This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care
11:31 am
I'd like to speak to the amendment that's been moved by Senator O'Sullivan, please. I just want to be really clear that the coalition wants this bill referred to a committee, not deferred and not parked until it suits the government. This is a bill whose substance was announced in a National Press Club speech. There was never any press release. It was never taken to the election. It was a policy that was written on the back of an envelope, and the government still will not show us that envelope.
The government told us that 44,000 people would drop their cover. Its own modelling, revealed under freedom of information, shows that that number is closer to 80,000. Just yesterday, we learned independently that more than 330,000 Australians will drop or downgrade their cover altogether. Parliamentary Budget Office analysis shows that $1.6 billion of this save comes directly from aged pensioners. Every one of those numbers had to be dragged out of the government. Just last week, the minister wouldn't even say whether he would exempt pensioners or whether he is looking for other savings.
When the Senate discharged this bill, the minister called it an absolute travesty. The real travesty is that the government is trying to make savings out of older Australians, forcing them out of private health insurance and into long hospital queues. We know that, for every dollar Mr Butler says he's saving, it'll cost the health system $1.20. Mr Butler said he was open to debate in the parliament and ready to engage constructively. Today we offer scrutiny, and you are intending to say no.
On 14 October, this Senate voted 38 to 23 to discharge the bill. Twenty-four hours later, the minister puts it back in the other place. As I said, 3.2 million older Australians will pay more, and, of them, 1.2 million at least will be aged pensioners. Every state and territory around the nation has condemned this legislation because they know it will cost more in their public hospital systems and make their waitlists longer.
We're really hopeful the Greens will support us in having this bill referred, because they know, too, that it is aged pensioners who will pick up the lion's share. I acknowledge the Greens leader himself said he would not allow Labor to 'punch down on pensioners for quick cash'. He also said:
None of the money planned from rolling back the rebate is slated to go into healthcare …
He said that he heard in the inquiry that people are planning to cut back on essentials like heating, cooling and putting food on the table just to keep their cover. He also said:
That is the reality that we need to face.
So we hope the Greens will support our referral so we can again try to get the facts, the truth, and understand the real impact of this legislation. Deferring this bill does not end it; it just drags it out. Older Australians are already dealing with cost-of-living pressures and an aged-care system that this government keeps on getting wrong. Health funds are setting premiums for next year. They need certainty. They have no idea what's going on. I say refer this bill—better still, why don't we scrap it altogether? Older Australians did the right thing for decades. It's about time this government did the right thing, too.
No comments