This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Migration


Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

5:33 pm

The Senate will now consider the proposal, under standing order 75, from Senator Hanson, which has been circulated and is shown on the Dynamic Red:

That in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Government to put Australians struggling through the cost of living crisis first and save $141 billion by cutting the humanitarian intake to 2,000 places a year, still above the OECD average on a per capita basis, and ending expensive permanent parental migration.

Is consideration of the proposal supported?

More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places—

With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.

Pauline Hanson

Pauline Hanson Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

I move:

That in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:

The need for the Government to put Australians struggling through the cost of living crisis first and save $141 billion by cutting the humanitarian intake to 2,000 places a year, still above the OECD average on a per capita basis, and ending expensive permanent parental migration.

Australians are hurting. They can't afford the rent. They can't afford the groceries. They can't afford or get a hospital bed. Every year the Albanese Labor government signs them up for another bill. This morning, One Nation announced we will cut two of the most expensive permanent visa programs in this country. We will cut the humanitarian program by 90 per cent, from 20,000 a year to 2,000 places a year. We will stop issuing new permanent parent visas. Mums, dads and grandparents will still be able to visit their families on long-stay temporary visas, but at their own cost. And we will largely end onshore asylum applications. Why? Because taxpayers can no longer afford to pay for the reckless and costly migration programs of the Labor Party and the coalition.

Each humanitarian entrant and each permanent parent-migrant costs Australian taxpayers more than half a million dollars over their lifetime. If we keep these programs running for another 10 years, that's a $141 billion bill. Parents arrive here late in life. They've spent their working years paying tax somewhere else. Then they come here, and Australian taxpayers pick up the bill for their health care, their aged care and their pension. Years after arriving, far too many humanitarian entrants are still on unemployment benefits, and the Australian people pay for it all.

This morning the Foreign minister had the gall to call these policies 'harsh' and 'divisive'. Harsh? I'll tell you what's harsh. Harsh is a young couple, both working full time, who will never own a home. Harsh is a pensioner sitting in the dark because she or he can't afford to turn the heater on. Harsh is forcing hardworking Australians to pay more than half a million dollars for every person in these programs when they can't pay their own bills. Divisive? I'll tell you what's divisive. Divisive is calling Australians racist for asking what it costs. Divisive is a government that prioritises foreign citizens over its own people. Divisive is being generous with other people's money.

Neither Labor nor the coalition is prepared to confront the costs of these immigration programs. Labor and the coalition have been all over the place on migration. Labor says they want more refugees; actually, they want to increase it to 27,000. Their coalition mates in here want it at least at 50,000. The coalition went to the last election promising 13,750 humanitarian places; now they say it's 10,000. They're changing their figures all the time. That's still five times the OECD average. Labor and the coalition would rather look away while Australians pay. One Nation won't look away.

These policies are not extreme. It's common sense that people who come to this country should make a positive contribution. Australia currently resettles refugees at more than 10 times the OECD average. We punch above our weight—well and truly, beyond that. One Nation would bring Australia in line with that average. I say to my colleagues in this chamber stop being afraid of this debate, stop hiding behind words like 'harsh' and 'divisive', look at the cost and look at the people paying it. Australians aren't extreme for asking these questions. They're not racist for wanting their government to put them first.

We are a generous country. Migrants helped build this nation. But I make no apology for this. I love this country and I love its people—the tradie up before dawn, the nurse on night shift and the farmer going through drought. They, the Australian people, are who I work for. I can tell you my colleagues and I in One Nation will always put them first.

Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

5:38 pm

Australians are rightly concerned about the scale of migration under this Labor government. Since Anthony Albanese came to office, about 1.5 million additional migrants have arrived in Australia—roughly the population of Adelaide. That has placed enormous pressure on housing, infrastructure, schools, hospitals and essential services. The Liberals and Nationals have been absolutely clear: migration numbers under Labor have been too high and standards have been too low.

Opposing this motion from One Nation does not mean endorsing Labor's disastrous migration policies. In fact, the coalition has already announced the largest cut to immigration in Australia's history. We'll reduce net overseas migration to 100,000 people a year for the first two years, rising to 160,000 in year 4. We will prioritise skilled migrants, protect essential regional industries and restore integrity to the migration system.

Importantly, we have told Australians exactly what our net overseas migration targets will be. By my count, this is One Nation's fifth migration policy in about five months, and they still cannot provide a credible year-by-year explanation of what their net overseas migration figures will be. We've heard promises of 130,000 migrants, negative migration and hundreds of thousands of temporary visa holders leaving the country, and now this latest announcement. Australians are seeking real solutions and concrete information on this issue, but with One Nation they simply get another headline every few weeks.

Today's motion proposes slashing the humanitarian intake to just 2,000 places annually and abolishing permanent parent migration. The coalition agrees that Labor's humanitarian intake is unsustainable, and that is why we have committed to halving the humanitarian program to 10,000 places annually. But we also recognise that Australia must retain the flexibility to respond to international crises. Wars, humanitarian disasters and the displacement of innocent people cannot be predicted years in advance. Governments need the ability to respond appropriately while maintaining firm control of the overall migration program.

Then there is One Nation's program to abolish permanent parent visas. Anyone who has dealt with these applications knows this is hardly an uncontrolled migration program. According to the Department of Home Affairs, the estimated processing time for a contributory parent visa application is 18 years. For standard parent visas, it is an astonishing 42 years. Applicants must meet visa requirements, including health and character checks, and sponsors are subject to financial obligations. These are tightly controlled programs with lengthy queues, so it is simply not credible to suggest that parent visas are the principal cause of Australia's housing shortage or cost-of-living crisis. One Nation also claims these proposals will save taxpayers $141 billion. Where are the independent costings, when would these savings materialise and what are the wider economic consequences?

The coalition's Australia First migration plan is straightforward. We must reduce migration, lift standards, restore proper controls and ensure that the people coming here want to make a positive contribution. We must also protect the industries and regional communities that depend on genuinely skilled migration. We will cap net overseas migration each year below the number of new homes completed. We'll reduce temporary visa holders by about 650,000 over four years and keep the Permanent Migration Program capped at 185,000 places a year. We will also reduce annual international student commencements by 55,000 people, abolish temporary graduate visas and restrict most students from bringing over family members.

Labor has created a mess. But replacing Labor's failures with constantly-changing One Nation announcements is not the answer. Australia's migration policy should be rigorous, practical, properly costed and capable of being delivered. We believe migrants should want to be Australians and not just live here but share our aspirations, our values and our way of life. That is what the Liberals and Nationals have put forward, and that is why we cannot support this motion.

Charlotte Walker

Charlotte Walker SA, Australian Labor Party

5:43 pm

I rise to speak on the urgency motion put forward by Senator Hanson. What is there to say, really? This is as unsurprising a policy idea from One Nation as finding out the Pope is Catholic or as a bear defecating in the woods. All the world's problems can simply be fixed, didn't you know, by getting rid of migrants. Senator Hanson believes that the cost-of-living crisis will simply disappear by getting rid of these visa holders. I would ask Senator Hanson to provide us with the costings for this idea, but we all know she hasn't done them.

While we're talking about the cost of living, let's go over Senator Hanson's track record of voting when it comes to matters that would help the average Australian in their day-to-day life. She voted against Labor's Housing Australia Future Fund, against our reforms to make university education more accessible, against fee-free TAFE, against our three-day guarantee for subsidised child care and against our cost-of-living tax cuts. She has even opposed measures to make student debt more manageable. And what does she support? Well, she was perfectly happy to champion the original stage 3 tax cuts, which would have delivered the biggest benefits to higher income earners. Too bad for young people, workers, new parents or first home buyers; Senator Hanson has bigger fish to fry. This is a pretty appalling line for someone who claims to be fighting for the Aussie battler out there—not to mention that this idea proposed today by Senator Hanson would do unbelievable damage to our economy. It would make the budget $100 billion worse off over the next decade; it would decimate the workforce in regional areas; and it would mean higher taxes, more debt and more cuts to services.

Not only is this nonsense not based on economic reality; it's also painfully cruel to some of the most vulnerable people in the world. Refugees are fleeing war and persecution and look to Australia for safety, stability and a chance at a new life. We should be proud of our country for its long and generous tradition of resettling refugees and people in humanitarian need. It's just an extension of the traditional Aussie values: mateship, compassion and stepping up for our neighbours when they're in need.

And let's talk about these parent visas for a moment, because it seems letting people live in the same country as their mum and dad is the beginning of endless rorts and corruption. Senator Hanson would have you believe that, the minute someone's parents arrive in Australia, they're handed a pension, a Medicare card and the keys to a taxpayer funded mansion—except a contributory parent visa costs around $53,000 per person, and to qualify for the age pension you generally need to have lived here for at least 10 years. These people aren't rocking up to Centrelink with their hands out. Another revolutionary idea—grandparents help look after their grandchildren, which means parents can get to work, businesses get the workers they need and families get to spend more time together. What an absolute disaster that would be!

Now, let's be clear. Labor absolutely believes in a migration system that works for Australia. That's why we've strengthened visa compliance, cracked down on dodgy migration agents and taken action on visa hopping. We've brought net overseas migration down 45 per cent from its post-pandemic peak, because, unlike One Nation, we understand that migration policy needs more than a slogan and a person to blame.

Then, of course, there's the coalition getting mogged by One Nation every day of the week. The opposition leader has apparently decided that the best way to demonstrate he's ready to govern is to announce massive migration cuts, but, sadly, without being able to explain what happens to our hospitals, aged-care homes, farms or construction sites when the workers disappear. Even the business community and unions are lining up to tell him that it's a terrible idea. Meanwhile, Labor will continue to run a sensible, orderly migration system; honour our humanitarian commitments; and recognise the enormous contribution migrants and refugees make to this country. This issue should be about what works for Australia, not political pointscoring that leaves families caught in the middle.

David Shoebridge

David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens

5:48 pm

Well, this is One Nation all over—another page in the long and shameful book of attacking immigrants. But Labor, One Nation and the Liberals have been engaged in a race to the bottom to turn back refugees, lock them up in offshore detention and then blame them for the cost of living. Every time Labor shift to the Right on migration, they're laying the groundwork for One Nation's next attack on migrants. And here's the thing. In One Nation's new shift to the Right, Labor is already there. Parent visa applications are taking more than 40 years to process, and you have Minister Burke out there bragging about it on behalf of Labor. The Labor government is already implementing One Nation policy. Think about what they're doing. Your mum's dying, you're prevented from caring for her; your kids are born, you try to get your parents here to see the new grandkid—only for the government under Labor to split the family.

Cutting refugee intake is one of the cruellest things you can do. But Labor, the coalition and One Nation are the war parties, the parties who in this place back the wars around the world, and then, when people start fleeing those exact same wars, they attack them. It's the lowest of the low. Those war parties—Labor, One Nation and the coalition—have made all our lives worse and, instead of fixing the problem, then turn around and blame migrants. Let's be clear. Labor, One Nation and Liberals blame migrants for the housing crisis, flat wages and underfunded services to give cover to their collective refusal to take on their big corporate donors so we have the public revenue to make the social fixes needed by millions of Australians.

Maybe this is a moment for Labor to wake up, to stop chasing One Nation down the far-right rabbit hole, but I don't think so. I think they're going to keep feeding this same ugly cycle of blame and division. Between Labor and the coalition, they've created the circumstances, the falling wages, the harder times and the billionaire bonuses that are being manipulated by One Nation to drive this division. The answer is to make people's lives better, to make this place work for people, to champion multiculturalism and to build hope and not feed fear.

Tammy Tyrrell

Tammy Tyrrell Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

5:50 pm

This urgency motion from One Nation is once again wildly out of touch with reality. One Nation seems to be living in a fantasy world where basic human decency doesn't exist and neither does economic logic. One Nation's migration policy would leave the budget about $100 billion worse off over the next decade. How does that help our economy? How does that help Aussies tackle the cost of living? And that's before you factor in the damage to the wider economy. Farms and businesses will be left without the workers they need, which means fewer jobs for Australians too. Someone has to pay for that hole. It means higher taxes, more debt and cuts to services. We need migration for our economic prosperity. It makes us stronger as a nation and allows us to fill critical workforce gaps in areas like health care, agriculture and construction.

Like any good country, we welcome people who make a genuine contribution to our country, but we don't support people who try to rort or defraud the system, so we're making changes to give us more control over who arrives, who stays and who should leave. That's why we're improving the system by strengthening compliance measures, improving the integrity of student visas by stopping visa hopping and cracking down on rogue migration agents. When we came to office, net overseas migration was soaring. We've made sensible, considered changes, which have brought it down by 45 per cent from its post-pandemic peak. Almost everyone who comes to Australia is a good guest in our country. Our reforms are about ensuring that our migration system can be better targeted to the current needs of Australia.

But, rather than doing the work and actually thinking up real policies that would help Australians, One Nation instead just wants to point the finger at minority groups. They go after some of our most vulnerable in our communities. First it was Asian Australians, then it was Muslim Australians, and now it seems to be refugees. What a bloody joke. Once again, this clearly isn't about trying to help Tasmanians or Australians. It's about playing the blame game. Research consistently shows that humanitarian migrants have some of the highest rates of small-business ownership in Australia after their initial settlement period, creating jobs for locals. Australia is a nation built by people seeking a better, safer life, from postwar European migrants to Vietnamese boat people and modern humanitarian entrants. Welcoming refugees isn't a political issue. It's an extension of our core values of mateship, compassion and stepping up when people are in need of safety.

This government will continue to provide a generous, orderly and humanitarian intake. When we offer safety to people fleeing war and persecution, we aren't just saving lives; we're strengthening the very fabric of our own country. Refugees are eager to work, rebuild their lives and give back to the community that welcomed them. They fill critical gaps in health care, construction, hospitality and trades. This need for migrants isn't a coincidence, whether it be refugees or other migrants. It's the backbone of our community and of our economy. Yet we still hear the tiresome base-level arguments. The angle peddled by some is simple, and, frankly, it's bloody lazy: 'We don't want this one'; 'We want that one'; 'We want no-one'. This isn't how a modern economy works, and it's certainly not how we build a strong, compassionate society in Tasmania or Australia. It's time the banging of the anti mass migration drum was drowned out by the sound of respect, logic and care. There's no question that migrants add to our nation, not detract from it. The work ethic, the commitment to family and the desire to engage in the community shown by migrants who have chosen to settle in Tasmania and Australia are both admirable and deeply patriotic. They're not taking jobs; they're filling gaps, creating new markets and sustaining our entire service economy.

Tasmania has a crucial choice. We can choose isolation, fear and stagnation, or we can choose growth, prosperity and, above all, kindness. Our ageing demographic means we are critically dependent on new blood and new skills. So, to every new Tasmanian—to the doctors, the drivers, the delivery riders, the small business owners and the factory workers—I say: we appreciate you, we value you, and you are welcome in our island state. Let us commit to responsibly leading the nation not in division but in radical, necessary inclusion.

Malcolm Roberts

Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

5:55 pm

Immigration policy must serve the Australians already here. Australians' safety and living standards come first. As a migrant and proud Australian, I appreciate that. We know that migrants build our country. One Nation will always welcome people who came here to work and pay their fair share in tax. Every entry into our country who doesn't work, though, is a decision about who Australians will support for decades to come—an added burden on taxpayers. Let's have some data, because you're going on feelings so far. Treasury modelling, adjusted for inflation and after taxes and visa charges, shows average net lifetime cost per humanitarian visa entry is $523,000. For those on a parent visa, it is $515,000.

I started on this immigration issue five years ago because I was absolutely horrified at the homelessness in Queensland—in every major provincial city in our country, in our state and in Brisbane—due to mass immigration, plus wages being suppressed, plus inflation because of increased demand, plus interest rates rising because of inflation. Housing costs are rising. The cost of living is rising. We have a debt of over $1 trillion, and you lot—both of you—tried to hide the gross domestic product per capita decline. That's why you're bringing them in. There is a lack of infrastructure and services. Student entry is being turned into a visa factory.

In One Nation, we listen. We get the data. We do our research. We consult. We use our ears, not our lips. Our integrity is important. Above all, we have heart for the people of Australia. We want to restore living standards, cut population pressure and restore wages growth without inflation from higher productivity. As we've already explained—it still remains—we want to slash immigration by three-quarters of a million over the next three years. We want negative net migration—more people leaving than entering. Temporary visa holders and illegals are the first area where we've got abuse of the immigration system. After three years we will have a net overseas migration ceiling of 130,000 people. That's the maximum. We would have fewer, depending upon the skills. It would be reviewed annually. To encourage voluntary departure, we would cut off illicit residents from income and privileges. Temporary skilled visas will be demand driven for real skills. We will maintain the existing PALM and working holiday-maker visas. We will return the temporary migrant population to 2017 levels and the international student population to 2015 levels. We will reset the immigration system. The total cut will be 766,000 temporary visa holders. That includes secondaries—in other words, families.

This is the latest package we're going to upgrade. First of all, we will cut the humanitarian intake from 20,000—the second-highest in the world, and more than 10 times the OECD average—to 2,000. That's a decrease of 90 per cent, or 18,000. We'll still have a target that is above the OECD average per capita.

Last year, in 2025, Australian resettlements rose nine per cent. Other nations are decreasing their refugee intake. In 2023-24, 41 per cent of working-age humanitarian entries who arrived in the previous five years received unemployment benefits. That's almost half. Among those who lived here more than a decade, 16 per cent received unemployment payments.

The permanent parent visa program we will scrap, but we will not deport parents already here. They can apply for a visa. If we continued the humanitarian and parent visas that you lot brought in for another decade, it would cost taxpayers $141 billion over net lifetime costs. That's from Treasury modelling, adjusted for inflation and after taxes and visa charges. The average cost, as I said, would be $523,000 per humanitarian entrant and $515,000 per parent entrant.

The Productivity Commission says it's actually cruel and lacks understanding to continue with what we're doing. Immigration policy should serve Australia and Australians who are already here. Safety and living standards in our country come first.

Mehreen Faruqi

Mehreen Faruqi NSW, Australian Greens

6:01 pm

Watching Bob Brown take a stand against the Howard government's cruel response to the Tampa affair was one of the reasons I joined the Greens, and I know so many others did the same. That heartfelt compassion shown by Bob Brown for refugees birthed a generation of activists and saw the Greens vote double in 2001. People still remember it 2½ decades on.

When I'm out and about, so many people I speak with tell me how deeply they care about Australia having a generous refugee program. They want this country to welcome and support people in need. They are proud of a country that generations of migrant families, just like mine, have chosen for a better life. I'll never forget the first time my dad told me about Australia—about the people, about the beaches, about the Harbour Bridge and, of course, about the cricket. We know that, at our best our streets, our schools and our offices are places where strangers turn into neighbours and hope, not hate, thrives.

Yet, as per usual, right on cue, One Nation is pointing their racist finger at migrants and refugees again. While their billionaire backers rip off working people, One Nation wants you to believe that it's your friends and neighbours that are making life harder. Where Labor and the Liberals have been bought by corporate donors and have really sold out working people, One Nation has stepped in and responded to people's anger by whipping up fear and hate. But, increasingly, people will see One Nation's policies for what they really are: a smokescreen by these merchants of hate, which will do nothing to improve people's material conditions.

This latest announcement by One Nation is nothing more than another cruel attack on migrants and refugees, framing them as the problem and pitting neighbours against one another. But it will not succeed. People know much better. They will see right through these fake solutions.

Dorinda Cox

Dorinda Cox WA, Australian Labor Party

The question before the chair is that the motion moved by Senator Hanson be agreed to.