This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Motions

Construction Industry


Jane Hume

Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations

10:42 am

I seek leave to move a motion relating to the coalition's sustained action against corruption, intimidation and unlawful conduct in the construction industry, as circulated.

Leave not granted.

Pursuant to contingent notice standing in the name of the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate, Senator Cash, I move:

That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the coalition's sustained action against corruption, intimidation and unlawful conduct in the construction industry.

The standing orders must be suspended. They must because Australians deserve to know why this government keeps voting down an inquiry into corruption in construction. The scrutiny of corruption in construction is so profoundly important, yet this government, in this parliament, continues to vote down scrutiny of that corruption in construction. If you think that corruption in construction is limited to Queensland and Victoria, you are kidding yourself. Yet, this government continually votes down scrutiny of that corruption in construction—the Labor government, along with their partners in crime the Greens.

I don't understand why it is that the Greens are voting this down. Why is it that they continually avoid this scrutiny? Five times this Senate has been asked by the coalition to establish an inquiry into corruption in construction, and five times Labor and the Greens have teamed up to vote it down. It's extraordinary that you can find the numbers to block scrutiny, but you can't find the courage to support it.

Well, time is up, Labor. Time is up, Greens. Time is up for the government. We should debate this motion today—and it is urgent to do so—and get an inquiry passed so that hearings can start immediately. Australians are entitled to ask: what more has to happen before the government agrees to follow the money? We are in the second week now of Victoria's Big Build royal commission. The Queensland commission of inquiry has now already delivered its interim report, and Queenslanders and Victorians are seeing just how deep this rot goes.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Hume, I'm going to draw you back to the suspension.

Jane Hume

Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations

That is why it is so important that we suspend standing orders right now, so we can debate the need for scrutiny of corruption in construction. Here in Canberra, Labor and the Greens won't even support a Senate inquiry—something as basic as a Senate inquiry. Just this week, the Victorian royal commission heard evidence about pressure on builders to employ people with criminal records and bikie connections as health and safety representatives. The irony in that! Health and safety representatives are there, and that's why it is so important that we suspend standing orders now so that we can debate this motion.

Health and safety representatives are supposed to protect workers, and instead we hear evidence that the CFMEU is pressuring builders to give these positions to their mates—threats, intimidation and disruption. I can't imagine anything that is more urgent to debate, because who pays the price for this? It is honest workers. It is honest builders. And of course it's the taxpayers that are funding these projects. So how many more builders need to give evidence? How many more whistleblowers need to come forward? How many more members of the media need to have their lives threatened? And how much more taxpayer money needs to be wasted before Labor and the Greens understand the urgency of this issue and agree that this parliament should investigate it? That is why standing orders need to be suspended today, because every single week brings more evidence while the government seems to insist that enough has been done. Labor promised to clean it up, but if they were serious they would agree to suspend standing orders and debate this motion right now.

After more than two years, after the revelations that led to the CFMEU construction division being placed into administration, Australians are still waiting for that promise to be delivered. Labor cannot rewrite its own records. You opposed the ABCC. You opposed the registered organisations commission. And, when you got into government, Labor abolished both. Now, we are seeing why this is so urgent. You dismantled the specialist watchdogs. Then Australians have had to stand by, and you've asked them to applaud you for finally acting on the CFMEU. Well, that is breathtaking hypocrisy, and nothing could be more urgent.

In 2019, the coalition introduced legislation to strengthen the Federal Court's powers to deal with dysfunctional unions through administration. And you voted against it. An inquiry is needed to follow the money through contractors, subcontractors, the labour hire companies and procurement decisions. Who knew? Who benefited? Who failed to act? These questions could not be more urgent, and they deserve answers from this parliament. Labor says it stands up for workers. Well, then stand up for workers. Those workers deserve safe and respectful workplaces with honest representation. So support scrutiny of the corruption that drives up costs, drives up wages and threatens worker safety. (Time expired)

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

10:48 am

This suspension is totally unnecessary. this suspension is not needed. The topics that Senator Hume wants to bring to the Senate—you can do that at any time.

Andrew Bragg

Andrew Bragg NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness

That's why we're doing it.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

There is ample opportunity to be able to do it. We know that the Albanese Labor government does not tolerate corruption, criminally, and violence in any part of the construction industry.

An opposition senator: Yes, you do.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Minister, please resume your seat. I hope I'm only going to have to sit the minister down once. Senator Hume was heard in complete silence—complete silence—and that same respect will be shown to Minister McCarthy. There will be no more interjections. Minister.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

As I was saying, there is no need for this suspension of business—

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

No corruption here! Nothing to look at!

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Minister McCarthy, please sit down. Senator McGrath, you are being incredibly disrespectful to me as the chair. I have just ordered there be no interjections. If you can't remain quiet, leave the chamber. I'm very serious about this. We're not having a member of the opposition stand up and you being able to hear a pin drop in here, which is what I expect—when Senator Hume spoke—and then, the minute the minister gets to her feet, you think it's fair game. It is not fair game, and I will not tolerate it. Minister McCarthy.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

Thank you, President, for the protection from the rabble over there, especially Senator McGrath. Seriously, we are talking about the need for a suspension of standing orders. There is no need for a suspension on this particular topic or any topic. Those opposite have ample opportunity at any other time of Senate business to bring this forward.

This hasn't just happened overnight. It is our government that made the Senate aware of the need to clean up this industry. It is us on this side who did it. For 10 years, there was no decision, no movement, by those on that side to do anything about the CFMEU.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator McGrath! It is not okay to show me, as the President of this chamber, such absolute disrespect. You might think it's funny. You might think it's clever. I don't think it's any of that. I asked for respect for the minister when she was speaking. I'm the President of this chamber. That is the least you can do.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

It is us on this side that brought the issue to the Senate, to the parliament, in terms of the CFMEU, following multiple referrals from the Albanese Labor government. Relevant federal agencies, including the AFP, the Fair Work Commission and the Fair Work Ombudsman, have 129 active investigations—

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

Point of order on relevance: the minister should be speaking to the motion rather than the substance of the corruption of Labor and the CFMEU.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

As would have been evidenced when Senator Hume made her contribution, I allow some leeway and then I draw people back to the question. I will give that same entitlement to Minister McCarthy.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

I ask that Senator McGrath withdraw his last words in that sentence, please.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

I'm not sure I heard.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

Senator McGrath knows exactly what he said. I ask that he withdraw, please.

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

I withdraw.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

We know that the Senate now wants to debate an issue that has been going on for a while. Those opposite have had ample opportunity—months, years even. In fact, when they were in government and we were in opposition, there was no mention from those on that side of the CFMEU. We've taken tangible action to stamp out corruption, criminality and violence within the CFMEU's construction division by appointing an independent administrator to the union. And it's clear from publicly available reports that the administration has achieved more progress in cleaning up the union in its first two years of operation than the coalition and the failed ABCC did in a decade, including commissioning multiple investigations by pre-eminent barristers and removing hundreds of individuals from their positions.

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

I don't like to do this, but, on a point of order, the minister is not speaking to urgency and has not done so for at least 55 seconds.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator McGrath, there's no need to time-keep. I was going to draw the minister back to the suspension order. Minister, I remind you it's a suspension order.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

Maybe the member opposite might want to time-keep how many times they raised the issue of the CFMEU while they were in government; I'd be interested to know that!

Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

Point of order on relevance, President. Just as soon as you indicated to the minister you were going to draw her back to the urgency motion, she took a gratuitous shot.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Thank you, Senator Scarr, I do not need advice from you. I'll listen carefully. I've only just reminded the minister to focus on the suspension, and I will continue to listen carefully.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

As I was saying before I was rudely interrupted many times, this Senate has plenty of opportunity to debate all matters, including what Senator Hume has brought to this suspension motion. There is no need to disrupt the order of the Senate right now when we know that these issues can be debated at any particular time. Those opposite have their private senators' bills, their motions, their matters of public importance and urgency—all those things that come to the Senate at the appropriate time. We have matters that we wish to get through now. That's why the suspension should not take place. Government business orders of the day is our opportunity to make sure that the pieces of legislation we want to see come through happen. I cannot reiterate enough what the Albanese government has done to not tolerate corruption in the construction industry. There is certainly no need for this suspension.

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

10:55 am

It is very important that this chamber, at this time, has the opportunity to debate the motion that has been put by my colleague Senator Hume. One of the prevailing cancers impacting upon the Australian economy is the relationship between the CFMEU and those in power, particularly those on the Labor side of politics.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator McGrath, I'm going to draw you back to the suspension motion.

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

Thank you, President. It is important for those who are watching and those who are listening to come to the understanding that there are certain senators in this chamber who are running a giant cover-up for corruption between an industrial union called the CFMEU and a political party.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator McGrath, please resume your seat. Senator McCarthy?

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

Point of order, President. I ask that the senator withdraw that comment in reference to senators in this chamber.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

I'm happy to take advice from the Clerk, but Senator McGrath did not name any senators. I will continue to listen carefully, but Senator McGrath hasn't named anyone. But, while there has been an interruption, Senator McGrath, I would like you to focus on the reason for the suspension notice. That's the matter at hand at the moment.

Malarndirri McCarthy

Malarndirri McCarthy NT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Indigenous Australians

President, may I just ask that you have another look at what was said?

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Certainly. I doubt I'll change my view, but I'm happy to look at the tape. Senator McGrath, please continue.

James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

It is urgent that this chamber have a detailed discussion in relation to issues pertaining to corruption, pertaining to governments, pertaining to how our society perceives the relationship between the CFMEU and a certain political party and certain politicians. It is important, and it is urgent, considering the events and the information that has come out of the royal commission in Queensland, which has been underway for two years and has actually been granted a further extension of 18 months because of the disgusting information coming out in relation to corruption between Labor ministers and the CFMEU. It is urgent and important that this chamber have a discussion in relation to issues that are coming out of Victoria concerning the corruption there between that cabal that sat around the cabinet table and the CFMEU. It is urgent that we have a discussion concerning at least a waste of $15 billion of taxpayers' money that has been wasted through the Big Build project. So it is urgent. It is important that this chamber discuss the motion that is being moved by Senator Hume.

There are two approaches for this chamber in relation to this motion for the suspension of standing orders. The first is to vote it down and not have a discussion in relation to the allegations of corruption between the CFMEU and Labor Party politicians. The other option in relation to the suspension motion is that the Labor Party politicians in this chamber wholeheartedly defend the $15 billion wasted on the big build through corruption. It is possible that Labor Party politicians, Labor Party senators from Queensland, in relation to this suspension motion, could come out and defend the actions of Steven Miles and Grace Grace and Mark Bailey and Cameron Dick and other Labor Party politicians in Queensland. That is possible. That is what happens in a suspension motion. This is a process to allow this chamber to discuss a motion. If you disagree with the motion, don't use process to stop it being debated. Indeed, if the Labor Party is so proud of its relationship with the CFMEU and so proud of what it's done in relation to corruption in Queensland and Victoria, well, come forth and say that.

This is a suspension motion that could also deal with the fact that the Labor Party took $7 million in donations from the CFMEU and has not handed back a single cent of that $7 million. I always say, 'Follow the money trail' —follow the money trail to the CFMEU's bank account from the Labor Party. (Time expired)

Maria Kovacic

Maria Kovacic NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Women

11:01 am

I too stand to speak to why this is urgent—and it is. The reason that I want to start with is that we have a problem in our country with a loss of trust in our public institutions and a loss of trust in our democracy. That is a big problem for us because it allows players from the fringes to come in and say that what we're doing here no longer works and doesn't matter. If that, for us, isn't urgent, then I don't know what is—because the very basis upon which we sit in these chambers becomes at risk.

This is urgent because Australians deserve answers as to why both the government and the Australian Greens continue to refuse to allow an investigation and scrutiny into corruption in the construction industry. It is urgent because we are in a cost-of-living crisis, it is urgent because we are in a cost-of-doing-business crisis, it is urgent because we are in a housing crisis, and it is urgent because this is taxpayer money. We have people in our country that cannot afford to feed their kids, and we have billions and billions and billions of dollars being wasted and filling the pockets of corrupt and criminal individuals—and we are not stopping them. That is why it is urgent.

I've seen someone sort of smiling on the other side of the chamber, and I take offence to that because this is not funny. This is serious to me. This matters to me. I've been fighting about this all year, as have others, because every single dollar that any Australian has to take out of their pay packet and pay in tax that we then decide how to distribute—we are custodians of that money. It does not belong to us, and that is why it is urgent.

Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

How many signed the petition?

Maria Kovacic

Maria Kovacic NSW, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Women

Sixty-four thousand Australians have signed my petition because it matters to them. Sixty-four thousand people so far have said, 'This is urgent to me because I can't afford to pay my bills'—or they're worried about their friend or their neighbour who can't pay their bills. 'I'm worried about my friend that's lost their job before Christmas and doesn't know what they are going to do'—that is why this is urgent.

I have people saying to me, 'Oh, you're just after workers.' No, I'm not. I listened when the Greens said to me, 'This is an attack on workers.' This is not an attack on workers; this is an attack on corruption, and that's why it's urgent. Australians deserve to have us fight corruption the moment that we see it, to take immediate and urgent action the moment that we are aware that there is something fundamentally wrong going on, particularly in relation to taxpayer funds being funnelled to organised crime. If we cannot stop that, then why are we even here? If we don't think that is urgent, then what do we actually think matters? How do we stand up and face them and say, 'You know what? Once again, we tried, but they don't think it matters.' I think that $15 billion on the Big Build in Victoria is urgent. I think that really matters. I don't know how much has been lost in my home state of New South Wales, but I expect it's a similar number, if not higher. I understand in Queensland the interim report has highlighted that $24 billion worth of taxpayer money could have been lost if the Crisafulli government hadn't acted on BPIC. If that's not urgent, then what is? I don't know.

We've got people who are struggling, who cannot pay their bills, and for them to hear that we think that tens of billions of dollars being lost to corrupt and criminal entities doesn't matter and is not urgent is, I think, probably one step too far. And to the point that the minister made that we've done nothing and we're pretending here, we took a lot of steps in relation to this when we were in government. In fact, those opposite voted against it. You voted against it and wouldn't allow us to deal with it, and now you're saying it's not urgent. You have thwarted it at every possible opportunity you've had, and you attempt to deflect the blame on us. And that is another matter, I have to say. If it is not urgent to consider why donations are kept from entities that are dealing with corruption and intimidation, then tell me what is.

Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

11:06 am

It is urgent. For all the reasons that we've just heard it is urgent for the people of Queensland. It is urgent for them because, under the Queensland Labor government with the support of the Labor federal government, every single school, hospital, major building, major piece of infrastructure, whether it be a highway or a dam, had a 30 per cent CFMEU tax added to it. That is tens and tens of millions, hundreds of millions of dollars, of taxpayer funds wasted.

It is urgent because of the human cost, and we have heard the human cost of the corruption of the CFMEU with its facilitators in the Labor Party on subcontractors and employees in the construction industry. I've previously spoken in this place about tragic cases where employees of subcontractors took their own lives because of the bullying from the CFMEU. It is urgent because in my home state of Queensland, workplace health and safety inspectors had to take protected industrial action. They wouldn't go on construction sites controlled by the CFMEU because they were concerned for their physical safety. Can you believe that? The workplace health and safety inspectors had to take protected industrial—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Scarr, I'm going to draw you back to the suspension motion.

Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

It's urgent for those workplace health and safety inspectors and for their well-being that the corruption of the CFMEU is expurgated from Australian society. That's why this motion is urgent.

It's also urgent because legislation that was put forward by my friend and colleague Senator Hume, who's been a warrior on this issue for the people of Victoria and the people of Australia, would have prevented the wrongdoers coming back into the industrial relations system. It's urgent because that legislation was just defeated by Labor and the Greens. That's why it's urgent. That legislation was just defeated. It's absolutely urgent that we have this debate given Labor and the Greens rejected that legislation. It's urgent for us to hear from them what their answers are. They don't have any answers. That's why it's urgent for us to have this debate.

It's urgent because every single day that this corruption continues millions of dollars of taxpayer funds are wasted. It's urgent because every single week there are more complaints coming from Victorian companies to this place about wrongdoing on Victorian Big Build construction sites. We heard that in the last Senate estimates. It's urgent because disproportionately those complaints are coming from Big Build projects in Victoria. That's why it's urgent. It's urgent because every single day we don't deal with this issue and every single day this corruption linked to the CFMEU continues millions of dollars of Australian taxpayer funds are being wasted. And it's urgent because, as we've heard, Australia is in a cost-of-living crisis, and we can't afford to lose those millions and millions of dollars.

I wonder if people listening to this debate are convinced that this is urgent. I would hope so. We've given lots and lots of reasons as to why this is an urgent debate and, in good faith, those reasons are compelling. The grounds for urgency have been established, and we should have this debate.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

11:10 am

What is the time limitation on integrity being dealt with by this parliament? That's the question that I would ask. And I would say—quite frankly, given that we have just seen a piece of legislation voted down that was about bringing integrity to the construction industry—that it is appropriate that we deal with this matter right now. What is the deal with Labor and the Greens, who have never voted for any single integrity motion in relation to the CFMEU? What is it with them?

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

Other than administration.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

The Greens voted against putting the CFMEU into administration, Minister—I'll take the interjection—so the coalition supported you in doing that. Let's get the facts straight. The Greens have never voted for any integrity measure with relation to the CFMEU. What is the story with that? Why, when this parliament has yet again voted down an integrity measure brought by the coalition with respect to the construction industry, can we not have this debate, when we bring on a motion to actually do the investigation? So what is the time limitation on integrity?

I know there are people on the other side of politics and in the Greens who see integrity in the Australian community and industry as important, but I just don't understand why we can't have this debate right now and deal with a simple motion now. That's what we're asking. We're asking to deal with a motion to establish a process with respect to integrity in the Australian construction industry. Why can't we do that now? It's not necessarily a process that's going to take a long time. So the arguments put by the government, with respect to why this is not urgent, quite simply don't fly. It's important— (Time expired)

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

The question is that the motion moved by Senator Hume be agreed to.