This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Matters of Urgency

Migration


Susan McDonald

Susan McDonald Queensland, National Party, Shadow Minister for Resources and Northern Australia

5:38 pm

Australians are rightly concerned about the scale of migration under this Labor government. Since Anthony Albanese came to office, about 1.5 million additional migrants have arrived in Australia—roughly the population of Adelaide. That has placed enormous pressure on housing, infrastructure, schools, hospitals and essential services. The Liberals and Nationals have been absolutely clear: migration numbers under Labor have been too high and standards have been too low.

Opposing this motion from One Nation does not mean endorsing Labor's disastrous migration policies. In fact, the coalition has already announced the largest cut to immigration in Australia's history. We'll reduce net overseas migration to 100,000 people a year for the first two years, rising to 160,000 in year 4. We will prioritise skilled migrants, protect essential regional industries and restore integrity to the migration system.

Importantly, we have told Australians exactly what our net overseas migration targets will be. By my count, this is One Nation's fifth migration policy in about five months, and they still cannot provide a credible year-by-year explanation of what their net overseas migration figures will be. We've heard promises of 130,000 migrants, negative migration and hundreds of thousands of temporary visa holders leaving the country, and now this latest announcement. Australians are seeking real solutions and concrete information on this issue, but with One Nation they simply get another headline every few weeks.

Today's motion proposes slashing the humanitarian intake to just 2,000 places annually and abolishing permanent parent migration. The coalition agrees that Labor's humanitarian intake is unsustainable, and that is why we have committed to halving the humanitarian program to 10,000 places annually. But we also recognise that Australia must retain the flexibility to respond to international crises. Wars, humanitarian disasters and the displacement of innocent people cannot be predicted years in advance. Governments need the ability to respond appropriately while maintaining firm control of the overall migration program.

Then there is One Nation's program to abolish permanent parent visas. Anyone who has dealt with these applications knows this is hardly an uncontrolled migration program. According to the Department of Home Affairs, the estimated processing time for a contributory parent visa application is 18 years. For standard parent visas, it is an astonishing 42 years. Applicants must meet visa requirements, including health and character checks, and sponsors are subject to financial obligations. These are tightly controlled programs with lengthy queues, so it is simply not credible to suggest that parent visas are the principal cause of Australia's housing shortage or cost-of-living crisis. One Nation also claims these proposals will save taxpayers $141 billion. Where are the independent costings, when would these savings materialise and what are the wider economic consequences?

The coalition's Australia First migration plan is straightforward. We must reduce migration, lift standards, restore proper controls and ensure that the people coming here want to make a positive contribution. We must also protect the industries and regional communities that depend on genuinely skilled migration. We will cap net overseas migration each year below the number of new homes completed. We'll reduce temporary visa holders by about 650,000 over four years and keep the Permanent Migration Program capped at 185,000 places a year. We will also reduce annual international student commencements by 55,000 people, abolish temporary graduate visas and restrict most students from bringing over family members.

Labor has created a mess. But replacing Labor's failures with constantly-changing One Nation announcements is not the answer. Australia's migration policy should be rigorous, practical, properly costed and capable of being delivered. We believe migrants should want to be Australians and not just live here but share our aspirations, our values and our way of life. That is what the Liberals and Nationals have put forward, and that is why we cannot support this motion.

Comments

No comments