberal-linked Cormack Foundation, any income, any interest, from those that goes to the parties for elections, is not a donation; it's just money that comes in. It's not included in any of the caps. It's just there. This is to advantage the major parties.

The Centre for Public Integrity, so often quoted by the coalition, has warned that the government has provided no adequate assessment of the consequences of this bill. And that's why we need an inquiry.

The government will say: 'We need this done by 1 January 2027.' The Senate has had many short inquiries into urgent legislation—a week or a few days. We could get this done, if the Senate actually believed in the kind of scrutiny that we hear about from some. We should not be allowing the major parties to rewrite our electoral laws just to suit them, just to ensure that they have more money than everyone else come election time. That is not good for our democracy, and it's not good for Australians, who want and deserve better.

The second bill is the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill. This bill should absolutely go to an inquiry. There are so many Australians who are concerned about government overreach and about these sorts of decisions where you hand the minister of the day extraordinary powers to just designate—'Oh, this area is a special defence area.' Local, state and territory laws don't apply. Certain Commonwealth laws don't apply. My understanding of the Senate is that we're elected here to represent our state or territory. In seeing the major parties vote for a bill which would allow the Commonwealth to override state and territory laws, we've got to ask ourselves questions, particularly when this has not been through a Senate inquiry other than the stitch-up we saw when it went to a committee that only had the major parties on it. It was a sham of a public hearing. Not a single person was invited who had any issues with the bill. Basically, it was the departments and, it seems, one Defence contractor.

My office has been inundated with concerns from Australians about this bill. The government doesn't want to hear from Australians who have very valid concerns. This is not the scrutiny that Australians expect, and I urge the Senate to send these bills to an inquiry. Surely, if we do not do better as a Senate, we will continue to see a declining rate of trust in our democracy, and that should concern all of us.

Sean Bell

Sean Bell NSW, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

11:46 am

One Nation will be supporting attempts to refer this legislation to an inquiry. The Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026 certainly deserves more scrutiny. Just for people watching, this bill was introduced this week. It was exempt from the normal rules this week. They're exempting it from committee this week. And, further, they've introduced a guillotine, so there'll be no debate. Not only will the committee not have a chance to look at it; the parliament won't have a chance to debate it. That means this has all of the hallmarks of a major party stitch-up.

The two parties that have run this country for a century, the uniparty—they don't like hearing that, but these are the actions of a uniparty—are changing the rules about how things work to favour themselves. And they'd rather no-one gets a chance to look at these rules closely. If they wanted scrutiny, it would be going to a committee. They wouldn't be guillotining it. They'd be happy to debate it. And the fact is that, in their own legislation, they highlight that this is to fix critical issues with the bill. Well, that means the legislation that they rushed through the first time had critical flaws. We rushed it through the first time. They didn't get it right. It had critical flaws. And now they're attempting to rush through another fix to hide the fact it had critical flaws.

The fact is Labor and the coalition spend most of this chamber's time pretending they disagree. And yet, on the rules that decide who gets elected, they're suddenly very comfortable with each other. Funny how that works! The people writing the rules of the contest— (Time expired)

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the amendment moved by Senator David Pocock be agreed to.